Thursday, March 21, 2013
Some numbers behind the split among Republicans over immigration reform
Some factions within the Republican Party favor paths to citizenship while other - notably the Tea Party, by large numbers - do not. Since the Tea Party contains many of the party's activists, there are risks to running for office as a pro-immigration Republican.
From Bruce Bartlett: The Politics of the 14th Amendment and the Debt Limit
The 14th Amendment contains language that some argue secures the national debt from political gamesmanship - the sort of thing that happens when battles over raising the debt ceiling arise. The full faith and credit of the US is paramount. But some argue that is not the case. Mr. Bartlett tries to debunk that argument by reviewing the history of Section 4 of the 14th Amendment. He argues that this provides a constitutional safeguard for debt service:
The purpose of the debt provision of the 14th Amendment was to say that national debt was beyond the realm of politics. In the words Jack Balkin, a Yale law professor: “It was stated in broad terms in order to prevent future majorities in Congress from repudiating the federal debt to gain political advantage, to seek political revenge or to try to disavow previous financial obligations because of changed policy priorities.”
Republican threats to hold the debt limit hostage to their agenda today present precisely the sort of political situation contemplated by the authors of the 14th Amendment.
From the Washington Post: How the NRA exerts influence over Congress
For our upcoming look at interest groups: How does the National Rifle Association use contributions and a rating systems to influence members of Congress.
Catching up with the legislature
- The Texas Legislature passes a $195.5 Billion Budget.
- School district oppose bill banning certain bonds.
- Lawmakers are now focusing on the big stuff.
- House Appropriations Committee votes to restore $1.5 Billion in cuts to education.
- End of life bills being considered by the Senate.
A few items on the Public Utility Commission:
- The House passes the PUC Sunset Bill.
- Cease and Desist authority proposed, but denied, to the PUC.
- Emergency powers considered in PUC Sunset Bill.
- Smart meters debated in the House.
- School district oppose bill banning certain bonds.
- Lawmakers are now focusing on the big stuff.
- House Appropriations Committee votes to restore $1.5 Billion in cuts to education.
- End of life bills being considered by the Senate.
A few items on the Public Utility Commission:
- The House passes the PUC Sunset Bill.
- Cease and Desist authority proposed, but denied, to the PUC.
- Emergency powers considered in PUC Sunset Bill.
- Smart meters debated in the House.
Can ther Republican Party make necessary adjustments?
Charlie Cook comments on the report the Republican National Committee released this week and discusses how difficult this may prove to be. The title of his article says it all: The GOP Faces 2 Stark Choices: Change or go over the Cliff. While the party leadership wants to moderate its positions to reach out to a broader constituency, activists in the party see not only no reason to change, they want to double down on the party's existing positions.
The past 96 hours should provide thinking Republicans both hope and despair about their party’s future. The hope centers on the Republican National Committee’s “Growth & Opportunity Project” report, an autopsy of sorts that looks at the GOP’s disastrous 2012 election and offers some highly constructive ideas. The party should take them seriously in addressing the problems that turned more than a few winnable Senate seats and a presidential election into bitter defeats. The despair, on the other hand, comes from the Conservative Political Action Conference, an annual congregation of the younger element of the party’s most conservative 5 percent, this year made up chiefly of those who think last year’s problem was that the party wasn’t conservative enough. Driving over to the Gaylord’s National Harbor Hotel and Convention Center to meet with a campaign manager Saturday afternoon, I passed a group on a street corner advocating the impeachment of President Obama. It was a useful reminder of just how far out the extremes—on the right in the GOP and on the left in the Democratic Party—really are.
Medical cost are rising because we have more old people.
Other than that, medical costs are pretty steady. Graphic from Wonkblog:

The story the chart is pulled from can be found here. Here's the basic point the study makes:
The story the chart is pulled from can be found here. Here's the basic point the study makes:
The latest CBO report, which takes into account three consecutive years of dramatically slower health care cost increases, should serve as a warning (and a reminder) that it is misleading to say the problem with the federal budget “is just a health care problem.”
If one only looks at the two CBO updates over the last six months, projected 10-year Medicare spending has been revised downward by $306 billion. Projected Medicaid spending has been revised downward by $273 billion (not counting revised estimates of lower Medicaid enrollment due to the Supreme Court’s ruling on Medicaid expansion in the Affordable Care Act (ACA)).
Yet even under that “better case scenario,” federal outlays for health care will soon be greater than outlays for Social Security -- placing it at the top of all federal budgetary commitments. Over the 10-year budget window, health care spending will experience growth of 1.2 percent of GDP, second fastest only to net interest.
The reason is simply that the “health care problem” actually reflects the large increase in the number of people who will become eligible for Medicare due to the retirement of the baby-boom generation. Over the next 10 years, 18 million new beneficiaries are expected to sign up for Medicare.
Nearly three-quarters of the spending increases in Medicare over the next two decades can be attributed to aging alone. And, as I will explain, the remaining increase in costs due to health care inflation will be very difficult to avoid because even that amount of projected growth is lower than anyone realistically believes we can sustainably achieve. Thus, the major problem in Medicare really is one of an aging population. In this case, the Medicare problem is no different than the Social Security problem.
Continuing Resolution passes US House and Senate
When 2305's start looking at the budget, we will discuss what "the budget" is and what it isn't. It is a statement declaring what revenues and outlays are to be over a given period of time, but it is not a binding document. The budgets I asked 2305s to discuss in this week's assignment are better considered as being political - not fiscal - instruments. The Constitution says nothing about budgets or a budgetary process, only that funds cannot be drawn from the treasury if an appropriations bill has been passed to authorize it. But the recent dysfunction in Congress has even made that problematic, and more recently the US government has been funded by a series of short term funding measures called continuing resolutions.
