Showing posts with label unemployment. Show all posts
Showing posts with label unemployment. Show all posts

Wednesday, March 8, 2017

From the Pew Research Center: What the unemployment rate does – and doesn’t – say about the economy

For our future look at economic policy in 2305.

- Click here for the article.

Every month, the federal Bureau of Labor Statistics releases a flood of data about employment and unemployment in the U.S. And every month, the lion’s share of the attention goes to one figure – the unemployment rate, which was a seasonally adjusted 4.8% in January. (The February report comes out on Friday.)
But the unemployment rate is just one indicator of how the U.S. economy is doing, and it’s not always the best one. Simply being out of work isn’t enough for a person to be counted as unemployed; he or she also has to be available to work and actively looking for work (or on temporary layoff). In any given month, the unemployment rate can rise or fall based not just on how many people find or lose jobs, but on how many join or leave the active labor force.
There are, in fact, five other monthly measures of what the BLS calls “labor underutilization” besides the official unemployment rate, as well as scores of other measurements – labor force participation rates, employment-population ratios, average weekly wages, average hours worked and more. Knowing what those other data points are, where they come from and how they’re calculated is critical in understanding what they do – and don’t – tell us about the nation’s workers.

Monday, March 21, 2016

From 538: Manufacturing Jobs Are Never Coming Back

In a word: automation.

The suggests presidential candidates are making promises they cannot deliver. We know where this leads.

- Click here for the article.
A plea to presidential candidates: Stop talking about bringing manufacturing jobs back from China. In fact, talk a lot less about manufacturing, period.
It’s understandable that voters are angry about trade. The U.S. has lost more than 4.5 million manufacturing jobs since NAFTA took effect in 1994. And asEduardo Porter wrote this week, there’s mounting evidence that U.S. trade policy, particularly with China, has caused lasting harm to many American workers. But rather than play to that anger, candidates ought to be talking about ways to ensure that the service sector can fill manufacturing’s former role as a provider of dependable, decent-paying jobs.|
Here’s the problem: Whether or not those manufacturing jobs could have been saved, they aren’t coming back, at least not most of them. How do we know? Because in recent years, factories have been coming back, but the jobs haven’t. Because of rising wages in China, the need for shorter supply chains and other factors, a small but growing group of companies are shifting production back to the U.S. But the factories they build here are heavily automated, employing a small fraction of the workers they would have a generation ago.

Sunday, March 23, 2014

From WonkBlog: Five reasons why the long-term jobless don’t matter to the economy

A bit of depressing news. This throws cold water on the idea that long term unemployment has an easy solution.

Reason #3:
Long-term unemployed who leave the labor force are unlikely to come back
Roughly one in 10 of the long-term jobless left the workforce altogether within a few months of the survey, and most of them stayed out of the labor market after a year. The paper notes that the most common reason for leaving is that they no longer wanted a job, suggesting the decision is permanent.

Sunday, February 23, 2014

From the Atlantic: The Zombie Numbers That Rule the U.S. Economy

In 2305 we looked briefly at the budgeting process and will also look at economic policy making soon enough. Both make use of numbers that purport to tell us how the economy is doing - but here's a suggestion that those numbers are misleading.

- Click here for the article:
We act as if they are markers from time immemorial, but in fact they were invented for modern industrial nations after the Depression and World War II and are now seriously outdated.
Take gross domestic product. Derived from formulas set down by the economist Simon Kuznets and others in the 1930s, its limitations have long been recognized, none more eloquently than by Robert F. Kennedy in a famous speech in 1968 when he declared that it measured everything except that which is worth measuring.
GDP treats all output as a positive. When you buy LED lights that obviate the need to spend on incandescent bulbs and reduce energy consumption, GDP goes down and what should be an unmitigated good becomes a statistical negative. If a coal company pollutes a river, the cleanup costs are positive for GDP, as are any health care costs for those harmed.
What’s more, we have also come to assume that with output comes more spending and employment, but factories today are powered by robotics and software, and robots don’t buy more lattes and shoes.
GDP is a good number for a nation that produces lots of stuff made by lots of workers, but for an information economy grounded in services and intellectual property and awash in apps that cost nothing yet enable commerce, it is not up to the task. Nor are many of our indicators. Our trade figures treat an iPhone made—more accurately, assembled—in China with no reference to the intellectual property created by Apple in California.

