Showing posts with label The Speaker. Show all posts
Showing posts with label The Speaker. Show all posts

Sunday, September 25, 2016

From the New York Times: Former House Speaker John Boehner Joins Washington Law Firm

For our look at lobbying and the revolving door.

- Click here for the article.

John A. Boehner, the former speaker of the House who left Congress and his leadership post last year, is joining Squire Patton Boggs, a Washington-based law firm long known for its lobbying work.
However, Mr. Boehner, who served as speaker for four years and as a Republican representative from Ohio for 24 years, will not lobby in his new role at the law firm. Instead, he will serve “as a strategic adviser to clients” in the United States and abroad on global business development, according to the firm’s announcement.
“I left the private sector and got into public service decades ago because I wanted to help remove government barriers to economic growth and job creation, and that’s still the mission that drives me,” Mr. Boehner said in a statement on Tuesday.
This month, Mr. Boehner, a cigarette smoker, was appointed to the board of the tobacco giant Reynolds American, which is currently fending off more regulation of the industry, including regulation of e-cigarettes. He is to serve on the board’s committee for corporate governance, nominating and sustainability.
He has kept a relatively low profile since stepping down from the Republican leadership in September 2015, drawing occasional attention, as when he described Senator Ted Cruz, Republican of Texas, as “Lucifer in the flesh.”
In April, Mr. Boehner made a surprise video appearance with President Obama — with whom he had scorching political battles, including a lawsuit House Republicans filed accusing the president of abuse of his official powers — in a humorous vignette for the annual dinner of the White House Correspondents’ Association.
In it, Mr. Boehner offered a cigarette to President Obama, who once smoked but says he gave it up; he stuck to that stance in the video.
In his new law firm role, Mr. Boehner will not be working with political adversaries but with a cadre of his former staff members. They include two longtime aides, John Criscuolo and Amy Lozupone, who will join the firm, forming a team that also includes the former speaker’s deputy chief of staff, Dave Schnittger, and former policy adviser, Natasha Hammond.

Friday, December 4, 2015

Paul Ryan and John Roberts

The latest on the new Speaker and the not so new Chief Justice.

Here's a bit on the folks he's surrounded himself and his efforts to set an agenda for House Republicans for next year.

- Meet Paul Ryan’s Kitchen Cabinet.
- Paul Ryan, the GOP's Idea Man, Calls for Bold New Ideas.
- Ryan Throws Down Republican Gauntlet in Outlining House Agenda for ’16.
- Paul Ryan Pitches ‘Confidence’ to a Timid GOP.

And few items related to Roberts - notably the unique responsibilities a chief justice has regarding the Supreme Court as an institution.

- Chief Justice John Roberts on taking on a Democratic President (FDR).
- Chief justice favors some when assigning court’s major decisions.
- Chief Justice Likely Helped Set Stage For Nationwide Marriage Equality Decision.
- Ten Years Of The Roberts Court.

Thursday, October 29, 2015

The Hill: Paul Ryan elected Speaker

Now comes the fun part.

- Click here for the story.
Ryan’s election gives House Republicans a chance to hit the reset button. Throughout Boehner’s nearly five years as Speaker, centrist members and Tea Party conservatives were at war with each other over policy and tactics.
Now, it’s all Ryan’s problem.
He has made peace with conservative hard-liners for now, saying he’s open to rules changes that will bring more rank-and-file members into the decision-making process. And Boehner helped “clean out the barn” for Ryan this week, ensuring his successor won’t face any major fiscal crises until after the 2016 election.

“If he’s committed to the process changes that he’s espoused, a honeymoon could last well into the first and second anniversary,” said conservative Rep. Mark Meadows (R-N.C.), who authored a resolution this summer that sparked a debate over whether to oust Boehner from power.
“If the actions follow the rhetoric we’ve heard, it will be a monumental and historic time for the Hill and the way we do business.”
In private meetings, Ryan has told members of the conservative Freedom Caucus he won’t engage in any retaliation against fellow Republicans — a move for which Boehner had famously been known.
And the new Speaker told all of his colleagues Wednesday that he wants the conference to figure out how to reorganize the Steering Committee by Thanksgiving.

