Dear ChatGPT: Outline the subject matter covered in the Federalist Papers

- Click here for the full answer.

Here’s a topic-by-topic map of the subject matter in the Federalist Papers to the specific essay numbers, organized the way constitutional law courses and serious history texts usually do it.

I. Failure of the Articles of Confederation

Why the existing system could not survive
- Federalist No. 15 – Insufficiency of the Confederation
- Federalist No. 16 – Impossibility of enforcing federal laws on states
- Federalist No. 17 – States’ attraction to their own power
- Federalist No. 18–20 – Lessons from ancient & modern confederacies (Greece, Rome, Holy Roman Empire, Netherlands)

Core takeaway: A government acting only on states is structurally defective.


II. Dangers of Disunion & Benefits of Union

- Federalist No. 1 – Purpose of the essays; choice between reason and force
- Federalist No. 2 – Advantages of unity (Jay)
- Federalist No. 3 – Union and foreign relations
- Federalist No. 4–5 – European threats & manipulation
- Federalist No. 6–7 – Interstate conflict without union
- Federalist No. 8 – Standing armies & militarization
- Federalist No. 9 – Union as a cure for faction
- Federalist No. 10 – Faction & the extended republic
- Federalist No. 11 – Commercial advantages of union
- Federalist No. 12–13 – Revenue and efficiency

Core takeaway: Union is the precondition for security and liberty.


III. Republican Government & Popular Sovereignty

- Federalist No. 9 – Republican principles refined
- Federalist No. 10 – Representation vs. pure democracy
- Federalist No. 14 – Geographic size and republicanism
- Federalist No. 39 – Definition of a republican government
- Federalist No. 57 – Accountability of representatives
- Federalist No. 63 – Stability and public trust

Core takeaway: The Constitution creates a representative republic, not a democracy.


IV. Factions & Majority Tyranny

- Federalist No. 10 – Causes of faction and structural remedy
- Federalist No. 51 – Internal controls on faction through separation of powers

Core takeaway: You cannot eliminate faction—only control its effects.


V. Federalism: Division of National & State Power

- Federalist No. 39 – Federal vs. national character
- Federalist No. 45 – Limited federal powers; broad state powers
- Federalist No. 46 – States as safeguards against federal overreach
- Federalist No. 47 – Separation of powers applied to federalism

Core takeaway: Dual sovereignty protects liberty through competition.


VI. Separation of Powers

- Federalist No. 47 – Montesquieu and separation of powers
- Federalist No. 48 – Dangers of legislative dominance
- Federalist No. 49 – Appeals to the people
- Federalist No. 50 – Periodic constitutional conventions rejected
- Federalist No. 51 – Structural checks: “ambition must counteract ambition”

Core takeaway: Liberty survives through institutional design, not virtue.


VII. Checks and Balances

- Federalist No. 51 – Internal checks
- Federalist No. 52–53 – House elections & accountability
- Federalist No. 54 – Representation and taxation
- Federalist No. 63 – Senate’s stabilizing role

Core takeaway: Overlapping powers force deliberation and restraint.


VIII. Legislative Branch (Congress)

- Federalist No. 52–56 – House of Representatives
- Federalist No. 57 – Electoral accountability
- Federalist No. 58 – Apportionment & population growth
- Federalist No. 59 – Federal control of elections
- Federalist No. 60–61 – Election safeguards
- Federalist No. 62–63 – Senate structure & purpose

Core takeaway: Bicameralism balances responsiveness and stability.


IX. Executive Branch (The Presidency)

- Federalist No. 67–71 – Nature of executive power
- Federalist No. 70 – Unity of the executive
- Federalist No. 71 – Duration in office
- Federalist No. 72 – Re-eligibility
- Federalist No. 73 – Veto power
- Federalist No. 74–75 – Military & treaty powers
- Federalist No. 76–77 – Appointments
- Federalist No. 78 (partly) – Executive influence on courts

Core takeaway: Energy + accountability beats plural executive chaos.


X. Judicial Branch

- Federalist No. 78 – Judicial review & independence
- Federalist No. 79 – Judicial compensation
- Federalist No. 80 – Jurisdiction of federal courts
- Federalist No. 81 – Limits on judicial power
- Federalist No. 82 – Concurrent jurisdiction
- Federalist No. 83 – Jury trials

Core takeaway: Courts defend the Constitution, not policy preferences.


XI. Military, War, and National Defense

- Federalist No. 23–29 – Military powers & militias
- Federalist No. 24–26 – Standing armies
- Federalist No. 41 – Defense as a core national function

Core takeaway: Defense requires national coordination, not state rivalry.


XII. Taxation, Spending, and Commerce

- Federalist No. 30–36 – Federal taxing power
- Federalist No. 41–44 – Necessary and Proper Clause
- Federalist No. 42 – Commerce Clause
- Federalist No. 45 – Balance of fiscal power

Core takeaway: Revenue power is inseparable from sovereignty.


XIII. Ratification & Constitutional Authority

- Federalist No. 40 – Legitimacy of the Convention
- Federalist No. 85 – Final defense of ratification
- Federalist No. 84 – Bill of Rights objection answered

Core takeaway: The Constitution derives authority directly from the people.


One-Sentence Synthesis: Each Federalist paper fits into a single grand project: designing a government strong enough to govern, but structured enough to remain free.