Tuesday, October 11, 2022

From Wikipedia: Telecommunications Act of 1996

- Click here for the entry.

Major components: 

Title I, "Telecommunications Service": Helps to outline the general duties of the telecommunication carriers as well as the obligations of all local exchange carriers (LECs) and the additional obligations of incumbent local exchange carriers (ILECs).

Title II, "Broadcast Services": Outlines the granting and licensing of broadcast spectrum by the government, including a provision to issue licenses to current television stations to commence digital television broadcasting, the use of the revenues generated by such licensing, the terms of broadcast licenses, the process of renewing broadcast licenses, direct broadcast satellite services, automated ship distress and safety systems, and restrictions on over-the-air reception devices

Title III, "Cable Services": Outlines the Cable Act reform, cable services provided by telephone companies, the preemption of franchising authority regulation of telecommunication services, VHS home video programming accessibility, and competitive availability of navigation devices.

Title IV, "Regulatory Reform": Outlines regulatory forbearance, a biennial review of regulations, regulatory relief, and the elimination of unnecessary Commission regulations and functions.

Title V, "Obscenity and Violence": Main article: Communications Decency Act

Outlines regulations regarding obscene programming on cable television, the scrambling of cable channels for nonsubscribers, the scrambling of sexually explicit adult video service programming, the cable operators' refusal to carry certain programs, coercion and enticement of minors, and online family empowerment, including a requirement for the manufacture of televisions that block programs using V-chip technology. Title V also gives a clarification of the current laws regarding communication of obscene materials through the use of a computer.

Title VI, "Effect on Other Laws" : Outlines the applicability of consent decrees and other laws and the preemption of local taxation with respect to direct-to-home sales.

Title VII, "Miscellaneous Provisions" : Outlines provisions relating to the prevention of unfair billing practices for information or services provided over toll-free telephone calls, privacy of consumer information, pole attachments, facilities siting, radio frequency emission standards, mobile services direct access to long-distance carriers, advanced telecommunications incentives, the telecommunications development fund, the National Education Technology Funding Corporation, a report on the use of advance telecommunications services for medical purposes, and outlines the authorization of appropriations.

From Freedom House: Freedom of the Press Research Methodology

Press freedoms are being limited, according to critics. But how do we know that?

- Click here for an explanation. 

Here are the components of the evaluation:

1. To what extent are media owned or controlled by the government, and does this influence their diversity of views?

2. Is media ownership transparent, thus allowing consumers to judge the impartiality of the news?

3. Is media ownership highly concentrated and does this influence diversity of content?

4. Are there restrictions on the means of news production and distribution?

5. Are there high costs associated with the establishment and operation of media outlets?

6. Do the state or other actors try to control the media through allocation of advertising or subsidies?

7. Do journalists, bloggers, or media outlets receive payment from private or public sources whose design is to influence their journalistic content?

8. Does the overall economic situation negatively impact media outlets’ financial sustainability?

Reporters without Borders uses different criteria: 

- Click here for more.

- pluralism (measures the degree of representation of opinions in the media space)
- media independence
- environment and self-censorship
- legislative framework
- transparency
- infrastructure
- abuses.

Ted Turner v Rupert Murdoch

- Ted Turner.

- CNN.

- Rubert Murdoch. 

- News Corps.

From Wikipedia: New York Post, History

Newspapers and political parties developed together.

- Click here for the entry.

The Post was founded by Alexander Hamilton with about US$10,000 (equivalent to $162,860 in 2021) from a group of investors in the autumn of 1801 as the New-York Evening Post, a broadsheet. Hamilton's co-investors included other New York members of the Federalist Party, such as Robert Troup and Oliver Wolcott, who were dismayed by the election of Thomas Jefferson as U.S. president and the rise in popularity of the Democratic-Republican Party. The meeting at which Hamilton first recruited investors for the new paper took place in Archibald Gracie's then-country weekend villa that is now Gracie Mansion. Hamilton chose William Coleman as his first editor.



- The editor: William Coleman.

William Coleman (February 14, 1766 – July 13, 1829) was the first editor of The New York Evening Post (today known as the New York Post), chosen by founder Alexander Hamilton. Coleman was born in Boston, Massachusetts on February 14, 1766. He studied law with Joshua Atherton of Amherst, New Hampshire, where his fellow students included William Plumer, who remained a lifelong friend. Coleman was admitted to the bar, and moved to Greenfield, Massachusetts, where he became the town's first lawyer and co-founder of the Impartial Intelligencer newspaper, now known as The Greenfield Recorder. He moved to New York City around 1794 and practiced law at one point with Aaron Burr. In 1801, he began The New York Evening Post, and he served as editor of the paper from 1801 to 1829.

Also: 

- Gazette of the United States.

The Gazette of the United States was an early American newspaper, first issued semiweekly in New York on April 15, 1789, but moving the next year to Philadelphia when the nation's capital moved there the next year.[1] It was friendly to the Federalist Party. Its founder, John Fenno, intended it to unify the country under its new government. As the leading Federalist newspaper of its time, it praised the Washington and Adams administrations and their policies. Its Federalist sponsors, chiefly Alexander Hamilton, granted it substantial funding; because some of it was directly from the government, the Gazette is considered to have been semi-official. The influence of the newspaper inspired the creation of the National Gazette and the Philadelphia Aurora, rival newspapers for the Democratic-Republicans.

- John Fenno.

Having previously written for the Massachusetts Centinel,[5] Fenno on April 11, 1789 in New York City published the first issue of the Gazette of the United States to support Federalist Party positions. Fenno moved it to Philadelphia when the national capital moved there in 1790.

As opposing factions, centered on Alexander Hamilton and Thomas Jefferson, developed within President Washington's administration, political newspapers such as the Gazette became increasingly important. Fenno's little three-column folio, printed on a sheet seventeen by twenty-one inches, became the semi-official government newspaper, with a share of the government's printing and with contributions from prominent Federalists such as John Adams. Hamilton was especially active, writing articles under various pseudonyms and rescuing the editor from bankruptcy in 1793 by raising $2,000 to pay off creditors.

Jefferson and his colleagues, angry at Fenno's attempt "to make way for a king, lords, and Commons" set up rival newspapers, the Aurora edited by Benjamin F. Bache and the National Gazette edited by Philip Freneau, to promote the newly formed Democratic-Republican Party. As a highly visible Federalist spokesman, Fenno was engaged in verbal disputes that once led to fisticuffs with Bache. The tone of the Gazette of the United States was somewhat above the average of its contemporaries, and the Federalists were well served through its columns, although the circulation never exceeded 1,400. Copies circulated to major cities where other Federalist newspapers freely copied the news and editorials.

From CBS News: Supreme Court declines to take up fetal personhood dispute

As discussed in class: 

- Click here for the article. 

The Supreme Court on Tuesday turned away a dispute over whether the unborn are entitled to constitutional protections, sidestepping an issue that could be at the center of the next big battle over abortion after high court's conservative majority reversed the nearly 50-year-old Roe v. Wade decision.