For the vote itself, click here.

Wednesday, September 30, 2015

Here's the secret to Boehner's success - as it were.


House Majority Leader Kevin McCarthy is one of the strongest campaign fundraisers in his conference, but he still can't hold a candle to outgoing SpeakerJohn A. Boehner, say Republicans mulling McCarthy as Boehner's successor.
Boehner’s fundraising operation was so extensive and successful — he donated tens of millions to his colleagues and candidates via multiple campaign committees and PACs — that his departure will leave a massive hole in Republican Party and GOP candidate coffers.
McCarthy is a Boehner protégé who has emulated the speaker’s fundraising practices — something that gives him a huge leg up in the contest to replace Boehner.
The only other House Republican considered in McCarthy’s league as a political money rainmaker is House Ways and Means Chairman Paul D. Ryan, a former vice presidential candidate who chairs a fundraising arm of the Republican National Committee known as the Presidential Trust. Ryan has taken himself out of the running for the speakership.
McCarthy has netted $13.1 million for his campaign committee and his personal leadership PAC since the beginning of 2014, according to the Center for Responsive Politics, a nonprofit that tracks political money. In the 2014 election cycle, a lucrative McCarthy joint fundraising committee known as the McCarthy Victory Fund pulled in $4.2 million.
But in that same election cycle, Boehner’s joint fundraising committee netted eight times that amount, with $35.4 million in receipts for the 2014 midterms alone. The Boehner for Speaker joint fundraising committee — a type of campaign account that raises large contributions and divvies them up amongst smaller committees — collected more than $71 million during Boehner’s tenure as speaker, CRP data show.
“The political operation that Speaker Boehner put together, I think, is unmatched, unparalleled,” said Dirk Van Dongen, president of the National Association of Wholesaler-Distributors. “He just raises a phenomenally large sum of money for members of the House and for candidates, and it remains to be seen what the future of the organization will be.”

Monday, September 28, 2015

From the Washington Post: 5 reasons why being Speaker of the House ain’t what it used to be

The rules in Congress have changed dramatically in recent years, so it might be unfair to compare Speaker Boehner with his predecessors. The author argues that the institutional powers that allowed previous speakers to control the House don't exist anymore.

- Click here for the article.

Here's a list of what's changed:

1. Earmarking ban.
2. Politics/ideology trumps loyalty. 
3. More paths to power.
4. The weakening of political parties.
5. Job uncertainty.

From the Intercept: Lobbyists Mourn House Speaker John Boehner's Departure

Not everyone is happy to see Boehner go:

- Click here for the article.

House Speaker John Boehner’s surprise resignation on Friday was reason to celebrate for members of his own caucus who often complained that he let corporate lobbyists exercise undue influence over Congress.
But for lobbyists, Boehner’s announcement was a reason to mourn.
“We are grateful for Speaker Boehner’s leadership in so many areas,” saidChip
Bowling, the chief lobbyist for the corn growers industry. “Speaker Boehner’s departure will leave a hole, to be sure,” said John Engler, a lobbyist who represents the chief executive officers of major American corporations.
Other lobbyists used social media to express grief and salute Boehner’s tenure as Speaker of the House.
. . . Lobbyists enjoy access to establishment politicians of both major parties. But Boehner leaves behind a career that is marked by a particularly extreme coziness with K Street.
He was once caught handing out tobacco industry campaign checks on the House floor before a vote on tobacco legislation.
In 2009, Boehner slowed down House proceedings to allegedly attend the “Boehner Beach Party,” an annual event hosted by lobbyists. Before he became Speaker, Boehner served as the House GOP contact for regular meetings with lobbyists and convened a weekly meeting with lobbyists called the “Thursday Group.”
And for a period of time, Boehner rented a Capitol Hill apartment from a lobbyist.
As he raised millions from corporate political action committees, Boehner encouraged lobbyists to have a direct influence over the policy process. Under Speaker Boehner, the reverse revolving door became a blur, with more and more corporate lobbyists hired to manage the day-to-day business of key congressional committees and to serve as senior staff.
Boehner at one point called on bank lobbyists to be more aggressive when dealing with congressional staff, declaring: “Don’t let those little punk staffers take advantage of you.”

