Showing posts with label earmarks. Show all posts
Showing posts with label earmarks. Show all posts

Friday, February 21, 2014

From the Atlantic: The Case for Corruption, Why Washington needs more honest graft

From Jonathan Rauch - the guy who gave us the word demosclerosis - an argument that cleaning up politics has made the political process less functional. He suggests that the governing system lost something vital when political machines were broken apart and the use of patronage to build coalitions became distasteful. Its an interesting counter-intuitive take on what makes governments work.

- Click here for the article.
The government shutdown last fall wasted billions of dollars, upset innumerable plans, and besmirched both political parties. But it did have one constructive effect. Surveying the wreckage, grown-ups in both parties realized that the politics of public confrontation is a lot better at closing the government than running it. So, to avoid a repeat, they decided to try something old. Something very old. In a healthy return to machine politics, they handed budget negotiations over to political hacks cutting deals behind closed doors.
Once upon a time, the budget process was reasonably regular. In fact, it was conducted under what was called regular order. The budget-committee chairmen would do some horse trading to build a consensus within each chamber, the House and Senate would then pass those budgets without too much ado, and the two chambers would work out their differences in a conference committee. Then the appropriations committees would do more or less the same thing, making sure to spread around enough pork-barrel goodies to get their friends paid off and the budget passed. The president and the congressional leaders would be involved throughout the process, every now and then calling a budget summit, but most of the real work would go on behind the scenes.
In the past few years, by contrast, regular order has been replaced by regular chaos.
Public ultimatums supplanted private negotiations, games of chicken replaced mutual back-scratching, and bumptious Republican House members took to dictating terms to their putative leadership. Last fall, after one tantrum too many, Congress seemed exhausted. As part of a deal to reopen the government, it returned the task of setting the next fiscal year’s budget to the budget and appropriations committees, sending them off to a smoke-free smoke-filled room to cut a deal. The result, a trillion-dollar spending bill loaded with incentives for each side, sailed through Congress in January.
How often backroom deal making will work in today’s age of hyper-partisanship remains to be seen, but Congress’s recourse to it represents a welcome rediscovery of a home truth. Politics needs good leaders, but it needs good followers even more, and they don’t come cheap. Loyalty gets you only so far, and ideology is divisive. Political machines need to exist, and they need to work. No one understood this better than the street-smart political sage George Washington Plunkitt, who articulated the concept of honest graft.
Plunkitt was a factotum of New York’s renowned Tammany Hall political machine during the late 19th and early 20th centuries. Among his accomplishments was holding four public offices at once, drawing salaries for three of them. It was his custom to opine on politics from the shoeshine stand at the county courthouse, where his reflections were taken down by a reporter named William L. Riordon and published in a 1905 classic called Plunkitt of Tammany Hall. His greatest insight was the distinction between honest and dishonest graft.
“There’s the biggest kind of a difference between political looters and politicians who make a fortune out of politics by keepin’ their eyes wide open,” Plunkitt said. “The looter goes in for himself alone without considerin’ his organization or his city. The politician looks after his own interests, the organization’s interests, and the city’s interests all at the same time.” Dirty graft is parasitic, mere larceny, whereas honest graft helps knit together a patronage network that ensures leaders can lead and followers will follow. Reformers who failed to understand this crucial distinction, Plunkitt said, courted anarchy. “First,” he reasoned, “this great and glorious country was built up by political parties; second, parties can’t hold together if their workers don’t get the offices when they win; third, if the parties go to pieces, the government they built up must go to pieces, too; fourth, then there’ll be h--- to pay.”

Wednesday, October 2, 2013

From Wonkblog: Why Boehner doesn’t just ditch the hard right?

Here's a good insiders look at the difficulty the Speaker is facing managing the Republican Caucus.

Party leaders don't have the tools they once had to build cohesion in their parties. External forces are gaining strength, which tempers the argument that parties are the dominant institution within Congress.

