Showing posts with label trials. Show all posts
Showing posts with label trials. Show all posts

Thursday, March 30, 2017

From the Texas Tribune: Judge orders Ken Paxton trial moved out of Collin County and delayed

For 2306, and our look at the executive and judicial branches - and the criminal justice system.

- Click here for the article.

The judge in the securities fraud case against Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton has ruled that the trial should be moved out of Collin County and delayed.

The ruling to change venue is a major victory for prosecutors, who had argued Paxton and his allies had tainted the jury pool in Collin County, where he lives.

Judge George Gallagher said the trial, initially scheduled for May 1, will now be postponed until a new venue is determined.
Gallagher on Thursday denied two other motions: to dismiss the case and to delay it until prosecutors can get paid.

Paxton is accused of misleading investors in a company from before his time as attorney general, a legal saga that began more than a year ago. He recently beat a federal, civil case involving similar allegations, but the state charges remain — and they are more serious, carrying a potential prison sentence of up to 99 years.

Gallagher's ruling on the venue is somewhat surprising. Weeks ago,
Gallagher had signaled that he had wanted to at least try to move forward with the case in Collin County, where jury selection had been set to begin in a few weeks.

In court, prosecutors had sought to show collusion among Paxton, his team and his supporters aimed at creating a sympathetic jury pool. Paxton's lawyers had argued they had no ties to the alleged effort and that it wasn't affecting public opinion even if it existed.

Wednesday, April 6, 2016

From the Washington Post: Former coal CEO sentenced to a year in prison for 2010 West Virginia coal mine disaster

We discussed Capperton v Massey in some classes recently.

This was the central character in that case. Note that the result will be appealed.

- Click here for the story.

The former chief executive of a company that owned a West Virginia mine where 29 miners were killed in a 2010 explosion was sentenced Wednesday to a year in federal prison.
Don Blankenship, who had been chief executive of Massey Energy, was found guilty by a jury in December on a charge of conspiracy to willfully violate mine health and safety standards, according to the Justice Department. He was sentenced one day after the sixth anniversary of the accident, which drew national attention and prompted congressional scrutiny.
The year in prison was the maximum sentence for this charge. Blankenship was also ordered to pay a $250,000 fine.
“This sentence is a victory for workers and workplace safety,” Carol A. Casto, the acting U.S. attorney for the Southern District of West Virginia, said in a statement after the sentence was handed down. “It lets companies and their executives know that you can’t take chances with the lives of coal miners and get away with it.”

Sunday, April 3, 2016

From the Atlantic: A Near-Epiphany at the Supreme Court: The justices come close to recognizing the perilous state of the American public-defense system.

The case was Luis v. United States.

- Here's what Scotusblog has to say about it: Click here.

- And here's what Oyez has: Click here.

The question in the case: Does the pretrial restraint of assets that are not directly related to the crime at issue and are needed to retain counsel of choice violate the defendant’s Fifth and Sixth Amendment rights?

And the holding: The pretrial freeze of a criminal defendant's legitimate, untainted assets violates the Sixth Amendment right to counsel of choice.

- Click here for the Atlantic article.

In a 5-3 decision in Luis v. United States on Wednesday, the U.S. Supreme Court forbade the government from seizing legitimate funds defendants could use to hire a lawyer of their choice. Along the way, the justices came close to asking a more troubling question: Does America’s underfunded public-defender system meet the Sixth Amendment’s standards for adequate legal counsel?
The case itself had nothing to do with public defenders, at least on the surface. Sila Luis, who brought the appeal before the Court, was indicted for federal health-care fraud to the tune of $45 million in 2012. Luis had $2 million in assets when a federal grand jury indicted her; she said she hoped to use the funds to pay for her legal defense.
But prosecutors sought a court order barring her from using any of her funds—even those wholly unconnected to the crime—in hopes of acquiring them after conviction for restitution and possible criminal penalties. Luis argued that seizing those untainted funds would violate her Sixth Amendment right to seek assistance of counsel of her choice. Lower courts disagreed, so she appealed the order to the Supreme Court, which agreed to hear the case last year.
Five justices agreed on the ruling itself: The Sixth Amendment forbids the government from seizing untainted assets before trial when defendants need those assets to hire lawyers of their choice. Four of them, led by Justice Stephen Breyer, ruled the right to counsel of choice outweighed the government’s interest in restitution and fines. Justice Clarence Thomas supported the result but saw a clear command from the Sixth Amendment instead of a balancing act.
In his plurality opinion, Breyer expressed alarm at the right-to-counsel implications in the government’s position. “How are defendants whose innocent assets are frozen in cases like these supposed to pay for a lawyer—particularly if they lack ‘tainted assets’ because they are innocent, a class of defendants whom the right to counsel certainly seeks to protect?” Then he made an interesting divergence. Indeed, what would happen if Luis and others like her could no longer afford to pay for a lawyer?
“These defendants, rendered indigent, would fall back upon publicly paid counsel, including overworked and underpaid public defenders,” he continued. “As the Department of Justice explains, only 27 percent of county-based public defender offices have sufficient attorneys to meet nationally recommended caseload standards. And as one amicus points out, ‘[m]any federal public defender organizations and lawyers appointed under the Criminal Justice Act serve numerous clients and have only limited resources.’”
“The upshot,” Breyer concluded, “is a substantial risk that accepting the Government’s views would—by increasing the government-paid-defender workload—render less effective the basic right the Sixth Amendment seeks to protect.”