This makes you think he'll land on his feet.

Was this the greatest Speaker of the US House?

Henry Clay-headshot.jpg

Meet Henry Clay.

Do not even think about comparing him to the Grinch.

How good a speaker was John Boehner?

I've yet to make up my mind, but a simple search turns up a lot of articles claiming he was pretty bad. If you are one of my 2305 students and you want to take that option, read through a few. Democrats wont say much nice about him, and neither will more conservative elements of the House Republican Conference, but that's likely more a function of their policy preferences rather than how Boehner was able to manage the institution itself.

I'll add more viewpoints soon - but here's a start:

- Freedom Works: Boehner's Ten Worst Moments as Speaker.
- Forward Progressives: John Boehner Will Go Down As One of the Worst House Speakers in History.
- The Week: How one Tea Partier learned to love John Boehner.
- NYT: Boehner, American Hero.
- The New Yorker: The Pointless Cowardice of John Boehner.
- Fox: Give Boehner a break: GOP Speaker brings real leadership to 114th Congress.
- Fox: Boehner resigns: The one thing you must understand about the Speaker's decision.

I'll add more - it'll be helpful to gather an objective list of the pros and cons of his speakership before making a judgement. In case you are interested, here is a completely unreliable ranking of the top 25 speakers in American history.

- The top 25 from Rankopedia.

It has Henry Clay at the top of the list, he's worth a look.

Friday, September 25, 2015

John Boehner announces plans to resign from Congress at the end of October

In 2305 we discussed internal attempts within the House Republican Conference to remove him as Speaker. He wasn't conservative enough according to some of its members. He's done them - apparently - a favor by stepping down.

Here's some detail:

- Roll Call: Boehner Stuns Colleagues With Resignation Announcement.
- 538: John Boehner Had A Good Run.
- Vox: Speaker John Boehner to resign from Congress.
- Roll Call: Potential Successors to Boehner in Ohio.
- Roll Call: K Street Crushed, Conservatives Elated over Boehner Departure.
- The Hill: McCarthy seen as favorite to succeed Boehner.

Thursday, September 17, 2015

From House.Gov: Origins & Development: From the Constitution to the Modern House

As I'm rewriting my power points I'll incorporate some of this - if not most of this - information in them. The website of the U.S. House of Representatives walks through the development of the U.S. House beginning with the ratification of the Constitution.

- Click here for the page.

It contains a variety of sections related to the parts of the Constitution that affect the design of the chamber. These are especially topic given current events:

- Speaker of the House. Since there's a move underway in the House Republican Conference to unseat John Boehner.
- Power of the Purse. Since the fiscal year is almost over and appropriations bills still need to be passed.
- Investigations and Oversight. Since its habitual for Congress to investigate every aspect of the activities of the president when one different parties control each branch.



Wednesday, September 16, 2015

From Vox: The revolt against John Boehner: Worst. Plan. Ever.

Vox thinks the effort to oust John Boehner from the Speakers chair is unrealistic. They do so by laying out the plan that conservative Republicans have developed to get the job done. It's a good opportunity for 2305 students to look inside the workings of the institution:

The rebels' plan

- Offer a resolution to vacate the speaker's chair (fire the speaker).- Claim that the resolution is "privileged" and thus must come to a vote.*- Pass the resolution with a majority of all 188 Democrats and 29-plus Republicans- Nominate a new Republican speaker within the Republican Conference.- Elect the new Republican candidate with a united Republican vote on the House floor.- Watch with glee as the new speaker forces the Senate and president to agree to the Liberty Caucus agenda, beginning with defunding Planned Parenthood.

