The use of the filibuster in the US Senate has increased greatly over the past few years, so much so that critics wonder whether it does more harm than good. Normally filibusters have been used sparingly by a minority in the Senate to stop bill they find objectionable, but more recently it has been used to place broad limits on the ability of government to operate at all. For example, executive and judicial positions remain unstaffed because Senate Republicans have enough votes to prevent the votes from getting to the Senate floor.
Senate Democrats are considering whether to change the rules that allow filibusters to happen - there is nothing in the Constitution about filibusters. They happen because of the process that evolved in the Senate over time. but these processes can be changed. That doesn't means its a good idea to do so, or that the change might not have consequences.
I want you to read up on this controversy and weigh in on it. What would the consequences of filibuster reform be on the the Senate? Is reform a good or bad idea?
150 words at a minimum.
Some links:
- Wikipedia: Filibuster in the US Senate.
- An Accident of History?
- US Senate: Filibuster and Cloture.
- Wikipedia: Rule XXII.
- Save the filibuster, Harry Reid.
- Democrats poised to limit filibusters, angering GOP.
Showing posts with label senate procedures. Show all posts
Showing posts with label senate procedures. Show all posts
Friday, July 12, 2013
Monday, January 23, 2012
In the US Senate today . . .
Just to keep up to date, from January 23rd's calendar:
4:00 p.m.: Proceed to executive session to consider the nomination of John M. Gerrard to be United States District Judge for the District of Nebraska.
The Senate Glossary defines an executive session as one where "A portion of the Senate's daily session in which it considers executive business." Wikipedia's section on the standing rules of the Senate has more, in addition to a list of the executive positions subject to advise and consent.
Here's background on John M. Gerrard. He was appointed on the recommendation of retiring Nebraska Senator Ben Nelson. This is the customary way that Federal District Judges are appointment when one of the state's US Senators are of the same party as the president. Alabama Senator Sessions has opposed Gerrard's nomination partly due to an opinion he issued challenging whether the executions by electric chair was constitutional.
If approved, Gerrard would fill a vacancy on the court (here's the Wikipedia page for the court, here's the court's website) and become its sixth judge. This is the only district court for the state of Nebraska. There are 89 such courts across the country. Each state has to have one according to the Constitution.
What is a US District Judge you ask? The US Court's website explains (its the trial court on the federal level) here's more info from the relevant Wikipedia page.
The appointment and confirmation has become increasingly contentious. Senate rules allow a minority to prevent confirmation votes - or any vote really - from going to the floor. Reports suggest that judicial vacancies have risen during the Obama Administration. Here are numbers from the US Courts site and judicialnomination.org.
For a list of Obama's judicial nominees, click here.
4:00 p.m.: Proceed to executive session to consider the nomination of John M. Gerrard to be United States District Judge for the District of Nebraska.
The Senate Glossary defines an executive session as one where "A portion of the Senate's daily session in which it considers executive business." Wikipedia's section on the standing rules of the Senate has more, in addition to a list of the executive positions subject to advise and consent.
Here's background on John M. Gerrard. He was appointed on the recommendation of retiring Nebraska Senator Ben Nelson. This is the customary way that Federal District Judges are appointment when one of the state's US Senators are of the same party as the president. Alabama Senator Sessions has opposed Gerrard's nomination partly due to an opinion he issued challenging whether the executions by electric chair was constitutional.
If approved, Gerrard would fill a vacancy on the court (here's the Wikipedia page for the court, here's the court's website) and become its sixth judge. This is the only district court for the state of Nebraska. There are 89 such courts across the country. Each state has to have one according to the Constitution.
What is a US District Judge you ask? The US Court's website explains (its the trial court on the federal level) here's more info from the relevant Wikipedia page.
The appointment and confirmation has become increasingly contentious. Senate rules allow a minority to prevent confirmation votes - or any vote really - from going to the floor. Reports suggest that judicial vacancies have risen during the Obama Administration. Here are numbers from the US Courts site and judicialnomination.org.
For a list of Obama's judicial nominees, click here.