The court declined to hear an appeal from two pregnant women, filed on behalf of their then-unborn fetuses, and a Catholic organization of a Rhode Island Supreme Court decision. The state court left intact a Rhode Island abortion rights law and found the unborn babies, Baby Mary Doe and Baby Roe, did not have legal standing to challenge the law because they were not "persons" under the 14th Amendment.

The legal battle involved the Reproductive Privacy Act, which was signed into law by then-Gov. Gina Raimondo in 2019 and sought to enshrine into law the right to an abortion established in the Supreme Court's 1973 decision in Roe.

- Click here for the brief.

INTRODUCTION

 This Court, in Dobbs v. Jackson Women’s Health Organization, 572 U.S. ___ (2022), avoided the question of “when prenatal life is entitled to any rights enjoyed after birth.” See Dobbs, slip op. at 38. Petitioners’ case presents the opportunity for this Court to meet that inevitable question head on. This Court’s Dobbs holding, that “Roe was egregiously wrong from the start,” id. at 6, and its further overruling of Roe v. Wade, 410 U.S. 113 (1973), and Planned Parenthood of Southeastern Pa. v. Casey, 505 U.S. 833 (1992), surely signal rejection of this Court’s statement in Roe that, “[t]he word ‘person,’ as used in the Fourteenth Amendment, does not include the unborn.” See Roe v. Wade, 410 U.S. 113, 158 (1973), overruled, Dobbs v. Jackson Women’s Health Organization, 572 U.S. ___ (2022). The Fourteenth Amendment has no textual definition of the term “any person” therein.

And it neither includes nor excludes unborn human beings specifically. Petitioners seek a writ of certiorari for questions presented that do not require this Court to adopt any particular “theory of life.” Dobbs at 38-39. They ask only that this Court identify the guarantees upon which Petitioners – and any unborn plaintiff regardless of gestational age – can rely for constitutional protection under the Fourteenth Amendment, and whether unborn human beings will categorically be denied access to the courts to challenge an abortion law. 

Monday, October 10, 2022

Key Terms - Week 7

The Media

Terms: 

- the media
- loud signal
- public watchdog
- journalism
- policy agenda
- priming 
- framing
- mass media
- personal presidency
- radio
- television
- cable
- infotainment
- 24 hour news
- new media
- fake news
- bias
- - political
- - sensational
- - confirmation
- - investigative
- - fairness
- private ownership
- profits
- Watergate scandal
- public ownership
- regulations
- Federal Communications Commission
- agency capture
- fairness doctrine
- consolidation
- Telecommunications Act of 1996
- horserace journalism
- sound bite

Sunday, October 9, 2022

From the Supreme Court Observer: Sedition was Created to Prevent the Criticism of the King

- Click here for the article.

Sedition was devised as a tool in 13th century Britain to suppress the freedom of the printing press and its ability to criticise the King. The Sedition Act, 1661 imposed punishment on anyone who wrote, printed or preached any words against the King. It evolved to mean slander and libel against the reputation or actions of government officials and judges. The goal was to protect the faith that the common person had in the government and to avoid a ‘breach of peace’ in society.

- Charles II, 1661: An Act for Safety and Preservation of His Majesties Person and Government against Treasonable and Seditious practices and attempts.

US Introduced Sedition to Protect the Federal Government

In 1798, the Sedition Act was passed under the presidency of John Adams, to criminalise the making of false statements against the federal government. It was designed to expire in 1801 since the justification for making these laws was the protection of the government during the Quasi-War.

The mention and criminalisation of sedition was next seen during World War I. Section 3 of The Sedition Act, 1918 was drafted to punish anyone making false statements that interfered with the U.S. war efforts. This included insulting the U.S. government, flag, Constitution or military.

The most prominent case in this regard is In Re Debs, where a socialist worker Eugene Debs was sentenced to 10 years in prison for an anti-war speech. Justice Oliver Wendell Holmes stated that the freedom of speech and expression could be curtailed under certain circumstances.

In 1921 the Act was repealed. The case of Sullivan v New York Times upheld the freedom of speech under the First Amendment, which affected the treatment of libel. The U.S. Supreme Court held that unless a statement was made with malice or reckless disregard for the truth, the First Amendment protected the criticism of public officials.

From Liberty Fund: Brief Narrative of the Trial of Peter Zenger

- Click here for it. 

More about the participants: 

- Colonial Governor William Cosby:

. . . On his arrival in New York City, Cosby had plunged into a rancorous quarrel with the council of the colony over his salary. Unable to control the colony's supreme court, he removed Chief Justice Lewis Morris, replacing him with the royalist James DeLancey. Supported by members of the Popular Party, Zenger's New-York Weekly Journal continued to publish articles critical of the royal governor. Finally, Cosby issued a proclamation condemning the newspaper's "divers scandalous, virulent, false and seditious reflections."



- Printer and Journalist John Peter Zenger: 

. . . a German printer and journalist in New York City. Zenger printed The New York Weekly Journal. He was accused of libel in 1734 by William Cosby, the royal governor of New York, but the jury acquitted Zenger, who became a symbol for freedom of the press.

In 1733, Zenger began printing The New York Weekly Journal, which voiced opinions critical of the colonial governor, William Cosby. On November 17, 1734, on Cosby's orders, the sheriff arrested Zenger. After a grand jury refused to indict him, the Attorney General Richard Bradley charged him with libel in August 1735. Zenger's lawyers, Andrew Hamilton and William Smith, Sr., successfully argued that truth is a defense against charges of libel.



- Lawyer Andrew Hamilton.

. . . a Scottish lawyer in the Thirteen Colonies, where he finally settled in Philadelphia. He was best known for his legal victory on behalf of the printer and newspaper publisher John Peter Zenger. His involvement with the 1735 decision in New York helped to establish that truth is a defense to an accusation of libel. His eloquent defense concluded with saying that the press has "a liberty both of exposing and opposing tyrannical power by speaking and writing truth."

His success in this case has been said to have inspired the now-archaic term "Philadelphia lawyer", meaning a particularly adept and clever attorney, as in "It would take a Philadelphia lawyer to get him off." His estate in Philadelphia, known as Bush Hill, was inherited by his son, William Hamilton, who leased it for use as the vice-president's house during the years that the city was the temporary capital of the United States.

The Zenger Trial Explained




- Crown v. John Peter Zenger, 1735.

From History.com: How US Presidents Have Communicated with the Public—From the Telegraph to Twitter

- Click here for the article. 

The US Military’s Massive Global Transportation System

The Ad Fontes Media Bias Chart

Perhaps you've seen it. 

- Click here for Ad Fontes Media.



How reliable is it?



About 30 paid analysts rate articles for Ad Fontes. Listed on the company’s website, they represent a range of experience — current and former journalists, educators, librarians and similar professionals. The company recruits analysts through its email list and references and vets them through a traditional application process. Hired analysts are then trained by Otero and other Ad Fontes staff.

To start review sessions, a group of coordinators composed of senior analysts and the company’s nine staffers pulls articles from the sites being reviewed. They look for articles listed as most popular or displayed most prominently.

