Showing posts with label FISA. Show all posts
Showing posts with label FISA. Show all posts

Saturday, December 29, 2012

The US Senate passes extension of FISA

The House had passed the bill previsously, so its' set for a presidential signature.

FISA stands for the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act which authorizes warrantless searches of communications with suspected spies and terrorists, but concerns exist that it allows open ended monitoring of anyone the government wants to surveil:

Critics of the bill, including Senators Ron Wyden of Oregon, a Democrat, and Rand Paul of Kentucky, a Republican, expressed concern that electronic surveillance, though directed at noncitizens, inevitably swept up communications of Americans as well.

“The Fourth Amendment was written in a different time and a different age, but its necessity and its truth are timeless,” Mr. Paul said, referring to the constitutional ban on unreasonable searches and seizures. “Over the past few decades, our right to privacy has been eroded. We have become lazy and haphazard in our vigilance. Digital records seem to get less protection than paper records.”

But the bill passed by comfortable margins in each chamber:

The bill, which extends the government’s surveillance authority for five years, was approved in the House by a vote of 301 to 118 in September. Mr. Obama is expected to sign the bill in the next few days.

It passed the Senate 73 - 23. Who says government is broken?

Sunday, July 20, 2008

About FISA

Was Congress' decision to pass amendments to the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act, which gave telecom companies immunity from any laws they may have violated while carrying out requests by the Bush Administration, a further erosion of individual liberties or a necessary way to ensure our nation's security? Of course it could be both. The question is whether this erosion is reasonable, or if its a simple power grab on the part of an ambitious executive branch.

In essence the bill stops any court proceedings underway to punish the telecom companies for their actions, so consider this a legislative and executive check on the judiciary.

A key problems faced by republics is how to balance the maximum extent of liberty while also providing for security, which is the central task of any government. Republics have to continually wrestle with this dilemma, and this is what we are currently doing.

I have no answers, but we may wish to cover this issue in class. Here's some background:

- The bill summary from Thomas.
- Bill overview by GovTrack.
- Bill overview by OpenCongress.

The ACLU plans a lawsuit and lists the problems it sees with the bill. Here is a key complaint: [FISA] permits only minimal court oversight. The Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Court (FISA Court) only reviews general procedures for targeting and minimizing the use of information that is collected. The court may not know who, what or where will actually be tapped.

This is a 4th Amendment issue. The ability of the people to control the investigatory powers of government by ensuring that searches are limited by a warrant issued by the judiciary is seemingly negated when the president wants it to be negated. Is this an appropriate way to address a new kind of threat or the typical way that executives grab power? The irony is that this legislation was originally passed in the wake of abuses by the Nixon Administration when domestic spying focused on political organizations. The system was designed to allow for the secrecy necessary to investigate national security matters, but not domestic politics. The question asked is how do we know this restriction is still in place?

Central to this dispute is the role of the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Court. This report prepared by the Congressional Research Service helps outline the court.