Key bit from the interview in the story I linked to above:

What we're seeing is the collapse of institutional Republican power. It’s not so much about Boehner. It’s things like the end of earmarks. They move away from Tom DeLay and they think they're improving the House, but now they have nothing to offer their members. The outside groups don't always move votes directly but they create an atmosphere of fear among the members. And so many of these members now live in the conservative world of talk radio and tea party conventions and Fox News invitations. And so the conservative strategy of the moment, no matter how unrealistic it might be, catches fire. The members begin to believe they can achieve things in divided government that most objective observers would believe is impossible. Leaders are dealing with these expectations that wouldn't exist in a normal environment.

Tuesday, January 1, 2013

Should we miss pork barrel politics?

A Slate writer does. Earmarks and pork barrel deals helped problems get solved. While they became symbols of corruption (both real and imagined) recently, they provided opportunities for congressional leaders to bargain in order to gain support for legislation, McConnell-Biden Plan now being debated in the House.

Earmarks have been banned in the past few years, along the same time that Congress has become dysfunctional and public approval ratings have plummeted. Are these related?

It turns out that a Congress full of highly principled men and women, fired-up by genuine idealism about America’s future, is a place where nothing gets done.

That’s not to say we should pine for a return to bribery and graft, but watching the prolonged fiscal cliff deadlock (and other Obama-era legislative battles) it was hard not to miss a little old-fashioned earmarking and pork.

Consider John Boehner’s embarrassing failure to line up sufficient House Republican support for his own Plan B legislation on the fiscal cliff. Coalition fragmentation has always been a problem for American legislative leaders, but defections normally arise from the center. Legislators holding at-risk seats sometimes feel they can’t do what the leadership wants, and wise leaders don’t expect vulnerable members to vote for everything. DeLay had a term for it: “catch and release”—only making the absolutely bare minimum of members with moderate seats take tough votes, and making sure no member who might be vulnerable in his next election needed to vote for too many leadership initiatives. But a member whose seat isn’t at risk has traditionally needed to vote with the leadership lest leaders retaliate by curtailing pet projects. Take away these pet projects, and a vital tool of legislative discipline goes missing.
You can't have everything.

Anyone who watched Lincoln saw political operates effectively buying votes by offering members who had been voted out of office patronage jobs. This raises an interesting dilemma, does our demand for hyper clean politics make governing difficult?

Tuesday, February 7, 2012

Earmarks used for projects near lawmaker's property

This won't help raise Congress' approval ratings. The Washington Post released a study showing that "thirty-three members of Congress have directed more than $300 million in earmarks and other spending provisions to dozens of public projects that are next to or within about two miles of the lawmakers’ own property." And is legal under ethics rules within Congress. 
- Click here for the study: Capitol Assets.

Wednesday, February 9, 2011

Are Congressmen Missing Earmarks Already?

From the NYT:

Gone for now are the likes of the taxpayer-financed teapot museum, or studies on the mating habits of crabs. But also shelved are a project to help consolidate information about warrants in Brazos County, Tex., and staffing for two new shelters for abused women and children in Salt Lake City. A rural Wisconsin county will not be able to upgrade its communication system, and a road in Kentucky will not be widened next year.

Across the country, local governments, nonprofit groups and scores of farmers, to name but a few, are waking up to the fact that when Congress stamped out earmarks last week, it was talking about their projects, too.

Tensions are particularly acute in districts where new conservative lawmakers, many of whom criticized throughout their campaigns the practice of quietly inserting earmarks into spending bills, are coming face to face with local governments and interest groups who were counting on federal dollars to help shore up their own collapsing budgets.

Tuesday, February 8, 2011

John McCain Thinks the President Should Have Line Item Veto Power over Earmarks

From Politico:

Republicans and Democrats may have temporarily outlawed earmarks in the Senate, but Sen. John McCain (R-Ariz.) said Tuesday that the president still needs the authority to block specific items from spending bills.


“The battle is not won. It is, at best, a truce,” McCain said about his decades-long battle against congressional pet projects. “This is just one tool we want the president of the United States to have. … This is one small, tough decision that is going to have to be made.”

