Showing posts with label voting. Show all posts
Showing posts with label voting. Show all posts

Tuesday, November 8, 2016

From the New York Times: Spread of Early Voting Is Forging New Habits and Campaign Tactics

As many as 50 million people may have voted early, and since this has become increasingly commonplace, it has altered campaign tactics - as is reported below.

Early voting is also an example of what we refer to in 2306 as policy diffusion. A policy developed in one state that is adopted by others.

- Click here for the article.
In 1977, a flood control measure on the ballot in Monterey, Calif., became what historians say was the first modern American election decided by people who voted before Election Day.
It was a strange moment even for some who participated; elections had traditionally been a kind of civic gathering, on one day.
But the practice caught on with voters, and it eventually spread from the West Coast to 37 states and the District of Columbia. Today, at least 43 million Americans have already voted in the presidential election. And when the ballots are tallied nationwide Tuesday evening, more than one-third of them will have come from people who voted early — a record.
Voting before Election Day has become so commonplace that it is reshaping how campaigns are waged, and how Americans see the race in its final, frantic days.
“The idea that one wakes up and it’s Election Day in America is actually a rather quaint idea now,” said Russ Schriefer, a Republican consultant who has worked on presidential campaigns for two decades. “It is as much as a monthlong process to draw people in. And so your advertising tactics, your messaging tactics and certainly your ground game have changed completely.”
The spread of early balloting is forging new habits that are forcing campaigns to rethink how they allocate their resources. And it tends to favor those campaigns that are more technologically sophisticated and can identify, draw out and measure its support over a longer voting period.
In Florida, a battleground state where just a few hundred votes can tip an election and victory can guarantee the White House, new behaviors are rapidly taking hold. Hispanics, who have tended to turn out mostly on Election Day, are voting earlier in much larger numbers this year, after a major Democratic-led effort to mobilize them. This is especially true among young and first-time Hispanic voters, who are just forming their voting habits and are likely to retain the practice of casting ballots early, according to those who study early voting.
That will mean that future campaigns will need to further adapt and dedicate more time and money to chasing votes up to six weeks before Election Day.

Wednesday, September 28, 2016

From Politico: Appeals court - Ballot selfie ban unconstitutional

It turns out that you can post selfies from the voting booth.

Let's see if the Supreme Court decides to review it.

- Click here for the article.

A federal appeals court has ruled that New Hampshire's ban on voters taking and publishing photos of their voted ballots is unconstitutional. 
The Boston-based 1st Circuit Court of Appeals on Wednesday upheld a lower court ruling that the law, revised in 2014, ran afoul of the First Amendment because lawmakers could not show that it was tailored to the purported threat of vote-buying and voter intimidation. The unanimous, three-judge appeals court panel also questioned how serious and present a threat that was.
“Digital photography, the internet, and social media are not unknown quantities – they have been ubiquitous for several election cycles, without being shown to have the effect of furthering vote buying or voter intimidation. As the plaintiffs note, ‘small cameras’ and digital photography ‘have been in use for at least 15 years,’ and New Hampshire cannot identify a single complaint of vote buying or intimidation related to a voter's publishing a photograph of a marked ballot during that period,” Judge Sandra Lynch wrote, in an opinion joined by Judges Ojetta Thompson and Kermit Lipez.
“The prohibition on ballot selfies reaches and curtails the speech rights of all voters, not just those motivated to cast a particular vote for illegal reasons,” Lynch added. “New Hampshire does so in the name of trying to prevent a much smaller hypothetical pool of voters who, New Hampshire fears, may try to sell their votes. New Hampshire admits that no such vote-selling market has in fact emerged. And to the extent that the State hypothesizes this will make intimidation of some voters more likely, that is no reason to infringe on the rights of all voters.”
“The ballot-selfie prohibition is like ‘burn[ing down] the house to roast the pig,’” the court's opinion added, borrowing language from a 1957 Supreme Court ruling.

Thursday, April 14, 2016

An argument against compulsory voting

It comes from a libertarian commentator - no surprise in that. He sees little benefit, nor impact, if voting was compulsory - but he doesn't seem to worked up about it either.

- President Obama endorses mandatory voting.

