Pages

▼

What is a Broker? What types exist? What rules govern them?

These questions stem from the following article: 


- Your phone knows you’re at the doctor, and data brokers are profiting from it.

More than 92 percent of patients in a 2022 American Medical Association survey said they thought their health data should not be available for purchase. But many people might not realize that when they are sitting in a hospital, an abortion clinic, or an Alcoholics Anonymous meeting in a church basement, the location data emitted from their mobile phones isn’t covered by the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA), which protects patient privacy.

That worries Eric Ellsworth, director of health policy and innovation at the Center for the Study of Services, a nonprofit focused on delivering consumers reliable information on local medical services and health care professionals.

“Data brokers typically are just hoovering up data from the open web and then buying it from anybody,” he said.

The U.S. government has begun to penalize some companies that track Americans when they visit health facilities and places of worship. But privacy and legal experts don’t think actions against a few companies will stop an entire industry built on scooping up Americans’ private data. They’re calling on more states or Congress to ban advertisers from tracking Americans’ locations via their phones.

But progress has been fitful. California Gov. Gavin Newsom, a Democrat, on Sept. 27 vetoed a bill that would have blocked the sale and sharing of location and other sensitive personal data, saying it went “a step too far.” And a recent study from Stanford University showed that only 9 percent of data brokers are adhering to an existing California privacy law that gives consumers the right to delete their data, correct personal information and learn what personal records the business is selling.

In January, Consumer Reports released model legislation giving state lawmakers a framework to ban or limit the sale of geolocation data, which uses GPS to identify a person’s movements in real time. Connecticut, Delaware, Maryland, New Jersey, Oregon and Virginia have already banned the sale of precise geolocation data. But digital advertisers have also lobbied states to block such proposed limits.



Related Questions: 

- What is a data broker?

- What is a broker? What types exist?

- Outline the development of brokers as a profession.

- What laws govern how brokers operate? Provide a timeline for how these evolved. 

- Breakdown the laws covering brokers into national, state, and local.

- What licenses are necessary in order to work as a broker? What groups over see them?

For 2305: 

- Describe the political power of the brokerage industry.

- What is the basis of the political power of the brokerage industry?

- 
Does the brokerage industry favor Democratic or Republican candidates, or does partisanship matter?


Friday, October 30, 2026

From the New York Times: Third-Party Spoilers, Long Fueled by Both Parties, Could Matter This Year

There is a long history of this strategy being used to pull votes away from competing candidates.


- Click here for the article.   

With modern elections often decided by extremely thin margins and billions of dollars sloshing through campaigns, both parties have ample incentives and opportunities to gain an edge through mischief involving third parties.

The jockeying around spoiler candidates is widely considered a legal yet shadowy part of political campaigning that has gone on for decades. The Sullivan episode in Alaska is far from the first time that multiple candidates with the same name have run for the same office, with the lesser-known one often deliberately trying to confuse voters. There was even an Eddie Murphy movie in 1992 based on the concept of his character’s winning a seat in Congress previously held by a deceased politician with the same name.

Usually the actors propping up spoiler candidates are careful enough about wiping away their fingerprints that they do not get caught in the kind of uproar that Mary Peltola’s Senate campaign now faces in Alaska. After a New York Times report detailing how allies of Ms. Peltola, a Democrat, had recruited little-known candidates to try to stack the ballot, Gov. Mike Dunleavy of Alaska ordered an investigation into whether the Peltola campaign should face criminal charges or civil penalties, and President Trump demanded that she be removed from the ballot. Neither suggested a specific law that had been violated.

“Ghost voters are a bad phenomenon, but it’s a phenomenon that’s been in American politics for decades,” said Benjamin Ginsberg, a prominent Republican election lawyer. “At this point there’s no legal violation. Coming when it does, it’s purely up to Alaska voters, who, after all, put both Dan Sullivans on the ballot with their votes.”


Related: 

- Provide a timeline of the use of minor parties to split the votes of major parties. How often is this strategy successful?

- Does the Libertarian Party in Texas pull votes away from the Republican Party?

- Has a Libertarian Party candidate helped swing an election towards the Democratic Party candidate in any election across the United States?

- Does the Green Party in Texas pull votes away from the Democratic Party?

- Has a Green Party candidate helped swing an election towards the Republican Party candidate in any election across the United States?

Thursday, October 29, 2026

What is an Immigration Court? Does the president have too much control over it?

From the Washington Post: - Democrats demand reform after judge says DOJ ordered her to reverse rulings.

Congressional Democrats have again demanded urgent reforms to the country’s immigration court system after The Washington Post revealed a veteran judge’s allegations that she was ordered to reverse rulings and urged to conduct sham bond hearings.

Democratic Sens. Chris Van Hollen of Maryland and Dick Durbin of Illinois, both longtime critics of President Donald Trump’s immigration policies, renewed calls this week to pass a bill that would remove immigration judges from the authority of the executive branch.

They spoke out in response to the story of Karen Donoso Stevens, a former Homeland Security prosecutor who joined the bench in 2016. After persistent interference by Justice Department officials, Donoso Stevens alleged, she was pulled from court mid-hearing, demoted and eventually fired.



Related questions: 

- What is an immigration court?

- What is a federal administrative tribunal?

- What is a administrative adjudication?

- Outline the development of immigration courts in the United States.

- What current controversies involve immigration courts?

- What jurisdiction does Congress have over immigration courts?

- What legislation has been introduced recently to change immigration courts?

- Are state and local governments ever litigants in proceedings before immigration courts?



From the New York Times: How a Legal Backlash Against Big Tech Is Forcing Big Changes

Public policy can be shaped by the courts as much as it can be shaped by the legislature - maybe more so.

- Click here for the article.  

From ScotusBlog

The previous term of the Supreme Court included a large amount of cases involving President Trump's expansive use of executive power. This one looks to be the same.

- The Trump Term?

- Another Trump Term? 

Monday, October 19, 2026

H.R.9497 - Water Resources Development Act of 2026

An example of internal improvements.

- Click here.  

This bill authorizes and modifies certain water resource infrastructure projects and programs of the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers and makes related requirements. For example, the bill authorizes and modifies various water resources feasibility studies and projects of the Corps of Engineers, such as studies or projects to:

- maintain ports and harbors,
- make certain waterways more navigable,
- reduce flood and storm damage,
- restore aquatic ecosystems and protect fish and wildlife,
- protect shorelines,
- address harmful algal blooms,
- rehabilitate dams,
- manage recreational sites and facilities,
- support water supply and storage projects, and
- support other water resources infrastructure.

The bill also directs the Corps of Engineers to establish an Office on Alternative Delivery Methods in order to accelerate project delivery of infrastructure.

In addition, the bill directs the Corps of Engineers to issue a rule that establishes categorical permissions for certain harbor or river improvements that will cause only minimal adverse environmental effects.

Thursday, October 1, 2026

Dear ChatGPT: What happened to the property of loyalists following the revolutionary war?

Despite Madison's call for the protection of property rights, this did not seem to exptent to loyalists. 

He would likely respond that property was conficated by state governments, not the national government - which did not effectively exist at that time. 

- Click here for the answer. 

- Also: Provide a timeline for when the property of loyalists was confiscated. Also state what entity did the conficating. Provide references and additional readings.

For background; 

- Who were the loyalists? 

- How were their interests served by maintaining a relationship with Britain?