Showing posts with label Texas Judges. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Texas Judges. Show all posts

Thursday, October 20, 2016

Grits for Breakfast: Pop Quiz on Fourth Amendment and the criminalization of the normal

For our look at due process in both 2305 and 2306, and especially for out look at appellate courts in Texas in 2306.

- Click here for the article.

Pop Quiz from the Texas Seventh Court of Appeals: Which of the following are NOT an indicia of drug trafficking under Texas law?
  • Breathing.
  • Having two hands.
  • Driving a clean vehicle.
  • Looking at a peace officer.
  • Looking away from a peace officer.
  • A young person driving a newer vehicle.
  • Driving in a car with meal wrappers.
  • Driving carefully.
  • Driving on an interstate.
The answer, according to a majority opinion from the Seventh Court of Appeals written by Chief Justice Brian Quinn, is that only the first two cannot be considered suspicious behavior that justifies an investigative detention, according to Texas courts. A dissent by Justice Campbell scolded his colleagues for failing to defer to the trial judge and "assume the court made implicit findings of fact supporting its ruling that are supported by the record." But the majority opinion is quite a read, lamenting that "most anything can be considered indicia of drug trafficking to law enforcement personnel."

Apparently if the police want to search you for drug possession for any reason, the Texas Courts say they can.

Monday, March 28, 2016

Texas Code of Judicial Conduct

For 2306 classes as we look at the judiciary in the state.

- Click here for it.

It is referred to in Article 5 of the Texas Constitution and is the guideline used by the Texas State Commission for Judicial Conduct in order to determine whether judges are acting in a manner that upholds the integrity of the judiciary.

Sunday, March 27, 2016

Some random items on the Texas judiciary

From the Texas Lawyer: Cornyn Pledges to Help Obama Seat Texas Judges.

While Texas' Senior U.S. Senator John Cornyn has pledged to block President Barack Obama's appointment of Merrick Garland to the U.S. Supreme Court, the influential Republican member of the Senate Judiciary Committee said he'll work with the White House to seat five Texans on U.S. District Court benches.

From the Texas Tribune: Survey Captures Fear Level Among Texas Judges.

Hundreds of Texas judges say they have feared for their safety at least once in the last two years, and a majority didn't know they are required by law to report threats, according to a survey taken after the attempted assassination of a Travis County judge.

From Law 360: Texas Supreme Court Judges Ward Off Primary Challengers.

Three Texas Supreme Court justices running for re-election beat back Republican primary challengers Tuesday, with each incumbent likely earning another six-year term on the state’s highest civil court. Having defended their seats, Justices Debra Lehrmann, Paul Green and Eva Guzman are now set up for the November general elections, where they will each face a Democratic opponent. Republicans have dominated Texas’ statewide elections for more than a decade, and the Texas Supreme Court’s nine seats have been filled by all Republicans since 1999.

From MySA: Former Texas Gov. Rick Perry's abuse-of-power case is not over yet.

The special prosecutor in the abuse-of-power case against Rick Perry said Thursday he still hasn't decided whether to drop the matter a week after the state's highest criminal court ordered that the indictment against the former governor be dismissed.

From KTLV: Judge accused of sexting while sitting on judicial conduct board.

An East Texas judge is facing serious allegations of explicit sexual behavior online while conducting government business. Smith County Judge Joel Baker serves as chief judge for Smith County and served as vice chair on the State Commission for Judicial Conduct(SCJC). The accusations come from a woman who asked to remain anonymous and private investigator, Tim McLemee who specializes in digital evidence.

From the Tyler Morning Telegraph: Smith County Judge Joel Baker resigns from State Commission on Judicial Conduct.

Smith County Judge Joel Baker has resigned from the State Commission on Judicial Conduct for personal and family reasons, his office announced Monday.






Wednesday, September 23, 2015

From the Texas Tribune: Judge Temporarily Halts Cuts to Children's Therapy

Checking and balancing in Texas. Notice the reference to ambiguous language in the state budget.

- Click here for the story.