- Click here for a look at the likelihood that this plan would work.


Thursday, September 10, 2015

From Vox: Tea Party Republicans want to fire John Boehner

This has been brewing for a while

- Click here for the article.

John Boehner has been through debt-ceiling fights, a government shutdown, and increasingly bitter challenges to his authority. But never has his job as speaker of the House seemed to be in so much jeopardy as right now.
Top Republicans expect that one of Boehner's adversaries within the Republican conference will try to force a vote on whether to dump him from the speakership this fall, according to Politico. If he survives that, which might require support from some House Democrats, many Republicans think Boehner should or will step down at the end of this Congress.

On the surface, it's an odd fix for Boehner to find himself in: He came to Congress as a reformer and rose to the speakership as an antidote to the big-government conservative ways of leaders who pushed the No Child Left Behind and Medicare prescription drug programs into law. He's even presided over a permanent extension of most of the Bush tax cuts and significant reductions in federal spending.
But on a deeper level, Boehner has long been the last sentry for the party, using charm, strategic superiority, and his control over House rules to prevent the Tea Party wing from crashing through the gates of the establishment and putting Washington on total legislative lockdown. That has made Boehner the immediate proxy for the war grassroots conservatives are waging against the GOP's Washington insiders, and his enemies are emboldened by Donald Trump's ability to galvanize an anti-establishment fervor that shows no signs of subsiding.

Wikipedia: Speaker of the United States House of Representatives.

Saturday, March 21, 2015

Catching up with Speaker Boehner


We'll breath a little life into the position of speaker when we get back to class next week.

- Click here for past stories about the position. These are worth a quick review.

And a few current items  regarding Mr. Boehner's leadership. Boehner has been speaker since 2011, and was minority leader from 2007 until then. This despite the fact that he is not well liked - despised might be the right word - by the hard right faction within the Republican Conference. They've attempted occasionally to remove him from office, but none of their proposed replacements have gathered enough support to make the effort successful.

The Constitution says nothing about the role of the Speaker, but it was assumed it would be the presiding officer of the House. With the rise of political parties it became instead the leader of the majority party and instead of managing the entire house, it would try to manage rival interests within the party.

- John Boehner is going to be House speaker in the 114th Congress. Boy was I wrong. A Washington Post writer tries to figure out how Boehner was reelected - rather comfortable as speaker. 
- Republicans: We've Got No Plans to Oust Boehner. Conservatives were angered that Boehner removed language in the bill to fund the Department of Homeland Security cancelling out Obama's executive order on immigration, but saw little point in moving against him. 
- Battle Between House GOP Factions Prompts Budget Vote Delay. The anti-Boehner faction with the conference is making it difficult for deficit and defense hawks within the party to agree on a budget.
- Boehner's New Strategy: Enlist Democrats First, Not Last. This wont make the conservatives in the conference happy. Boehner can easily get moderate legislation passed if he tailors it to get votes from Democrats. He seem to be making that a first option in this legislation on the "doc fix."

Here's an article from 2010 which outlines Boehner's contentious relationship with Republicans affiliated with the Tea Party.

- House Rule: Will John Boehner control the Tea Party Congress?
 

Wednesday, February 12, 2014

From the NYT: House Approves Higher Debt Limit Without Condition

For our look at the budgeting process - though the debt ceiling is more about paying for items that have already been authorized in the budget.

It also gives an opportunity to look at the bill making process, the consequences of a bicameral Congress, parties in Congress, and the Speaker - among other things.

Click here for the article.
Ending three years of brinkmanship in which the threat of a devastating default on the nation’s debt was used to wring conservative concessions from President Obama, the House on Tuesday voted to raise the government’s borrowing limit until March 2015, without any conditions.

The vote — 221 to 201 — relied almost entirely on Democrats in the Republican-controlled House to carry the measure and represented the first debt ceiling increase since 2009 that was not attached to other legislation. Only 28 Republicans voted yes, and only two Democrats voted no.