Wednesday, January 29, 2014

From the Atlantic: The Fastest-Growing Jobs of This Decade (and the Robots That Will Steal Them)

More on which jobs are most likely to be done by a robot in the near future.

This article comes with the following handy chart which shows the tops term jobs of the near future and the likelihood they will be done by a robot or a software program:

1) Personal care aides: 74%
2) Registered nurses: 0.9%
3) Retail salespersons: 92%
4) Combined food prep & serving workers: 92%
5) Home health aides: 39%
6) Physician assistant: 9%
7) Secretaries and admin assistants: 96%
8) Customer service representatives: 55%
9) Janitors and cleaners: 66%
10) Construction workers: 71%
Good luck - seriously. Think about nursing, not office administration.

Saturday, January 25, 2014

Ideological disputes over unemployment insurance

The article linked to in the story below has content that describes ideological differences in opinions on unemployment insurance. It doesn't specifically say so, but the first view point tends to be the stereotypical liberal point of view while the second is the stereotypical conservative point of view:

Here's a link to the story again:

These are obviously two contrasting views about what happened to North Carolina's labor force, based on seemingly conflicting data sets. In their paper, Hagedorn and his co-authors wrote, "We could not establish the reasons for this discrepancy based on our conversations with the BLS." So it's very possible that the data's just noisy, and it's too soon to draw any broad conclusions from a half year's worth of data in a single state.
This does, however, touch on a long-standing economic discussion about the effect of unemployment insurance. Let's rehash that debate a bit for context.
The view that extended jobless benefits are helpful during a recession. One mainstream view is that cutting unemployment benefits during a recession doesn't actually spur people to find jobs. After all, jobs have been very scarce these past few years. Even today, there are still three workers seeking work for every one job opening. People can't find jobs if there aren't jobs to be found.
That's why many economists think that unemployment insurance isn't really discouraging workers from getting jobs right now. For instance, the University of California, Berkeley's Jesse Rothstein has estimated that the expansion of jobless benefits only added 0.1 to 0.5 percentage points to the unemployment rate in 2010. JPMorgan's Michael Feroli has helpfully rounded up a variety of studies that come to a similar conclusion
Those studies imply that workers won't magically find jobs if their unemployment insurance gets cut. Instead, many workers may stop looking for work — since they no longer have to keep search to qualify for benefits. The BLS numbers on North Carolina seem to support this story.
The view that jobless benefits are causing problems. Hagedorn, however, has dissented from this mainstream view. In October, he released a paper (pdf) with three co-authors suggesting that the expanded unemployment insurance program was actually responsible for much of the rise in joblessness during the Recession. Importantly, that paper doesn't argue that jobless benefits discourage workers from looking for jobs. (They find that this effect is small, just like Rothstein did.) Instead, his model suggested that the unemployment program raised costs for employers, who saw a drop in profits and, in turn, are less likely to offer jobs.
By extension, this paper suggests that cutting unemployment insurance might be a good thing — it would boost incentives for hiring. The Census's establishment survey numbers on North Carolina seem to support this story.
Others remain skeptical of Hagedorn's argument. As Chad Stone of the Center on Budget and Policy Priorities explained in this critique last fall, the paper relies on a very different model of how the U.S. economy acts during the recession — namely, one in which insufficient demand from consumers for goods and services isn't the economy's main problem. Stone argues that this model gets cause and effect backwards: Businesses aren't hiring because there's not enough consumer demand, which is why we had extended jobless benefits. Not the other way around.