Deep cuts to a therapy program for poor and disabled children will not take effect Oct. 1, a state district judge ruled Tuesday afternoon — the second such delay in recent weeks.
“Procedurally I'm not making a determination that these acts are valid or invalid,” said State District Judge Tim Sulak in his announcement that he would grant a temporary injunction to prevent the state from slashing payments to therapists. But he said he made his ruling in part because he’d been convinced the cuts could jeopardize the health of children receiving the therapy services.
It marked the first decision in a series of legal challenges filed by therapy providers and families of children with disabilities, who seek to prove that by slashing payments to therapists, the state will cause as many as 60,000 children to lose access to those services. The idea is that the low pay will force providers to drop out of the program.
State lawmakers this year ordered the Texas Health and Human Services Commission to reduce funding for therapy services by roughly $350 million in state and federal funds over two years. Those savings would primarily come from reductions in the rates paid to therapists by Medicaid, the public insurance program for the poor and disabled — in some cases by about 20 or 25 percent.
But that seemingly simple goal to reduce payments has been complicated by some ambiguous language in the state budget, which directs the health commission to consider “access to care” when applying the cuts. Families of children who need the services say the speech, physical and occupational therapy covered by Medicaid can be life-saving — by helping kids learn to nurse, walk and speak, for example — and that the state is poised to limit access by forcing providers to drop out of the program.

Friday, August 29, 2014

Texas State Judge John Dietz - again - finds Texas' school finance system unconstitutional

In GOVT 2306 this week we covered the purpose behind education in the Texas - the fact that it is tied into the ability of the electorate to secure right and liberties, as well as the capacity for self governance.

This point is made in both the Texas Declaration of Independence and the Article 7 of the Texas Constitution. We read through the first section of that article and say the following language: "it shall be the duty of the Legislature of the State to establish and make suitable provision for the support and maintenance of an efficient system of public free schools."


While the Texas Constitution is normally held to be clear - that's what 80,000 words gets you - there can be a debate over what the phrase "suitable provision" and the word "efficient" actually mean.

That's the broader context for the judge's decision. More specific is the fact that the 82nd Texas legislature cut over $5 billion in education funding, some of which was restored by the 83rd Legislature. Over 600 school districts sued the state alleging that the Texas Constitution - the language highlighted above - had been violated.

For detail on the case, click on these articles:

- Texas Tribune: Judge: Texas School Finance System Unconstitutional.
- Dallas Morning News: Texas' school finance system again overturned in court.
- Austin American-Statesman: Judge: Texas school finance system unconstitutional.

More importantly:

- here is a link to the judge's decision.
- here is the findings of fact and conclusions of law.

In case you're curious - this applies to later parts of the class - here's Judge Dietz's website. Her serves as the judge for the 250th District Civil Court.

The AAS summarizes the basic argument made by the judge. these will be reviewed by the Texas Supreme Court.
Dietz found four constitutional problems with the way Texas finances its schools:
• The Legislature has failed to suitably provide for Texas public schools because the school finance system “cannot provide a constitutionally adequate education for all Texans,” Dietz said in his order.
• The finance system is inadequate because it does not provide enough money to accomplish a “general diffusion of knowledge.
• The system effectively imposes a property tax, in violation of the Texas Constitution, because districts do not have “meaningful discretion” over how the taxes are raised, assessed or spent.
• The system is financially inefficient because all Texas students do not have equal access to the educational money needed.
“Consequently, the court enjoins further funding under the system until the constitutional infirmities are corrected,” Dietz wrote.

Thursday, January 23, 2014

School funding trial back on track

In the opening lectures this semester we mentioned that the Texas Constitution contains language related to the need for the legislature to adequately fund public education in the state and that a lawsuit followed the $5 billion in cuts made to the education budget following the 82nd session of the legislature.

Click here for a few stories related to the lawsuit.

The lawsuit was put on hold once the 83rd session of the legislature restored $3.9 billion, but the lawsuit is back on track.

From the Lubbock Avalanche-Journal:

The second school funding trial began Tuesday with this basic argument from the attorneys representing the more than 600 school districts in the state suing the Texas Legislature: Despite the $3.9 billion the lawmakers restored to public education funding in last year’s session, the same old problems continue because of inequitable funding.

“Nothing has changed,” argued David Hinojosa, lead school finance attorney for the Mexican American Legal Defense and Education Fund, or MALDEF. The San Antonio-based organization represents some of the property-tax poorest districts in the state and a group of parents, including two from Amarillo.

