Showing posts with label standing. Show all posts
Showing posts with label standing. Show all posts

Monday, June 27, 2016

From Scotublog: United States v. Texas

The court upheld a preliminary injunction issued by a federal judge in Texas temporarily halting the president's Deferred Action for Parents of Americans and Lawful Permanent Residents program. No substantive decision was made about why it did so, meaning - as I see it - the question about whether the president exceeded - in fact - his authority still needs to be fleshed out. In addition, if he did, how?

- Click here for the summary from Scotublog.

- For facts of the case, click here for Oyez's page on it.

This is the list of the issues raised by the case:

(1) Whether a state that voluntarily provides a subsidy to all aliens with deferred action has Article III standing and a justiciable cause of action under the Administrative Procedure Act (APA) to challenge the Secretary of Homeland Security’s guidance seeking to establish a process for considering deferred action for certain aliens because it will lead to more aliens having deferred action;
(2) whether the guidance is arbitrary and capricious or otherwise not in accordance with law;
(3) whether the guidance was subject to the APA’s notice-and-comment procedures; and
(4) whether the guidance violates the Take Care Clause of the Constitution, Article II, section 3.

For background on some terms used above:

- Standing.
- Arbitrary and Capricious.
- Administrative Procedures Act.
- Take Care Clause.

Wednesday, February 10, 2016

From USA Today: Chief Justice John Roberts seeks to limit role of courts

Opportunities to bring lawsuits forward are being limited. Fewer people are felt to posses "standing" to sue.

- Click here for the article.

By siding with the Supreme Court's liberal wing on two major cases last week, Chief Justice John Roberts lent credence to conservatives' concerns that they can't count on his vote. But as he moves into his second decade as the nation's 17th chief justice, Roberts is proving to be strikingly consistent in one area that conservatives applaud. He wants to close the courthouse doors to challengers with tenuous legal grounds or claims, thereby limiting the role of the judicial branch he leads.
That desire has been on display regularly during the first half of the high court's 2015 term, both in rulings Roberts joined and in those he opposed. At nearly every opportunity, he voted to limit plaintiffs' access — demanding that they prove being harmed, back up their challenge with facts, and opt for arbitration over litigation.
The chief justice wrote the court's first decision of the term, ruling Dec. 1 that a California woman had no right to sue the Austrian national railroad in a U.S. court for severe injuries she suffered on a train platform in Innsbruck.
Two weeks later, he joined the court's 6-3 majority ruling that California customers cannot join a class action lawsuit against satellite TV provider DIRECTV because a federal law favoring arbitration over litigation trumps state law.
. . . In a report on Roberts' first decade as chief justice, the liberal Constitutional Accountability Center found him uniformly stingy on standing and generous on forced arbitration. "He has repeatedly emphasized that the role of the courts should be limited, that they’re not there to solve policy debates," says Elizabeth Wydra, the group's president.
Roberts' preferences and his court's precedents are starting to filter down to lower federal courts. In the year ending Sept. 30, the number of cases filed at federal appellate, district and bankruptcy cases all declined, following a trend begun several years ago. The Supreme Court has seen a 13% drop over five years. To liberals, the trend is ominous. Brian Wolfman, co-director of the Supreme Court litigation clinic at Stanford Law School and former director of Public Citizen Litigation Group, says the trend from class action lawsuits toward arbitration penalizes consumers and workers who cannot afford to sue on their own.
"The consumer is effectively shut out from the civil justice system, and the employer or the corporation is effectively creating its own law," Wolfman says.

Also worth a look: Chief Justice John Roberts' Supreme Court at 10, defying labels.

Saturday, January 16, 2016

From the Tampa Bay Times: Marco Rubio seeks to dismiss court challenge to his eligibility to be president

As pointed out in a previous post, Senator Rubio's eligibility to hold office is also being challenged in court. The Tamps Bay Times lays out the conflict.

- Click here for the article.

