Showing posts with label loose construction. Show all posts
Showing posts with label loose construction. Show all posts

Monday, April 25, 2016

From Supreme Court Review: Justice Kennedy's Jurisprudence

For a discussion of how Anthony Kennedy approaches the Constitution:

- Click here for the article.

It was clear from Kennedy's confirmation hearing that he was not an originalist, as was Bork or Scalia: he testified at his confirmation hearing: "Over time, the intentions of the framers are more remote from their particular political concerns, and so they have a certain purity and a certain generality now that they did not have previously . . . it sometimes takes humans generations to become aware of the moral consequences of their own conduct. That does not mean that moral principles have not remained the same."
For Kennedy, the liberties in the constitution are not strictly limited to the way they would have been applied at the time of the adoption of the constitution, rather they are general moral principles that may require different applications as time passes in order to maintain the generalized concepts of individuality, liberty and dignity that the framers memorialized in the constitution.
Because Justice Kennedy's philosophy is not as capable of being pigeonholed as other justices, Justice Kennedy has often confounded legal scholars who have attempted to extrapolate a rule-oriented jurisprudence from Justice Kennedy's decisions. In general, however, one can say that Justice Kennedy is reliably conservative in most areas except in cases involving individual rights. For example, Kennedy has consistently departed from his conservative colleagues in gay rights cases.

For more:

- Living in Anthony Kennedy’s World.
- Anthony M. Kennedy: A Study of His Judicial Opinions.
- Anthony Kennedy turns moderation into power.
- The Key to Justice Kennedy? Why, It’s Liberty!

Here text from the last link:

The key to Justice ­Kennedy’s votes, Mr. Colucci says, is his moral ­reading of the Constitution: He sees the document as an unfolding story of ever greater individual liberty. Thus he ­opposes laws that abridge sexual ­freedom, including laws against homosexual conduct. If an originalist reading of the Constitution does not reveal such a liberty—relying on the received meaning of the ­Constitution’s words at the time they were ­written—Justice Kennedy’s moral ­reading does. But he is skeptical of race-conscious ­programs, too, because they treat applicants as members of a group rather than as individuals who possess the right to be free from group-based policies or rules.
. . . Most valuably, Mr. Colucci shows Justice Kennedy’s judicial philosophy to be a deeply rooted one and not, as one might suspect, the result of varied decisions that require a casuist or law professor to make coherent. He unearths a speech from 1986 in which Justice Kennedy (then an appeals-court judge) criticized ­Bowers v. Hardwick, a case in which the Supreme Court upheld a conviction for sodomy. At the time the judge did not argue, as others had, that the decision ­violated the right to privacy minted more than a ­decade before in Roe v. Wade. He argued instead that the liberty interests of gay Americans had been breached. In 2003, the court overruled Bowers v. Hardwick, and Justice Kennedy wrote the majority opinion using the rhetoric of liberty rather than privacy.

Sunday, February 21, 2016

From Ozy: A CHERISHED RIGHT THAT WAS ALMOST NEVER BORN

The right to privacy is not in the Constitution. For some this is sufficient to maintain that it does not exist. Other argued that it exists in the loose language of clearly stated rights in the Bill of Rights. Scalia was no fan of the right since it did not fit his preferred means of interpreting constitutional language.

Here's the story of how the right was claimed in the case of Griswold v Connecticut.