Part of the Ad Fontes analyst political bias test. The test asks analysts to rank their political bias on 18 different policy issues.

Ad Fontes administers an internal political bias test to analysts, asking them to rank their left-to-right position on about 20 policy positions. That information allows the company to attempt to create ideological balance by including one centrist, one left-leaning and one right-leaning analyst on each review panel. The panels review at least three articles for each source, but they may review as many as 30 for particularly prominent outlets, like The Washington Post, Otero said. More on their methodology, including how they choose which articles to review to create a bias rating, can be found here on the Ad Fontes website.

When they review the articles, the analysts see them as they appear online, “because that’s how people encounter all content. No one encounters content blind,” Otero said. The review process recently changed so that paired analysts discuss their ratings over video chat, where they are pushed to be more specific as they form ratings, Otero said.

Individual scores for an article’s accuracy, the use of fact or opinion, and the appropriateness of its headline and image combine to create a reliability score. The bias score is determined by the article’s degree of advocacy for a left-to-right political position, topic selection and omission, and use of language.

To create an overall bias and reliability score for an outlet, the individual scores for each reviewed article are averaged, with added importance given to more popular articles. That average determines where sources show up on the chart.

From the Pew Research Center: More U.S. locations experimenting with alternative voting systems

 A discussion of ranked choice voting.

- More U.S. locations experimenting with alternative voting systems.

The recent Democratic primary for New York City mayor attracted even more attention than usual, as the nation’s biggest city also became the largest jurisdiction to use an alternative voting system known as ranked-choice voting (RCV).


This is the first time New York has used RCV. In this system, voters can rank more than one candidate in order of preference. (New Yorkers could rank up to five of the 13 candidates on the Democratic ballot. The GOP ballot had only two candidates, so RCV didn’t come into play.)

If one candidate receives a majority of first-choice votes, that person wins, and no subsequent rounds are needed. If no one wins a majority of first-preference votes, the last-place candidate is dropped and their votes are reallocated to those voters’ second choices. If there’s still no majority winner, the process repeats with the new last-place candidate being eliminated – and so forth until someone has a majority. (This is why RCV is also called “instant-runoff voting.”)

Advocates for RCV and other alternative voting systems (such as “top-two” primaries, cumulative voting and approval voting) typically argue that they’re more fairly representative than the first-past-the-post (or “winner-take-all”) system that’s standard in most of the United States, and that they can encourage campaigns to appeal beyond their base voters to broader swaths of the electorate. Critics dispute both of those points and claim that unfamiliar and complex voting systems can depress rather than encourage turnout, especially in communities of color.



The World in 2050: Characteristics of New Rising Powers

From the White House: A Proclamation on Granting Pardon for the Offense of Simple Possession of Marijuana

Biden uses one of the president's constitutional power to check judicial power.

- Click here for it.

Acting pursuant to the grant of authority in Article II, Section 2, of the Constitution of the United States, I, Joseph R. Biden Jr., do hereby grant a full, complete, and unconditional pardon to (1) all current United States citizens and lawful permanent residents who committed the offense of simple possession of marijuana in violation of the Controlled Substances Act, as currently codified at 21 U.S.C. 844 and as previously codified elsewhere in the United States Code, or in violation of D.C. Code 48–904.01(d)(1), on or before the date of this proclamation, regardless of whether they have been charged with or prosecuted for this offense on or before the date of this proclamation; and (2) all current United States citizens and lawful permanent residents who have been convicted of the offense of simple possession of marijuana in violation of the Controlled Substances Act, as currently codified at 21 U.S.C. 844 and as previously codified elsewhere in the United States Code, or in violation of D.C. Code 48–904.01(d)(1); which pardon shall restore to them full political, civil, and other rights.

My intent by this proclamation is to pardon only the offense of simple possession of marijuana in violation of Federal law or in violation of D.C. Code 48–904.01(d)(1), and not any other offenses related to marijuana or other controlled substances. No language herein shall be construed to pardon any person for any other offense, including possession of other controlled substances, whether committed prior, subsequent, or contemporaneous to the pardoned offense of simple possession of marijuana. This pardon does not apply to individuals who were non-citizens not lawfully present in the United States at the time of their offense.

Pursuant to this proclamation, the Attorney General, acting through the Pardon Attorney, shall administer and effectuate the issuance of certificates of pardon to eligible applicants who have been charged or convicted for the offense of simple possession of marijuana in violation of the Controlled Substances Act, as currently codified at 21 U.S.C. 844 and as previously codified elsewhere in the United States Code, or in violation of D.C. Code 48–904.01(d)(1). The Attorney General, acting through the Pardon Attorney, is directed to develop and announce application procedures for certificates of pardon and to begin accepting applications in accordance with such procedures as soon as reasonably practicable. The Attorney General, acting through the Pardon Attorney, shall review all properly submitted applications and shall issue certificates of pardon to eligible applicants in due course.

IN WITNESS WHEREOF, I have hereunto set my hand this sixth day of October, in the year of our Lord two thousand twenty-two, and of the Independence of the United States of America the two hundred and forty-seventh.

_______

- Wikipedia: The Controlled Substances Act.

The Controlled Substances Act (CSA) is the statute establishing federal U.S. drug policy under which the manufacture, importation, possession, use, and distribution of certain substances is regulated. It was passed by the 91st United States Congress as Title II of the Comprehensive Drug Abuse Prevention and Control Act of 1970 and signed into law by President Richard Nixon. The Act also served as the national implementing legislation for the Single Convention on Narcotic Drugs.

The legislation created five schedules (classifications), with varying qualifications for a substance to be included in each. Two federal agencies, the Drug Enforcement Administration (DEA) and the Food and Drug Administration (FDA), determine which substances are added to or removed from the various schedules, although the statute passed by Congress created the initial listing. Congress has sometimes scheduled other substances through legislation such as the Hillory J. Farias and Samantha Reid Date-Rape Prevention Act of 2000, which placed gamma hydroxybutyrate (GHB) in Schedule I and sodium oxybate (the isolated sodium salt in GHB) in Schedule III when used under an FDA NDA or IND.[2][3] Classification decisions are required to be made on criteria including potential for abuse (an undefined term),[4][5] currently accepted medical use in treatment in the United States, and international treaties


________

From Brookings: Congressional candidates’ silence on cannabis reform.

Cannabis reform has grown in popularity with voters, activists, and state legislators; cannabis is now legal for medical use in 38 states and DC and for adult-use in 19 states and DC. Despite those advances in state level reforms and in the broader conversation nationwide, Congress has failed to pass a major piece of legislation addressing the issue, and many voters and activists wonder why.

One argument is that federal level officials—in the executive branch and in Congress—simply don’t care enough about the issue to address it. To consider this question, I included a coding about cannabis reform in Brookings Primaries Project in 2022. The Brookings Primaries Project examines the publicly stated views—via the websites and social media presence—of all candidates running in U.S. congressional primary races. We coded each candidate on a four-point scale: whether they supported legalization or decriminalization of cannabis, whether they supported medical legalization only, whether their position was complex or indecipherable, and whether they failed to mention the issue at all.

