Showing posts with label Sunset Review. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Sunset Review. Show all posts

Wednesday, December 21, 2016

From the Texas Tribune: Lawmakers Push Back on Railroad Commission Overhaul Proposals

This is from August, but it foreshadows a series of battles that will pick up this coming legislative session when the Texas Legislature considers the proposals made to it by the Texas Sunset Commission. Along with 25 or so other agencies, the Texas Railroad Commission is being evaluated. The various stakeholders involved with the agency are locking horns already.

- Click here for the article.
One legislator said he believed the entire review was unnecessary, and the criticism mean-spirited.

"When I went through this report, I thought to myself, 'Why are you so angry at the Railroad Commission?'" Rep.
Dan Flynn told Sunset commission staff.

“Oil and gas industry is the heart and soul of the state of Texas, the Canton Republican added, "And for us to go and attack an agency that’s done a pretty good job, it just doesn’t make sense to me.”

Though no lawmaker completely echoed Flynn, his spirited defense of the Railroad Commission underscored the difficulty of implementing change at the hulking agency in Texas, the nation's oil and gas king.

Sunset Commission staffers said they did not intend to be mean.

“We are not angry with the Railroad Commission,” said Ken Levine, executive director of the Sunset Commission. “We think in a lot of ways, they do a really good job. And when we spotted things where they weren’t, we brought it forward.”

Monday, April 25, 2016

From the Texas Tribune: Analysis: Texas Legislative Review Process Needs a Review

The Sunset Review process is falling under criticism.

- Click here for the article.

When the Texas Department of Transportation was up for its periodic legislative review in 2009, the must-pass bill became a magnet for every legislative idea that had not already passed on its own.|
“There were, like, 200 or 250 amendments,” recalled House Speaker Joe Straus, R-San Antonio, in an interview last week. “I couldn’t even see the parliamentarian for the stacks of amendments everywhere. It was just ridiculous.”
He has a pretty good memory: An aide looked it up and found there were 222 amendments. The most important thing to remember, however, was that after months of work on one of the state’s biggest and most important agencies, that so-called Sunset legislation failed.
“It makes a mockery of the whole Sunset process, and it makes me question whether or not it still serves a useful purpose,” Straus said. “So, let’s give it a try, to try to refocus and instill some discipline, and see how we do.”

Tuesday, December 22, 2015

In the news today ....

- Texas Speaker Joe Straus has two Tea Party affiliated challengers to his seat in the upcoming primary election. Straus represents the 121st district in the Texas House. Tea Party opponents , who think Straus is too liberal, have failed to defeat him in two previous primary challenges. They think he might be more vulnerable if he has to face two challengers since he might not win a majority and could defeated in a run-off with low turnout: See Straus faces two-candidate challenge from the far right in Republican primary.

- I still need to post items detailing the recent spending bill. It contains a variety of items (riders) related to non-spending issues including rules loosening campaign spending rules. Some allowing greater use of what is called dark money - dark because its source can;t be traced. This a road we've been heading down for decades: See: White House surrenders on 'dark money' regulation.

- Dark money is also becoming more influential in state races. States vary in their policies regarding transparency - Texas requires little. Most of the additional money spent on campaigns since the Citizens United decision removed many caps on expenditures has been through channels that do not require disclosure. Much of this spending on state races comes from groups located in other states, but the precise source is difficult to determine, and there are sufficient loopholes in place to continue to make them secret. See: 'Dark money' grows in politics even as states try to stop it.

- Texas Lieutenant Governor Dan Patrick is continuing to shape the state panels by appointing people with more conservative bona-fides. This includes the Sunset Commission and the Legislative Budget Board. Among the recent appointees of the latter is area state senator Larry Taylor. See: Dan Patrick shows, through new panel picks, that he wants a more conservative Texas Senate.

- A common theme regarding the early race for the Republican nomination has been what impact Trump will have on the party and whether a division might emerge within it that leads to a third party run. Most previous analyses have looked at the possibility the Trump runs as a third party candidate is he looses the nomination. Here's a look at the possibility that a traditional Republican runs as a third party candidate if Trump wins the nomination. See: Will the GOP Mount a Third-Party Challenge to Trump?