Wednesday, March 30, 2016

From the Lubbock Avalanche-Journal: Tort Reform is Killing Trial by Jury

- Click here for the article.

Jury trials are disappearing in the State of Texas.
So-called "tort reform" is killing the people's right to a trial of their peers. Caps on penalties, increasing court costs, and skyrocketing usage of binding mandatory arbitration are taking cases out of the hands of juries and into the hands of judges and arbitrators.
Practically speaking, this means that tons of cases are never making it to a courtroom in the first place. In the last 15 years, Texas has seen a two-thirds drop in the number of jury trials along with a 30% rise in motions for summary judgment, all while the number of lawsuits has gone up by %25. This increases the power of judges and of defendants who have lots of resources (usually that means big bidniss, mmmkay). The little guy is getting shooed out the courthouse door rather than getting his or her day in court.
I believe this has a sinister, less-considered side effect too: ordinary people will forget (or never even know) what jury duty is like. Individuals may breathe a sigh of relief when they don't get picked for jury duty or when a jury trial is called off at the last minute in favor of arbitration, but collectively this hurts our democracy. Jurisprudence belongs to the people and reminds us that ordinary people are the backbone of the country. It's yet another civic duty that we are all too willing to throw away (and that powerful interests are all too happy to help us throw away in the name of efficiency).
Again, I really do doubt that people will be outraged by this, although they should be. The state of American education when it comes to the law and to civics is dismal.
There is no cheerful quip at the end of this blog. Our legal system is in serious trouble and we don't even realize it.

Tuesday, March 29, 2016

From Slate: Samuel Alito’s Sixth Amendment Denialism

For our look at constitutional meaning - apparently there is a dispute on the Supreme Court about what aspects of a trial procedure are and are not covered under the "right to a speedy and public trial."

- Click here for the article.

Monday’s case, Betterman v. Montana, is not strictly about the evils of plea bargaining. Rather, it poses a seemingly simple question: Once a defendant has accepted a plea deal, can the government detain him for 14 months before giving him a sentencing hearing?

You might respond to this question by reciting the Sixth Amendment, which states that “In all criminal prosecutions, the accused shall enjoy the right to a speedy and public trial.” Even by the measure of our perpetually clogged-up court system, 14 months is not “speedy,” and so Brandon Thomas Betterman—the defendant here who spent all that time waiting for a hearing—should win. But Montana disagrees, insisting that Betterman’s right to a speedy trial was never violated. That’s because, in Montana’s telling, a sentencing hearing isn’t a trial at all, and so isn’t subject to the Sixth Amendment’s speedy-trial guarantee.

There are two problems with that argument, not including the fact that it would upend
50 years of precedent. The first was highlighted repeatedly throughout the morning by Justice Elena Kagan, whose vim is invigorating on an otherwise torpid court. (I counted at least four catnaps by three justices over the course of the hour.) A delay in court proceedings, Kagan noted, may “impair the defense”: Evidence disappears; witnesses scamper off; memories fade. This problem is present in both conventional trials and sentencing hearings.

“You know,” Kagan tells Montana Solicitor General Dale Schowengerdt, “in most cases these days, most of the actual adjudication of contested issues goes on in sentencing rather than at the trial stage, given that we don’t have very many trials anymore.”

Wednesday, March 6, 2013

Mistrial declared in Dallas murder case

From the Dallas Morning News, something for this week's look at the Texas judiciary and the criminal justice system:
Dallas County murder case ended in a mistrial Tuesday after the ex-girlfriend of a defendant accosted jurors in their deliberation room and showed them a picture of their 10-year-old son.