States experiment on cutting jobless benefits

We introduced the phrase "laboratories of democracy" in 2306 and mentioned that it is considered to be one of the benefits of granting the states leeway in implementing different policies. State experimentation with policy proposals allows for a pragmatic evaluation of those proposals. Instead of resting opinions on ideological assumptions, they can be based on facts.

As Congress considers cutting unemployment insurance - which has been expanded considerably following the financial crash of 2008 - and legislators debate the consequences of doing so, North Carolina went ahead and did it this past July.

Wonkblog analyses the consequences, but points out that the data does not tell a clear story:

So what happened in North Carolina? As it turns out, the data is still fairly ambiguous and there are two conflicting interpretations here:
1) Many workers may have dropped out of the labor force. Everyone agrees that North Carolina's unemployment rate kept dropping, much as it did in the rest of the country, after benefits got cut.
But that might have been a bad omen: According to data from the Bureau of Labor Statistics, the number of people in the labor force has plummeted in North Carolina since last summer (even as it rebounded slightly in the rest of the nations).
. . . some people who saw their jobless benefits lapse may well have found jobs — perhaps they decided to take a lower-paying gig than they otherwise would have, out of desperation. But a greater number of workers appeared to have simply given up looking altogether, possibly because jobs are still extremely difficult to come by, and they no longer have to keep searching to qualify for benefits.
2) ...or perhaps employment actually increased. Yet other data sets seem to tell a different tale. A more optimistic view of what happened in North Carolina comes from a new paper (pdf) led by Marcus Hagedorn of the University of Oslo. He and his three co-authors sifted through the Census Bureau's "household survey" and the "establishment survey" for the same period. And the results were striking.
What they found is that overall employment has actually gone up in North Carolina since benefits got cut in June of 2013. The household survey in particular showed a big increase in both employment and labor force participation. But both surveys suggested that North Carolina's labor force is growing, not shrinking.
Hagedorn's paper suggests that, by and large, workers in North Carolina do seem to be finding jobs ever since unemployment insurance got cut. And it's not clear that these are lesser jobs or lower-paying jobs: The data suggests that overall hours in North Carolina went up, and there was little change in wages and earnings.

Evaluating the outcomes of a policy change seems to be trickier than one would expect. Does this throw cold water on the "states as laboratories of democracy" thesis?  

Wednesday, January 22, 2014

Can a robot do your job? Will it be able to soon?

This is a bit long, but promises to be one of the more important things you might read this semester.

Cut to the chase - from the conclusion:

Our model predicts that most workers in transportation and logistics occupations, together with the bulk of office and administrative support workers, and labour in production occupations, are at risk. These findings are consistent with recent technological developments documented in the literature. More surprisingly, we find that a substantial share of employment in service occupations, where most US job growth has occurred over the past decades (Autor and Dorn, 2013), are highly susceptible to computerisation. Additional support for this finding is provided by the recent growth in the market for service robots (MGI, 2013) and the gradually diminishment of the comparative advantage of human labour in tasks involving mobility and dexterity (Robotics-VO, 2013).

Finally, we provide evidence that wages and educational attainment exhibit a strong negative relationship with the probability of computerisation. We note that this finding implies a discontinuity between the nineteenth, twentieth and the twenty-first century, in the impact of capital deepening on the relative demand for skilled labour. While nineteenth century manufacturing technologies largely substituted for skilled labour through the simplification of tasks (Braver-man, 1974; Hounshell, 1985; James and Skinner, 1985; Goldin and Katz, 1998), the Computer Revolution of the twentieth century caused a hollowing-out of middle-income jobs (Goos,et al., 2009; Autor and Dorn, 2013). Our model predicts a truncation in the current trend towards labour market polarisation, with computerisation being principally confined to low-skill and low-wage occupations. Our findings thus imply that as technology races ahead, low-skill workers will reallocate to tasks that are non-susceptible to computerisation – i.e. , tasks requiring creative and social intelligence. For workers to win the race, however, they will have to acquire creative and social skills.