Here's Wikipedia's definition of a continuing resolution: A continuing resolution is a type of appropriations legislation used by the United States Congress to fund government agencies if a formal appropriations bill has not been signed into law by the end of the Congressional fiscal year. The legislation takes the form of a joint resolution, and provides funding for existing federal programs at current, reduced, or expanded levels.
If the resolution is not passed - assuming that the appropriations bills have not passed either - they money cannot be drawn from the treasury to fund government agencies and they have to shut down. At least those that perform non-vital programs do.
We will cover this more fully later, but I bring it up now because the US House and Senate have passed continuing resolutions in order to avoid a shutdown - which tends to be unpopular.
Here are the stories that provide detail:
- Congress moves one step closer to avoiding a government shutdown.
- House to approve bill to keep government running.
- House approves resolution to keep government running; bill heads to White House.
This guarantees funding until September 30th, when further funding can be subject to hostage taking again.
Here's Wikipedia's definition of a continuing resolution: A continuing resolution is a type of appropriations legislation used by the United States Congress to fund government agencies if a formal appropriations bill has not been signed into law by the end of the Congressional fiscal year. The legislation takes the form of a joint resolution, and provides funding for existing federal programs at current, reduced, or expanded levels.
If the resolution is not passed - assuming that the appropriations bills have not passed either - they money cannot be drawn from the treasury to fund government agencies and they have to shut down. At least those that perform non-vital programs do.
We will cover this more fully later, but I bring it up now because the US House and Senate have passed continuing resolutions in order to avoid a shutdown - which tends to be unpopular.
Here are the stories that provide detail:
- Congress moves one step closer to avoiding a government shutdown.
- House to approve bill to keep government running.
- House approves resolution to keep government running; bill heads to White House.
This guarantees funding until September 30th, when further funding can be subject to hostage taking again.
Wednesday, March 20, 2013
From Seth Masket: Parties don't get to choose their own adventure
We've been discussing the shift Democrats made on civil rights in the mid 20th Century and its ongoing consequences. Here's an observation that these shifts don't happen that often:
Huge shifts are the norm? On the contrary -- they're incredibly rare! The Democrats' shift from being the party of white supremacy to the party of civil rights was pretty much a singular act in American political history. Parties rarely pull off a major shift on a hot-button issue (that's what killed the Whigs in the 1850s), and indeed it was a very costly shift for the Democrats, breaking their electoral lock on the southern states and ultimately ending their four-decade run of controlling the House of Representatives. To be sure, parties do evolve slowly on some issues, but the parties are much better defined by consistency than change.
Tuesday, March 19, 2013
From the FWST: George P. Bush to run for land commissioner
From what I can see, this is the first announced candidate for the 2014 Texas election. His Hispanic heritage - backed by the political machine that surrounds the Bush family - is intended to help lure the Latino vote to the Republican Party. His Uncle W did well with the Hispanic community when he ran for governor in the 90s.
From the story:
Well, now we know. He has already attracted a large number of contributors, which might suggest he'll have little trouble winning, but are Texans tired of the Bush name?
From the story:
George Prescott Bush filed the paperwork Tuesday to run for Texas land commissioner next year, hoping to use a little-known but powerful post to continue his family's political dynasty in one of the country's most conservative states.
A Spanish-speaking attorney and consultant based in Fort Worth, Bush is considered a rising star among conservative Hispanics, and his political pedigree is hard to match.
He is the grandson of former President George H.W. Bush, the nephew of former President George W. Bush and the son of Florida Gov. Jeb Bush -- often mentioned as a 2016 presidential hopeful.
Bush unveiled a campaign website with a "George P. Bush for Land Commissioner" logo and a three-minute video in which he says, "Texas is an exceptional state because we as Texans are exceptional."
Well, now we know. He has already attracted a large number of contributors, which might suggest he'll have little trouble winning, but are Texans tired of the Bush name?
[Current Land Commissioner Jerry] Patterson said he believes that running with the Bush name is "both a blessing and a curse."
Some critics accused Bush of cynically shopping for the most politically opportunistic Texas office rather than showing serious interest in one.
But Patterson said that was a mere byproduct of Bush not being ready to make an announcement.
"That's the problem you have when your last name is Bush," Patterson said. "It's impossible to control the message."
Proposed term limits on statewide elected officials passes Texas Senate
The vote was overwhelming: 27-4. Now it goes to the House. From My SA:
The bill's supporters claim it has nothing to do with Rick Perry's lenghty service as governor, but ....
Statewide elected officials, including the governor, would be limited to two consecutive terms in office under a proposed constitutional amendment approved 27-4 on Tuesday by the Texas Senate.
Gov. Rick Perry, Texas' longest-serving governor, and other current officeholders affected by the measure would be “grandfathered” and allowed to seek two more terms if it were enacted.
Senate Joint Resolution 13 by Sen. Kevin Eltife would require Texas House approval by a two-thirds vote before being put on a statewide ballot. If both chambers approved, the proposal would not require Perry's signature, only voter approval. If passed, it would apply only to officials in the state executive branch.
The bill's supporters claim it has nothing to do with Rick Perry's lenghty service as governor, but ....
Perry's long service is the undeniable elephant in the room when term limits are discussed.
“No Texas governor before Rick Perry ever served two full four-year terms consecutively, but Perry's threat to run for a fourth full term in 2014 opens the prospect of him serving as governor for eighteen years,” said Southern Methodist University political scientist Cal Jillson. “This has everybody, including Sen. Eltife, wondering whether this is a good idea and whether future governors should have this option.”