Saturday, January 29, 2011
Senate Procedures Changed to Address Gridlock
Here's an NYT story that might help my 2302's with this weeks written assignment:
In an effort to ease persistent Senate gridlock, the leadership on Thursday promised to temper the procedural warfare that has consumed the chamber in recent years and increased partisan tension. “We want the Senate to move deliberately,” said Senator Harry Reid, the Democratic majority leader. “But we want it to move.”
The bipartisan agreement left intact the filibuster, the most powerful weapon that can be used on the Senate floor. But the Senate approved other changes Thursday in rules intended to quicken the pace of action, including new limits on a single lawmaker’s ability to anonymously block legislation and nominations.
At the same time, Senator Harry Reid, the Nevada Democrat and majority leader, made a commitment to give Republicans more opportunity to change legislation on the floor in exchange for a commitment from Senator Mitch McConnell of Kentucky, the Republican leader, to refrain from filibustering attempts to bring up measures for debate.
“We want the Senate to move deliberately,” Mr. Reid said. “But we want it to move. We have to find a balance that will encourage us to debate and that also enables us to legislate.”
In an effort to ease persistent Senate gridlock, the leadership on Thursday promised to temper the procedural warfare that has consumed the chamber in recent years and increased partisan tension. “We want the Senate to move deliberately,” said Senator Harry Reid, the Democratic majority leader. “But we want it to move.”
The bipartisan agreement left intact the filibuster, the most powerful weapon that can be used on the Senate floor. But the Senate approved other changes Thursday in rules intended to quicken the pace of action, including new limits on a single lawmaker’s ability to anonymously block legislation and nominations.
At the same time, Senator Harry Reid, the Nevada Democrat and majority leader, made a commitment to give Republicans more opportunity to change legislation on the floor in exchange for a commitment from Senator Mitch McConnell of Kentucky, the Republican leader, to refrain from filibustering attempts to bring up measures for debate.
“We want the Senate to move deliberately,” Mr. Reid said. “But we want it to move. We have to find a balance that will encourage us to debate and that also enables us to legislate.”
Wednesday, January 26, 2011
The Filibuster Lives On
Democrats drop efforts to limit the use of the filibuster.
After a lengthy meeting with their colleagues and clear signs that they lacked the votes to try to force through new restrictions on the filibuster, the lawmakers — Senators Tom Udall of New Mexico, Jeff Merkley of Oregon and Tom Harkin of Iowa — said they would relent now but press their case over the long term.
“While I’m disappointed this body lacks the necessary will to enact truly substantive reforms, we have certainly succeeded in bringing reform to the forefront and shining a light on the sources of our dysfunction,” Mr. Udall said. He added that he was committed to “making sure the Senate is more than just a graveyard for good ideas and we are able to address the challenges we face as a nation.”
The Democrats had never championed elimination of the filibuster, but sought to reduce its use and to require senators taking part in any blockade to be represented on the floor while doing so.
After a lengthy meeting with their colleagues and clear signs that they lacked the votes to try to force through new restrictions on the filibuster, the lawmakers — Senators Tom Udall of New Mexico, Jeff Merkley of Oregon and Tom Harkin of Iowa — said they would relent now but press their case over the long term.
“While I’m disappointed this body lacks the necessary will to enact truly substantive reforms, we have certainly succeeded in bringing reform to the forefront and shining a light on the sources of our dysfunction,” Mr. Udall said. He added that he was committed to “making sure the Senate is more than just a graveyard for good ideas and we are able to address the challenges we face as a nation.”
The Democrats had never championed elimination of the filibuster, but sought to reduce its use and to require senators taking part in any blockade to be represented on the floor while doing so.
Labels:
112th Congress,
filibusters,
senate procedures,
The Senate
Sunday, January 23, 2011
Senate Traditions
From the U.S. Senate homepage, a list of Senate traditions as well as the guides they provide newly elected senators.