Creativity and social skills will save you from the robots!

Tuesday, September 24, 2013

Has austerity hampered economic growth?

Here is an argument that it has.

In recent recessions, government spending has increased. Not in the current recession. Here's one factoid. Government jobs have been cut, which keeps the unemployment rate high. In previous recessions they increased.



A CBO report argues that austerity has cut GDP growth by .8 percent.

Friday, April 19, 2013

Is there a reason for businesses to hire workers?

Maybe not. This graph shows that since the end of the recession, productivity (the blue line) has increased despite the fact that employment (the red line) has barely budged. In fact this seems part of a trend that dates back to the 70s. Maybe more indication of the impact of technology on employment.

What types of jobs will be available in the future?

And will these be good jobs? Are face with increased inequality in the future? Here's commentary:

The NYT wonders if the good jobs are gone, and whether governmental policies can address this issue. Can the market - on its own - create the next wave of middle skill jobs that will limit increased inequality?

Richard Posner points out the various ways that technological advances displaces - but does not eliminate - labor. While he mentions jobs that do not require high IQ's he points out that many jobs that are specialized - including the practice of law - are vulnerable.

He has this scary point to make about driverless cars:

Take the case of the driverless car. This technology is advancing very rapidly and has great promise for reducing labor costs (drivers), traffic accidents (for example by eliminating drunk driving), traffic violations, and traffic jams (by optimizing speed, lane usage, and choice of routes and times). There are approximately 4 million truck, taxi, limousine, and bus drivers in the United States, not to mention gas station attendants and traffic policemen. Not all these jobs will be eliminated overnight, but they could go quite fast.


He also points out that these trends - coupled with increased life expectancy - wil lincrease the dependent population:

These trends bear on the current debates over the size of government. Technological advances are increasing longevity, and with it an increase in the dependent population. By reducing demand for workers, and therefore employment and wages, in many labor markets, the same technological advances may be creating a second dependent population, consisting of people of working age and their children who cannot support themselves without public assistance that will either replace or augment wages. Republicans may therefore be tilting against windmills in thinking that the size of government can be reduced.


Gary Becker tells us that the future will not be kind to low skilled workers, and that the rewards for skilled workers may not be as great as they have been in the past:

During the past 30 years the market for workers with few skills has been weak pretty much everywhere. The reason is that economies, including developing economies, have increased their demand for knowledge workers at the expense of low skilled workers. The future is not likely to be any kinder to workers with little education and few other work skills.

Various forces have favored skilled workers during the past several decades; indeed, many of them began much earlier. Technological changes and automation, including the development of computers, the Internet, and electronic controls, have reduced the demand for certain types of skilled workers, such as secretaries and clerical workers. They have increased the demand for workers who command considerable knowledge, and who know how to access any additional knowledge necessary to perform various tasks.

He is critical of governmental policies that impede the incentives for individuals to increase their skill levels, as well as those that limits access to the opportunity to do so.

Friday, April 12, 2013

From Wonkblog: The incredible shrinking labor force, in one chart

Here's a positive observation: The U.S. labor force is shrinking. Back in 2007, 66 percent of Americans had a job or were actively seeking work. Today, that number is at 63 percent and falling.

Here's what this looks like by age group:

Screen Shot 2012-09-07 at 11.06.40 AM (1)


The labor force is shrinking for the young but increasing for the old. These might be related. Fewer retirees means fewer job openings.

Tuesday, April 9, 2013

What's driving youth unemployment?

Adding to the posts below about the causes of high unemployment - and whether it might stick around for a while - here's detail on job prospects for young Americans with and without college diplomas:

Here's a tiny little graph from the Wall Street Journal showing the number of college grads with minimum wage jobs. What's more troubling is that they are crowding out less educated workers from those jobs. So a college dregree does not guarantee a good job, but it seems required in order to get a bad one - or at least a sub-par one.


