For my 2301's, as we begin to discuss political parties:
Political science types tend to argue that parties must provide clear alternatives to the voters in order to provide them a choice. This allows the population to collectively influence the direction of public policy, enhancing the democratic nature of the republic. If this is true, then the division of the parties on health care provides such an opportunity -- assuming nothing else comes up between now and November to overshadow health care.
William Saletan says as much in Slate. He wonders whether there might be risks for Republicans in opposing the bill after Democrats are able to shift to campaign mode presenting the bill in a positive light:
This is the risk Republicans have taken by voting unanimously against health care reform. They've bet their whole party against it. If the public hates the program, they'll be rewarded at the polls. But if the public likes it, they're in trouble. And if the public fears it might be taken it away, they could suffer a beating, as they did in 1996 when voters feared cuts in Medicare.
Showing posts with label responsible party model. Show all posts
Showing posts with label responsible party model. Show all posts
Tuesday, March 23, 2010
Monday, February 9, 2009
Are Party Line Votes a Good Thing?
Critics are blasting Republicans in Congress for not being bipartisan, and voting almost unanimously against the stimulus bill. They suggest that the party is voting against the bill for purely partisan reasons. They believe, maybe even hope, that the stimulus will fail and they will be able to use this as a campaign item against Democrats in 2010.
But it is just as easy to say that they should stake a position against the bill, and even further that the health of American democracy depends on their taking a position against the bill.
Its the argument made by supporters of responsible parties. Very simply it holds that democracy in the United States ultimately comes down to a choice between two parties, and these two parties must take clear and distinct positions on issues if voters are to be able to make an intelligent choice in the ballot box. If there is no distinction between the parties, there is no real choice for the voter to make.
By taking a position against the stimulus bill, the Republicans will give voters an option in 2010 if the bill does not work as advertised. Of course they stand to lose if the bill does have a positive impact on the economy, but them's the breaks.
But it is just as easy to say that they should stake a position against the bill, and even further that the health of American democracy depends on their taking a position against the bill.
Its the argument made by supporters of responsible parties. Very simply it holds that democracy in the United States ultimately comes down to a choice between two parties, and these two parties must take clear and distinct positions on issues if voters are to be able to make an intelligent choice in the ballot box. If there is no distinction between the parties, there is no real choice for the voter to make.
By taking a position against the stimulus bill, the Republicans will give voters an option in 2010 if the bill does not work as advertised. Of course they stand to lose if the bill does have a positive impact on the economy, but them's the breaks.
Wednesday, April 11, 2007
Iraq, Democrats, and the Responsible Party Model
I had the pleasure of picking up a class for Elizabeth McLane and went over the power point slides for the political parties chapter in the Lowi, Ginsburg, Shepsle textbook.
A discussion picked up when we covered the responsible party model and applied it to the current efforts of the Democrats to impose a timetable on our involvement in Iraq. The Responsible Party Model, which was an effort by the American Political Science Association to ensure that parties are meaningful instruments of democratic choice, holds that "An effective party system requires, first, that the parties are able to bring forth programs to which they commit themselves and, second, that the parties possess sufficient internal cohesion to carry out these programs."
Regardless of one's opinion on what the Democrats are up to, and the wisdom of imposing a time limit, would the Democrats be negligent in their duty as a responsible party if they not seek to impose a time limit? It is generally conceded that the 2006 election was a referendum on the Iraq War, so the Democrats are the majority party for a reason. If they do not go forward with opposition to the war they could be undermining democracy at home. Voters opposed to the war wont really know whether they can trust the Democrats to do what they say they will do if they continue to voice opposition to the war.
One could also argue that it is important that one of the presidential candidates, John McCain, seems to be basing his campaign on support for the existing policy. Voters may have a choice, and this is what makes political parties vital instruments of democratic politics.
At least that's what the model holds. Is it wrong?
A discussion picked up when we covered the responsible party model and applied it to the current efforts of the Democrats to impose a timetable on our involvement in Iraq. The Responsible Party Model, which was an effort by the American Political Science Association to ensure that parties are meaningful instruments of democratic choice, holds that "An effective party system requires, first, that the parties are able to bring forth programs to which they commit themselves and, second, that the parties possess sufficient internal cohesion to carry out these programs."
Regardless of one's opinion on what the Democrats are up to, and the wisdom of imposing a time limit, would the Democrats be negligent in their duty as a responsible party if they not seek to impose a time limit? It is generally conceded that the 2006 election was a referendum on the Iraq War, so the Democrats are the majority party for a reason. If they do not go forward with opposition to the war they could be undermining democracy at home. Voters opposed to the war wont really know whether they can trust the Democrats to do what they say they will do if they continue to voice opposition to the war.
One could also argue that it is important that one of the presidential candidates, John McCain, seems to be basing his campaign on support for the existing policy. Voters may have a choice, and this is what makes political parties vital instruments of democratic politics.
At least that's what the model holds. Is it wrong?
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)