- Click here for it.
For 50 years, thanks to the Supreme Court’s landmark decision in Griswold v. Connecticut, Americans have enjoyed a constitutional right to privacy. That right, nowhere expressly mentioned in the Constitution but now relied upon by millions, has since been invoked to cover everything from contraception to abortion to gay rights, helping to ignite a raging culture war along the way. But few realize that this right, considered by some a “bedrock principle” of American law — and one that has prevented countless unwanted pregnancies and births over the past half century — came very close to never being born.
In fact, just two months before the Supreme Court issued its controversial decision in Griswold on June 7, 1965, the embryonic right was mostly confined to the scribblings of a 66-year-old jurist. Shortly after being assigned to write the majority opinion in the case, Justice William O. Douglas, a committed civil libertarian who authored 1,164 opinions in 36 years on the Court, had sketched out a first draft — a mere six typewritten pages in length. 
. . . None of the nine men sitting on the Supreme Court thought Connecticut’s 1879 anti-contraception law, both prohibiting the use of contraceptives and abetting that use, was a sensible law (in his dissent, Justice Potter Stewart called it “uncommonly silly”). But the problem was finding something in the Constitution that agreed, a task willingly undertaken by the seven-justice majority. Douglas’ solution, cobbled together like an all-you-can-justify meal from a Bill of Rights buffet, was ingenious and somewhat laughable — and one reason Griswold has since become a lighting rod for those decrying the court’s judicial activism.
According to Douglas, the specific guarantees enunciated in the Bill of Rights “have penumbras, formed by emanations from those guarantees that help give them life and substance,” and the “right to marital privacy” violated by the Connecticut statute emanated from the “zones of privacy” created by several constitutional amendments, including the first (free association), third (prohibition on the quartering of troops), fourth (searches and seizures) and ninth (other rights retained by the people).
When Douglas’ draft opinion was circulated, says Garrow, the clerks in other chambers were shocked at how thin it was, and the references to “penumbras” and “emanations” elicited more than a few sniggers. Could such an unorthodox opinion command a majority of the court? Even Chief Justice Earl Warren, the court’s liberal lion who had assigned Douglas the opinion, was hesitant to sign on. One of Warren’s clerks, John Hart Ely, later a preeminent constitutional scholar, wrote him a 30-page memo on the case. “No matter how strong a dislike for a piece of legislation may be,” Ely counseled, “I do not think the Court should enforce clauses which are not there.”

Tuesday, September 1, 2015

The next round in the battle between Texas and the EPA

The Texas Tribune reports on the latest chapter of the never ending conflict between the government of Texas and the United States Environmental Protection Agency. More specifically, its between the business interests within the state of Texas which focus on extracting and processing natural resources and heavily influence that activities of the state government and the environmental forces that look to minimize the side effects of those processes and are represented on the national level.

It's classic federalism.

- Click here for the article: Judge Casts EPA Rule into Muddy Legal Waters.

After a setback in court Thursday, can the federal government enforce its controversial "Waters of the U.S." rule in Texas?

The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency says yes. Texas says no.
The agency on Friday said the regulation, aimed at better defining the scope of bodies of water protected under the federal Clean Water Act, took effect in Texas and several other states, rankling Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton.

The confusion started Thursday. Hours before the regulation was set to take effect, U.S. District Court Judge Ralph Erickson of North Dakota granted a request from 13 states — not including Texas — to block the rule, which would allow the federal government to regulate small streams and wetlands.

The debate over the EPA rule has to do with what the term "navigable waters" means, as well as the extent of the judges decision regarding the implementation of the rule.

For background over the question of what "navigable waters" means click on the following:

- EPA Seeks to Clarify Federal Water Law.

In 2000, when the Chevron Pipe Line Co. spilled 126,000 gallons of oil into a creek in West Texas, no water was flowing in the tributary. When the federal government sued the company under the Clean Water Act, though, a federal trial court judge ruled in the company's favor, arguing that the oil had not reached “navigable” water.

The EPA said that the clarifications the agencies are seeking do not add new bodies of water to its jurisdiction, they just explain that both wetlands and intermittent streams that often dry up in the summer are included in the act's definition.

“It is universally understood that term ("navigable water") includes many kinds of non-navigable waters,” said Jon Devine, senior attorney at the Natural Resources Defense Council. “The agencies are seeking to protect those water bodies that have a significant affect on waters that are navigable.”
But opponents of changing the federal rules say the EPA is overstepping its bounds, and that it could damage private property rights in the process.
“This potentially could allow for the federal government to require a permit to do anything on your land,” said Steve Pringle, legislative director of the Texas Farm Bureau. The Farm Bureau Federation is one of 29 groups in the Waters Advocacy Coalition that is lobbying against the EPA changes on behalf of the construction, mining, agricultural and energy interests.

Before 2001, the EPA and the Army Corps of Engineers believed the Clean Water Act protected almost all of the waters in the U.S. But in 2001 the U.S. Supreme Court ruled that the Clean Water Act did not protect an abandoned sand and gravel pit that had evolved into permanent and seasonal ponds — and that a solid waste agency wanted to fill.

A 2006 Supreme Court case in which a plaintiff filled 22 acres of Michigan wetland with sand in preparation for the construction of a mall only added to the confusion. The plaintiff argued that since the land was 20 miles from a navigable waterway, he wasn't breaking the law. The high court did not reach a majority opinion and remanded the case to a lower court; in that case, the Supreme Court justices each wrote individual opinions of what constituted "navigable waters."
“That Supreme Court case created mass confusion. It created room for additional defenses," said Daniel Cooper, a partner at Lawyers for Clean Water, which supports the proposed changes. "Clearly this will create more clarity of what is covered by the Clean Water Act. I think this will decrease the amount of litigation.”