Jillson said two-thirds of states restrict statewide elected officials to two four-year terms. He said Texas is one of a dozen that have four-year terms with no limit.
Lobbyist and consultant Bill Miller said, “Regardless of whether you say it is not about Perry, he is the poster boy for the bill.”
Miller was critical of the measure, saying it “is a candidate talent killer and enhances immeasurably the power of staff who are beyond the reach of voters.”
Jillson and Rice University political scientist Mark Jones took note that after Franklin D. Roosevelt was elected president four times, Congress passed and states adopted the 22nd Amendment limiting presidential service.
“Just as FDR's unprecedented tenure in office helped generate support for a two-term limit for the U.S. president, Perry's equally unprecedented tenure has bolstered the efforts of term limits advocates in Texas,” Jones said.
Weekly assignment #3 - 8 week classes
These assignments are for students in the 8 week mini:
GOVT 2305: I want you to look at immigration reform, and specifically the question about whether it is likely to be passed by the Senate and the House. I've posted a few items on this already. A "gang" of four Democratic and four Republican Senators proposed comprehensive immigration reform, and speculation exists that passage of these reform might easily pass that chamber. The president has also made a set of proposals and seems ready to "go public" to promote them. The question is what will happen in the House because Republicans are in the majority and they are split between a faction that sees it necessary to pass immigration reform in order to gain support from the emerging Latino community, and a factions that is opposed to it - mostly the remnants of the Tea Party.
I want you to read up on this conflict and provide a reasoned, informed commentary on the likelihood that immigration reform can actually pass the 113th Congress, and if so, in what form. Part of the purpose of this assignment is to get you to think more about the separated powers and the fact that each of the elected institutions on the national level are designed differently in order to ensure that they behave differently. The conflict we see is intended. But explain what design factors make this issue - that seems ready to be passed in the Senate - may not be in the House.
GOVT 2306: We've been looking at founding documents, including the Declaration of Independence. We noted that the declaration was intended to convince an impartial world that their desire to be independent. Normally this is something nations do not like to see happen - for an obviously self interested reason - which is why it was important that substantive reasons be offered in order to ensure that the decision was based on reason, not passion.
As you may know, after the 2012 election many petitions were sent to the White House requesting permission for some states - Texas included - to secede from the nation. I want you to find these petitions, and any other supporting documents, and analyze the arguments they make. What reasons were offered? How do these stack up against the arguments made in the Texas Declaration of Independence (2301s might want to look at the US Declaration of Independence). Are the arguments reasonable, or driven by passion? Support your assessment.
GOVT 2305: I want you to look at immigration reform, and specifically the question about whether it is likely to be passed by the Senate and the House. I've posted a few items on this already. A "gang" of four Democratic and four Republican Senators proposed comprehensive immigration reform, and speculation exists that passage of these reform might easily pass that chamber. The president has also made a set of proposals and seems ready to "go public" to promote them. The question is what will happen in the House because Republicans are in the majority and they are split between a faction that sees it necessary to pass immigration reform in order to gain support from the emerging Latino community, and a factions that is opposed to it - mostly the remnants of the Tea Party.
I want you to read up on this conflict and provide a reasoned, informed commentary on the likelihood that immigration reform can actually pass the 113th Congress, and if so, in what form. Part of the purpose of this assignment is to get you to think more about the separated powers and the fact that each of the elected institutions on the national level are designed differently in order to ensure that they behave differently. The conflict we see is intended. But explain what design factors make this issue - that seems ready to be passed in the Senate - may not be in the House.
GOVT 2306: We've been looking at founding documents, including the Declaration of Independence. We noted that the declaration was intended to convince an impartial world that their desire to be independent. Normally this is something nations do not like to see happen - for an obviously self interested reason - which is why it was important that substantive reasons be offered in order to ensure that the decision was based on reason, not passion.
As you may know, after the 2012 election many petitions were sent to the White House requesting permission for some states - Texas included - to secede from the nation. I want you to find these petitions, and any other supporting documents, and analyze the arguments they make. What reasons were offered? How do these stack up against the arguments made in the Texas Declaration of Independence (2301s might want to look at the US Declaration of Independence). Are the arguments reasonable, or driven by passion? Support your assessment.
Why can't we be more like Finland?
Another student forwards this story that tries to understand why Finish schools are so successful. For starters they do everything exactly the opposite of how we do things here in the US:
For starters, Finland has no standardized tests. The only exception is what's called the National Matriculation Exam, which everyone takes at the end of a voluntary upper-secondary school, roughly the equivalent of American high school.
Instead, the public school system's teachers are trained to assess children in classrooms using independent tests they create themselves. All children receive a report card at the end of each semester, but these reports are based on individualized grading by each teacher. Periodically, the Ministry of Education tracks national progress by testing a few sample groups across a range of different schools.
As for accountability of teachers and administrators, Sahlberg shrugs. "There's no word for accountability in Finnish," he later told an audience at the Teachers College of Columbia University. "Accountability is something that is left when responsibility has been subtracted."
For Sahlberg what matters is that in Finland all teachers and administrators are given prestige, decent pay, and a lot of responsibility. A master's degree is required to enter the profession, and teacher training programs are among the most selective professional schools in the country. If a teacher is bad, it is the principal's responsibility to notice and deal with it.