- Is Trump's campaign organization playing with fire? Lot's of Trump's activities are being performed by people that work in many of his businesses, which creates problems since these are to be treated as campaign expenses, meaning that they are to be reported as such. Trump appears to be testing the limits of campaign funding law. See: Trump’s reliance on business questioned.

Tuesday, October 27, 2015

Let's take a look at the Texas Sunset Advisory Commission

It's one of the many ways to get an idea of the number of executive agencies that exist in the state and the degree of influence the legislative branch has over them. We also saw these listed in the Fiscal Size-Up. Agencies are automatically terminated unless they are reauthorized by the legislature under the advisement of the commission.

- Click here for their website.
- Wikipedia: Sunset Advisory Commission.
- Weaker Party: Sunset Review.

For detail: How Sunset Works.

These are the agencies that will be reviewed during the 2016-2017 cycle:

- Bar of Texas, State
- Central Colorado River Authority
- Chiropractic Examiners, Texas Board of
- Counselors, Texas State Board of Examiners of Professional
- Dental Examiners, State Board of
- Employees Retirement System of Texas, Board of Trustees of
- Law Examiners, Board of
- Marriage and Family Therapists, Texas State Board of Examiners of
- Medical Board, Texas
- Nursing, Texas Board of
- Occupational Therapy Examiners, Texas Board of
- Optometry Board, Texas
- Palo Duro River Authority
- Pharmacy, Texas State Board of
- Physical Therapy and Occupational Therapy Examiners, Executive Council of
- Physical Therapy Examiners, Texas Board of
- Podiatric Medical Examiners, Texas State Board of
- Psychologists, Texas State Board of Examiners of
- Railroad Commission of Texas
- Social Worker Examiners, Texas State Board of
- Sulphur River Basin Authority
- Transportation, Texas Department of
- Upper Colorado River Authority
- Veterinary Medical Examiners, State Board of

Conveniently enough, the last sunset review looked at the Texas Department of State Health Services, which is the agency mentioned in the previous story about the birth certificates.

- Click here for their website.
- Click here for their review.
- Here is a direct link to the report.

Saturday, March 28, 2015

The Sunset Advisory Commission

This might help bridge the gap between the legislative and executive branches in Texas. As we've discussed in 2306 earlier this semester, the legislature established the Sunset Advisory Commission in 1977 to review each state level executive agency an determine whether it is to be kept as is, modified, merged with another agency or abolished. Each agency is set to expire unless it is reauthorized by the commission.

This is the basic question it asks about each agency:

“Does the agency and its functions continue to be needed and if so, what improvements need to be made?”

Here's background on the commission:

- Click here for the Texas Sunset Advisory Commission.
- FAQ's.
- Texas Sunset Act.
- Agency History.
- Government Code: Title 3, Subtitle C, Chapter 325.
- This is the list of all agencies subject to review.

These are the agencies under review this session, the links take you to the reports for each:

- Administrative Hearings Tax Division, State Office of
- Administrative Hearings, State Office of
- Aging and Disability Services, Department of
- Assistive and Rehabilitative Services, Department of
- Children With Special Needs, Interagency Task Force for
- Developmental Disabilities, Texas Council for
- Education Agency, Texas ( Limited Scope Review )
- Facilities Commission, Texas ( Re-review )
- Family and Protective Services, Department of
- Health and Human Services Commission
- Health Care Information Council, Texas ( Special Purpose Review )
- Health Services Authority, Texas
- Health Services, Department of State
- People with Disabilities, Governor’s Committee on
- Purchasing from People with Disabilities, Texas Council on
- Self-Directed Semi-Independent Agencies, Entry Criteria for ( Special Review )
- Soil and Water Conservation Board, State ( Limited Scope Review )
- University Interscholastic League
- Workforce Commission, Texas
- Workforce Investment Council, Texas

It's currently looking at two of the largest, The Texas Education Agency and the Heath and Human Services Commission.

Friday, November 30, 2012

Who should appoint commissioners to the Port of Houston Authority?