The results provide three general takeaways. First, primary candidates for Congress do not consider the issue important enough to elevate to be included on their website or on social media. Second, on average, candidates who do engage on the issue are at least not harmed by staking out a public position. Third, stark differences exist between Democratic primary candidates for Congress and Republican primary candidates for Congress.

More on the Powell Memo

Comments on the once secret memo

- The Powell Memo: A Call-to-Arms for Corporations.

- From Washington and Lee University.

- The Powell Memo with Commentary.

- Time to Fight.

- How the Powell Memorandum changed capitalism — and what we can learn from it today.

- The Legend of the Powell Memo.

- The Myth of the Powell Memo.

There's much more if you are interested.


 

Friday, October 7, 2022

Section Seven - Political Parties and Interest Groups

The two major political organization in the United States and Texas are political parties and interest groups. They are both similar in that they are composed of groups of individuals in order to increase their strength and influence, but there is a major difference between the two. While interest groups seek to influence the decisions made by governing institutions, political parties attempt to control them by competing in and winning elections to office.

Interest Groups: . . . organizations or associations formed by individuals, businesses, or other entities to advocate for specific policies, issues, or interests within a society or political system. These groups are often focused on influencing public policy, legislation, and government decisions in line with their members' objectives. Interest groups can operate at various levels of government (local, state/provincial, national, or international) and across different sectors of society.

Political Parties: . . . an organized group of people who share similar political beliefs and goals, and who seek to influence public policy by getting their candidates elected to public office. Political parties play a central role in representative democracies by offering voters a coherent set of policies and positions on various issues, and by mobilizing support for their candidates during elections.

Collective Action: 

Free Riders:

Selective Incentives:


Lecture Topics

- Collective Action, the Free Rider Problem and Selective Incentives.
- Albany Congress.
- Sons of Liberty.
- First Continental Congress.
- Political Parties.
- Rise of political parties.
- The Two Party System.
- Political Eras / Party Systems of the United States.
- Loyalists v Revolutionaries (Patriots).
- Texas Party Platforms.
- Political Machines.
- Eras - Political Party.
- Voter Turnout. 



Political Parties
- political parties
- interest groups
- collective action
- ambition
- nominations
- recruitment
- GOTV
- providing choices
- candidates
- primaries
- closed
- open
- caucus
- factions
- coalitions
- parties in government
- congress
- majority party
- president
- the judiciary
- parties in the electorate
- party identification
- psychological attachment
- ideological affinity
- tally of experiences
- party activists
- groups
- pluralism
- gender gap
- parties as institutions
- donors
- consultants
- national, state, local organizations
- conventions
- congressional campaign committees
- NRCC, NRSC, DCCC, DSCC
- party systems
- two party system
- winner-take-all
- proportional representation
- party machines
- minor parties
- political parties
- faction
- coalition
- nonpartisan / partisan elections
- winner take all elections
- elite politics
- mass politics
- Democratic Party
- Republican Party
- minor parties
- two party system
- party eras
- minor parties
- party boss
- party machine
- New Deal
- New Deal Coalition
- GOP
- party identification
- straight ticket voter
- split ticket voter
- base voters
- Republican Factions
- Democratic Factions
- party organization
- party platform
- party organization
- party in government
- party in the electorate
- the big tent
- party caucus
- partisanship
- divided government
- conservative
- decentralization
- Duverger's Law
- two party system
- gerrymandering
- Legislative Redistricting Board
- liberal
- New Deal
- partisans
- party competition
- party platform
- reapportionment
- redistricting
- winner-take-all elections



Interest Groups
- organized interests
- unorganized interests
- formal groups
- informal groups
- factions
- interest groups
- lobbies
- collective action
- incentives to not participate
- selective incentives
- lobbying
- think tanks
- public interest
- social movements
- upper class bias
- political participation
- direct participation
- association
- schools of democracy
- deliberation
- pluralism
- membership
- financial structure
- leadership
- staff
- cooperation
- prisoner's dilemma
- free ridership
- problems of large groups
- anonymity, no difference, enforcement
- informational benefits
- material benefits
- solidary benefits
- purposive benefits
- insider strategies
- lobbying
- regulations
- using the courts
- outsider strategies
- going public
- advertising
- social movements
- protests
- electoral politics
- PACs
- independent expenditures
- voter turnout
- voter initiatives
- agency capture
- amicus curiae briefs
- astroturf lobbying
- disclosure
- electioneering
- elite theory
- free rider problem
- grassroots lobbying
- interest groups
- iron triangle
- issue network
- lobbying
- pluralist theory
- private interest groups
- public interest groups
- recuse
- revolving door
- selective benefits
- transactional theory

Labor laws as of 1619 Virginia

I pulled these from the laws discussed in this post below.

First, in detestation of idlers, be it enacted that if any man be found to live as an idler or renegade, though a freed man, it shall be lawful for that incorporation or plantation to which he belongs to appoint him a master to serve for wages till he shows apparent signs of amendment.

. . . As touching the instruction of drawing some of the better disposed of the Indians to converse with our people and to live and labor among them, the assembly, who know well their dispositions, think it fit to enjoin at least to counsel those of the colony neither utterly to reject them nor yet to draw them to come in. But in case they will of themselves come voluntarily to places well peopled, there to do service in killing of deer, fishing, beating corn, and other works, that then five or six may be admitted into every such place and no more, and that with the consent of the Governor, provided that good guard in the night be kept upon them, for generally, though some among many may prove good, they are a most treacherous people and quickly gone when they have done a villainy. And it were fit a house were built for them to lodge in apart by themselves, and lone inhabitants by no means to entertain them.

. . . Be it also enacted that all necessary tradesmen, or so many as need shall require, such as are come over since the departure of Sir Thomas Dale or that shall hereafter come, shall work at their trades for any other man; each one being paid according to the quality of his trade and work, to be estimated, if he shall not be contented, by the Governor and officers of the place where he works.

. . . Be it further ordained by this General Assembly, and we do by these presents enact, that all contracts made in England between the owners of land and their tenants and servants which they shall send hither may be caused to be duly performed and that the offenders be punished as the Governor and Council of Estate shall think just and convenient.

. . . Be it established also by this present assembly that no crafty or advantageous means be suffered to be put in practice for the enticing away the tenants and servants of any particular plantation from the place where they are seated. And that it shall be the duty of the Governor and Council of Estate most severely to punish both the seducers and the seduced and to return these latter into their former places.

. . . That no man living in this colony but shall between this and the first of January next ensuing come or send to the Secretary of State to enter his own and all his servants names and for what term or upon what conditions they are to serve

. . . whatsoever masters or people do come over to this plantation that within one month of their arrival, notice being first given them of this very law, they shall likewise report to the Secretary of State and shall certify him upon what terms or conditions they become hither, to the end that he may record their grants and commissions and for how long time and upon what conditions their servants, in case they have any, are to serve them, and that upon pain of the penalty next above mentioned.