Here's the a bit from the article:

Rubio was born in Miami in 1971. But Rubio's Cuban immigrant parents did not become U.S. citizens until 1975.
That’s convinced so-called birthers to conclude Rubio is ineligible under Article 2 of the Constitution, which says "no person except a natural born citizen … shall be eligible to the Office of President."
. . . Birthers rely on various passages to back up their argument. One is the treatise The
Law of Nations by Swiss philosopher Emer de Vattel, which they say influenced the founding fathers. "The natives, or natural-born citizens, are those born in the country, of parents who are citizens," Vattel wrote.
They also cite the U.S. Supreme Court, which in the 1875 case Minor vs. Happersett, used the term "natural born citizen" in reference to persons who were born in the United States, of U.S.-citizen parents.
"The arguments aren't crazy," said Georgetown law professor Lawrence Solum, an expert in constitutional theory. But, he added, "the much stronger argument suggests that if you were born on American soil that you would be considered a natural born citizen."

The article points out that Rubio took the claim seriously enough - they go back at least to 2011 - to prepare a legal argument stating that he is a "natural born citizen according to the Constitution. It is contained in his motion to dismiss the lawsuit against his eligibility.

- Click here for it.

I'll note briefly that in page 3, Rubio argues that the plaintiff lacks standing to bring the lawsuit forward. They argue - among other things - that standing requires that the plaintiff demonstrate a special injury, which he has not suffered.

More on this as the semester progresses.

Friday, December 4, 2015

Regarding the concept of "standing"

I asked 2305 students to think about the concept of standing since there might be - might be - a question about it on the test. Simply put, it's what allows you to sue someone - and what allows the courts to hear your case. You have been directly impacted by a law or executive action.

- Here's the relevant Wikipedia entry on the subject.

Legal observers have noticed that the current Supreme Court - the Roberts Court - has been tightening up the concept of standing, making it more difficult for people to prove harm and thereby taking cases to the court.

- Here's the latest along those lines.

It's written with an ideological agenda, the author argues that conservative justices have been trying to make it more difficult for people too use the courts to address grievances. So in addition to filling you in on the concept of standing, this also touches on ideology.

Here's a test of his argument:

Like many conservative judges, Roberts has sought to make it more difficult for people to get the standing to sue in federal court. In 2007, for example, Roberts joined anopinion that held that taxpayers did not have the standing to challenge expenditures by the executive branch that go to religious institutions.

Conservative justices on the supreme court have also narrowed standing in environmental cases. In a 1992 opinion written by Justice Scalia, the court deniedstanding to citizens bringing a lawsuit based on the Endangered Species Act. Vigilant citizens were denied the ability to compel enforcement of the statute in the face of executive inaction.


Wednesday, February 27, 2013

For today's look at the Supreme Court

A few items for today's look at the court:

- Justices Turn Back Challenge to Broader U.S. Eavesdropping: The court argued that the people who brought a lawsuit against the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act did not have standing to sue, and it may well be that no one has standing to sue.

- Justices Hear Arguments on Missed Deadline in Murder Case: The court heard arguments regarding a claim of innocence and whether federal habeas corpus challenges challenges override state deadlines to file innocence claims.

- From Scotus Blog: a look at what's on tap for today.

Today at the Court: February 27, 2013

Today is the last day of the February sitting. We are expecting one or more opinions in argued cases this morning and will begin live blogging shortly before ten o’clock.

After issuing opinions, the Justices will hear oral arguments in two cases: Shelby County v. Holder, followed by American Express Co. v. Italian Colors Restaurant.

In Shelby County, which Lyle previewed yesterday, and which Amy previewed on Monday “In Plain English,” the Court will consider the constitutionality of Section 5 of the Voting Rights Act of 1965. Lyle will post his analysis of the oral argument shortly after it concludes; we will also have analysis from Tom and a report from Amy “In Plain English.” In addition, the blog will have commentary on the oral argument from Roger Clegg, Ellen Katz, Abigail Thernstrom, and Elizabeth Wydra.

David Garcia and Leo Caseria previewed the argument in American Express, in which the Court will consider the Federal Arbitration Act and antitrust claims on credit card “swipe fees.”
We should spend time looking at the court record on Shelby County v Holder.
Shelby County v. Holder
Shelby County v. Holder

Saturday, December 29, 2012

A Federal Judge throws out a lawsuit claiming that the filibuster is an unconstitutional denial of majority rule

The judge argues that the petitioners did not have standing to sue (it was brought by Common Cause), and the courts would violated the separation of powers doctrine if it were to intrude on what it sees as an internal issue within the Senate.

The decision can be found here.