The woman held up the photo on her cellphone and told jurors that she wanted them to think about the boy as they heard the case, attorneys involved in the case said.

The breach brought questions about courthouse security and finger-pointing about which county department was responsible.

A spokeswoman for Dallas County Sheriff Lupe Valdez said that court bailiffs, who work for the sheriff, were not at fault. The spokeswoman, Carmen Castro, said that the state district clerk’s office is responsible for that area — not the sheriff.

Castro said the Sheriff’s Department “had our areas covered.” Castro said because the security issue was not the concern of the sheriff’s office, she did not have many details about what happened.

Dallas County District Clerk Gary Fitzsimmons laughed at the idea his clerks were responsible for security.

“The jury room is under the control of the bailiffs. I can’t get in there, theoretically,” Fitzsimmons said. “It’s not part of my domain.”

Testimony had not yet begun in the case in which Robert Earl Oliver is accused of stabbing his friend Eric Franklin to death in October 2011. Franklin was stabbed in the neck with a butcher knife and nearly decapitated.

State District Judge Fred Tinsley, who questioned jurors and then declared the mistrial at the state’s request, could not be reached for comment.

Tuesday, February 12, 2013

What would you do?

A very sad local story raises a troubling question:
An Alvin father remained in the Brazoria County Jail Monday, charged with murder in the alleged revenge killing of a drunk driver who plowed into his truck, killing his two young sons last December. David Barajas Sr., 31, a construction worker, is being held in lieu of $450,000 bail in the fatal shooting of 20-year-old Jose Inez Banda minutes after the Dec. 7 crash that claimed the lives of Barajas' 11- and 12-year-old sons.
"The whole incident is extremely tragic," said Brazoria County sheriff's lead investigator, Dominick Sanders. "The grand jury reviewed it and has indicted him for murder."
Tests showed Banda's blood alcohol was twice the legal limit when his Chevrolet Malibu rear-ended the Barajas' family's Ford 250 truck that had run out of gas on an unlit county road near Alvin, investigators said. The inebriated driver failed to swerve or even apply his brakes before plowing into the truck and crushing Barajas' sons, David Jr., 12, and Caleb, 11.
I was surprised to read that he was indicted for muder considering the circumstances until I read this:
During a two-month investigation, authorities located a witness who reported seeing David Barajas walk from the crash scene to his nearby home and return to Banda's car, after which the witness heard gunshots.
He - allegedly - walked home, got a gun and killed the driver. That makes this less a crime of passion than a premeditated act .... but still. So if you were on the jury, how would you rule?


Sunday, September 9, 2012

Animal trials

Apparently there's a long history of putting animals on trial for violating laws - including killing people. Here's a look at it. It's a fun read if you're up to it.

Thursday, April 26, 2012

Trials in the news

For future reference when covering the judiciary, and especially trials:

- The HC's coverage of the Roger Clemens trial.
- The Huffington's Posts on the John Edwards trial.
- An entire website devoted to the trial (and now conviction) of Charles Taylor.

Tuesday, April 17, 2012

Is Zimmerman's indictment based on evidence or politics?

Here's an exhaustive post - embedded with comments from various law types - that probable cause was likely not sufficient to justify the indictment.

And now his lawyers want a new judge.

Seminole Circuit Judge Jessica Recksiedler disclosed late last week that her husband works with CNN legal analyst Mark NeJame, who was approached by Zimmerman earlier in the week about representing him after his original lawyers quit. NeJame declined, but said he gave Zimmerman a short list of alternatives, including Mark O'Mara, who Zimmerman ultimately chose as his legal counsel shortly before his arrest.

O'Mara told
CNN late Monday night after filing his request that he expected Recksiedler to grant it and recuse herself.

Thursday, April 12, 2012

Are online publishers guilty of violating anti trust laws?

The Justice Department is set to find out. It is suing publishers (in the United States District Court for the Southern District in New York) for price fixing.

Anti trust laws - which have been a staple of national power since passed of the Sherman and Clayton anti-trust acts - allow the national government to break apart real or budding monopolies, or any activity which leads to uncompetitive practices.

The Justice Department is investigating whether this has happened in the e-book market. Did Apple secretly force- or persuade - other publishers to not under price its books? But this effort might allow Amazon, which controls 60% of the market, to expand its influence over it by reducing its prices far below what other publishers can command.

Zimmerman arrested and charged - What roles will each participant in the case play?