Thursday, September 11, 2014

How to interpret the Constitution



We talked about this a bit in a couple classes. Disputes over interpretation are covered in the last few slides in section 6 where we take an overview of the Constitution. We hit these controversies in later sections of the class - but here's a novel take on the dispute.

- Click here for more from Troubletown.

Tuesday, March 18, 2014

More on the Fair Housing Act and discrimination based on physical ability

The previous post includes a story that mentions the Fair Housing Act and discrimination based on physical disabilities, so here's background since it's related to civil rights policy. We don't much time - if any really - on housing discrimination since this is a survey class, but here's an opportunity to learn a bit about it since its topical. This is a bit of a loose timeline - but hopefully its instructive.

- Title VIII of the Civil Rights Act of 1968 is the Fair Housing Act which was the law that made discrimination in the sale, rental and financing of housing based on a variety of factors including race and gender. It is intended to protect buyers and renters from discriminatory practices by landlords, sellers and financiers. As with previous civil rights legislation, it was driven into law by the Johnson Administration and was passed soon after Martin Luther King's assassination.

- The law is implemented primarily by allowing people to sue those they allege are discriminating against them. Which allows the Supreme Court to weigh in on the merit of these suits. An unsympathetic court can throw them out.

- These lawsuits are assisted by the Department of Housing and Urban Development and specifically the Office of Fair Housing and Equal Opportunity. Click here for how to file a housing discrimination complaint. And click here for a statement of your rights to fair housing.

- This was expanded in 1988 to include discrimination against people with disabilities as well as families with children.

- The law was weakened in the late 1980s by making it more difficult to prove discrimination. The Supreme Court has also narrowed the definition of disability in several key Supreme Court cases. Click here for a review of these cases.

- Discrimination against the disabled was expanded substantively in the Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990.

- This lead to a question: What is the legal definition of a disability? "...A physical or mental impairment that substantially limits a major life activity." What does "substantially limits" mean?

- In Sutton v. United Airlines, the court ruled that it was acceptable for the airline to not hire pilots with poor eyesight even if glasses made their vision acceptable. Since the vision could be corrected, it did not "substantially limit" their life activity. They could be discriminated against. One does not a have a disability if there can be a corrective device - like a prosthesis - that allows for some degree of compensation.

- This was based on the courts interpretation of the original language of the ADA, so the language was altered in amendments passed in 2008:
In 2008, effective January 1, 2009, the ADAAA broadened the interpretations and added to the ADA examples of "major life activities" including, but not limited to, "caring for oneself, performing manual tasks, seeing, hearing, eating, sleeping, walking, standing, lifting, bending, speaking, breathing, learning, reading, concentrating, thinking, communicating, and working" as well as the operation of several specified major bodily functions. The Act overturns a 1999 U.S. Supreme Court case that held that an employee was not disabled if the impairment could be corrected by mitigating measures; it specifically provides that such impairment must be determined without considering such ameliorative measures. Another court restriction overturned is the interpretation that an impairment that substantially limits one major life activity must also limit others to be considered a disability
- The Fair Housing Act has not been expanded to ban discrimination based on sexual orientation or gender identity.

If you are interested:
- The Disability Rights Movement.
- Timeline of disability rights in the United States.

Tuesday, September 10, 2013

The Pacificus-Helvidius Debate

Despite the fact that James Madison and Alexander Hamilton worked together on both the drafting of the Constitution and the campaign to get it ratified, they soon started to disagree with each other over aspects of the document - including the relative powers of the legislative and executive branches over foreign policy making, including war making powers.

Like the Federalist Papers, this argument was carried out in dueling essays, this time Madison and Hamilton were on opposing sides of the issue.

They were called the Pacificus-Helvidius Debates.

