Showing posts with label racial discrimination. Show all posts
Showing posts with label racial discrimination. Show all posts

Wednesday, January 25, 2017

From the Saturday Evening Post: The Civil Rights Act vs. States’ Rights

A look at the tension between the two.

- Click here for the article.

Goldwater recognized that the Civil Rights Act would split the liberal and conservative wings of the Democratic Party. For years, the Democrats had been able to hold these two warring factions together, but as the liberal wing began supporting the growing civil rights movement, many white, conservative Democrats began withdrawing their support of the party their families had supported for generations.
The day would come, Goldwater predicted in a 1963 Post article, “The G.O.P. Invades the South,” when the region would vote solidly Republican. He noted that Republican candidates were already winning elections in Florida, North Carolina, and Georgia. The South would shift its party allegiance, he said, because of “a profound evolution of political thinking and acting.”
It had nothing to do, he asserted, with white voters being angry with liberal Democrats’ support of integration. Southerners were leaving the party, he said, because they believed in “state’s rights,” and limiting the role of the federal government. They viewed the Civil Rights Act as an intrusion that, Goldwater argued, would eventually lead to “the creation of a police state.”
Civil rights were important, Goldwater believed, but they were “resolved more safely and soundly on the state or local level.”
But the local level, as Anthony Lewis wrote, was precisely where the problem lay. (“Goldwater Is Wrong On Civil Right” September 26, 1964) The law in southern states and towns was vigorously enforcing racist policies, using intimidation and violence to deprive African Americans of their rights.
The U.S. Government had tried Goldwater’s approach for nearly a century, Lewis argued. When states were left on their own to handle race relations, “the result was massive inequality, injustice, and cruelty that shocked the conscience of this nation…The law has been cynically manipulated to maintain white supremacy, in defiance of the most elementary rights of a citizen.”
Federal intervention was necessary, he said, to prevent state officials from enforcing racist politics

Wednesday, September 28, 2016

From the Houston Chronicle: Feds file discrimination suit against owners of Midtown bar Gaslamp

For out look at civil rights.

- Click here for the article.
A Midtown bar that was accused of charging cover charges only to non-white patrons and turning other minorities away under the guise of "dress code violations" is now the subject of a federal discrimination lawsuit.
The Justice Department filed a lawsuit on Wednesday against the owners and operators of 360 Midtown, which was formerly Gaslamp, at the corner of Brazos and Hadley streets.
Scandal embroiled the bar last year when three black men made the racism allegations last year.
Brandon Ball, Dan Scarbrough and Ken Piggee — all attorneys — said that when they approached the doors of Gaslamp, the doormen immediately told them that to enter, they had to pay $20.
Deciding against it, the trio went to a nearby bar and later walked by Gaslamp.
"We're looking, and there are white people going in and getting their hands stamped," Ball told the Chronicle in September 2015. "They were going in and not paying anything."
The three sat and watched the door for some time, they said last year, watching white customers enter free of charge and minorities get turned away. They said they spoke with the others as they were turned away.
The lawsuit was filed Wednesday in the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Texas.
It alleges that Ayman Jarrah and his company, Land Guardian Inc., discriminated against African-American, Hispanic and Asian-American patrons "by charging such persons a cover charge to enter the establishment, while not imposing such a charge on similarly situated white persons, and denying such persons the right to enter the establishment while admitting similarly situated white patrons."

Saturday, July 11, 2015

This day in Texas History: The Longview Race Riot of 1919

This seems related to the previous post below.

- Click here for this post from the TSHA.

I'm sorry to say that I'm unaware of this event - or the Red Summer it refers to. It's interesting to note that one of the factors leading to the conflict was a rumored interracial affair. In the wake of the gay marriage decision, some have revisited out history of laws against inter racial marriage and the Supreme Court decision that found them unconstitutional.

From the story:

The Longview Race Riot occurred during the Red Summer, as May to October of 1919 has been called. It was the second of twenty-five major racial conflicts that occurred throughout the United States during these months. In 1919 Longview, a rural cotton and lumbering community in Northeast Texas, had a population of 5,700; 31 percent were black. Racial tension was especially high immediately before the riot because two locally prominent black leaders, Samuel L. Jones and Dr. Calvin P. Davis, had urged black farmers to avoid local white cotton brokers and sell directly to buyers in Galveston. Then an article in the July 10 issue of the Chicago Defender, a sensationalistic nationwide black newspaper, described the death of a young black man, Lemuel Walters, in Longview. The article reported that Walters and an unnamed white woman from Kilgore, Texas, were in love and quoted her as saying they would have married if they had lived in the North. Walters, according to the article, was safely locked in the Gregg County Jail until the sheriff willingly handed him over to a white mob that murdered him on June 17.

And - of course - Wikipedia has a page on the Red Summer.

- Click here for it.

The riots are alleged to be tied into the end of WWI and fears of communism. Here's a taste:

The riots followed postwar social tensions related to the demobilization of veterans ofWorld War I, both black and white, and competition for jobs among ethnic whites and blacks. The riots were extensively documented in the press, which along with the federal government conflated black movements with bolshevism.