. . . All ministers in the colony shall once a year, namely in the month of March, bring to the Secretary of Estate a true account of all the christenings, burials, and marriages, upon pain, if they fail, to be censured for their negligence by the Governor and Council of Estate; likewise, where there be no ministers, that the commanders of the place do supply the same duty.

. . . All ministers shall duly read divine service and exercise their ministerial function according to the ecclesiastical laws and orders of the Church of England and every Sunday in the afternoon shall catechize such as are not yet ripe to come to the communion. And whosoever of them be found negligent or faulty in this kind shall be subject to the censure of the Governor and Council of Estate.

. . . Be it enacted by the present assembly that whatsoever servant has heretofore or shall hereafter contract himself in England, either by way of indenture or otherwise, to serve any master here in Virginia and shall afterward, against his said former contract, depart from his master without leave or, being once embarked, shall abandon the ship he is appointed to come in and so being left behind shall put himself into the service of any other man that will bring him hither, that then at the same servant’s arrival here, he shall first serve out his time with that master that brought him hither and afterward also shall serve out his time with his former master according to his covenant.

From Wikipedia: List of colonial governors of Virginia

Executive power came first.

- Click here for it. 

Virginia Company of London Governors (1607–1624)

From 1606 until 1624, Proprietary Governors oversaw the operation of the Virginia Colony. Most were styled "President of the Council", although some were styled "governor" by the proprietors.

- President of the Council Edward Maria Wingfield (1607)
- President of the Council John Ratcliffe (1608) 
- Matthew Scrivener (1608)
- President of the Council John Smith (1608–1609)
- President of the Council George Percy (1609–1610)
- Governor Thomas West, 3rd Baron De La Warr (1609–1618)
- Governor Sir George Yeardley (1619–1621)
- Governor Sir Francis Wyatt (1621–1624)

After the Virginia Company of London lost its proprietary charter in 1624, the colony was taken over by the English Crown, and became a crown colony. Governors were appointed by the ruling monarch to oversee the interests of the Crown.

_________

For more on colonial executive power: 

- The Governor’s Council.

The governor’s Council, also known as the Council of State or simply the Council, consisted of about a dozen of colonial Virginia‘s wealthiest and most prominent men. Beginning in the 1630s the Crown appointed Council members, although from 1652 to 1660 the General Assembly elected the members. Crown appointments were lifetime appointments. From 1625, when Virginia became a royal colony, until the outbreak of the American Revolution (1775–1783), the Council members advised the royal governor or his deputy, the lieutenant governor, on all executive matters. The Council and the governor together constituted the highest court in the colony, known initially as the Quarter Court and later as the General Court. The Council members also served as members of the General Assembly; from the first meeting of the assembly in 1619 until 1643 the governor, Council members, and burgesses all met in unicameral session. After 1643 the Council members met separately as the upper House of the General Assembly. The Virginia Constitution of 1776 effectively abolished the governor’s Council and distributed its executive, judicial, and legislative functions to three separate bodies of men.

Lawes Divine, Morall and Martiall

Another set of early laws from Virginia.

- Click here for the document.

- Click here for description.

From the American Historical Review: The Labor Problem at Jamestown, 1607-18

This is behind a paywall, but let's see what we can do with it.

It seems that it took a while to figure out how to get people to work in Jamestown. It would be interesting to see how labor policy progressed from there.

- Click here for the article. 

The intro: 






SpongeBob - Scurvy Ain't For The Likes Of Me

Wednesday, October 5, 2022

The Crying Indian - full commercial - Keep America Beautiful

Cuyahoga River Fire: Cleveland's Burning River Sparks Environmental Revo...

Links - 10/5/22

https://jyfmuseums.org/jamestown-settlement/fashion-in-colonial-virginia/

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tobacco_Master_Settlement_Agreement

https://www.tdi.texas.gov/agent/general-life-apply.html

https://www.kaplanfinancial.com/insurance/texas/state-requirements

https://www.nhtsa.gov/recalls?utm_source=DV&utm_medium=display&utm_content=P2&utm_campaign=Geo

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flat_Stanley

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Safety_glass 

https://www.archives.com/genealogy/president-madison.html#:~:text=James%20Madison%2C%20Jr.,in%201590%20in%20London%2C%20England.

https://www.mbacentral.org/history-of-the-mba/

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_Environmental_Protection_Agency




From Gallup: Most Important Problem

This applies to a few areas of class.

- Click for the article.  

A walk around Historic Jamestown Fort (Jamestown VA)

 


Tuesday, October 4, 2022

- The Powell Memo.

- Lewis Powell. 

- Corporate lawyer.

- United States Chamber of Commerce.

- Tobacco Institute.

- Tobacco industry.

- Consumer movement.

From the Liberty Fund: 1619: Laws enacted by the First General Assembly of Virginia

- Click here for it. 

Examples: 

Against idleness, gaming, drunkenness, and excess in apparel the assembly has enacted as follows.

First, in detestation of idlers, be it enacted that if any man be found to live as an idler or renegade, though a freed man, it shall be lawful for that incorporation or plantation to which he belongs to appoint him a master to serve for wages till he shows apparent signs of amendment.

Against gaming at dice and cards be it ordained by this present assembly that the winner or winners shall lose all his or their winnings and both winners and losers shall forfeit ten shillings a man, one ten shillings whereof to go to the discoverer and the rest to charitable and pious uses in the incorporation where the faults are committed.

Against drunkeness be it also decreed that if any private prsons be found culpable thereof, for the first time he is to be reproved privately by the minister, the second time publicly, the third time to lie in bolts 12 hours in the house of the provost marshal and to pay his fees, and if he still continue in that vice to undergo such severe punishment as the Governor and Council of Estate shall thinke fit to be inflicted on him. But if any officer offend in this crime, the first time he shall receive a reproof from the Governor, the second time he shall openly be reproved in the church by the minister, and the third time he shall first be committed and then degraded. Provided it be understood that the Governor has always power to restore him when he shall, in his discretion, think fit.

Against excess of apparel, that every man be assessed in the church for all public contributions, if he be unmarried according to his own apparel, if he be married, according to his own and his wife’s or either of their apparel.

_____


- Journals of the House of Burgesses 1619- 1658.
- Colonialism / Mercantilism.

- Chartered Companies and the Financing of the Settlement of the American Colonies.

- Walter Raleigh in the New World.

Issues and interests mentioned in Federalist 10

It would be interesting to focus on the evolution of these over American history. 

- religion
- government
- the various and unequal distribution of property
- A landed interest
- a manufacturing interest
- a mercantile interest
- a moneyed interest
- private debts
- creditors
- debtors
- domestic manufactures be encouraged, and in what degree, by
- restrictions on foreign manufactures
- landed
- manufacturing classes
- the apportionment of taxes
- personal security
- rights of property
- paper money
- abolition of debts
- an equal division of property

Links 10/4/22

https://www.regulations.gov/

https://www.govinfo.gov/app/collection/cfr

https://www.lbb.texas.gov/Documents/Publications/Fiscal_SizeUp/Fiscal_SizeUp_2022-23.pdf

http://www.tfsc.state.tx.us/BoardMembers.html

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Death_care_industry_in_the_United_States

https://www.scotusblog.com/case-files/cases/sackett-v-environmental-protection-agency/

https://nwfa.org/

https://www.brazoriacountyclerktx.gov/home/showpublisheddocument/13605/637998094094600000

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Privileges_and_Immunities_Clause

From Wikipedia: Royal African Company

Among the chartered companies that assisted the development of the English colonies. 