Here's a description of the debates from the Liberty Fund:

The Pacificus-Helvidius Debates of 1793–1794 matched Hamilton and Madison in the first chapter of an enduring discussion about the proper roles of executive and legislative branches in the conduct of American foreign policy. Ignited by President Washington’s Neutrality Proclamation of 1793, which annulled the eleventh article of America’s Treaty with France of 1778, the debate addressed whether Washington had the authority to declare America neutral, despite an early alliance treaty with France. Hamilton argued that Washington’s actions were constitutional and that friction between the two branches was an unavoidable, but not harmful, consequence of the separation of powers. Madison countered that Washington’s proclamation would introduce “new principles and new constructions” into the Constitution and contended that “the power to declare war and make treaties can never fall within the definition of executive powers.” In the introduction, Morton Frisch asserts that the debate between Hamilton and Madison helped to clarify “certain constitutional principles that we now associate with executive power generally” such as that foreign policy is essentially an executive function. Yet it is the open-ended character of our Constitution that has continued to allow different interpretations of the limits of the powers of government, a debate that continues to this day. Frisch writes in the introduction, “The open-ended character of some of the constitutional provisions afforded opportunities for extending the powers of government beyond their specified limits. Although not given prior sanction by the Constitutional Convention, such additions served to provide a more complete definition of powers without actually changing the ends of government.”

Click here for more on the debates. I find it interesting - and instructive - that we've been arguing about the nature of war making powers as long as we have.

Thursday, September 27, 2012

From Balkanization: B.U. Symposium on Living Originalism and The Living Constitution

For our ongoing look at disputes about how the Constitution ought to be interpreted. Here are a variety of takes on whether it should be though of as a dynamic document that ought to evolve with the times.

Worh a look: The Roots of the Living Constitution.

Tuesday, September 11, 2012

Should the national government promote scientific research?

Jim Cooper - a member of Congress from Tennessee says yes:

The United States may now risk falling behind in scientific discoveries as other countries increase their science funding. We need to get serious about science. In fact, maybe it’s time for researchers to fight back, to return a comeback for every punch line.

Toward that end, we are announcing this week the winners of the first Golden Goose Awards, which recognize the often-surprising benefits of science to society. Charles H. Townes, for example, is hailed as a primary architect of laser technology. Early in his career, though, he was reportedly warned not to waste resources on an obscure technique for amplifying radiation waves into an intense, continuous stream. In 1964, he shared the Nobel Prize in Physics with Nikolay Basov and Alexander Prokhorov.

Similarly, research on jellyfish nervous systems by Osamu Shimomura, Martin Chalfie and Roger Y. Tsien unexpectedly led to advances in cancer diagnosis and treatment, increased understanding of brain diseases such as Alzheimer’s, and improved detection of poisons in drinking water.
Its worth pointing out that there is no "scientific research clause" in the Constitution, so justifying this activity requires a loose reading of constitutional language.

Thursday, December 22, 2011

Does Gingrich have a good point regarding the courts?

Newt Gingrich's recent criticisms of the judiciary have angered some, but Eric Posner thinks he makes a reasonable point. As we continue to wade through the Constitution, its appropriate to wonder who has the last word on the document's meaning. The Constitution itself says nothing about who gets to decide this, though Alexander Hamilton sides with the judiciary on the subject and lays out his argument in Federalist #78.

Give it a read.

Friday, October 21, 2011

What is a "natural born citizen?"

Now that birthers seem to be unable to pursue legitimate claims that President Obama was not born in the United States, they have turned their attention - ironically - to a Tea Party favorite - Florida Senator Marco Rubio. Here's the issue:

. . . the activists are not challenging whether Rubio was born in Miami. Rather, they say Rubio is ineligible under Article 2 of the Constitution, which says "no person except a natural born citizen … shall be eligible to the Office of President."

The rub is that "natural born citizen" was never defined.

The birthers rely on writings at the time of the formation of the republic and references in court cases since then to contend that "natural born" means a person born to U.S. citizens. Rubio was born in 1971 at Cedars of Lebanon Hospital, his office said, but his parents did not become citizens until 1975.

"Marco Rubio was born a Cuban citizen via his parents," screams a headline on a blog by birther Charles Kerchner, who obtained copies of the naturalization petitions by Rubio's parents in May, igniting talk that is spreading across the Internet.

Kerchner said Rubio is no different from Obama, who even if he was born in Hawaii (which he doubts) was not born to two U.S. citizens. Obama's father was a Kenyan national. The birthers say Louisiana Gov. Bobby Jindal, whose parents are from India and were not citizens at the time of his birth, is also unqualified.

Monday, September 26, 2011

From Balkinization: The Whole Constitution Pledge

Progressives are trying to counter Tea Party efforts - refered to below - to influence how people read the Constitution:

Tea Party activists claim to love the Constitution, except for all the parts of our nation’s foundational document that they would prefer to ignore or repeal outright. Dismissing the full story of our Constitution, including the 27 Amendments ratified by the American people over the last 220 years, these self-professed “constitutional conservatives” have distorted the Constitution beyond all recognition, cherrypicking the parts of the document they like, and jettisoning the rest. To take back America’s charter from the Tea Party, Constitutional Progressives – an initiative launched by the Constitutional Accountability Center and supported by numerous other organizations concerned with protecting the constitutional rights of all Americans – have urged all Americans to pledge to support the whole Constitution.
it continues . . .