From the Atlantic: Most States Elect No Black Prosecutors

This article bridges 2305 and 2306. Related topics:

GOVT 2305: Civil Rights and the Equal Protection Clause, and Interest Groups
GOVT 2306: Local Government, Criminal Justice Policy, and Local Elections

The author argues that because most states elect their district attorneys - elections that in Texas are carried out at the county level - and because Whites are a majority in each state, as well as most counties, district attorneys are primarily White. This has consequences for the decisions that the criminal justice system makes regarding who gets prosecuted and who does not.

From the article:
Here are a few of the numbers, according to a report on elected prosecutors commissioned by the Women Donors Network and conducted by the Center for Technology and Civic Life, a nonpartisan group that grew out of the progressive National Organizing Institute:
- 95 percent of elected prosecutors are white;- 79 percent are white men;- three in five states have no black elected prosecutors;- 14 states have no elected prosecutors of color at all*;- just 1 percent of elected prosecutors are minority women.

This has consequences for who goes to trial and who does not:
In the U.S. legal system prosecutors may wield even more power than cops. Prosecutors decide whether to bring a case or drop charges against a defendant; charge a misdemeanor or a felony; demand a prison sentence or accept probation. Most cases are resolved through plea bargains, where prosecutors, not judges, negotiate whether and for how long a defendant goes to prison. And prosecutors make these judgments almost entirely outside public scrutiny.

Why does this matter?

This ought to be worrying in a democracy: Although trying to assemble a government that perfectly represents each minority population may be a recipe for disaster—ask Lebanon!—the magnitude of the disparity here should startle even jaded observers. At the federal, state, and local levels, African Americans, Hispanics, and Asians hold elective office at rates lower than their percentages of the overall population, but even so, the gap among prosecutors is particularly large. There’s also little question that the U.S. justice system as it exists perpetuates and encourages huge racial gaps, leading to much higher incarceration rates for black men and serious social disparities in housing, education, employment, and beyond.

Which raises an important question regarding majoritarian democracy: If elected institutions do not have the same ethnic breakdown as the general population - if the majority is over represented - are the rights of minority populations in jeopardy? The author suggests that the answer is yes. This is central to the argument that the United States' governing system is systematically racist, that is, biased in favor of the majority due to winner take all electoral rules. Obviously this is an area of controversy. People are divided on the issue based on ideology. Liberals are more likely to see systemic racism at work, conservatives less likely.

Some important terms in the article:

These are related to the position of district attorney:

- Wikipedia: District Attorney.
- Wikipedia: Prosecutor.
- Texas Association of Counties: District and County Attorney.
- Texas District & County Attorneys Association.
- Harris County: Office of the District Attorney.

These are relate to the concept of systemic racism:

- Wikipedia: Institutional Racism.
- The Atlantic: Systemic Racism or Isolated Abuses? Americans Disagree.
- The Daily Beast: Supreme Court: Institutional Racism Is Real.

Thursday, June 11, 2015

From Vox: Virginia's congressional map has been thrown out by judges for racial bias

OK - one more post about the courts and racial gerrymandering. Vox reports on another case that might well end up in the Supreme Court.

- Click here for the article.

On Friday, a federal court panel reaffirmed an earlier decision throwing out Virginia's map of congressional districts, due to unconstitutional racial gerrymandering.
The panel found that one district, the third, was unconstitutionally racially gerrymandered in violation of the Equal Protection Clause. "Individuals in the Third Congressional District whose constitutional rights have been injured by improper racial gerrymandering have suffered significant harm," a two-judge majority of the panel wrote.
Virginia is widely believed to be one of the most gerrymandered states in the country. In 2012, Republican House candidates won just 51 percent of the votes cast in the state — but they ended up winning eight of the state's 11 congressional districts.

The last sentence in a nutshell explains why gerrymandering happens. It allows a narrow majority to become a super-majority.

Wednesday, June 10, 2015

The Supreme Court rules that Alabama drew legislative districts in order to restrict black representation.

This was the result in two related cases:

- ScotusBlog: Alabama Legislative Black Caucus v. Alabama.
- ScotusBlog: Alabama Democratic Conference v. Alabama.
- Oyez Project: Alabama Legislative Black Caucus v. Alabama.

The court ruled - by a 5-4 vote - that the state was guilty of racial gerrymandering - more specifically a tactic known as packing. By successfully packing members of a group in a small number of districts, then the voting strength of that group is minimized. If that group happens to be a racial group - especially a racial minority - that violates both the 14th and 15th Amendments as well as the Voting Rights Act. The problem is that proving racial gerrymandering can be difficult to do. The court's majority ruled that racial gerrymandering should be considered on a district by district method - taking each individually - rather than statewide, which is what a lower court had ruled.

For analysis from smarter people than me:

- Supreme Court sends Alabama redistricting plan back to lower court.
- Opinion analysis: A small victory for minority voters, or a case with “profound” constitutional implications?