In his speech, President Obama claimed that mandatory voting would diminish the significance of money in politics. The opposite effect is more likely. Most campaign spending represents expenditures on televised ads. For fairly obvious reasons, relatively ignorant voters are more likely to be influenced by simplistic 30 second ads than relatively well-informed ones (who, among other things, tend to have stronger preexisting views). Thus, a more ignorant electorate is likely to be one where campaign spending on television ads exercises more influence. I don’t think the influence of money on politics is either as great or as harmful as President Obama and many other liberals do. But if you disagree with me on that, you may have even more reason to oppose mandatory voting than I do.

Like other defenders of compulsory voting, the president touts the example of Australia, which is indeed a generally well-governed nation that has a compulsory voting law. But the full list of
nations with compulsory voting is not one that inspires confidence. It includes such paragons of civic virtue as Argentina, Egypt, Congo, and Lebanon. By contrast, one of the few democracies with lower turnout rates than the United States is Switzerland, which is often considered one of the best-governed nations in the world. I don’t claim that Argentina and Egypt have bad governments and Switzerland a good one because of their respective voting laws. My point is merely that there is no clear correlation between turnout and good governance.

In addition to its potentially harmful consequences, mandatory voting is also an unjust infringement on individual liberty. Some people choose not to vote because they find the available options so distasteful that they don’t want to be in the position of supporting any of them. Even if the ballot includes some sort of “none of the above” option, choosing to vote might still be viewed as at least a partial endorsement of the status quo political system, and some citizens might prefer not to signal any such endorsement. It is debatable whether this is the correct approach to an election with terrible options. I personally believe that is still usually best to vote for the lesser of the available evils. But the opposing view is not unreasonable, and those who act on it don’t deserve to be punished by the government for doing so.

Others can reasonably choose to abstain from voting because
they lack the knowledge to make a well-informed choice and (quite rightly) don’t want to harm the rest of society by making ignorant decisions. Given the vast size and complexity of modern government, even intelligent and conscientious people will sometimes find themselves in that position. Finally, many people might prefer not to vote simply because they have better uses for their time, including in some cases uses that create more benefit for society, as well as themselves. Jason Brennan discusses this latter scenario in greater detail in The Ethics of Voting.

Liberal Democratic advocates of compulsory voting are in part motivated by the hope that it will generate increased turnout among young people and racial minorities, thereby securing more electoral victories for their party. But Democratic strategists’ hopes for a bonanza of extra votes in that quarter are matched by
GOP hopes for higher turnout among working class whites, who in recent elections have tended to back Republicans, but also have relatively low turnout rates. In addition, as Brennan emphasizes, lower-class and less-educated voters tend to be more socially conservative as well as more economically left-wing. Thus, even if increased turnout within this group gave the Democrats more victories, the resulting Democratic Party would likely be more socially conservative.

Wednesday, March 16, 2016

Here's a reason why you don't need to vote

I asked both 2305 and 2306 students whether it was their responsibility vote - yes or no. There was no reason to give a knee-jerk yes answer.

Here's a powerful argument from Salon that you shouldn't:

- Vote for Hillary, be a sucker: It’s OK to reject the choice of a tyrannical liberal or a right-wing tyrant
“Vote for Hillary or be responsible for Trump” is slogan of someone maintaining -- or being played -- by the system.

Nothing generates more insipid analysis than a U.S. presidential election. It’s a wonderful opportunity for two-party functionaries to distill American mythologies into the high-minded diction of corporate wonkery. I suppose it isn’t helpful to complain about election analysis by adding to the babble, but it does seem worthwhile to highlight the limitations of the genre.
I dislike voting as a model of political engagement, especially in a corrupt and constrained system that devalues grassroots organizing and tries to limit our imagination to mechanical support of stage-managed icons. Yet I accept that people find inspiration in public figures and express approval by casting votes, sometimes the only political commodity available to a disempowered public. We can critique U.S. elections without being contemptuous of their participants.
Most election skeptics actually value (and perhaps overvalue) their votes. Pundits who insist on voting as a precondition of respectability exhibit contempt for anybody who rejects the mythologies of U.S. exceptionalism. To be respectable, one mustn’t simply vote. One must vote correctly. Such entreaties preclude third-party candidates or acts of conscience deemed inadequately practical. We remain confined to a political canon that produced the greatest crisis of inequality in world history.
Americans are enamored of the vote as a symbol of collective power. The right to vote certainly shouldn’t be taken for granted, but deification of voting can prevent us from treating ourselves as something grander than a massive focus group curated by a few dozen affluent lickspittles. The mythography of voting has conditioned us to treat mediocrity as superior.