- Click here for the entry. 

The Royal African Company (RAC) was an English mercantile (trading) company set up in 1660 by the royal Stuart family and City of London merchants to trade along the west coast of Africa.[1] It was led by the Duke of York, who was the brother of King Charles II and in 1685, York took the throne as James II. The RAC shipped more African slaves to the Americas than any other company in the history of the Atlantic slave trade, and was owned entirely by the British Crown.[2][3]

It was established after Charles II gained the English throne in the Restoration of 1660.[4] While its original purpose was to exploit the gold fields up the Gambia River, which were identified by Prince Rupert during the Interregnum, it soon developed and led a brutal and sustained slave trade.[3] It also extracted other commodities, mainly from the Gold Coast. After becoming insolvent in 1708, it survived in a state of much reduced activity until 1752 when its assets were transferred to the new African Company of Merchants, which lasted until 1821.

First Colonies: 1565-1700 | American Colonial History | Jamestown, Plymo...

Monday, October 3, 2022

From Wikipedia: Kleptocracy

A term commonly used to describe Russia.

Does that make Putin a kleptocrat?

-  Click here for the entry.

Kleptocracy (from Greek κλέπτης kléptēs, "thief", κλέπτω kléptō, "I steal", and -κρατία -kratía from κράτος krátos, "power, rule") is a government whose corrupt leaders (kleptocrats) use political power to expropriate the wealth of the people and land they govern, typically by embezzling or misappropriating government funds at the expense of the wider population. Thievocracy means literally the rule by thievery and is a term used synonymously to kleptocracy. One feature of political-based socioeconomic thievery is that there is often no public announcement explaining or apologizing for misappropriations, nor any legal charges or punishment levied against the offenders.

Kleptocracy is different from plutocracy (rule by the richest) and oligarchy (rule by a small elite). In a kleptocracy, corrupt politicians enrich themselves secretly outside the rule of law, through kickbacks, bribes, and special favors, or they simply direct state funds to themselves and their associates. Also, kleptocrats often export much of their profits to foreign nations in anticipation of losing power.

Links - 10/3/22

- Texas Occupation Code.

- OCCUPATIONS CODETITLE 13. SPORTS, AMUSEMENTS, AND ENTERTAINMENT. 

- City of London.

- History of cartography.

- Clean Water Act.

http://www.uky.edu/~jafine2/nov25.htm

https://avalon.law.yale.edu/17th_century/va01.asp

https://www.supremecourt.gov/

https://www.oyez.org/cases/2005/04-1034

https://news.gallup.com/poll/394103/confidence-supreme-court-sinks-historic-low.aspx

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Occam%27s_razor

https://www.investopedia.com/terms/e/escheat.asp

https://www.scotusblog.com/2022/10/in-a-dispute-over-uncashed-moneygram-checks-delaware-faces-the-ire-of-30-other-states/

https://www.scotusblog.com/case-files/cases/delaware-v-pennsylvania-and-wisconsin/

https://www.businessinsider.com/guides/tech/scam-likely

https://statutes.capitol.texas.gov/?link=PE

https://www.brookings.edu/2022/08/11/the-future-of-crypto-regulation-highlights-from-the-brookings-event/

https://abc13.com/astroworld-aftermath-festival-tragedy-10-people-killed-at-travis-scott-concert-changes-made-after/11769859/

https://www.legalmatch.com/law-library/article/what-is-theft-by-deception.html

https://www.clf.org/blog/fishing-for-a-future/

https://www.insider.com/video-fishermen-erupt-after-tourney-champs-accused-of-cheating-ohio-2022-10

https://carnegieendowment.org/2005/10/18/essence-of-putin-s-managed-democracy-event-819

Anniversary of the final days of Ceaușescu regime

From Scotusblog: EPA’s authority over wetlands is at stake as justices wade back into regulatory morass

 https://www.scotusblog.com/2022/09/epas-authority-over-wetlands-is-at-stake-as-justices-wade-back-into-regulatory-morass/

https://www.scotusblog.com/case-files/cases/sackett-v-environmental-protection-agency/


Sunday, October 2, 2022

 https://texashighways.com/culture/history/the-comanche-trail-in-big-bend-recalls-a-bygone-era-of-tribal-raids-into-mexico/?fbclid=IwAR3qXPCrxdnP1Q3FTey8xqTWihbzgXn4JRvta0jZ4jJ8PaFKW4pw03mx9Tg

From the Texas Tribune: Immigration, abortion and economy expected to take center stage when Abbott, O’Rourke debate Friday

The debate already happened - more on that later - but for 2306 classes, I'd like to discuss which issues seem to work better for which gubernatorial candidate.

- Click here for the article. 

Immigration, abortion, the economy and guns are expected to be major topics of conversation Friday night as Republican Gov. Greg Abbott faces off against his Democratic challenger, Beto O’Rourke, in their only planned debate ahead of the Nov. 8 election.

Abbott, who is seeking a third term in office, is leading in the polls by single-digit margins and will look to push his priority issue of border security to the forefront of the debate, along with the country’s struggling economy under the watch of Democratic President Joe Biden.

O’Rourke, who came within 3 percentage points of unseating Republican U.S. Sen. Ted Cruz in 2018, is expected to attack Abbott’s resistance to gun restrictions after the Uvalde school shooting in May, his record on the state’s electricity grid that led to widespread power outages during last year’s deadly winter freeze and his support of the Legislature’s move to ban nearly all abortions in the state.

“This is a race where a choice between the two candidates could not be more clear,” said Rebecca Deen, a political science professor at the University of Texas at Arlington. “If you think about a Venn diagram, I’m not quite sure if there’s any overlap. So you’re just going to see the two folks appealing to the things that they know their voters want to hear.”

Interview: Attorney David Thompson explains Chapter 313 tax breaks | KVUE

From the Texas Tribune: Tesla among surge of companies rushing to take advantage of Texas’ expiring tax incentive program

An example of business interests. 

- Click here for the article. 

The Austin-based electric car company Tesla wants to leverage an expiring state tax incentive program to build what could be the nation’s first plant that produces battery-grade lithium hydroxide, which electric cars require for energy storage purposes. Tesla applied for a tax break under a state program that would enable the company to potentially avoid millions in property taxes to build the projected $375 million plant in Nueces County.

The program, referred to as Chapter 313 after its section in the state’s tax code, was designed to incentivize businesses to set up shop in Texas by offering 10-year property tax breaks. A bipartisan group of legislators ensured that what has become Texas’ largest corporate tax incentive program would not continue after it’s set to expire at the end of 2022.

The impending end of Chapter 313 has touched off a rush of applicants, state officials testified at a legislative hearing this week, as the state’s energy and manufacturing companies try to lock in massive property tax breaks before time runs out.