At the moment, the Port of Houston Authority ( a single purpose governing entity that controls the Port of Houston) is headed by a seven person board appointed by different governing entities in Harris County:

The City of Houston and the Harris County Commissioners Court each appoint two commissioners. These two governmental entities jointly appoint the chairman of the Port Commission. The Harris County Mayors & Councils Association and the city of Pasadena each appoint one commissioner.


But the port has undergone the Sunset review process and the Sunset Commission recommends that the governor appoint the commissioners, in addition to a variety of other changes. This is part of a general effort to coordinate the activities of all ports in the state, as well as the belief that the port is poorly managed and that management is not transparent. It is difficult for the general population to know what the port is up to.

Click here for links to the report from the Sunset Commission's site as well as the Port of Houston's.

Both the City of Houston and the Harris County Commissioners' Court are opposed to the proposal that the governor appoint board members. Both argue that it compromises local control.

- Story from KUHF. Is this another power grab by the governor?
- The Chronicle reports that the Commisioners' Court would like to appoint all board members on the grounds that the county holds the port's debt.
- Houston Business Journal points out that the port is reorganizing as a response to the Sunset Review report.
- KUHF reports that State Senator John Whitmire of Houston recommended the change, and that County Judge Ed Emmett agrees that a statewide port authority would be a good idea in order to coordinate port activity across the state.

Wednesday, March 14, 2012

Is the State Commission on Judicial Misconduct immune from Sunset review?

They seem to think so. According to the Austin American Statesman:

When the Sunset Advisory Commission, which is legislatively charged with determining if state agencies are operating efficiently, asked for records of meetings of the State Commission on Judicial Conduct, the commission refused. The commission, which hears misconduct complaints levied against the state's 4,000 judges, argued that "its meetings are closed to everyone, including the Sunset Commission and its staff," according to the sunset agency's report on the judicial conduct commission, released this month.

Not only that, the report said, but the judges' commission refused to grant state investigators permission to read any of the memoranda about its rulings because of attorney-client privilege.

The denials, in effect, prevented the auditors from determining not only if the commission operated efficiently, but also if its deliberations concerning judges — most of whom are elected — were fair or impartial.

"As a result, staff could not assess the commission's primary duty," the report concluded. "By preventing a full review, the Commission on Judicial Conduct seriously limits the ability of the Sunset Commission and the Legislature to assess the oversight of judges in Texas, as required by law."

The reason for the refusal seems to be the need for judicial independence:

The judicial commission argued that, as a judicial organization, it is not subject to the same type of review as other state agencies.

As far as withholding records from the sunset inspectors, "it's not our closed records policy," Willing said. "It's the constitution and the statute."

By law, the only time the commission is required to reveal information about its deliberations is during what are known as "formal proceedings" and when it issues a public sanction against a judge. Both of those are rare events.

Last year, only a fifth of the commission's disciplinary actions involved a public sanction against a judge. And, over the past 10 years, the commission has held a formal proceeding only 12 times, the sunset report stated.

The Sunset Advisory Commission argues that this refusal to release records is a probem:

"Unlike most state agencies that must operate openly and transparently," the report concluded, "the commission operates largely behind closed doors to protect the confidentiality of the judges it oversees, most of whom are elected officials.

"While Sunset recognizes the need to protect judges from public disclosure of unfair or unwarranted complaints stemming from individuals unhappy with the outcome of a case or from political opponents, this must be balanced against the public's right to know that the process is working fairly and effectively when judges misuse or abuse the substantial authority they have been granted."

2302s should take note since this points out an unusual aspect of the Texas executive, the fact that every (or most every) agency has to be reviewed from time to time, which gives the state the opportunity to terminate the agency if it is no longer performing it delegated duty efficiently.

For more info:

- The Sunset Advisory Commission.
- The State Commission on Judicial Conduct.

Thursday, July 7, 2011

2011 Texas Sunset Reports

For my upcoming 2302 summer 2 students:

- The Texas Sunset Commission.
- Report to the 82nd Session.

Every few years Texas executive agencies are reviewed and be potentially eliminated if its seen as necessary. This link takes us to this year's list. Expect an assignment at some point regarding the process.