The system is also inefficient because it is not producing results, Hinojosa and other attorneys told State District Judge John Dietz.

But Texas Assistant Attorney General Shelly Dahlberg countered that the funding of the public education system is constitutional.

In last year’s session, when the Legislature restored most of the funding cuts made in the 2011 session when the lawmakers tackled a $27 billion shortfall, the state narrowed the funding gap in the overwhelming majority of all school districts, Dahlberg told Dietz.

“The Legislature also improved the equity of the system,” she said in reference to one of the key arguments the plaintiffs used when they sued the state two years ago.

From the Texas Tribune:

With the Texas school finance trial reopening Tuesday, state district court Judge John Dietz is set to consider how changes made during the 2013 legislative session could affect his February ruling that the state has underfunded its public schools.

Attorneys for the state will spend the next four weeks arguing that new high school graduation requirements and the $3.4 billion lawmakers added back to the public education budget in 2013 should change his mind. But the most prominent player in the state’s defense of the lawsuit could remain outside the courtroom, where the trial has become a political football in the state’s heated 2014 gubernatorial contest.

The leading Republican candidate for governor, Greg Abbott, is also the state’s attorney general. His office is responsible for the state’s defense against the more than two-thirds of Texas school districts that are suing over what they say is an inadequate and unfair funding system in a case that is expected to travel to the state Supreme Court.

He said last week that he does not plan to appear in court during the latest hearings. That has not stopped his expected Democratic opponent, Wendy Davis, from lobbing attacks based on his role in the litigation. Davis, a Fort Worth state senator, has her own connection to the school finance lawsuit. In 2011, she filibustered the 2011 budget bill that enacted the $5.4 billion in cuts that led to the litigation that arose two summers ago.

Tribpedia contains full background of the case.







Thursday, September 26, 2013

From The Texas Tribune: Judge Ken Anderson Resigns Amid Ethics Lawsuit

This picks up a story we highlighted in the spring.

The state district judge was found to have withheld evidence in a murder case while he was a prosecutor in 1986. He is now facing civil and criminal proceedings, but has already been accused by the State Bar's Commission for Lawyer Discipline of violating several of its rules of disciplinary conduct.

Monday, April 15, 2013

The Texas Tribune: Donations to Judicial Campaigns Spur Ethics Worries

More on the problems posed by judicial elections in Texas:

Tom Phillips, a former chief justice on the Texas Supreme Court, has a strong opinion of the state’s judicial elections. “Of the ways you can elect judges,” he said, “Texas has one of the worst systems.”

In 1988, when he ran for the state’s highest court, he voluntarily capped individual donations to his campaign at $5,000. Today, his law firm — which regularly represents clients before the state Supreme Court — routinely donates tens of thousands of dollars to the campaigns of the justices who preside over those cases.

. . . “Voters insist they want the right to elect their judges,” said Supreme Court Justice Don Willett, who has served since 2005. “Ask them to name one, and they'll likely come up blank. But they want a voice, even as they say that judicial fundraising raises appearance concerns.”

A case that illustrates those concerns is one that former Chief Justice Phillips, now an Austin-based attorney for the law firm Baker Botts, helped argue before his former colleagues.

In 2001, 71-year-old Leonel Garza died of a heart attack after taking the anti-inflammatory drug Vioxx for 25 days. His family sued the drug manufacturer Merck & Co. in what was one of numerous wrongful death lawsuits filed around the country. A district court and a San Antonio appeals court agreed with the family, awarding them nearly $7.75 million in damages.

Merck — which was represented by Baker Botts — appealed to the state Supreme Court, arguing that Garza had a history of heart problems and that there was no proof that the company’s drug caused the heart attack. In August 2011, the court sided with the company.

In the 10 years preceding the decision, justices who sided with Merck in the 7-0 vote received at least $85,000 combined in campaign contributions from the Baker Botts political action committee. Justice Nathan Hecht, who wrote the court’s opinion in the case, received $20,000. Chief Justice Wallace Jefferson received $12,750.


While no one admits to being influenced by a campaign contribution, a relationship between teh two has been found to exist:
In the 1994 Democratic primary between Rene Haas and Raul Gonzalez, the two candidates together spent nearly $4.5 million campaigning. The following year, the Texas Legislature responded by passing the Judicial Campaign Fairness Act, which limited contributions to justices to $5,000 for individuals and $30,000 for law firms.

