- Congress.gov: The Ninth Amendment Explained.
From ChatGPT:
Provide a comprehensive list of unenumerated rights alledged to exist under the Ninth Amendment.
- Click here for the full answer.
Below is a comprehensive, structured list of unenumerated rights alleged to exist under the Ninth Amendment, as recognized, argued, or debated in U.S. constitutional law, political theory, and Supreme Court jurisprudence.
I divide them into five analytical categories, distinguishing between rights with strong judicial recognition, partial or indirect recognition, and contested or theoretical claims.
I. Core Personal Autonomy & Bodily Integrity Rights
(Most strongly associated with modern Ninth-Amendment-adjacent doctrine, often via substantive due process)
1. Right to Privacy (General)
-
Control over intimate personal information
-
Freedom from unwarranted government intrusion into private life
-
Foundation for many derivative rights below
2. Reproductive Autonomy
-
Right to use contraception
-
Right to decide whether to bear or beget a child
-
Right to bodily autonomy in reproductive decisions
(Status varies post-Dobbs; still claimed as unenumerated)
3. Medical Autonomy
-
Right to refuse unwanted medical treatment
-
Right to informed consent
-
Right to make end-of-life decisions (e.g., declining life-sustaining care)
4. Sexual Intimacy
-
Right to engage in private, consensual adult sexual conduct
-
Freedom from criminalization of private sexual relationships
II. Family, Home, and Child-Rearing Rights
(Among the most historically rooted unenumerated rights)
5. Right to Marry
-
Choice of spouse
-
Marriage as a fundamental personal decision
6. Right to Establish a Family
-
Right to procreate
-
Right to live together as a family unit
7. Parental Rights
-
Right to direct the upbringing and education of one’s children
-
Right to choose private, religious, or home schooling
-
Right to make medical and moral decisions for children
8. Right to Family Integrity
-
Freedom from arbitrary state interference in family relationships
-
Limits on forced separation absent due process
III. Property, Labor, and Economic Liberty Claims
(Historically important but judicially weakened after the New Deal)
9. Right to Acquire, Use, and Dispose of Property
-
Ownership beyond explicit Fifth Amendment protections
-
Control over lawful use of property
10. Freedom of Contract
-
Right to enter voluntary economic agreements
-
Once treated as fundamental, now largely regulatory
11. Right to Choose One’s Occupation
-
Freedom to pursue a lawful trade or profession
-
Opposition to arbitrary licensing or exclusion
12. Right to Earn a Living
-
Economic self-sufficiency without unreasonable state barriers
IV. Intellectual, Associational, and Personal Development Rights
13. Freedom of Thought
-
Inner freedom of belief beyond speech or religion
-
Cognitive liberty (often discussed in modern contexts)
14. Right to Personal Identity and Self-Definition
-
Control over personal identity
-
Autonomy in defining one’s life path
15. Freedom of Association (Beyond the First Amendment)
-
Choice of personal relationships
-
Freedom from compelled association in private life
16. Right to Travel
-
Interstate travel
-
International travel (subject to regulation)
V. Political, Structural, and Residual Natural Rights
(Closest to the original understanding of the Ninth Amendment)
17. Natural Rights Retained by the People
-
Rights existing prior to government
-
Rights not surrendered upon entering civil society
18. Right to Be Free from Arbitrary Government Action
-
General liberty interest against unjustified state power
-
Often invoked rhetorically rather than doctrinally
19. Right to Local Self-Governance
-
Community control over local affairs
-
Especially argued in federalism contexts
20. Right to Resist Tyranny (Highly Theoretical)
-
Moral or philosophical right of resistance
-
Not judicially enforceable
VI. Modern & Emerging Ninth Amendment Claims
(Not judicially settled but increasingly discussed)
21. Data Privacy
-
Control over personal digital information
-
Resistance to mass surveillance
22. Cognitive Liberty
-
Freedom from manipulation of thought or perception
-
Increasing relevance in AI and neurotechnology debates
23. Genetic Privacy
-
Control over genetic information
-
Freedom from genetic discrimination
24. Right to Informational Self-Determination
-
Originating in comparative constitutional theory
-
Sometimes argued as implicit in Ninth Amendment logic
VII. What the Ninth Amendment Does Not Do (Doctrinal Limits)
-
It does not automatically create new rights
-
It does not specify enforcement mechanisms
-
It does not override federalism
-
Courts rarely rely on it alone; it is usually paired with:
-
Substantive Due Process (14th Amendment)
-
Privileges or Immunities arguments
-
Natural law reasoning
-
Structural constitutional principles
-