Friday, January 21, 2011
The Texas Senate Retains the 2/3rds Rule
From the Texas Tribune:
In a party-line vote, the Texas Senate adopted its rules today without making any changes to the rule that requires the consent of two-thirds of the body in order to bring an issue to the floor. Of course, no change means that controversial legislation on voter ID — as it was last session — is exempt.
This has been controversial because though Republicans have a comfortable majority in the Senate, they don't have a 2/3rds majority. Democrats still have the ability to stop legislation, except now for Voter ID legislation.
In a party-line vote, the Texas Senate adopted its rules today without making any changes to the rule that requires the consent of two-thirds of the body in order to bring an issue to the floor. Of course, no change means that controversial legislation on voter ID — as it was last session — is exempt.
This has been controversial because though Republicans have a comfortable majority in the Senate, they don't have a 2/3rds majority. Democrats still have the ability to stop legislation, except now for Voter ID legislation.
Saturday, January 8, 2011
Filibuster Reform . . .
. . . just might happen.
Labels:
bill making,
filibusters,
senate procedures,
The Senate
Friday, December 31, 2010
Would the Constitution's Framers have Supported the Filibuster?
Here's an academic paper arguing that they would not have.
Two other academic types argue that the filibuster is actually unconstitutional.
Two other academic types argue that the filibuster is actually unconstitutional.
Thursday, December 9, 2010
Tax Bill and DADT Blocked
An example of how legislation can be stopped -- even though majorities support them -- by blocking bill form reaching the floor.
- The Senate and DADT.
- The Senate and Aid for 9/11 Workers.
- The House and the Tax Bill.
- The Senate and DADT.
- The Senate and Aid for 9/11 Workers.
- The House and the Tax Bill.
Friday, December 3, 2010
Filibuster Reform Proposal
Oregon Senator Jeff Merkley would like to see us return to the old fashioned filibusters of yesterday, the one's that actually involved an endless floor debate.
- The Plum Line.
- The Senator's Memo.
- Congress 101.
- Kevin Drum.
- The Plum Line.
- The Senator's Memo.
- Congress 101.
- Kevin Drum.
Saturday, October 2, 2010
Senator Jim DeMint and Unanimous Consent
South Carolina Senator Jim DeMint apparently intends to block all action in the Senate until after the elections by refusing to allow his consent to the days business. This call attention -- not only to the Senator -- but to this practice. As we discussed in 2302, the Senate is far more subject to the preferencs of individual members than is the House. This is proof.
Here's a brief description of unanimous consent from a larger, critical, piece in the The New Republic:
The chamber conducts most of its business via what’s known as unanimous consent. Under this procedure, the Senate majority leadership announces it intention to do something, like setting the hours for debate on a given day, and reaches an agreement with the minority leadership. Once that agreement is in place, the leadership gives senators a chance to object. If nobody objects--i.e., if the consent is unanimous--the leadership’s proposal takes effect. But if even one senator does object, the majority must secure sixty votes via the cumbersome cloture process in order to reach a vote on the pending measure. As a recent brief for the Center for American Progress puts it, "It may only take 60 votes to get something accomplished in the Senate, but it takes 100 votes to do so quickly."
Among the items of business the Senate handles through unanimous consent is non-controversial legislation, such as a new law prohibiting federal prisoners from keeping cell phones while serving time. (It's called the “Cell Phone Contraband Act.”) The Senate Democratic leadership had planned this week to dispense with a backlog of such proposals before adjourning, as is customary at the end of a session. But DeMint has said no, vowing to object to any further business. That means no more laws will pass until after the election--and it will happen then only if the Senate decides to deal with the bills during the lame duck period.
- More info from the Senate Glossary.
- Unanimous Consent Agreement.
- The Senate as a collective action problem.
Here's a brief description of unanimous consent from a larger, critical, piece in the The New Republic:
The chamber conducts most of its business via what’s known as unanimous consent. Under this procedure, the Senate majority leadership announces it intention to do something, like setting the hours for debate on a given day, and reaches an agreement with the minority leadership. Once that agreement is in place, the leadership gives senators a chance to object. If nobody objects--i.e., if the consent is unanimous--the leadership’s proposal takes effect. But if even one senator does object, the majority must secure sixty votes via the cumbersome cloture process in order to reach a vote on the pending measure. As a recent brief for the Center for American Progress puts it, "It may only take 60 votes to get something accomplished in the Senate, but it takes 100 votes to do so quickly."