That measure may have curbed spending, but researchers found it didn't curb influence. Madhavi McCall, a political science professor at San Diego State University, conducted a study of the relationship between judicial decisions and campaign contributions in 530 Texas Supreme Court cases between January 1994 and June 1997. “In every instance,” she said, “the probability of a party garnering votes increases if the party contributed to a given justice’s campaign.”

Wednesday, March 6, 2013

Mistrial declared in Dallas murder case

From the Dallas Morning News, something for this week's look at the Texas judiciary and the criminal justice system:
Dallas County murder case ended in a mistrial Tuesday after the ex-girlfriend of a defendant accosted jurors in their deliberation room and showed them a picture of their 10-year-old son.

The woman held up the photo on her cellphone and told jurors that she wanted them to think about the boy as they heard the case, attorneys involved in the case said.

The breach brought questions about courthouse security and finger-pointing about which county department was responsible.

A spokeswoman for Dallas County Sheriff Lupe Valdez said that court bailiffs, who work for the sheriff, were not at fault. The spokeswoman, Carmen Castro, said that the state district clerk’s office is responsible for that area — not the sheriff.

Castro said the Sheriff’s Department “had our areas covered.” Castro said because the security issue was not the concern of the sheriff’s office, she did not have many details about what happened.

Dallas County District Clerk Gary Fitzsimmons laughed at the idea his clerks were responsible for security.

“The jury room is under the control of the bailiffs. I can’t get in there, theoretically,” Fitzsimmons said. “It’s not part of my domain.”

Testimony had not yet begun in the case in which Robert Earl Oliver is accused of stabbing his friend Eric Franklin to death in October 2011. Franklin was stabbed in the neck with a butcher knife and nearly decapitated.

State District Judge Fred Tinsley, who questioned jurors and then declared the mistrial at the state’s request, could not be reached for comment.

Thursday, February 7, 2013

Catching up with Ken Anderson's Court of inquiry



Anderson (left); Morton (right)

Sunday I posted a story about a court of inquiry being conducted against a sitting judge accused of covering up evidence against a defendant who was falsely convicted of murdering his wife. He served 25 years in prison before being released. A good addition to 2306's upcoming look at the criminal justice system in the state.

Here's an update on the proceedings from Texas Monthly:

- Court of Inquiry Begins: The court of inquiry will function essentially as a grand jury, in that it will determine if criminal charges should be brought. But unlike a grand jury, it will be conducted in open court. There will be no jury, only a judge. And Anderson’s legal team can present evidence and cross-examine witnesses. A visiting judge from Fort Worth, state district judge Louis Sturns, has been appointed by the Texas Supreme Court to oversee the inquiry. Legendary defense attorney Rusty Hardin will serve as the “attorney pro tem” who will present witnesses and evidence to help Sturns “determine if an offense has been committed,” according to the Code of Criminal Procedure.

- Day One: A court of inquiry into Anderson’s alleged prosecutorial misconduct began yesterday with Michael Morton taking the stand. Trial lawyer Rusty Hardin—who is serving as the inquiry’s “attorney pro tem,” and who must present witnesses and evidence to state district judge Louis Sturns to determine if an offense has been committed—asked Michael about several documents that have come to light which his defense lawyers never saw at trial. ....

- Court of Inquiry Continues: The third day of the court of inquiry into alleged prosecutorial misconduct in the Michael Morton case began with startling testimony. Williamson County Court at Law Judge Doug Arnold recounted a conversation he had years ago with then-D.A. Ken Anderson, who, according to Arnold, told him that he had used an unusual trial strategy on more than one occasion in criminal cases he had prosecuted: Anderson said he would deliberately not call the lead investigator in a case to the stand so that he would not have to turn over the investigator’s reports and notes to the defense. (According to state law, the defense has the right to see an officer’s notes before cross-examining him or her.)