And while Americans love to talk about competition, Sahlberg points out that nothing makes Finns more uncomfortable. In his book Sahlberg quotes a line from Finnish writer named Samuli Paronen: "Real winners do not compete." It's hard to think of a more un-American idea, but when it comes to education, Finland's success shows that the Finnish attitude might have merits. There are no lists of best schools or teachers in Finland. The main driver of education policy is not competition between teachers and between schools, but cooperation.
Finally, in Finland, school choice is noticeably not a priority, nor is engaging the private sector at all. Which brings us back to the silence after Sahlberg's comment at the Dwight School that schools like Dwight don't exist in Finland.
"Here in America," Sahlberg said at the Teachers College, "parents can choose to take their kids to private schools. It's the same idea of a marketplace that applies to, say, shops. Schools are a shop and parents can buy what ever they want. In Finland parents can also choose. But the options are all the same."
Herein lay the real shocker. As Sahlberg continued, his core message emerged, whether or not anyone in his American audience heard it.
Decades ago, when the Finnish school system was badly in need of reform, the goal of the program that Finland instituted, resulting in so much success today, was never excellence. It was equity.
The Anti-Drone
The potential onslaught of drones has created a market for counter-drone technology.
A student sends this story about such a company:
A student sends this story about such a company:
"We understand the nature of the equipment drone manufacturers are using and understand how to counter their sensors," Faucett says. "We're not going to be countering Predator drones that are shooting cruise missiles, but we're talking about local law enforcement drones and commercial ones that people might be using for spying."
For now, Faucett admits the technology is "expensive," but the company is already ready to design custom anti-drone boxes for customers.
"We envision it could be cheap enough for residential use very soon," he says. "It's quite possible to deploy it if you were shooting a movie and wanted to protect your set, or if you had a house in Malibu and wanted to protect that, we could deploy it there. If a huge company like Google wanted to protect its server farms, it can be scaled up for a larger, fixed installation."
As drones become more commonplace, Faucett says more people will begin searching for a way to protect their privacy.
"The thing that brought it home for me was Senator [Rand] Paul doing the filibuster, there's a lot of unanswered questions," he says. "We think there might be as much business for this counter drone stuff as there is for the drones themselves."
Weak voter turnout negates Democrats ID advanatage over Republicans
If you looked through the graphics below and noticed the sizable lead Democrats had over Republicans regarding Party ID, you might have wondered why Democrats don't win every election. The answer - as we will cover in class - is that the groups that vote Democrat tend to vote at lower rates than those who vote Republican.
We will be be looking more at the groups that tends to comprise each party soon enough, but overall Republicans include groups that are wealthier and more highly educated than Democrats, and those groups are far more likely to vote, especially in midterm and primary elections. This makes them powerful beyond their numbers.
More on that soon enough, but here some graphics related to voter turnout:


We will be be looking more at the groups that tends to comprise each party soon enough, but overall Republicans include groups that are wealthier and more highly educated than Democrats, and those groups are far more likely to vote, especially in midterm and primary elections. This makes them powerful beyond their numbers.
More on that soon enough, but here some graphics related to voter turnout:

The latest trends in Texas' party identification
While Democrats beat Republicans in terms of party nationally - Republicans have made significant gains over Democrats over the past 30 years. Their lead kicked in with the 1994 election, and state-wide Republicans have not lost a race. Democrats remain competitive - even dominant in some large cities, including Houston, but the Republican advantage in sub-urban and rural areas is large enough to cancel out that advantage state-wide.
This coincides with the national shift each party went through beginning in the late 1940s and picking up in 1964 when the parties changed positions on civil rights. The South gradually switched allegiances from the Democratic to the Republican Party. The online Texas Politics text book has a sub-chapter briefly detailing the shift and offers this graphic:

Some observers argue that this reveals three distinct eras in the Texas party system. The first era dates back to the ratification of the 1876 Constitution and extends to the mid to late 1970s. This was the era of one party rule in the state. Republicans had little ability to win general elections, although the election of Senator John Tower to LBJ's vacant Senate seat following the 1960 presidential election foreshadowed a change. Democratic dominance during this era was absolute. There were some sessions of the legislature where no Republicans held seats. Any ideological divisions that existed in the state were contained within the Democratic Party - which had a conservative and liberal wing. The conservative wing did occasionally support the national Republican Party, so tension did exist.
From 1978 or so until 1994, the parties were in rough parity and Texas had something like a two party system in place. Democrats still held on to the legislature and competed with the Republican Party for governorships, but the shift favored Republicans and by 1994 - in-keeping with the national electoral wave that favored the Republican Party - the party dominated statewide offices, meaning the executive and top judicial positions. The Democratic Party is still competitive in legislative races, so they are not as weak as the Republican were prior to 1964, but Texas' is close to being the one party state it was at that time. Whether it remain so will depend on whether demographic trends that indicate a rise in the Latino population, which tends to vote Democrat, will bring the party back to power.
This coincides with the national shift each party went through beginning in the late 1940s and picking up in 1964 when the parties changed positions on civil rights. The South gradually switched allegiances from the Democratic to the Republican Party. The online Texas Politics text book has a sub-chapter briefly detailing the shift and offers this graphic:
Some observers argue that this reveals three distinct eras in the Texas party system. The first era dates back to the ratification of the 1876 Constitution and extends to the mid to late 1970s. This was the era of one party rule in the state. Republicans had little ability to win general elections, although the election of Senator John Tower to LBJ's vacant Senate seat following the 1960 presidential election foreshadowed a change. Democratic dominance during this era was absolute. There were some sessions of the legislature where no Republicans held seats. Any ideological divisions that existed in the state were contained within the Democratic Party - which had a conservative and liberal wing. The conservative wing did occasionally support the national Republican Party, so tension did exist.