A good story for 2302 as we continue looking at the judiciary, and the criminal justice process in general. 2301s shoudl consider this case also as it opens a handful of issues related to the rights of criminal defendants, as well as those related to stand your ground laws.

The NYT details the decision to charge George Zimmerman with Trayvon Martin's shooting, and attempts to outline the events leading to the shooting (the facts of the case as best they can be discerned).

The Atlantic discusses what will be required of the prosecutor, the defendant, and the judge in the case. Given the amount of publicity the case has had - how likely will he get a fair trial?

Tuesday, March 6, 2012

Stanford Guilty

For 2302's upcoming look at the judiciary - a recently completed trial. Perhaps you heard of it?

Sunday, February 26, 2012

From the NYT: Why Do Innocent People Confess?

A great question:

If you have never been tortured, or locked up and verbally threatened, you may find it hard to believe that anyone would confess to something he had not done. Intuition holds that the innocent do not make false confessions. What on earth could be the motive? To stop the abuse? To curry favor with the interrogator? To follow some fragile thread of imaginary hope that cooperation will bring freedom?

Yes, all of the above. Psychological studies of confessions that have proved false show an overrepresentation of children, the mentally ill and mentally retarded, and suspects who are drunk or high. They are susceptible to suggestion, eager to please authority figures, disconnected from reality or unable to defer gratification. Children often think, as Felix did, that they will be jailed if they keep up their denials and will get to go home if they go along with interrogators. Mature adults of normal intelligence have also confessed falsely after being manipulated.

False confessions have figured in 24 percent of the approximately 289 convictions reversed by DNA evidence, according to the Innocence Project. Considering that DNA is available in just a fraction of all crimes, a much larger universe of erroneous convictions — and false confessions — surely exists.

Thursday, December 8, 2011

The Confrontation Clause

In recent years the Supreme Court has given additional attention to the Sixth Amendment's Confrontation Clause. Defendants can confront their accusers during trials. What if, however, the evidence presented is expert testimony created by analysts? Do they always have to show up? And if they do, what about the costs that that requirement imposes?

The recently argued case of Williams v. Illinois presents this question to the court.

- The Bill of Rights Doesn't Come Cheap.
- ScotusBlog: Williams v. Illinois.
- Sixth Amendment's Confronation Clause. 

Thursday, October 6, 2011

Can you be coerced into a confession?

It seems that you can:

SINCE 1992 the Innocence Project, an American legal charity, has used DNA evidence to help exonerate 271 people who were wrongly convicted of crimes, sometimes after they had served dozens of years in prison. But a mystery has emerged from the case reports. Despite being innocent, around a quarter of these people had confessed or pleaded guilty to the offences of which they were accused.


It seems hard to imagine that anyone of sound mind would take the blame for something he did not do. But several researchers have found it surprisingly easy to make people fess up to invented misdemeanours. Admittedly these confessions are taking place in a laboratory rather than an interrogation room, so the stakes might not appear that high to the confessor. On the other hand, the pressures that can be brought to bear in a police station are much stronger than those in a lab. The upshot is that it seems worryingly simple to extract a false confession from someone—which he might find hard subsequently to retract.

Something to ponder as 2301s dig into prodecural civil liberties.


Friday, September 30, 2011

Are Suspect Sketches Worthless?

A link from Andrew Sullivan which continues our look at the reliability of eyewitness testimony.

Thursday, September 29, 2011

The Michael Jackson Trial

I tend to avoid celebrity trials - but since they are topical examples of judicial activity, I shouldn't. We should follow developments in the Michael Jackson trial in order illustrate key points in both 2301 and 2302.

- Here's a list of past sensational trials. It might tbe proper for us to wonder about why these trials become such media events.

Should you act as your own lawyer?

You can, the Constitution has interpreted the right of representation to allow for it, but it is almost never a good idea. As much as we like to tease lawyers, they tend to be good at what they do - or at least better than we are at it.

Friday, September 16, 2011

From the Texas Tribune: Supreme Court Grants Stay of Duane Buck Execution

Some checks and balances in the news, coupled with due process and civil rights claims:

Buck's guilt is not in doubt, but his lawyers and supporters argue he deserves a new sentencting trial because race was a factor during his original sentencing in 1997. Dr. Walter Quijano, a psychologist the defense called as a witness, said that Buck would not likely be a future danger to society. But during cross-examination, prosecutors asked Quijano whether he believed the fact that Buck was black increased his potential threat to society. Quijano said yes. The jury sentenced Buck to death.


Here's a complicating factor: The defense called the witness.