Thursday, January 13, 2011

Sunset Review -- 82nd Legislature

Once every twelve years, each executive agency in the state is reviewed in order to determine whether the agency's functions are still necessary.

This year the following 28 agencies are to be reviewed:

*Capital Metropolitan Transportation Authority
Coastal Coordination Council
*Electric Reliability Council of Texas (ERCOT)
Electronic Government Program Management Office of the Department of Information Resources
Emergency Communications, Commission on State
Environmental Quality, Texas Commission on
*Equine Research Account Advisory Committee
Forest Service, Texas
Hearing Instruments, State Committee of Examiners in the Fitting and Dispensing of
Housing and Community Affairs, Texas Department of
*Housing Corporation, Texas State Affordable
Information Resources, Department of
Injured Employee Counsel, Office of
*Insurance Counsel, Office of Public
*Insurance, Texas Department of
*Juvenile Probation Commission, Texas
On-site Wastewater Treatment Research Council
Public Finance Authority, Texas
Public Utility Commission of Texas
Public Utility Counsel, Office of
*Racing Commission, Texas
Railroad Commission of Texas
Soil and Water Conservation Board, State
Speech-Language Pathology and Audiology, State Board of Examiners for
*Transportation, Texas Department of
Water Development Board, Texas
Workers' Compensation, Texas Department of Insurance Division of
*Youth Commission, Texas

*Subject to a focused, limited scope, or special purpose review

- Sunset Advisory Commission
- Guide to the Sunset Process.

Chubbing and Sunset Bills

Again from Burka Blog, background on two rules changes members of the Texas House are looking to change

Thursday, October 28, 2010

Texas Sunset Advisory Commission 2011

Every several years, the Texas Legislature reviews the performance of state agencies to determine if they should be maintained. Here's a link to the legislative agency in charge, and agencies under review this year.

*Capital Metropolitan Transportation Authority
Coastal Coordination Council
*Electric Reliability Council of Texas (ERCOT)
Electronic Government Program Management Office of the Department of Information Resources
Emergency Communications, Commission on State
Environmental Quality, Texas Commission on
*Equine Research Account Advisory Committee
Forest Service, Texas
Hearing Instruments, State Committee of Examiners in the Fitting and Dispensing of
Housing and Community Affairs, Texas Department of
*Housing Corporation, Texas State Affordable
Information Resources, Department of
Injured Employee Counsel, Office of
*Insurance Counsel, Office of Public
*Insurance, Texas Department of
*Juvenile Probation Commission, Texas
On-site Wastewater Treatment Research Council
Public Finance Authority, Texas
Public Utility Commission of Texas
Public Utility Counsel, Office of
*Racing Commission, Texas
Railroad Commission of Texas
Soil and Water Conservation Board, State
Speech-Language Pathology and Audiology, State Board of Examiners for
*Transportation, Texas Department of
Water Development Board, Texas
Workers' Compensation, Texas Department of Insurance Division of
*Youth Commission, Texas

*Subject to a focused, limited scope, or special purpose review

- Wikipedia: Sunset Advisory Commission.

Tuesday, November 10, 2009

Sunset Committee Set

From the Texas Tribune.

Texas Speaker Joe Straus has named members of the Texas Sunset Committee for 2010.

Texas Sunset Commission.

Sunday, November 30, 2008

Sunset Review 2008 - 2009

The government of the state of Texas, as opposed to the national government, requires all its state agencies to periodically justify their existence in a process coordinated by the Sunset Advisory Commission.

From the agency's website:

In 1977, the Texas Legislature created the Sunset Advisory Commission to identify and eliminate waste, duplication, and inefficiency in government agencies. The 12-member Commission is a legislative body that reviews the policies and programs of more than 150 government agencies every 12 years. The Commission questions the need for each agency, looks for potential duplication of other public services or programs, and considers new and innovative changes to improve each agency's operations and activities. The Commission seeks public input through hearings on every agency under Sunset review and recommends actions on each agency to the full Legislature. In most cases, agencies under Sunset review are automatically abolished unless legislation is enacted to continue them.

Click here for a list of the agencies under review in 2008 - 2009.