Sunday, March 29, 2015

Should voting be compulsory?

President Obama made heads scratch recently when he speculated that perhaps voting should be mandatory - it already is in some countries, including Belgium and Australia. Voter turnout in the U.S. is at or near the bottom of all democracies.

2305's written assignment this week will be whether this is a good idea, and what the impact of the law might be.

Some - hopefully helpful - links:


- A case for compulsory voting.
- President Obama floats mandatory voting.
- Obama: Maybe it's time for mandatory voting.
- Views: Mandatory voting idea based on flawed assumption.
- Obama suggests making it mandatory to vote. That would change very little.
- Even more on the potential impact of mandatory voting.
- Wikipedia: Compulsory Voting.
- IDEA: Compulsory Voting.

Tuesday, October 22, 2013

Early voting begins in Texas

It actually began yesterday, October 21.

Click here for important 2013 election dates in Texas - this is from votetexas.gov.
Click here for similar information from the Secretary of State's office.

Texas Tribune reports that this election will provide an early indication of the impact of voter ID laws in the state.

Early voting is one of a handful of processes that make it easier for people to vote - Tuesday's can be difficult for working people. The NCSL provides a look at the range of methods used by different states. In addition to early voting, there's absentee voting - either with or without an excuse - and all mail voting.

Click here for detail and the map - suffice to say that the political culture in some states - in addition to the political interests in different states - lead to drives to enhance or restrict access to the polls. Texas historically has tended to restrict access, which leads to the suspicion by some that the intent of voter ID laws is to impact the tendency of certain groups to turn out.

Tuesday, April 2, 2013

The campaign process according to Richard Kimball

I though this quote from the wikipedia site on Project Vote Smart was good enough to highlight separately:

"Understand what we do to you. We spend all of our time raising money, often from strangers we do not even know. Then we spend it in three specific ways: First we measure you, what it is you want to purchase in the political marketplace — just like Campbell's soup or Kellogg's cereal. Next, we hire some consultants who know how to tailor our image to fit what we sell. Lastly, we bombard you with the meaningless, issueless, emotional nonsense that is always the result. And whichever one of us does that best will win."

Kimbal founded Project Vote Smart after losing a Senate race in 1986.

Monday, December 10, 2012

Becker and Posner on the Paradox of Voting

A couple rational guys try to figure out why people do something apparently irrational: Vote in an election that there is little or no chance they will be able to sway. One person's vote out of 100 million will not change results, but ...

Posner sees a similarity to clapping:

Some people vote because the political campaigns make it costly for them not to vote—one technique in “get out the vote” drives is pestering people to vote so that they will feel uncomfortable not voting. Some vote because they think that it will encourage others to do so. Some vote because they consider it a civic duty. Some voting is purely expressive—a way of expressing strong feelings pro or con a candidate (or pro one and con his opponent); certainly anger played a role in votes against Romney by members of groups that he or his party seemed to disrespect, and anger at Obama played a role in the large number of votes that Romney received. In this respect voting is like booing or cheering at an athletic event or other entertainment. One person’s applause at a concert is inaudible to the performers, yet people applaud, and not mainly I think because others in the audience would look askance at them if they did not. And finally people interested in politics like to vote to convince themselves and others that their interest is serious—they are willing to put their money (not money exactly, but the cost in time and bother of voting) where their mouth is.

No one thinks that applauding is irrational, even though like voting it has no instrumental value, and has some, though very slight, cost.


Becker is concerned that the fact that we know our vote does not matter makes it unlikely we will learn about the candidates we are voting for:

Since the great majority of voters presumably do not expect to influence election outcomes, who they support is influenced disproportionately by campaign rhetoric, debates among candidates that have little intellectual content, and by other methods of persuasion that are not very informative about the candidates. I like to say that consumers put more time and effort into deciding which cereal to buy and into other small consumer choices than in gathering information on economic and other issues about presidential candidates.
But I am not claiming that voters are less “rational” than consumers of everyday products. Individuals pay more attention to what they buy than whom they vote for because what they buy has a direct and tangible effect on their wellbeing. Since the incentives to become well informed are radically different, “rational” voting implies very different kinds of behavior than does rational choice of cereals or peanut butter.