Among the items of business the Senate handles through unanimous consent is non-controversial legislation, such as a new law prohibiting federal prisoners from keeping cell phones while serving time. (It's called the “Cell Phone Contraband Act.”) The Senate Democratic leadership had planned this week to dispense with a backlog of such proposals before adjourning, as is customary at the end of a session. But DeMint has said no, vowing to object to any further business. That means no more laws will pass until after the election--and it will happen then only if the Senate decides to deal with the bills during the lame duck period.
- More info from the Senate Glossary.
- Unanimous Consent Agreement.
- The Senate as a collective action problem.
Monday, January 11, 2010
Is the Filibuster Unconstitutional?
Thomas Geoghegan makes a good case that they are:
. . . the Senate, as it now operates, really has become unconstitutional: as we saw during the recent health care debacle, a 60-vote majority is required to overcome a filibuster and pass any contested bill. The founders, though, were dead set against supermajorities as a general rule, and the ever-present filibuster threat has made the Senate a more extreme check on the popular will than they ever intended.
This change to the Constitution was not the result of, say, a formal amendment, but a procedural rule adopted in 1975: a revision of Senate Rule 22, which was the old cloture rule. Before 1975, it took two-thirds of the Senate to end a filibuster, but it was the “Mr. Smith Goes to Washington” filibuster: if senators wanted to stop a vote, they had to bring in the cots and the coffee and read from Grandma’s recipe for chicken soup until, unshaven, they keeled over from their own rhetorical exhaust.
For the record, nothing like Senate Rule 22 appears in the Constitution, nor was there unlimited debate until Vice President Aaron Burr presided over the Senate in the early 180os. In 1917, after a century of chaos, the Senate put in the old Rule 22 to stop unlimited filibusters. Because it was about stopping real, often distressing, floor debate, one might have been able to defend that rule under Article I, Section 5 of the Constitution, which says, “Each house may determine the rule of its proceedings.”
As revised in 1975, Senate Rule 22 seemed to be an improvement: it required 60 senators, not 67, to stop floor debate. But there also came a significant change in de facto Senate practice: to maintain a filibuster, senators no longer had to keep talking. Nowadays, they don’t even have to start; they just say they will, and that’s enough. Senators need not be on the floor at all. They can be at home watching Jimmy Stewart on cable. Senate Rule 22 now exists to cut off what are ghost filibusters, disembodied debates.
As a result, the supermajority vote no longer deserves any protection under Article I, Section 5 — if it ever did at all. It is instead a revision of Article I itself: not used to cut off debate, but to decide in effect whether to enact a law. The filibuster votes, which once occurred perhaps seven or eight times a whole Congressional session, now happen more than 100 times a term. But this routine use of supermajority voting is, at worst, unconstitutional and, at best, at odds with the founders’ intent.
Here's more on Senate Rule 22:
- Senate.gov: Cloture.
- Wikipedia.
. . . the Senate, as it now operates, really has become unconstitutional: as we saw during the recent health care debacle, a 60-vote majority is required to overcome a filibuster and pass any contested bill. The founders, though, were dead set against supermajorities as a general rule, and the ever-present filibuster threat has made the Senate a more extreme check on the popular will than they ever intended.
This change to the Constitution was not the result of, say, a formal amendment, but a procedural rule adopted in 1975: a revision of Senate Rule 22, which was the old cloture rule. Before 1975, it took two-thirds of the Senate to end a filibuster, but it was the “Mr. Smith Goes to Washington” filibuster: if senators wanted to stop a vote, they had to bring in the cots and the coffee and read from Grandma’s recipe for chicken soup until, unshaven, they keeled over from their own rhetorical exhaust.