What is Chapter 313? 

- From Texas Statutes: TAX CODE CHAPTER 313.
- TEXAS ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT ACT.
- From the Texas Comptollers Office: TAX CODE CHAPTER 313.
- Wikipedia: Texas Tax Code Chapter 313.
- Texas Schools for Economic Development: Chapter 313 Agreements.
- 

Section Six - Suffrage, Elections, Campaigns, etc . . .

In this section we dig further into elections -  the mechanism that is used to tie the people with the government. 

In addition to the mechanics of he electoral process, this involves questions involving who gets to participate, who runs elections, who is allowed to run for office, and how they campaign for office. 

These can be divided into the following topics: 

1 - Suffrage 
2 - Elections 
3 - Voting 
4 - Voter Suppression
5 - Candidates 
6 - Campaigns 
7 - Campaign Consultants
7 - Campaign Finance
8 - The Donor Class

These can be defined as follows: 

1 - Suffrage: "Suffrage, political franchise, or simply franchise is the right to vote in public, political elections and referendums (although the term is sometimes used for any right to vote)."
 
2 - Elections: the formal process of selecting a person for public office or of accepting or rejecting a political proposition by voting.
 
3 - Voting:  a method by which a group, such as a meeting or an electorate, convenes together for the purpose of making a collective decision or expressing an opinion usually following discussions, debates or election campaigns.

4 - Voter Suppression: any legal or extralegal measure or strategy whose purpose or practical effect is to reduce voting, or registering to vote, by members of a targeted racial group, political party, or religious community.

5 - Candidate: A candidate is someone who is being considered for a position, for example someone who is running in an election or applying for a job.

6 - Campaign: an organized effort which seeks to influence the decision making progress within a specific group. In democracies, political campaigns often refer to electoral campaigns, by which representatives are chosen or referendums are decided.

7 - Campaign Consultants: 

8 - Campaign Finance: . . . the funds raised to promote candidates, political parties, or policy initiatives and referendums. Donors and recipients include individuals, corporations, political parties, and charitable organizations.

8 - The Donor Class: . . . a group of individuals or organizations that contribute significant amounts of money to political campaigns or causes. These donors often wield influence over political decision-making processes due to their financial contributions, which can fund advertising, lobbying efforts, and other activities that promote their interests or preferred policies.

Lectures: 

- U.S. Election Code.
- Texas Election Code.
- Is Voting a Right Guaranteed in the U.S. Constitution?
- Information, Disinformation, and Misinformation.
- Suffrage.
- Political Parties and Party Systems.
- Political Eras / Party Systems of the United States.
- Campaign Finance.
- Types of voter suppression.


Terminology

Elections
- elections
- regular elections
- voting
- adverse selection
- moral hazard
- institutions
- election rules
- suffrage
- participation rates
- who votes
- voter turnout
- nonvoters
- the franchise
- voter registration
- the ballot
- the secret ballot
- indirect democracy
- electoral districts
- single members districts
- electoral college
- majority rule
- minority rights
- redistricting
- fairness
- bias
- plurality
- proportional representation
- two party system
- winner take all 
- direct democracy
- referendum
- initiative
- recall
- party loyalty
- issue voting
- prospective voting
- retrospective voting
- spatial issues
- valence issues
- median voter theorem
- candidate characteristics
- campaigns
- campaign finance
- FECA
- media
- winning
- PACs
- Super PACs
- primaries
- general elections
- at large
- closed primary
- disenfranchisement
- early voting
- 15th Amendment
- get out the vote
- incumbents
- microtargeting
- motor voter law
- name recognition 
- negative campaigning
- open primary
- PACs
- Super PACs
- political efficacy
- political socialization
- poll tax
- primary election
- public opinion polling
- partisan election
- non-partisan election
- register
- runoff election
- single-member districts
- special election
- split ticket voting
- straight ticket voting
- Voting Rights Act






GOVT 2306
Assemblies
Parties in the Early Congress
Washington's warnings
Advantages of political parties
Expansion of suffrage
Democrats and the development of Texas
Rise of Republicanism
- business regulation
- civil rights
State parties
Local parties



Terminology

GOVT 2305: WTP - Chapter 8: Campaigns and Elections
advanced or early voting
blanket or wide-open primary
casework
closed primary
credit claiming
cross-filing 
direct primary
disclosure
equal protection clause
general election
grandfather clause
incumbent
independent candidate
literacy test
majority election
Motor Voter Act
open primary
party-line voting
party primary
plurality election
poll tax
position taking
preference primary
primary election
private financing
public financing
roll off
runoff election
second-order elections
suffrage 
voter turnout 
Voting Rights Act of 1965
white primary 

GOVT 2306: LSP - Chapter 9: Political Parties
allocation 
chronic minority
conventions (caucuses) 
county chair 
county or senatorial district convention 
electoral competition model 
executive committee 
grassroots organization 
party machines 
party platform
patronage 
permanent party organizations 
plank 
political party 
precinct chair 
responsible party model 
runoff primary 
state party chair 
straight-ticket voting 
temporary party organizations 

__________

Fall 2022

- What are parties and interest groups? 
- Contract allowing the formation of the Virginia Company
- Elite politics
- Interests highlighted in Federalist #10
- Territorial Expansion
- Free rider problem
- Tragedy of the commons 
- Public and private interests
- Federalists and Democrat - Republicans
- Party eras
- Contemporary politics
- The Powell Memo

Minor v. Happersett (1875)

The effort to continue limits on suffrage, and disenfranchise those who had been - sort of - suffrage picks up steam.

It adds to the argument that there is no guaranteed right to vote if one is a citizen.

- Click here for more.

Minor v. Happersett, 88 U.S. (21 Wall.) 162 (1875),[1] is a United States Supreme Court case in which the Court held that, while women are no less citizens than men are, citizenship does not confer a right to vote, and therefore state laws barring women from voting are constitutionally valid. The Supreme Court upheld state court decisions in Missouri, which had refused to register a woman as a lawful voter because that state's laws allowed only men to vote.

The Minor v. Happersett ruling was based on an interpretation of the Privileges or Immunities Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment. The Supreme Court readily accepted that Minor was a citizen of the United States, but it held that the constitutionally protected privileges of citizenship did not include the right to vote.

The opinion infamously concluded with the poorly crafted statement that "...the Constitution of the United States does not confer the right of suffrage upon anyone". This was clarified in Ex parte Yarbrough 110 U.S. 651 (1884) stating that "the Constitution adopts as the qualification for voters of members of Congress that which prevails in the State where the voting is to be done; therefore... the right is not definitely conferred on any person or class of persons by the Constitution alone, because you have to look to the law of the State for the description of the class. But the court did not intend to say that when the class or the person is thus ascertained, his right to vote for a member of Congress was not fundamentally based upon the Constitution."

The Nineteenth Amendment, which became a part of the Constitution in 1920, effectively overruled Minor v. Happersett by prohibiting discrimination in voting rights based on sex.[2] Minor v. Happersett continued to be cited in support of restrictive election laws of other types until the 1960s, when the Supreme Court started interpreting the Fourteenth Amendment's Equal Protection Clause to prohibit discrimination among citizenry in voting rights.