Simply by holding the vote, Speaker John A. Boehner of Ohio effectively ended a three-year Tea Party-inspired era of budget showdowns that had raised the threat of default and government shutdowns, rattled economic confidence and brought serious scrutiny from other nations questioning Washington’s ability to govern. In the process, though, Mr. Boehner also set off a series of reprisals from fellow Republican congressmen and outside groups that showcased the party’s deep internal divisions.

. . .The vote was a victory for President Obama, Democrats and those Senate Republicans who have argued that spending money for previously incurred obligations was essential for the financial standing of the federal government. “Tonight’s vote is a positive step in moving away from the political brinkmanship that’s a needless drag on our economy,” Jay Carney, the White House press secretary, said in a statement.

But outside Republican groups were sharply critical of the speaker. Both the Club for Growth and Heritage Action for America, for example, had put out a “key vote” alert urging members to vote against the measure.

“A clean debt ceiling is a complete capitulation on the speaker’s part and demonstrates that he has lost the ability to lead the House of Representatives, let alone his own party,” said Jenny Beth Martin, co-founder of the Tea Party Patriots. “It is time for him to go.”

Wednesday, October 2, 2013

From Bloomberg: Jim DeMint, Congressional Republicans' Shadow Speaker

Bloomberg Businessweek argues that recently resigned Senator Jim DeMint - who now heads the Heritage Foundation - is the de facto Speaker of the House - or at least the guy who helps determine its agenda far more than John Boehner.

They describe how he developed the idea of using the continuing resolution process to defund Obamacare and has been pitching the idea for months. Many Republicans in Congress have been opposed to doing so, but DeMint appears ready to play hardball:

Many Republicans looked on in horror as the defund movement gained steam. If the government shuts down, polls suggest blame will fall most heavily on the GOP. North Carolina Senator Richard Burr calls DeMint’s plan “the dumbest idea I’ve ever heard.” Representative Tom Cole, a veteran Oklahoma Republican, has likened the shutdown threat to “putting the gun to your own head. You’re basically saying, do what I want or I’ll shoot.” DeMint doesn’t see why his ploy should hurt Republicans. “Democrats will be shutting down the government to protect Obamacare,” he insists. As DeMint sees it, if Republicans would just toughen up and start singing from the same hymnal, public opinion might swing to their side. And if they won’t, he plans to turn his legions of supporters inside and outside of government against them.

The story highlights a growing division within the Republican Party, a fight over how to regain power, and suggests that the current level of dysfunction in Congress is due to this internal conflict:

When most Americans look at Washington, they see a broken Congress, riven by partisanship and lurching from crisis to crisis. While the hostility between Republicans and Democrats is indeed severe, it isn’t the real reason the engine of government keeps seizing up. What’s causing the malfunction is a battle within the GOP over how to return the party to its former glory after two consecutive losses to Obama and setbacks in the House and Senate. It’s a fight that pits uncompromising, Heritage-style conservatives against more cautious Republican elders. What makes it so contentious is that both sides have radically different—and mutually exclusive—ideas about how to move forward.

Boehner and his allies want to avoid direct confrontation. DeMint and company do not. DeMint also seems to be building one of the external organizations that may have more influence on the positions taken by Republican members of Congress than their elected leaders.

From Wonkblog: Why Boehner doesn’t just ditch the hard right?

Here's a good insiders look at the difficulty the Speaker is facing managing the Republican Caucus.

Party leaders don't have the tools they once had to build cohesion in their parties. External forces are gaining strength, which tempers the argument that parties are the dominant institution within Congress.

Key bit from the interview in the story I linked to above:

What we're seeing is the collapse of institutional Republican power. It’s not so much about Boehner. It’s things like the end of earmarks. They move away from Tom DeLay and they think they're improving the House, but now they have nothing to offer their members. The outside groups don't always move votes directly but they create an atmosphere of fear among the members. And so many of these members now live in the conservative world of talk radio and tea party conventions and Fox News invitations. And so the conservative strategy of the moment, no matter how unrealistic it might be, catches fire. The members begin to believe they can achieve things in divided government that most objective observers would believe is impossible. Leaders are dealing with these expectations that wouldn't exist in a normal environment.