From 1978 or so until 1994, the parties were in rough parity and Texas had something like a two party system in place. Democrats still held on to the legislature and competed with the Republican Party for governorships, but the shift favored Republicans and by 1994 - in-keeping with the national electoral wave that favored the Republican Party - the party dominated statewide offices, meaning the executive and top judicial positions. The Democratic Party is still competitive in legislative races, so they are not as weak as the Republican were prior to 1964, but Texas' is close to being the one party state it was at that time. Whether it remain so will depend on whether demographic trends that indicate a rise in the Latino population, which tends to vote Democrat, will bring the party back to power.
The latest trends in party identification
For today's look at political parties in GOVT 2305: A look at how party identification has shifted over time, and where it stands today. Click here for the Google images on party identification for a range of graphics highlighting different aspects of it.
The Pew Research Center also reports on trends over time in a study released last year. And click here for a great interactive graphic of ID from 1939-1012. The biggest story over the past 20 years has been the increase in self described independents, but as we will see, calling your self independent does not mean that one does not consistently vote for one of the major parties over the other. These people are called leaners.
Here are some of their graphics. This looks at ID overall:

And another that breaks down ID by race:

by gender:

by religion:

and by age:

The Pew Research Center also reports on trends over time in a study released last year. And click here for a great interactive graphic of ID from 1939-1012. The biggest story over the past 20 years has been the increase in self described independents, but as we will see, calling your self independent does not mean that one does not consistently vote for one of the major parties over the other. These people are called leaners.
Here are some of their graphics. This looks at ID overall:
And another that breaks down ID by race:
by gender:
by religion:
and by age:
Six media trends noted by the Pew Center report
I wanted to highlight these specific trends noted by the report on the state of the media referred to below. These might be worth discussing further when we cover the media later this semester.
1 - The effects of a decade of newsroom cutbacks are real – and the public is taking notice.
2 - The news industry continues to lose out on the bulk of new digital advertising.
3 - The long-dormant sponsorship ad category is seeing sharp growth.
4 - The growth of paid digital content experiments may have a significant impact on both news revenue and content.
5 - While the first and hardest-hit industry, newspapers, remains in the spotlight, local TV finds itself newly vulnerable.
6 - Hearing about things in the news from friends and family, whether via social media or actual word of mouth, leads to deeper news consumption.
More gun owners claim self-protection as the reaosn why they own guns despite the fact that violent crime is decreasing. Why?
This graph in the Pew Center site popped out at me while I was putting together the previous post. Here's the related study:

But this graph points out that violent crime is decreasing the in the US over roughly the same period of time described above:

This suggests that there is less reason for people to justify using protection as a reason to own a gun since there is less likelyhood that one will be affected by violent crime. Of course this doesn't mean that violent crime doesn't happen and one might reasonably choose therefore to own a gun for protection, but the trend lines do not jive. Fewer violent crimes suggest that protection should be less a factor used to justify gun ownership.
But this assumes that people are basing their decisions about why to own a gun based on unvarnished facts. Something is likely convincing people that violent crime is a bigger problem than it really is. There may be certain groups that are advantaged by convincing people that crime is more prevalent than it actuall is. It is also commonly pointed out that local news tends to hype local crime since it tends to attract viewers. I'll surf around and look for attitudes about the prevalence of crime and see if it conflicts with actual crime rates, but this might lend support to the argument below that the information we receive about factual matters is distorted.
In fact it might be worth investigating who or what best determines attitudes about crime.
But this graph points out that violent crime is decreasing the in the US over roughly the same period of time described above:
This suggests that there is less reason for people to justify using protection as a reason to own a gun since there is less likelyhood that one will be affected by violent crime. Of course this doesn't mean that violent crime doesn't happen and one might reasonably choose therefore to own a gun for protection, but the trend lines do not jive. Fewer violent crimes suggest that protection should be less a factor used to justify gun ownership.
But this assumes that people are basing their decisions about why to own a gun based on unvarnished facts. Something is likely convincing people that violent crime is a bigger problem than it really is. There may be certain groups that are advantaged by convincing people that crime is more prevalent than it actuall is. It is also commonly pointed out that local news tends to hype local crime since it tends to attract viewers. I'll surf around and look for attitudes about the prevalence of crime and see if it conflicts with actual crime rates, but this might lend support to the argument below that the information we receive about factual matters is distorted.
In fact it might be worth investigating who or what best determines attitudes about crime.
Labels:
crime,
democracy,
gun control,
gun policy,
Public Opinion
Will the decline in the number of people working in the media create problems for the viability of democracy in the US?
The Pew Research Center for the People and the Press have released their latest analysis of the state of the media in the US: The State of the News Media 2013. Perhaps the simplest message it is sending is that declining revenue has lead news providers to layoff reporters and editors and has allowed public and private agencies - news makers - to take their messages directly to the public. This allows them to by-pass the critical filter that the news media generally provides.
Increasingly the news we receive is formulated by those normally covered by the news. They have a greater ability to shape how we think about news events. Public relations professional now have more influence than reporters, which negates the traditional role that the media is meant to play in a democracy. Instead of making evaluations of public matters based on objective information, the information we receive will be purposely biased in favor of the interests sending the information out.
From the report's overview:
Increasingly the news we receive is formulated by those normally covered by the news. They have a greater ability to shape how we think about news events. Public relations professional now have more influence than reporters, which negates the traditional role that the media is meant to play in a democracy. Instead of making evaluations of public matters based on objective information, the information we receive will be purposely biased in favor of the interests sending the information out.