McCain was joined by a bipartisan group of senators who back legislation introduced by McCain and Sen. Tom Carper (D-Del.) that would give President Barack Obama authority similar to a line-item veto. Under the plan, several version of which have been introduced over the years, the president would have the power to single out earmarks and other non-entitlements in spending bills, and send them back to Congress for an up or down vote.

Tuesday, November 23, 2010

Earmarks

Given Republican opposition to earmarks, its worth considering their actual impact on the communities that receive them. Here's a bit of background from TNR, and a map showing the distribution of earmarks from a 2005 bill:

Earmark loacations from 2005 federal highway bill

Tuesday, March 9, 2010

Angling for Deals

Here's great insight into how Congress works. Health Care reform is a game of chicken. Some members arr pretending to be opposed to the bill so that they may be able to get goodies for their districts:

...if the representative wants to extract concessions from the Democratic leadership, it’s thus a good idea to signal uncertainty or even opposition to the bill — as many conservative Democrats have done. This raises the possibility, as one friend noted to me, that the prevalence of these signals in news stories may inflate the perceived chance that health care reform will fail in the House.

Perhaps the health care bill has more support than is being reported

Monday, March 8, 2010

Contributions and Earmarks

From the Washington Post:

House Appropriations defense subcommittee member James P. Moran Jr. (D-Va.) works hard at fundraising: Two to three times a week, he telephones contributors to ask for more. Yet, according to the account he supplied to the Office of Congressional Ethics last year, he is unaware of "who made donations" or how much they gave, and so that information plays no role in his earmarking -- the systematic granting of public funds for mostly private purposes.

Fellow subcommittee member Norm Dicks (D-Wash.) similarly presides over fundraisers arranged by his staff for defense firms and
lobbyists every three months or so, according to his office's account. An aide in charge of Dicks's earmarks attends the fundraising events. But Dicks and the aide told investigators they were unaware of the substantial overlap between defense industry contributions to Dicks and his earmarks to contributors.

We'll be discussing elections in 2301 and the amount of time and energy members of Congress have to spend raising campaign funds. This story suggests that the contributors may be getting more than an open ear from recipients.

Friday, February 5, 2010

Is the Senate Broken? Part 1

One Senator is placing a hold on all Obama appointees until he is granted two earmarks for his state. Is it possible that the Senate will be unable to conduct any business this year? Will Republicans overplay the hand they have been dealt?

Sunday, March 1, 2009

Libertarian Pork

Ron Paul voted against the stimulus bill but was still able to secure almost $100 million in earmarks. The best among Texans, but others did well too.

Saturday, February 28, 2009

Yes Those are Earmarks

President Obama touched a nerve with some by claiming in his state of the union message that the stimulus bill does not contain earmarks. Unless one wished to parse the definition endlessly, it does. But earmarks have become a necessary way to gain the votes for legislation to pass Congress, and congressmen claim that this enables them to determine which projects get funded in their districts, rather than an executive official who lacks knowledge of the district.

The following story points out how this need makes it difficult for overall economic planning (the type the national government was set up to provide) difficult. While the executive is in a position to make plans nation wide, the local needs of the 435 members of the House of Representatives make this difficult:

You do not need an economics degree to see, for instance, how tens of millions of dollars of unconnected train station projects scattered around the nation might derail a focused program to concentrate high-speed rail where it is most needed. A college or Girl Scouts initiative might not have the same effect as a federal effort to support after-school programs. Is a $22 million addition to the Kennedy library more important than propping up our struggling public libraries?

Monday, July 23, 2007

Local Pork

The Sunday Chron ran an overview of our senators and House reps and the local funding they provide their constituents. Here's what they say about Kay Bailey: "A member of the Senate Appropriations Committee, Hutchison has been the go-to person in Congress for government officials and private groups in Texas who seek federal money but often are unable to secure it through the traditional method of applying to federal agencies."

Now we know.