Monday, September 30, 2013

The Hastert Rule

Here is one of the factors driving dysfunction in Congress.

Despite the fact that we assume we are a majoritarian democracy there are many places were the will of the majority - which tends to be understood as the will of the people is thwarted. One of the many areas this happens is in the US House of Representatives where the majority of House members do not determine what comes to the floor of the chamber - rather it is a majority of the majority party that matters.

Theoretically this means that 117 members can prevent the preferences of the remaining 318.

The Republican Conference tends to use this rule when in charge. It has been called the Hastert Rule after Speaker Dennis Hastert who was speaker from 1999 - 2007, and also the majority of the majority rule. Other Speakers have also adhered to the rule.

- Hastert was quoted as saying that his job as Speaker was to please the majority of the majority.

There is nothing set in stone about the rule, but it argued to be an effective way to keep House Republicans cohesive, though it does not encourage bi-partisanship.

Related stories:

- Hastert rule not working.
- The absurdity of the Hastert Rule.
- What the rule tells us about House Republicans.

Sunday, September 29, 2013

What exactly does a Speaker do anyway?

I though this list from a helpful stranger named Jack on Yahoo answers was worth sharing:

There was a time when Speakers of the House were all powerful. Those days are long gone. Nevertheless, Speakers still possess a few formidable powers worth noting:

1. The Speaker is the chair of the steering committee that chooses all committee chairs.

2. The Speaker directs all bills to their respective committees. (This is a HUGE power -- as if the Speaker hates the bill he can send it to a committee he knows will kill it -- or vice versa).
3. The Speaker is personally responsible for elevating members to the all powerful (and never to be messed with) "Rules Committee". 
4. The Speaker is responsible for organizing floor debates, ruling on the acceptability of floor motions, and recognizing members who wish to address the House. 
5. In any dealings with the Senate, the Speaker appoints all members of conference committees. 
6. Because of all of these things, the Speaker is the agenda setter of the House. What bills are heard? What bills simply get thrown away? What policies do we wish to impact, and how? These are all questions that only the Speaker gets to answer.

I'll keep posting criticisms of the Speaker Boehner's job performance, but this gives us a guideline for evaluating him.

Its important to keep in mind that while the Speaker is meant to preside over the entire House - and is elected by the entire House - each party nominates its leader for the position. Obviously the party which holds the majority will win, so the Speaker is less a neutral presiding officer than an advocate for the interests of the majority party.

Saturday, September 28, 2013

If Boehner is ousted he won't be the first Republican Speaker to suffer that fate

The Week tells us its actually common, Democrats have been less likely to do so - surprising since Democrats have traditionally been argued to be less cohesive than Republicans (though this seems less the case now).
House Republicans have had a propensity, throughout the 20th century, for periodically getting rid of their leaders. 

Tossing out a speaker is in many ways a drastic measure because, unlike other congressional leaders, the Speaker of the House has demonstrable power over the institution. In one of the many ironies of American politics, the House of Representatives, which was intended to channel voters' opinions, has been a top-down, leadership driven branch of government, in contrast to the historical every-Senator-for-himself model on the other side of the Capitol. Due to this top-down structure, the speaker, unlike the majority leader of the Senate (frequently referred to derisively as the majority pleader), can bend the chamber to his or her will. 
Nevertheless, speakers occasionally have had to ward off intra-party threats to their power. These attacks are unusual — in The Ambition and the Power, John Barry compares overthrowing a speaker or minority leader to regicide. And, perhaps surprisingly, all of the successful overthrows have been on the Republican side of the aisle.
The most notable of which was Newt Gingrich, who was originally revered for leading the party back to the promised land of the majority after 40 years in the minority, but then had a very rocky tenure. Gingrich was forced out right after the party's unexpectedly poor showing in 1998.