From the report's overview:
. . . so far, this trend has emerged most clearly in the political sphere, particularly with the biggest story of 2012—the presidential election. A Pew Research Center analysis revealed that campaign reporters were acting primarily as megaphones, rather than as investigators, of the assertions put forward by the candidates and other political partisans. That meant more direct relaying of assertions made by the campaigns and less reporting by journalists to interpret and contextualize them. This is summarized in our special video report on our Election Research, only about a quarter of statements in the media about the character and records of the presidential candidates originated with journalists in the 2012 race, while twice that many came from political partisans. That is a reversal from a dozen years earlier when half the statements originated with journalists and a third came from partisans. The campaigns also found more ways than ever to connect directly with citizens.
There are signs of this trend that carry beyond the political realm, as more and more entities seek, by various means, to fill the void left by overstretched editorial resources. Business leaders in Detroit, MI, for example, have created an organization to serve as a kind of tour guide to journalists with the goal of injecting more favorable portrayals of the city into media coverage. The government of Malaysia was recently discovered to have bankrolled propaganda that appeared in several major U.S. outlets under columnists’ bylines. A number of news organizations, including The Associated Press, recently carried a fake press release about Google that came from a PR distribution site that promises clients it will reach “top media outlets.” And recently, journalist David Cay Johnston in writing about a pitch from one corporate marketer that included a “vacation reward” for running his stories, remarked, “Journalists get lots of pitches like this these days, which is partly a reflection of how the number of journalists has shriveled while the number of publicists has grown.” Indeed, an analysis of Census Bureau data by Robert McChesney and John Nichols found the ratio of public relations workers to journalists grew from 1.2 to 1 in 1980 to 3.6 to 1 in 2008—and the gap has likely only widened since.
The Supreme Court will hear a case regarding age discrimination
From ScotusBlog:
Click here for detail about Madigan v. Levin, here's the fancy desscription of the case:
Click here for background on the Age Discrimination in Employment Act, and click here for the facts of the case as outlined in the circuit court opinion.
From what I can tell, and older white guy - a lawyer - was fired from the Illinois Attorney General's office and replaced with a younger woman. The employer claims that he was let go due to "low productivity, excessive socializing, inferior litigation skills, and poor judgment," but he is claiming age discrimination and apparently wants to pursue the case under the constitution's Equal Protection Clause. It seems that the case is simply about whether he can do so.
Remember when we discussed discrimination under the law in 2305, we mentioned that the hurdle for discriminating on the basis of age is rather low. The defendant seems to want to prove that even that low standard was not met by the state.
The Supreme Court agreed on Monday to decide whether state and local government workers may file constitutional claims of age discrimination, instead of pursuing their complaints under the Age Discrimination in Employment Act — an issue on which lower federal courts are split. The case is Madigan v. Levin (12-872). That was one of three cases accepted for review, with oral arguments and decisions in each to be held next Term.
Click here for detail about Madigan v. Levin, here's the fancy desscription of the case:
Issue: Whether the Seventh Circuit erred in holding, in an acknowledged departure from the rule in at least four other circuits, that state and local government employees may avoid the federal Age Discrimination in Employment Act’s comprehensive remedial regime by bringing age discrimination claims directly under the Equal Protection Clause and 42 U.S.C. § 1983.
Click here for background on the Age Discrimination in Employment Act, and click here for the facts of the case as outlined in the circuit court opinion.
From what I can tell, and older white guy - a lawyer - was fired from the Illinois Attorney General's office and replaced with a younger woman. The employer claims that he was let go due to "low productivity, excessive socializing, inferior litigation skills, and poor judgment," but he is claiming age discrimination and apparently wants to pursue the case under the constitution's Equal Protection Clause. It seems that the case is simply about whether he can do so.
Remember when we discussed discrimination under the law in 2305, we mentioned that the hurdle for discriminating on the basis of age is rather low. The defendant seems to want to prove that even that low standard was not met by the state.
The US Supreme Court hears arguments on a case asking whether states can impose additional requirements to vote in elections.
The case is Arizona v. The Inter Tribal Council of Arizona, and it raised questions about the meaning of the Elections Clause in the Constitution.
The conflict pits the National Voter Registration Act of 1993 against an Arizona law - the Taxpayers and Citizen Protection Act - enacted by a ballot initiative in 2004. The federal law only requires that people swear they are American citizens under penalty of perjury, the Arizona law requires that actual proof be submitted.
Here's detail from the NYT:
ScotusBlog details the constitutional question presented, and states that generalluy under the Elections Clause Congress has greater power over state laws than under other parts of the Constitution - notable the Supremacy Clause:
The conflict pits the National Voter Registration Act of 1993 against an Arizona law - the Taxpayers and Citizen Protection Act - enacted by a ballot initiative in 2004. The federal law only requires that people swear they are American citizens under penalty of perjury, the Arizona law requires that actual proof be submitted.
Here's detail from the NYT:
The question for the justices was whether that state law conflicted with the National Voter Registration Act of 1993, which allows voters to register using a federal form that asks, “Are you a citizen of the United States?” Prospective voters must check a box yes or no, and they must sign the form, swearing that they are citizens under penalty of perjury.
Several members of the court’s conservative wing indicated that the state was free to impose additional requirements to make sure only citizens vote.
Justice Antonin Scalia said the federal form was inadequate. “So it’s under oath,” he said. “Big deal. If you’re willing to violate the voting laws, I suppose you’re willing to violate the perjury laws.”
“Under oath,” he added, “is not proof at all. It’s just a statement.”