For students who are focusing on this case, you may wish to consider the following topics, even if you aren't writing about this case, you should be familiar with the following as they arise in different contexts in both 2305 and 2306.

- Gerrymandering: An attempt to draw an electoral district for political advantage.
- Racial Gerrymandering: An attempt to draw electoral districts to impact - favorably or negatively - the strength of a racial group. This is unconstitutional since race is a suspect classification under the equal protection clause. Since parties are not a protected classification, partisan gerrymandering is not illegal, but since party identification increasingly varies based on race, it can be difficult to distinguish between the two.
- Packing and Cracking: These are the names of two gerrymandering techniques. Packing refers to when members of a group are packed into a small number of districts so that their competitiveness elsewhere is minimized. Cracking refers to when the members are spread out to a number of districts so that the group is not a majority in any district.
- 14th Amendment's Equal Protection Clause: Added to the Constitution after the Civil War, clause prevented states from treating persons in their jurisdiction unequally, though it does not define "equality." 
- 15th Amendment: For the first time - again just after the Civil War - the Constitution negated the ability of states to deny the right to vote to people on the basis of race, among other things.
- Reynolds v Sims: The 1964 Supreme Court case that mandated that state legislative districts had to be roughly equal in population.  
- Voting Rights Act: An act Congress passed in 1965 to strengthen the voting rights of minority groups primarily in the South by outlawing tactics that had minimized their ability to vote, as well as the impact of their votes. It also established agencies that could enforce the law. It also mandated that states with a history of racial discrimination had to have changes in their elections, as well as districts, pre-cleared by a panel of federal judges or the Justice Department. 
- Shelby County v Holder: A 2013 Supreme Court case which limited the Voting Rights Act by arguing that throwing out the map that had been used  to determine which states were subject to pre-clearance.

Tuesday, April 7, 2015

Does religious liberty protect racial discrimination?

No, at least not since the 1982 case of Bob Jones University v. U.S.

Here's background.

- Oyez Project.
- Wikipedia.
- Legal Information Institute.
- Tax Policy Analysis of Bob Jones University v. U.S.

From Oyez's summary:
Facts of the Case

Bob Jones University was dedicated to "fundamentalist Christian beliefs" which included prohibitions against interracial dating and marriage. Such behavior would lead to expulsion. In 1970, the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) changed its formal policy to adopt a district court decision that prohibited the IRS from giving tax-exempt status to private schools engaging in racial discrimination. The IRS believed that the University's policies amounted to racism and revoked its tax-exempt status. The University claimed that the IRS had abridged its religious liberty. This case was decided together with Goldsboro Christian Schools Inc. v. United States, in which Goldsboro maintained a racially discriminatory admissions policy based upon its interpretation of the Bible, accepting for the most part only Caucasian students. The IRS determined that Goldsboro was not an exempt organization and hence was required to pay federal social security and unemployment taxes. After paying a portion of such taxes for certain years, Goldsboro filed a refund suit claiming that the denial of its tax-exempt status violated the U.S. Constitution.
Question
Can the government prohibit race discrimination at the expense of the First Amendment's Free Exercise Clauses?

Decision: 8 votes for U. S., 1 vote(s) against
The Court found that the IRS was correct in its decision to revoke the tax- exempt status of Bob Jones University and the Goldsboro Christian School. These institutions did not meet the requirement by providing "beneficial and stabilizing influences in community life" to be supported by taxpayers with a special tax status. The schools could not meet this requirement due to their discriminatory policies. The Court declared that racial discrimination in education violated a "fundamental national public policy." The government may justify a limitation on religious liberties by showing it is necessary to accomplish an "overriding governmental interest." Prohibiting racial discrimination was such a governmental interest. Hence, the Court found that "not all burdens on religion are unconstitutional."

Tuesday, March 4, 2014

From Think Progress: When ‘Religious Liberty’ Was Used To Justify Racism Instead Of Homophobia

An interesting wrinkle in the question about religious liberty and discrimination based on sexual orientation.

- Click here for the article.

As early as 1867, the Pennsylvania Supreme Court upheld segregated railway cars on the grounds that “[t]he natural law which forbids [racial intermarriage] and that social amalgamation which leads to a corruption of races, is as clearly divine as that which imparted to [the races] different natures.” This same rationale was later adopted by state supreme courts in Alabama, Indiana and Virginia to justify bans on interracial marriage, and by justices in Kentucky to support residential segregation and segregated colleges.

In 1901, Georgia Gov. Allen Candler defended unequal public schooling for African Americans on the grounds that “God made them negroes and we cannot by education make them white folks.” After the Supreme Court ordered public schools integrated in Brown v. Board of Education, many segregationists cited their own faith as justification for official racism. Ross Barnett won Mississippi’s governorship in a landslide in 1960 after claiming that “the good Lord was the original segregationist.” Senator Harry Byrd of Virginia relied on passages from Genesis, Leviticus and Matthew when he spoke out against the civil rights law banning employment discrimination and whites-only lunch counters on the Senate floor.