Tuesday, October 2, 2012

From the NYT: Pennsylvania Judge Puts Voter ID Law on Hold for Election

This seems similar to the decision affecting Texas' elections:

A Pennsylvania judge on Tuesday delayed full implementation of a highly contested state law requiring strict photographic identification to vote in next month’s election, saying that the authorities had not done enough to ensure that potential voters had access to the new documents.

The judge, Robert Simpson, who upheld the law in August when it was challenged by liberal and civil rights groups, was instructed by the state’s Supreme Court two weeks ago to hold further hearings. He was told to focus on the question of whether enough had been done to ensure “liberal access” to the picture ID cards or alternatives.
Judge Simpson said in his Tuesday ruling that for the presidential election of Nov. 6, voters in Pennsylvania could be asked to produce the newly required photo IDs, but if they did not have them could still go ahead and vote. The decision could still be appealed to the state Supreme Court.

Tuesday, September 25, 2012

Absentee Ballots Sent

The election has officially begun in Texas. County clerks have been sending out absentee ballots to those eligible to receive them: Military and overseas voters, as well as the elderly, disabled, and those who will be out of town on voting day.

Here's a guide to absentee voting, and additional information from the Texas Secretary of State's office.

Ballots can be requested until October 30.

Ballotpedia has background on absentee ballot voter fraud, with special attention paid to Texas - of course.

Wednesday, June 20, 2012

Should voting be mandatory?

It is in Australia and a few other countries. Why not here?

William Galston wonders: JURY duty is mandatory; why not voting?

Tuesday, November 1, 2011

Range Voting

I have no idea what to make of this. It's a bit outside the box, but worth a look.

Monday, July 11, 2011

Comment or Vote

From a link taken from the post below, possibly the greatest video ever made.

http://www.commentorvote.com/

Tuesday, April 5, 2011

The Morality of Political Ignorance

A great post from the Volokh Conspiracy. Is political ignorance moral? Despite the fact that voters have only a small chance of ever making a decisive vote in an election, is this an excuse for not being informed?

Unfortunately, extensive evidence shows that most voters both know very little about public policy and do a poor job of evaluating the political information they do know. Elsewhere, I have argued that such ignorance and bias is actually rational. There is only an infinitesmal chance that any one vote will be decisive. So individual voters have strong incentives to remain ignorant. But not every form of rational behavior is morally defensible. Sometimes, rational individual behavior leads to terrible collective outcomes. Consider the case of air pollution, where individuals might rationally choose not to limit their emission of dangerous pollutants because any one person’s behavior has only a tiny effect on overall air quality in the area. Widespread voter ignorance is a kind of pollution of the political system.


- from Andrew Sullivan's Site

Monday, March 28, 2011

2009 Military and Overseas Voting Empowerment Act

From the Chronicle, a story regarding access to the polls:

Legislators have been working on making it easier for far-from-home Texas military personnel to vote. Texas must comply with the 2009 Military and Overseas Voting Empowerment Act. The law known as MOVE requires states to provide ballots to military personnel at least 45 days before an election.

The San Antonio Express-News reported Monday that making it easier for military personnel to cast ballots is expected to require Texas to change March primary and runoff dates. State Sen. Leticia Van de Putte of San Antonio and Rep. Van Taylor of Plano are working to develop a bipartisan plan.

Taylor, as a Marine captain in 2003, led a platoon during the Iraq war. He says the real issue “is the amount of time to request, receive and return a ballot by mail.”

Thursday, March 10, 2011

Will the Attack on Collective Bargaining Make Democrats More Enthusiastic than Republicans in the 2012 Election?

We've been asking this in class recently, Nate Silver comments and give some evidence that it might.

Disenfranchising Democrats

A few posts argue that Republican controlled legislatures are making it more difficult for groups that tend to vote Democrat to vote.

- The GOP's war on voting.
- Disenfranchising Democrats.
- Voter Disenfranchisement.

The three dominant techniques seem to be Voter ID laws, limiting the right of ex-felons to vote, and disenfranchising college students.