Patricia A. Millett, a lawyer for several groups challenging the Arizona law, responded that “statements under oath in criminal cases are proof beyond a reasonable doubt” sufficient to lead to the death penalty.
She added that tens of thousands of people had been rejected from the registration rolls because of the Arizona law, though there was no evidence that they were not citizens.
ScotusBlog details the constitutional question presented, and states that generalluy under the Elections Clause Congress has greater power over state laws than under other parts of the Constitution - notable the Supremacy Clause:
Under the Constitution, state legislatures are given the authority to decide “the time, place and manner” of holding elections, including elections for federal offices, but Congress is given the authority to “make or alter such regulations.” The Ninth Circuit interpreted that Elections Clause to give Congress full and final veto power over any state law or regulation dealing with federal elections — that is, for Congress and for the Presidency. Congress used that power in 1993, in enacting the National Voter Registration Act, the Circuit Court said, and any state requirement that conflicts with that Act’s provisions must yield.ScotusBlog also points out that the case is similar to recent ones concerning access to the polls, the effort on the part of some to ensure the integrity of election results and on others to enhance access to the polls. As with other similar cases involving voter id requirements for example, positions on either side of the issue tend to be determined by whether one's political interests are enhanced or inhibited by increased voter turnout.
In reaching the result, the Circuit Court spelled out a special kind of constitutional analysis for judging when a state vote requirement is displaced by a federal one. It ruled that this analysis is different under the Elections Clause than under the Supremacy Clause. Usually, if a state law is found to be preempted, that results from the operation of the Supremacy Clause. But the Ninth Circuit said that, while the Supremacy Clause requires courts to maintain a delicate balance between federal and state interests, the Elections Clause established its own balance with Congress in a position to veto any state procedure on federal elections.
The Circuit Court said that the usual “presumption against preemption” that applies to protect state laws under the Supremacy Clause does not apply when the Elections Clause is at issue. Moreover, it ruled that Congress need not, in overruling a state on federal election procedures, provide a plain statement of its intention to override the state procedure.
Monday, March 18, 2013
Attitudes continue to shift on gay marriage
The Washington Post reports on a poll which shows that 58% of American now support gay marriage. The expected divide exists between liberals and conservatives and Democrats and Republicans. What tips the scale is self described moderates and Independents. Both groups support gay marriage by comfortable margins.
A very large gap exists between seniors and people younger than 30. 44% of seniors support it while 81% of people under 30 do. Its easy to see where this is heading.
A very large gap exists between seniors and people younger than 30. 44% of seniors support it while 81% of people under 30 do. Its easy to see where this is heading.
SB1 - The Appropriations Bill - heads to the floor of the Senate.
In 2306 we will be looking at the Texas budget process soon enough, but the appropriations bill (SB 1) is heading to the floor of the Senate so its not a bad idea to check it out early. As we will see soon enough - the only thing the legislature has to pass is the general appropriations bill. This is what authorize agencies in the state of Texas to draw money from the treasury, which is inkeeping with one of the traditional responsibilities of a legislative branch - to protect the treasury from the executive.
The Legislative Budget Board prepared and introduced a General Appropriations Act for 2014-2015 to both the House and the Senate. The Senate Finance Committee has held hearings on the bill and made changes to it, which mostly included slight increases in spending beyond what was initially proposed by the LBB. This included an extra $1.4 billion to public education - which is short of the $5 billion and change cut in the 82nd session.
We will be looking at detail soon enough, but here's are a few sites where you can get info about the process the appropriations bill has gone through so far. Suffice to say the bill was reported favorably by the committee and was placed on the intent calendar:
- LBB: Budget > 83rd Legislature.
- Open : States SB 1.
- GTLI: General Appropriations and Act.
The companion bill in the House (HB 1) has been referred to the Appropriations Committee, but from what I can see there have been no hearings yet.
The Legislative Budget Board prepared and introduced a General Appropriations Act for 2014-2015 to both the House and the Senate. The Senate Finance Committee has held hearings on the bill and made changes to it, which mostly included slight increases in spending beyond what was initially proposed by the LBB. This included an extra $1.4 billion to public education - which is short of the $5 billion and change cut in the 82nd session.
We will be looking at detail soon enough, but here's are a few sites where you can get info about the process the appropriations bill has gone through so far. Suffice to say the bill was reported favorably by the committee and was placed on the intent calendar:
- LBB: Budget > 83rd Legislature.
- Open : States SB 1.
- GTLI: General Appropriations and Act.
The companion bill in the House (HB 1) has been referred to the Appropriations Committee, but from what I can see there have been no hearings yet.
From the NYT: Republicans Plan Overhaul for 2016 Primary Season
The Republican National Committee has issued a report aimed at improving its electoral prospects nationally.
The NYT describes it:
A good point to keep in mind as 2305's look into the nature of political parties nationally. They are decentralized, meaning that there is no one leader that determines what the party stands for or what its over all strategy is. Notice that the national party is looking at the states for for guidance. Here's more from the NYT:
The NYT describes it:
In a sweeping review of the party’s 2012 election efforts, Republican leaders say too many voters saw their party as out of touch with the country’s needs and call for a new approach to voters.
“The G.O.P. today is a tale of two parties,” the report begins. “One of them, the gubernatorial wing, is growing and successful. The other, the federal wing, is increasingly marginalizing itself, and unless changes are made, it will be increasingly difficult for Republicans to win another presidential election in the near future.”
A good point to keep in mind as 2305's look into the nature of political parties nationally. They are decentralized, meaning that there is no one leader that determines what the party stands for or what its over all strategy is. Notice that the national party is looking at the states for for guidance. Here's more from the NYT:
Republicans, trying to heed the lessons of their 2012 losses in advance of the 2016 election cycle, unveiled proposals for improving the way the party talks about its ideas, turns out potential voters and raises money.