Saturday, October 1, 2022

 https://www.motherjones.com/politics/2021/02/14th-amendment-section-2-mass-incarceration/

From the Atlantic: Putin’s Newest Annexation Is Dire for Russia Too

The author has some interesting things to say about democracy. I'm especially interested in her use of the term "managed democracy." It seems like something we deal with in the United States as well. 

- Click here for the article. 

It requires a subscription, so I posted it below.

Vladimir Putin today announced his annexation of four provinces of Ukraine—four provinces that he does not fully control, that did not vote to join Russia, that have been the site of mass murder and mass deportation since Russia invaded Ukraine in February. With this statement, the Russian president is also declaring war. But this is not merely a war on Ukraine.

Putin’s war—Russia’s war—is also a war on a particular idea of world order and international law, an idea upheld not just by Europeans and North Americans, but by most of the rest of the world, indeed by the United Nations itself. One core principle of this world order is that larger countries should not be able to grab parts of smaller countries, that mass slaughter of whole populations is unacceptable, that borders have international significance and cannot be changed through violence or on one dictator’s whim. Putin already challenged this idea in 2014, when he annexed Crimea. At the time he also held a sham referendum, but he convinced many outsiders that it had some validity. Although some sanctions followed, the world largely gave him a pass. Commerce and diplomacy with Russia continued.

This time, Putin is no longer able even to pretend that the farcical votes he has staged in Donetsk, Luhansk, Zaporizhzhia, and Kherson have any validity, and no one, anywhere, believes that they do. The simulation was played out: Armed men went house to house collecting so-called ballots, and some people, left destitute by the war, were bribed in exchange for showing up to vote. But in regions where hundreds of thousands of Ukrainian citizens have been evacuated, deported, or murdered, where violent conflict continues and where an active resistance is raging, nothing remotely like an actual vote could ever have taken place. Even as Putin was speaking in Moscow, the Ukrainians announced that they were surrounding and cutting off a large group of Russian soldiers in Lyman, a strategically significant city in Donetsk province.

Russia’s actions under these circumstances show contempt not only for international lawyers in European capitals, but also for Chinese politicians who like to talk about sovereignty and African diplomats who have agreed that borders matter, even when they are arbitrary. In the upside-down reality that Putin has created, he will now claim that Ukrainians, by defending their own land and their own people, are somehow attacking Russia. He will even raise the stakes, will try to frighten Ukraine and the West by calling Ukraine’s self-defense an existential threat to Russia that requires an extraordinary response—perhaps even a nuclear response, echoing a threat he has made repeatedly since he began his invasion.

This annexation is also more specifically a declaration of war against the democratic world, a statement of contempt for democracy itself. Putin has been treating democracy as a tool for decades, using fake parties, creating fake opponents, and rigging elections. For a long time, he and his spin doctors promoted a form of “managed democracy,” a system that allowed some space for public opinion, while at the same time ensuring that he always remained in power. With today’s announcement, he no longer pretends or plays games. This deliberate farce mocks the very idea of referenda, of voting, of popular opinion. Nothing about this act has any legitimacy, and that is also part of the point. In his world, there is no such thing as legitimacy. Only brutality matters.

Finally, this annexation marks the culmination of a two-decade war against any Russians whose vision of their country differs from his. Some of those Russians belong to ethnic minority groups—Dagestanis, Buryat, Tuvans, Crimean Tatars, all of whom have been subject to vigorous mobilization drives, as if Putin wants to use his genocidal war against Ukraine to eliminate them as well. Some simply want to live in a country governed by different rules, a country that does not have murderous designs on its neighbors, a country that is not a menace to the world. Although thousands of such people have fled the country over the past decade, the invasion deliberately sparked a new exodus. Putin’s propagandists have celebrated the departure of anti-war Russians as a form of cleansing; Putin himself has said that the nation should “spit them out like a midge that accidentally flew into their mouths.”

Since the war began, the crackdown at home has also accelerated, because the war provides the context in which dissent can be portrayed as treason, and because any criticism of the war is a crime. Newspapers, websites, social-media channels, and civic groups of all kinds have been shut down. More than 16,400 Russians have been detained in prison for protesting. In the past few days, some protesters have received draft notices after being taken to jail. Others are now the focus of special efforts to undermine and destroy them. Alexei Navalny, the Russian politician who came the closest to creating a grassroots, anti-Putin, prodemocracy movement, received a nine-year jail sentence in May and is now locked in a maximum-security prison. He has spent most of the past several weeks in an isolation cell, as punishment for tiny (or invented) infractions of jailhouse rules. Other inmates are forbidden to speak with him and even to look at him. But his anti-corruption foundation continues to function in exile (I am an unpaid member of its advisory board). And when he was allowed to speak in an internal prison court last week, Navalny responded to Putin’s call for the mobilization of military reservists without mincing words: “It is already clear that the criminal war that is going on is getting worse and deeper, and Putin is trying to involve as many people as possible in this. He wants to smear hundreds of thousands of people in this blood.”

Vladimir Kara-Murza, another opposition politician who has played an important role in campaigning for individual sanctions, is also in prison, where he remains equally defiant. “It continues to amaze me,” he told an interviewer via smuggled messages, “how many serious Western analysts buy the Kremlin’s propaganda on the ‘overwhelming popularity’ of Putin and of the war. If this were true, the authorities wouldn’t need to rig elections, muzzle the media, or imprison and murder their opponents. The Kremlin knows the real situation—and the only thing it has left in the toolbox to prevent protests in Russia is fear.”

Today’s annexation, along with the mobilization that has been launched to defend these occupied territories, has also been designed to increase that fear. The battle against independent thinkers is now expanding beyond Putin’s opponents and is reaching even Russians who felt too distant, too apathetic, or too afraid to protest in the past. If, once upon a time, the threat of the gulag was used to keep all Soviet citizens in a state of permanent fear, the threat of the war in Ukraine is now being used in exactly the same way against Putin’s subjects. The regime is now treating ordinary citizens exactly as if they were expendable prisoners, throwing untrained, poorly equipped men into the battlefield, where some are rumored to have already died. New draftees are being driven to empty fields with no shelter and no food, just as new prisoners were once abandoned in the 1930s to build their own labor camps. Putin, like Stalin, believes that his sinister, unbalanced idea of collective glory matters more than the prosperity, well-being, happiness, and even physical existence of ordinary Russians.

But nothing lasts forever: “Your time will pass,” Navalny told his jailers last week. Kara-Murza, in a prison interview published this week, said the same thing: “None of us knows exactly how and when the Putin regime will end—but we know that it will.”

And they are right. We don’t know how and when it will end. Nor do we know what kind of regime will follow. But there is nothing predestined about Putinism or his form of kleptocratic autocracy. There is nothing “forever” about the annexation of territories that aren’t even under full Russian control, and none of the people who were at the annexation ceremony today will live forever either. Russia’s sham annexation of Ukrainian land will end, whatever false words are spoken this week.

What is a border?