For the record, nothing like Senate Rule 22 appears in the Constitution, nor was there unlimited debate until Vice President Aaron Burr presided over the Senate in the early 180os. In 1917, after a century of chaos, the Senate put in the old Rule 22 to stop unlimited filibusters. Because it was about stopping real, often distressing, floor debate, one might have been able to defend that rule under Article I, Section 5 of the Constitution, which says, “Each house may determine the rule of its proceedings.”
As revised in 1975, Senate Rule 22 seemed to be an improvement: it required 60 senators, not 67, to stop floor debate. But there also came a significant change in de facto Senate practice: to maintain a filibuster, senators no longer had to keep talking. Nowadays, they don’t even have to start; they just say they will, and that’s enough. Senators need not be on the floor at all. They can be at home watching Jimmy Stewart on cable. Senate Rule 22 now exists to cut off what are ghost filibusters, disembodied debates.
As a result, the supermajority vote no longer deserves any protection under Article I, Section 5 — if it ever did at all. It is instead a revision of Article I itself: not used to cut off debate, but to decide in effect whether to enact a law. The filibuster votes, which once occurred perhaps seven or eight times a whole Congressional session, now happen more than 100 times a term. But this routine use of supermajority voting is, at worst, unconstitutional and, at best, at odds with the founders’ intent.
Here's more on Senate Rule 22:
- Senate.gov: Cloture.
- Wikipedia.
Sunday, July 5, 2009
And Franken Makes 60
From the NYT, some observations about the consequences of Dems having 60 senators:
With 60 votes (including those of two independents) now most likely aligned with the Democrats, the party could avoid filibusters.
But Mr. Franken swiftly made it clear that he did not view himself as the Democrats’ No. 60. “That’s not how I see it,” he said, adding that he was “going to be the second senator from the state of Minnesota, and that’s how I’m going to do this job.”
Though Republicans expressed disappointment at the outcome, they had in recent weeks become increasingly resigned to Mr. Franken joining the Senate.
On Tuesday, they joined Mr. Coleman in acknowledging defeat and immediately sought to raise expectations for Democrats.
“With their supermajority, the era of excuses and finger-pointing is now over,” said Senator John Cornyn of Texas, who heads the National Republican Senatorial Committee. Mr. Cornyn said it was “troubling to think about what they might now accomplish with 60 votes.”
But whether Democrats can consistently rely on 60 senators being present is in question. Two veteran Democrats, Senators Robert C. Byrd of West Virginia and Edward M. Kennedy of Massachusetts, are ailing and have regularly been absent from the Senate. In addition, a handful of moderate to conservative Democrats have shown a willingness to break from the party, and even liberals will do so on some issues.
Democrats are known for being difficult to organize in some coherent manner, especially in the Senate. Conversely, as Republicans decrease in size, they become more cohesive and more disruptive. It will interesting to follow the dynamic between the respective parties.
With 60 votes (including those of two independents) now most likely aligned with the Democrats, the party could avoid filibusters.
But Mr. Franken swiftly made it clear that he did not view himself as the Democrats’ No. 60. “That’s not how I see it,” he said, adding that he was “going to be the second senator from the state of Minnesota, and that’s how I’m going to do this job.”
Though Republicans expressed disappointment at the outcome, they had in recent weeks become increasingly resigned to Mr. Franken joining the Senate.
On Tuesday, they joined Mr. Coleman in acknowledging defeat and immediately sought to raise expectations for Democrats.
“With their supermajority, the era of excuses and finger-pointing is now over,” said Senator John Cornyn of Texas, who heads the National Republican Senatorial Committee. Mr. Cornyn said it was “troubling to think about what they might now accomplish with 60 votes.”
But whether Democrats can consistently rely on 60 senators being present is in question. Two veteran Democrats, Senators Robert C. Byrd of West Virginia and Edward M. Kennedy of Massachusetts, are ailing and have regularly been absent from the Senate. In addition, a handful of moderate to conservative Democrats have shown a willingness to break from the party, and even liberals will do so on some issues.