Saturday, September 17, 2011

From the NYT: On Day Devoted to Constitution, a Fight Over It

This is an appropriate opinion piece for 2301 - and is applicable to 2302 - considering our focus on Constitutional meaning. There is a current battle underway between Tea Party members and others about how the document should be interpreted.

Sunday, August 28, 2011

Texas Tribune: High Court Approves "Pole Tax" on Strip Clubs

A story that touches on the first amendment, checks and balances, and the judicial system:

The Texas Supreme Court has unanimously ruled that a $5-per-patron tax on strips clubs does not violate the First Amendment, adding the latest chapter to a four-year legal battle.

After the 2007 Legislature passed the law known as the Sexually Oriented Business Fee Act — or the "pole tax" in the vernacular — strip club owners challenged the fee in court. They argued it violated their freedom of expression under the First Amendment.

But the court today disagreed, saying that the fee was directed not at the expression of nude dancing, but at the "secondary effects of nude dancing when alcohol is being consumed." Adult entertainment businesses can "avoid the fee altogether simply by not allowing alcohol to be consumed," according to the decision written by Justice Nathan Hecht.

How ought we interpret the Constitution's patent clause.

From The Hill, debate over "H.R. 1249, a bill that would mark the first major overhaul of U.S. patent laws in several decades."

At issue is whether changing the U.S. system from a "first-to-invent" system to a "first-inventor-to-file" system violates Article 1, Section 8, Clause 8 of the Constitution. That clause grants Congress the power to "promote the Progress of Science and useful Arts, by securing for limited Times to Authors and Inventors the exclusive Right to their respective Writings and Discoveries."

Supporters of the bill, called the
America Invents Act, argue that moving to a "first-inventor-to-file" system is in line with the Constitution and also has the benefit of moving the U.S. closer to the "first-to-file" system that most of the rest of the world uses.

"The bill's inclusion of a move to a first-inventor-to-file system is absolutely consistent with the Constitution's requirement that patents be awarded to the inventor," House Judiciary Committee Chairman Lamar Smith (R-Texas) argued.

But several Republicans and Democrats objected, arguing that the proposed change would put in place a new requirement that inventors file for their patents first in order to be awarded rights that they should already have under the Constitution by having invented a novel product or process.

Recent controversy has kicked up over the patent process, especially the recent tendency of patent trolls to purchase patents and hunt around for anyone who might  - even loosely - be violating it.

Thoughts about the bill:

- The America Invents Act (HR 1249) – A Bad Law That Will Change Your Life.
- Rep Conyers Speaks Out Against HR 1249.
- House Debate on Constitutionality of H.R. 1249 – America Invents (NOT) Act.

Do we need FEMA?

Ron Paul doesn't think so. This raises a question worth discussing in class: Should the federal government be involved in disaster assistance? And if so, since there is no disaster relief clause in the Constitution, what is the constitutional basis for that power?

Some related reads:

- Wikipedia: FEMA.
- FEMA: FEMA History.
- For the conspiracy minded: FEMA - The Secret Government.
- Mike Lee: Federal Disaster Relief Is Unconstitutional. 

Sunday, August 7, 2011

Friday, July 22, 2011

The Founders, Taxes, and the National Debt

Here's an argument that the founders - at least those who supported the ratification of the Constitution - did so with the idea that it would be better able to tax, and assume the debt necessary to develop projects that would enhance the safety and well being of the nation.

I'll track down counter-arguments.

Thursday, June 23, 2011

What does "Lawfully Detained" Mean?

The Texas Tribune has a story today on what may be unintended consequences of the "sanctuary cities" legislation: the deportation of children brought to the country illegally by their parents, but are now excelling in school. If they are lawfully detained, they may be asked about their immigration status, but what exactly does that phrase mean? It's not just about being arrested, but can relate to almost any interaction one might have with a police officer.

There are concerns the law might not be used to simply focus on people deemed dangerous, but those that Texas might wish to retain. Supporters of the legislation are attempting to ensure the language will not lead to its arbitrary and capricious use.

In both 2301 and 2302 we tough on interpretation of law and constitutional language. Here's an example.