The Prospect picks up that idea:

People between the ages of 18-24 without a high school degree face an unemployment rate of 27.4% and an underemployment rate of 41.7%. Those in the same age group with only high school degrees face an unemployment rate of 19.7% and an underemployment rate of 34.6%.

In the 25-34 age group, the numbers are somewhat better, but still bad. Those between the ages of 25-34 without a high school degree have an unemployment rate of 15.4% and an underemployment rate of 29.2%. Those with only high school degrees have an unemployment rate of 11.2% and an underemployment rate of 19.9%. In short, it's terrible to be young in this job market, and really terrible to be in it without a degree.

These job problems heavily fall upon Black and Hispanic youth as well. Black youths between the ages of 18-24 and 24-35 face unemployment rates of 25.4% and 14.8% respectively, while Hispanic youths between the ages of 18-24 and 24-35 face unemployment rates of 16.3% and 9.2% respectively. These statistics are made worse when you consider the number of incarcerated youth of color, which are not counted in the BLS data used for this report.


If you are feeling ambitious, here's a link to a study which attempts to get to the root of the jobs crisis among the young.

Monday, April 8, 2013

Automated technology is starting to hit a bit too close to home

Software programs can grade your papers now. On the bright side - I don't have to do it, but what else can they do better than I can?

Sunday, April 7, 2013

From IBT: Technology Rapidly Making Clerical Jobs Obsolete, Driving Inequality, US Reports

Here's another article helping us understand what's keeping the unemployment rate up. Automation means that employers don't need actual people to perform more and more tasks.

This is kinda scary:

The United States has gained 387,000 managers but lost almost 2 million clerical jobs since 2007, as new technologies replace office workers and further squeeze the American middle class, government figures show.

Data from the Bureau of Labor Statistics, reported Monday by the Financial Times, divide the U.S. workforce into 821 jobs from dishwasher to librarian. They show rapid structural shifts amid the Great Recession that are likely to further increase income inequality, which has already been growing for decades.

Another BLS report, released last week, showed that employment rose in the nation’s major counties from September 2011 to September 2012, but average hourly wages fell.

The figures help explain why the U.S. median household income has fallen 5.6 per cent since June 2009 to $51,404, even as the economy – as measured by traditional yardsticks -- recovers. The top 10 per cent of earners, meanwhile, are reaping most benefits of the recovery.

One likely driver of inequality is new computing technologies that destroy some middle-class occupations even as they create jobs for highly skilled workers who can exploit them, as the FT notes.

The number of such clerical workers as bookkeepers, bank tellers, data entry keypunchers, file clerks and typists has been falling, pointing to a broad, structural decline. The number of retail cashiers has also dropped as online shopping and self-checkout systems erode another entry-level, low-wage occupation.

Friday, April 5, 2013

Are corporate profits keeping unemployment high?

A NYT piece from last month points out that corporate profits are soaring while unemployment remains high.

With millions still out of work, companies face little pressure to raise salaries, while productivity gains allow them to increase sales without adding workers.
“So far in this recovery, corporations have captured an unusually high share of the income gains,” said Ethan Harris, co-head of global economics at Bank of America Merrill Lynch. “The U.S. corporate sector is in a lot better health than the overall economy. And until we get a full recovery in the labor market, this will persist.”
The result has been a golden age for corporate profits, especially among multinational giants that are also benefiting from faster growth in emerging economies like China and India.
These factors, along with the Federal Reserve’s efforts to keep interest rates ultralow and encourage investors to put more money into riskier assets, prompted traders to send the Dow past 14,000 to within 75 points of a record high last week.

Here's a graphical description of the shift:




And while sequestration might cost jobs, they will not affect corporate profits.