Sunday, February 3, 2013

Court of Inquiry looking into past actions of Texas judge in wrongful conviction case

The Texas Tribune reports on an unusual - for Texas at least - case in Williamson County. A sitting judge will face a court of inquiry that will determine whether he should face trial for withholding evidence in a murder case he prosecuted as a district attorney two decades ago. The man convicted in the case has since been exonerated. There are allegations that the real suspect is the since dead Sheriff of Williamson County, but evidence suggests that the evidence was suppressed during the original trial, and that further evidence has not been provided since the investigation began sometime back.

The investigation coincides with efforts to pass legislation this session that would address similar actions in the future.
The court of inquiry could last up to two weeks, and it is unclear whether state district Judge Louis Sturns, who has been appointed to oversee the case, will issue findings at the conclusion of the hearings or later. If Sturns finds that Anderson committed a criminal violation, he could issue a warrant for his arrest.

The court of inquiry is not the only threat to Anderson’s career, though. The State Bar of Texas filed a civil lawsuit against him last year, alleging that Anderson withheld evidence and made a false statement to the court when he told Judge Lott he had no evidence that could be favorable to Morton’s claims of innocence. If he is found to have violated professional rules of conduct, Anderson could be disbarred.

As the court of inquiry action unfolds just 30 miles north of the state Capitol, lawmakers are also looking on. Morton is lobbying them to pass laws that ensure prosecutors are held accountable for mistakes that cost innocent people years of liberty.

“Not only is this a prosecutor being practically put on trial, but it’s a sitting judge,” said Jennifer Laurin, a professor at the UT-Austin School of Law. “This is a person of enormous stature in the criminal justice system who is being called to account.”
I don't have much on courts of inquiry, but here are a few links that explain the process. They are unique to Texas and are used when there is evidence of a wrongful conviction.

- Texplainer: What is a court of inquiry and when is it used?
- Texas Statues - Chapter 52.
- Grits for Breakfast weighs in.
- Previous coverage from the Huffington Post.

Monday, April 16, 2012

From the AAS: Lower-level judges receive big share of sanctions from judicial commission

Justice of the Peace and Municipal Court judges come under fire for inesperience:

Last year, complaints against justices of the peace represented 19 percent of the total complaints filed about equal to their numbers among state judges. Yet justices of the peace received 55 percent of the sanctions issued by the Commission on Judicial Conduct. Municipal court judges accounted for 9 percent of the complaints filed in 2011 but earned 24 percent all disciplinary measures. District and appellate judges, by comparison, are rarely sanctioned by the agency, even though they generate nearly half the total complaints.

One reason lower-court judges are sanctioned more often, judges and attorneys say, is that many aren't lawyers — which is often a point of pride.

"I'm not an attorney; I'm a citizen," said George Boyett, a Brazos County justice of the peace who has appeared in front of the commission three times.

Known as "people's courts," justice of the peace dockets are busy and proceedings can be informal. "The judge conducted court proceedings in an undignified manner when he heard the case while barefooted and wearing a T-shirt and shorts," said a 2003 private admonishment of an unnamed justice of the peace.

Another unidentified justice of the peace received the same sanction in 2001 after "the judge confiscated a defendant's shotgun as surety for payment of a $300 fine," according to commission records. "The judge's action was without legal authority."

Travis County District Judge Ruling Could Cost Texas Billions

From State Impact:

A new ruling this week from Travis County District Judge John Dietz this week could cost the state of Texas billions in tax revenue. Ruling in favor of the drilling company Southwest Royalties, the court found that oil and gas equipment used for exploring and completing wells should not be subject to sales tax because it qualifies for an manufacturing exemption.

The ruling was first reported by the Texas Energy Report, but Dale Craymer of the Texas Taxpayers and Research Association says we’ll have to wait and see.

“The judge has indicated he’s going to rule with the plaintiffs, but we know the state is going to appeal,” he says. “We’ve had instances where plaintiffs have won big judgments in trial court, only to see it be reversed on appeal and vice-versa. This is still very early in what will be a long legal process.”

Craymer says it also depends on how the final ruling is written. It could be broad enough to include billions in tax funds or narrow enough to only affect a smaller amount. Southwest Royalties is owned by Clayton Williams, a Midland oilman known for his failed campaign against Ann Richards for Texas Governor in 1990.

Friday, March 30, 2012

Texas Supreme Court Chief Justice Wallace Jefferson call for an appointed judiciary in Texas

Story in the Texas Tribune.