From ScotusBlog:

Ruling that the courts have no power to do anything about it, a federal judge on Friday threw out a claim that Senate filibusters are an unconstitutional denial of majority rule. U.S. District Judge Emmet G. Sullivan, in a forty-seven-page opinion, said none of the challengers had a right to pursue their case in court, and ruled that it would intrude on the Senate’s powers for the court to decide “an important and controversial issue.”

The decision leaves any chance of reducing the routine use of filibusters to block Senate action entirely within the hands of the Senate itself. There, Democratic leaders have been talking about a possible effort at the opening of the next Congress in January to make at least some changes in Rule XXII.

Under Rule XXII, it takes the votes of sixty senators to move ahead with debate or to close down debate on bills or presidential nominations. While the Senate is in the midst of one of its regular two-year sessions, the rule also requires a two-thirds vote to start or close debate on any proposal to change the Senate’s rules. Only at the opening of a new Congress could the Senate change its rules by a simple majority vote.

Judge Sullivan commented that, in today’s Senate, “even the mere threat of a filibuster is powerful enough to completely forestall legislative action.” But, he said, he “cannot find that any of [those who sued] have standing to sue….Second, and no less important, the Court is firmly convinced that to intrude into this area would offend the separation of powers on which the Constitution rests.”
The Constitution, the judge wrote, does not contain any “express requirements regarding the proper length of, or method for, the Senate to debate proposed legislation. Article I reserves to each house the power to determine the rules of its proceedings. And absent a rule’s violation of an express constraint in the Constitution or an individual’s fundamental rights, the internal proceedings of the Legislative Branch are beyond the jurisdiction of this Court.”

Tuesday, October 30, 2012

Do we have standing to sue the US government for unauthorized surveillance?

The recently argued case Clapper v. Amnesty International asked this question. The case is a challenge to secret wiretapping but - as we discussed in 2305 when we covered the Supreme Court - one can only take a lawsuit forward if one has standing, which means you have been harmed by the enforcement of a law. But if its a clandestine wiretap (and aren't they all?) how do we know if you've been harmed by it? How do you prove you have standing?

The law in question is the FISA Amendments Act of 2008, FISA stands for Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act.

Oyez describes the facts of the case:

Several groups, including attorneys, journalists, and human rights organizations, brought a facial challenge to a provision of the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act (FISA). The provision creates new procedures for authorizing government electronic surveillance of non-U.S. persons outside the U.S. for foreign intelligence purposes. The groups argue that the procedures violate the Fourth Amendment, the First Amendment, Article III of the Constitution, and the principle of separation of powers. The new provisions would force these groups to take costly measures to ensure the confidentiality of their international communications. The District Court for the Southern District of New York granted summary judgment for the government, holding that the groups did not have standing to bring their challenge. The groups only had an abstract subjective fear of being monitored and provided no proof that they were subject to the FISA. The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit reversed, holding that the groups had standing based on a reasonable fear of injury and costs incurred to avoid that injury.

And states the question presented the court:

Do respondents have Article III standing to seek prospective relief under the FISA?

So there's no substantive issue at hand as to whether it is legal for the government to engage in surveillance. There's only a question about whether there can be a challenge to it at all.

- Commentary here from the New Republic.
- Transcripts of the oral argument here.

Friday, November 18, 2011

Victory for Prop. 8 backers : SCOTUSblog

Victory for Prop. 8 backers : SCOTUSblog.

From the LA Times:

The California Supreme Court decided Thursday that the sponsors of Proposition 8 and other ballot measures are entitled to defend them in court when the state refuses to do so, a ruling likely to spur federal courts to decide the constitutionality of same-sex marriage bans.

The state high court’s decision, a defeat for gay rights groups, sets the stage for a federal ruling -- which could go all the way to the U.S. Supreme Court -- that would affect marriage bans outside California.

Background from the NYT:

Some gay rights groups were disappointed today when the California Supreme Court ruled that the sponsors of Proposition 8, ProtectMarriage, have standing to defend the discriminatory law, even though Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger and Attorney General Jerry Brown had refused to do so.

Previously, Judge Vaughn Walker, who ruled the ban against same-sex unions unconstitutional in federal court, had said that ProtectMarriage could not appeal his decision to the Ninth Circuit, because they were never able to prove that gay marriage harmed them in any way.

That, of course is one of the many huge flaws in the argument against marriage equality.

But, as we wrote in an editorial on December 10, 2010, denying standing to the anti-marriage crowd would effectively nullify the referendum, confounding the initiative process and the voters’ right to have their choices defended. That’s probably not the best way to secure equality for a minority group.