With $85 billion in automatic cuts taking effect between now and Sept. 30 as part of the so-called federal budget sequestration, some experts warn that economic growth will be reduced by at least half a percentage point. But although experts estimate that sequestration could cost the country about 700,000 jobs, Wall Street does not expect the cuts to substantially reduce corporate profits — or seriously threaten the recent rally in the stock markets.
“It’s minimal,” said Savita Subramanian, head of United States equity and quantitative strategy at Bank of America Merrill Lynch. Over all, the sequester could reduce earnings at the biggest companies by just over 1 percent, she said, adding, “the market wants more austerity.”

A writer in the Atlantic argues these two factors are causally related.

Here are two things that are true about the economy today.
(1) The Dow Jones industrial average is poised to set a new record as corporate profits stretch to all-time highs.
(2) There are still fewer working Americans today than there were before the start of the Great Recession.
The fact that these two things can be true at the same time might outrage you. But it shouldn't surprise you. In the last 30 years, there has been a great divergence between growth and workers' incomes, as the New York Times reminds us today. Corporate profits have soared, in the last decade especially, particularly because of three things: Globalization has pushed down the cost of labor available to multinational corporations; technology has allowed companies to make more with fewer workers, in general; and Big Finance has gobbled up the economy, as the banks' share of total corporate profits has tripled to about one-third since the middle of the last century, according to Evan Soltas.

The New Unemployables

I'll post a few items that try to help explain why the unemployment rate is so high, especially since corporate profits are up, and the stock market returned to record territory once again.

Older workers - those in their 50s and above - "were less likely to lose their jobs during the recession, but those who were laid off are facing far tougher conditions than their younger colleagues. Workers in their fifties are about 20% less likely than workers ages 25 to 34 to become re-employed."

Reports show they are actively seeking work, but find themselves less employable than younger, recent graduates.

Is age discrimination a factor?

Older workers also have the longest bouts of unemployment. The average duration of unemployment for workers ages 55 to 64 was 11 months as recently as January, according to the Labor Department. That's three months longer than the average for 25- to 36-year-olds.
Given these circumstances, many workers can't help but think age discrimination is a factor. AARP's Public Policy Institute surveyed unemployed baby boomers in 2010 and 2011. While 71% blamed their unemployment on the bad economy, almost half also said they believed age discrimination was also at play.
About 23,000 age discrimination complaints were filed with the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission in fiscal 2012, 20% more than in 2007.
Proving discrimination is next to impossible, though, unless it's blatant.
"It's very difficult to prove hiring discrimination, because unless somebody says, 'you're too old for this job,' you don't know why you weren't hired," said Michael Harper, a law professor at Boston University.

Here are two studies that try to get to the bottom of what;s driving this:

- The New Unemployables.
- Age Disparity in Unemployment and Reemployment During the Great Recession and Recovery.

March unemployment report is out: 88,000 jobs created, labor force shrinks, 7.6% unemployment rate

The Dish runs through the commentary. The numbers are actually below what is necessary to keep up with population growth. Almost half a million people dropped out of the labor force, and fewer people are actually working now than a month ago.

Many point out that this is the first report out since both the sequester and the increase in the payroll tax. Government jobs - in addition to private sector jobs based on government contracts are being shred, and this is just the beginning of the process, so some fear the numbers might get worse.

Jobs Report



Monday, January 14, 2013

One reason unemployment remains high . . .

. . . more and more jobs are performed by robots.



60 minutes reports on it. Most other aspects of the economy are doing well. One frightful observation in the story: The tech companies in the US (Facebook, Google, Apple, etc) have a market value of over $1 trillion, but only hire collectively 150,000 people. They don't need that many human workers. That's a bad figure for monthly job growth. Older companies - General Motors for example - hired upwards of half a million.

An unusually high number, and variety, of jobs are performed by robots.

This creates the obvious problem: what to do with the large number of jobless? We are not replacing these jobs very quickly.

Wednesday, December 12, 2012

The Federal Reserve to Hold Interest Rates Down Until the Unemployment Rate Goes below 6.5%

Story in the NYT and Washington Post.

This marks a significant shift for the Fed. It will no longer focus strictly on inflation. It will also now take unemployment into account. This was part of its original mandate.