Democrats are known for being difficult to organize in some coherent manner, especially in the Senate. Conversely, as Republicans decrease in size, they become more cohesive and more disruptive. It will interesting to follow the dynamic between the respective parties.
Tuesday, June 23, 2009
Judicial Vacancies in Texas
Charles Kuffner updates us on a conflict between the Obama White House and our Texas Senators regarding two federal judicial vacancies in the state:
As we know, there are vacancies in the US Attorney's offices in the Southern and Western district offices in Texas, which will be filled by Presidential appointment. Normally, when the President is of one party and both of a given state's Senators are of the other party, "the primary role in recommending candidates for district court judgeships is assumed by officials in the state who are of the President's party." That's from a report last year by the non-partisan Congressional Research Service. Except that as Steve Benen noted, Texas' Republican Senators have refused to honor this practice, and instead have insisted on sending to Obama candidates who have been screened by the committee he and Hutchison have always used for making nominations -- a committee he admits is "heavily stacked with Republican lawyers." Because, you know, it's different when Democrats are in charge.
Read on ....
As we know, there are vacancies in the US Attorney's offices in the Southern and Western district offices in Texas, which will be filled by Presidential appointment. Normally, when the President is of one party and both of a given state's Senators are of the other party, "the primary role in recommending candidates for district court judgeships is assumed by officials in the state who are of the President's party." That's from a report last year by the non-partisan Congressional Research Service. Except that as Steve Benen noted, Texas' Republican Senators have refused to honor this practice, and instead have insisted on sending to Obama candidates who have been screened by the committee he and Hutchison have always used for making nominations -- a committee he admits is "heavily stacked with Republican lawyers." Because, you know, it's different when Democrats are in charge.
Read on ....
Thursday, September 20, 2007
The Power of 60
Three majority votes in the Senate failed this week because Democrats were unable to muster 60 votes in their favor. 60 allows for a cloture vote, which breaks a filibuster.
1- A proposal to lengthen home leaves failed even though it received a majority vote of 56 to 44.
(S A 2909)
2- A proposal to give DC a vote in Congress failed despite receiving a vote of 57 to 42. (S 1257)
3- A proposal to habeas corpus to those detained by the United States despite a vote of 56 to 43. (SA 2022)
No surprise really since the Senate, by design, has always been able to empower a minority to stop legislation. That's why it looks the way it does. If we tallied the populations represented by the senators we may well find that they represent the interest of an even smaller fraction of the population.
The votes demonstrate that president Bush still has the ability to rally his party behind him. If the population is firmly behind the Democrats, they will be able to use these votes as campaign items in 2008. That's why we have elections.
Here's my question: When Democrats were in the minority and used similar tactics, Republicans argued that they violated democratic principles and proposed a nuclear, or constitutional, option that would have eliminated filibusters. It's not a constitutional power after all. So why don't we hear the same from Democrats?
1- A proposal to lengthen home leaves failed even though it received a majority vote of 56 to 44.
(S A 2909)
2- A proposal to give DC a vote in Congress failed despite receiving a vote of 57 to 42. (S 1257)
3- A proposal to habeas corpus to those detained by the United States despite a vote of 56 to 43. (SA 2022)
No surprise really since the Senate, by design, has always been able to empower a minority to stop legislation. That's why it looks the way it does. If we tallied the populations represented by the senators we may well find that they represent the interest of an even smaller fraction of the population.
The votes demonstrate that president Bush still has the ability to rally his party behind him. If the population is firmly behind the Democrats, they will be able to use these votes as campaign items in 2008. That's why we have elections.
Here's my question: When Democrats were in the minority and used similar tactics, Republicans argued that they violated democratic principles and proposed a nuclear, or constitutional, option that would have eliminated filibusters. It's not a constitutional power after all. So why don't we hear the same from Democrats?
Tuesday, February 6, 2007
minority rules
We need to chew on the procedural rules that have allowed the minority to prevail over the majority on the fate of the non-binding resolutions in the Senate. Here is one story covering latest. More will follow today.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)