Saturday, July 30, 2011

How would the Supreme Court rule if Obama uses the 14th Amendment to borrow money if the debt ceiling is not raised?

A few previous posts have highlighted the ongoing dispute concerning the language in the 14th Amendment which mandates that the full faith and credit of the US should be maintained and whether this means that Obama can go ahead and keep borrowing money to meet obligations.

So what if he does and a challenge to that action is brought up in court?

There is reason to believe that the Supreme Court may not even rule on that case since few if any people will be able to state that they have standing before the court:

When it comes to Congress’s ability to stop the Obama administration from ignoring the debt ceiling, legal experts note that the first obstacle standing in its way is the question of standing, or whether a certain party has the right to sue over an issue in the first place. Jonathan Zasloff, a professor at the UCLA School of Law who has discussed this idea on a blog that he writes with several other academics, told me that while an order from the president for the Treasury Department to continue issuing new debt sounded extreme, it was unclear who could prove sufficient injury from the decision that would qualify the person to sue the administration in court. “Who has some kind of particularized injury, in fact?” Zasloff asked, and he could not come up with a satisfying answer.

Part of the reason for Zasloff’s difficulty in identifying an appropriate plaintiff is that members of Congress have tried before to sue the president for diminishing their legislative and appropriating power and have typically failed. . . .

Even if they do decide to hear it, past voting records and philosophies suggest that Most justices - with the exception of Thomas - would side with the president.

A post in Volock Conspiracy argues that a recently decided Supreme Court decision might provide an opportunity for standing to be granted.

All this aside, Andrew Sullivan seems to think this is all an impeachment trap.

Tuesday, July 5, 2011

A Big Business Friendly Term

Commentators seem to agree (here's an exception) that the recent Supreme Court term was great for big business in the United States. Dahlia Lithwick complains that their decisions have given corporations a guide book for how to discriminate among their employees and lie to customers and investors. Much of this is achieved by limiting the ability of people to take cases to the judiciary.

She highlights three specific cases:

- Wal-Mart v. Dukes
- AT&T Mobility v. Concepcion
- Janus Capital Group, Inc. v. First Derivative Traders

For 2302, her article highlights points we've raised the about the court narrowing "standing" and making it more difficult for people to actually take cases to court. For 2301 this is a great example of the ability of a well financed, cohesive small group to win out over a larger, less cohesive group in the political process.

Wednesday, April 27, 2011

Supreme Court Allows Contracts Forbidding Class-Action Arbitration

The Supreme Court continues to make class action lawsuits more difficult to move forward. The case is  AT&T Mobility v. Concepcion.

From the NYT:

Businesses may use standard-form contracts to forbid consumers claiming fraud from banding together in a single arbitration, the Supreme Court ruled on Wednesday in a 5-to-4 decision that split along ideological lines.

Though the decision concerned arbitrations, it appeared to provide businesses with a way to avoid class-action lawsuits in court. All they need do, the decision suggested, is use standard-form contracts that require two things: that disputes be raised only through the informal mechanism of arbitration and that claims be brought one by one.

“The decision basically lets companies escape class actions, so long as they do so by means of arbitration agreements,” Brian T. Fitzpatrick, a law professor at Vanderbilt University, said. “This is a game-changer for businesses. It’s one of the most important and favorable cases for businesses in a very long time.”

The decision fits in with recent rulings that have favored arbitrations and been wary of aspects of class actions. 

Tuesday, April 5, 2011

Supreme Court Allows Tax Credit for Religious Tuition

From the NYT, for my 2302s:

The Supreme Court on Monday let stand an Arizona program that aids religious schools, saying in a 5-to-4 decision that the plaintiffs had no standing to challenge it.

The program itself is novel and complicated, and allowing it to go forward may be of no particular moment. But by closing the courthouse door to some kinds of suits that claim violations of the First Amendment’s ban on government establishment of religion, the court’s ruling in the case may be quite consequential.

Justice Elena Kagan, in her first dissent, said the majority had laid waste to the doctrine of “taxpayer standing,” which allows suits from people who object to having tax money spent on religious matters. “The court’s opinion,” Justice Kagan wrote, “offers a road map — more truly, just a one-step instruction — to any government that wishes to insulate its financing of religious activity from legal challenge.”