Among other things, elections don't guarantee qualified judges. Key quote:

A brief search of judicial candidates’ TV and web campaign videos brings up plenty of examples, like a spot by former state Rep. Rick Green during his 2010 bid for the Texas Supreme Court.

"Hey, friends. I have some earth-shattering news for you,” he says in the ad. “First of all, this campaign is now Chuck Norris approved. And secondly, we've got our money bomb today."

Green has a law degree but little legal experience. But thanks in part to Norris and some key endorsements from the then-budding Tea Party movement, Green made it to a GOP primary runoff against a candidate with judicial experience.

Does this kind of political wrangling lower the overall quality of the judicial system? Frank Cross, a professor at the University of Texas law and business schools, said it absolutely does.

"Because we have an elected judiciary, our judges are of lower quality,” Cross said. “But it doesn't seem to terribly bother anyone that much."

Monday, April 13, 2009

Tort Reform and Judicial Activism in Texas

Tort reform is once again in the news in Texas thanks to Entergy v. Summers, a case where a Texas appellate court ruled that a worker injured in an accident in an electric generating plant, cannot sue that plant because he worked for a general contractor doing work on the site, not directly for the corporation which owned the plant.

If understand the ruling correctly, a majority on the Texas Supreme Court ruled that the plant was acting as its own contractor, so could not be sued for negligence by the injured employee. Some members of the legislature who were involved in drafting the law governing this decision argue that the court went beyond its jurisdiction in making its decision. From the Austin Chronicle:

Sen. Kirk Watson of Austin echoed that, saying, "The Court reached a result that the Legislature has rejected over and over again. The Legislature has avoided reducing and has, instead, worked to assure worker protections and also make sure employers keep a commitment to safety."

"Non-substantive re-codifications of statutes are a constitutionally mandated duty of the Legislature ... specifically meant to NOT change the intent of law," said Brownsville Sen. Eddie Lucio in a statement. "In the Entergy decision, the Texas Supreme Court has violated the separation of powers in this state using judicial activism to write law."

Since we're heading into a discussion of interest groups in 2301, tort reform is a perfect example of an issue which divides business and labor. On one side of the issue is the business backed Texans for Lawsuit Reform, and on the other the AFL-CIO. In 2302, we've touched on the problems posed by an elected judiciary. Critics argue that since all the current members of the Texas Supreme Court are Republicans supported by the business community, their judgements will be biased against the interests of labor. Supporters generally point out that the Texas Supreme Court was equally biased against business interests and in favor of lawsuit plaintiffs when they were all Democrats elected with the support of trial lawyers.

So to tie 2301 and 2302 together, does interest group involvement in judicial elections undermine judicial independence?

Saturday, March 7, 2009

Judicial Misconduct in Texas

Sharon Keller, the presiding judge of the Texas Court of Criminal Appeals, is in trouble:

Seventeen months ago, lawyers for a man facing execution sought extra time to file a last-minute appeal. Judge Keller refused to delay the closing of her clerk’s office past 5 p.m., even though late filings are common on the day of a scheduled execution. The man, Michael Richard, was put to death by lethal injection a few hours later.

Based on that case, the State Commission on Judicial Conduct last month
charged Judge Keller with incompetence, violating her duties and casting public discredit on the judiciary. Judge Keller, who has been the chief judge of the Texas Court of Criminal Appeals since 2000, faces a public trial and could be forced off the bench.

Her lawyer insists that she did nothing wrong and that she was being blamed for the mistakes of the defendant’s lawyers and court staff.


Some links:
- Sharon Keller's website.
- State Commission on Judicial Misconduct.
- The Chron details efforts to prevent similar problems in the future.
- Rick Casey's commentary.

Monday, February 9, 2009

Texas Democrats to Influence Choice of Federal Judges in the State

From Capitol Annex:

It should come as no surprise to anyone that Texas’ Democrats in Congress are making noise about the selection of judicial nominees from Texas, given that the state’s two senators are both Republicans and likely wouldn’t have too many decent suggestions to make to President Barack Obama.

This coupled with Democratic success in recent judicial racs in the state suggest that things might be different in the state.

The story includes a potential controversy since the Senate is given the power to advise and consent. This should be interesting to 2302 students