The decision divided the court along the usual ideological lines, with the three other more liberal members — Justices Ruth Bader Ginsburg, Stephen G. Breyer and Sonia Sotomayor — joining the dissent.

-
Arizona Christian School Tuition Organization v. Winn.

Wednesday, March 2, 2011

Ashcroft v. al-Kidd

The Supreme Court will hear arguments on a case involving both the material witness statute and whether the Attorney General can be sued.

The case is Ashcroft v. al-Kidd.

- ScotusBlog. Argument preview: An old law in new guises?
- ScotusBlog: Ashcroft v al-Kidd.
- Wikipedia: Material Witness Statute.
- Wikipedia: Qualified Immunity Doctrine.

Saturday, December 11, 2010

Standing, Class Action Lawsuits and Wal-Mart v. Dukes

A case involving accusations of gender discrimination at Wal-Mart is also allowing the court to question the very practice of bringing class action lawsuits forward. Once again the court is flirting with the idea of limiting standing, the right of people to demonstrate to the court that they have a legitimate reason to take a case to the court.

- ScotusBlog: Walmart v. Dukes.
- ScotuBlog: This Week at the Court.
- Wikipedia: Walmart v. Dukes.
- ClassActionBlawg.
- Wikipedia: Class Action.
- Findlaw: Gender Discrimination

Monday, October 18, 2010

More on The Constitutionality of Health Care Reform

Here's a great example of the consequences of a decentralized, federal judicial system. While last week a federal judge in Michigan said the individual mandate in the health care law is a constitutional use of Congress' commerce powers. a Virginia court stated that it isn't so sure, and a Florida court stated that it isn't.

Here's reasonable commentary.

Friday, October 8, 2010

A District Court Judge Finds the Individual Mandate Constitutional

Here's huge -- and relevant -- news. A district court judge has ruled that the individual mandate in the recently passed health care law does fall under the authority of Congress under the Commerce Clause. Pay attention 2301s:

From Ezra Klein:

A district court judge has ruled the individual mandate is constitutional, reports N.C. Aizenman: "Other federal courts have already dismissed some challenges to the law on technical grounds - ruling, for instance, that the plaintiffs lacked standing. However, the decision issued Thursday by Judge George Caram Steeh of the Eastern District of Michigan is the first to reject a claim based on the merits, marking a notable victory for the Obama administration...Steeh found that 'far from 'inactivity,' by choosing to forgo insurance, plaintiffs are making an economic decision to try to pay for health-care services later, out of pocket, rather than now through the purchase of insurance, collectively shifting billions of dollars...onto other market participants.'"

- Here's the opinion...

...and a key quote from it:

“In assessing the scope of Congress’ authority under the Commerce Clause,” the court’s task “is a modest one.” The court need not itself determine whether the regulated activities, “taken in the aggregate, substantially affect interstate commerce in fact, but only whether a ‘rational basis’ exists for so concluding.”



There is a rational basis to conclude that, in the aggregate, decisions to forego insurance coverage in preference to attempting to pay for health care out of pocket drive up the cost of insurance. The costs of caring for the uninsured who prove unable to pay are shifted to health care providers, to the insured population in the form of higher premiums, to governments, and to taxpayers. The decision whether to purchase insurance or to attempt to pay for health care out of pocket, is plainly economic. These decisions, viewed in the aggregate, have clear and direct impacts on health care providers, taxpayers, and the insured population who ultimately pay for the care provided to those who go without insurance. These are the economic effects addressed by Congress in enacting the Act and the minimum coverage provision.

- From the NYT.
- Here's a decision from a previous case where the law was dismissed on procedural grounds.

Now it will go on to higher level appelate courts further consideration. Pay attention 2302s!

Saturday, September 25, 2010

Regarding Standing: Who Has the Right to Sue?

The concept of "standing" refers to whether the court has the jurisdiction to hear a particular case, which is a nice way of saying that a litigant does not in fact have the right to sue, or take a case to court. The current court has increasingly restricted the concept of standing, meaning that access to the courts has contracted recently. Cases, like the one involving  have been the inclusion of "under God" in the Pledge of Allegiance, not on the merits, but because the person who brought the case forward was not directly affected by the law.

Linda Greenhouse predicts that the Supreme Court will get tangled up now that conservatives want to challenge the constitutionality of the health care law, among other things.