Reince Priebus, the chairman of the Republican National Committee, outlined the plans at a news conference in Washington on Monday morning, acknowledging Democrats’ comparative success with digital strategy and outreach to voters in critical demographic groups.
The party will also work to overhaul the way it chooses a presidential candidate, including shortening its primary season and limiting the number of debates, party leaders announced on Monday.
The report notes that the party has lost four of the last six presidential elections, often by wide margins, after winning five of six between 1968 and 1988. “Public perception of the party is at record lows,” the report says, and the party’s image is particularly weak among younger voters.
It remains unclear, though, whether party leaders mostly want to change their tactics and messaging — and whether such an approach can work — or whether they also want to change policies. Although some Republican strategists have called for an overhaul of strategy, most elected officials continue to say that many of the party’s policies, especially on economic matters, are sound.
Sunday, March 17, 2013
Weekly Assignment #9 - 16 week classes
2301 and 2305: It's budget season in DC. A handful of players have introduced their proposed budgets. I want you to look at three of them and compare them. First, I want you to find out what stage in the budgetary process we are in, and what the significance is of the timing of the release of each plan. Soon enough we will be looking at the budgetary process so this will help you get a head start in it. Then I want you to discuss the different visions of the role of government each contains. Do they each share the same idea about what the primary economic problem the nation faces is? How do they propose solving that - and other - problems? Head off in whatever direction seems fruitful to you after that. The purpose is to not only become familiar with the budgetary process, but the ideological disputes over what the US budget should look like.
Here are links to three budgetary proposals made so far:
- The House Republican Plan (the Paul Ryan budget)
- The Senate Democratic Plan
- The Congressional Progressive Caucus Plan
I'll link to commentary over the next few days.
2302 and 2306: I posted below about the last day to file bills in the Texas Legislature (last Friday). Now comes committee hearings and floor action, but various commentators have weighed in on the nature of the bill introduced and what this says about the nature of the 83rd Legislative session. Now its your turn.
What does the content of the bill introduced this session tell us about the priotities of this session? If you want to focus on certain bills that have been introduced, go for it. What types os bills do you think are likely to pass?
Here are links to three budgetary proposals made so far:
- The House Republican Plan (the Paul Ryan budget)
- The Senate Democratic Plan
- The Congressional Progressive Caucus Plan
I'll link to commentary over the next few days.
2302 and 2306: I posted below about the last day to file bills in the Texas Legislature (last Friday). Now comes committee hearings and floor action, but various commentators have weighed in on the nature of the bill introduced and what this says about the nature of the 83rd Legislative session. Now its your turn.
What does the content of the bill introduced this session tell us about the priotities of this session? If you want to focus on certain bills that have been introduced, go for it. What types os bills do you think are likely to pass?
Thursday, March 14, 2013
Houston has civil service exams for fire fighters
Here's a look at the civil service process on the local level. A couple thousand people went to the GRB Convention Center to take a three hour exam to join the fire department.
- KUHF: What Does It Take To Be A Houston Firefighter?
- 2,000 turn out to take Houston Fire Department Civil Service Exam.
- HFDCareers.
- Human Resources - City of Houston.
- KUHF: What Does It Take To Be A Houston Firefighter?
- 2,000 turn out to take Houston Fire Department Civil Service Exam.
- HFDCareers.
- Human Resources - City of Houston.
Wednesday, March 13, 2013
Do ZIP Codes allow for illegal discrimination?
Possibly:
Today, our ZIP code determines how we are read by policy-makers, politicians, statisticians, pollsters, insurers, businesses, organizers, and marketers. Governments use ZIP codes to determine who gets what—and this, in turn, stokes our political divisions. Private companies use ZIP code information to determine if they will, or will not, move into our communities. Retailers collect ZIP codes from customers, which can protect against fraud, but also helps a consumer database marketer collect personal information on us without our permission.
ZIP codes, in other words, have evolved from finding where we are to defining who we are—far beyond our mailbox. "Organizations—business, government—can look at the mass of people we've become and break us down into usable points," says Nancy Pope, curator at the Smithsonian's National Postal Museum. "While it was designed to help our letters travel faster, it's become like an ID system we all agree to and all use."
From the Texas Tribune: The Texas Weekly Index
I still haven't completely figured out the methodology here, but it purports to show the "political climate" in each of the legislative districts in the state.
Deadline for filing new bills in the leg has passed
The deadline was actually Friday, but with spring break and all there was enough to think about. So now we can start analyzing what's bee introduced - and what has not been introduced. Hint: 16 week 2302s and 2306s will have to do a preliminary analysis for the weekly assignment for the week we get back from the break.
- Click here for filed House bills.
- Click here for filed Senate bills.
- For complete information click here.
For background here are a couple news stories commenting on the deadline, expect more soon:
- Texas legislators file flurry of bills before session’s deadline.
- Bill numbers just was Legislature organizes.
Some general notes:
Over 2,000 bills were introduced week before the deadline. Over 750 were filed Friday the 8th - the last day bill could be introduced. Some of the last bills filed were some of the more controversial: the school choice / voucher bill, regulations for charter schools, restrictions on abortion, among other topics. Fewer bill were filed this session than in the previous two, about 5,500 total, with just under 4,000 in the House and just under 2,000 in the Senate. Filing in general has been very slow this session.
- Click here for filed House bills.
- Click here for filed Senate bills.
- For complete information click here.
For background here are a couple news stories commenting on the deadline, expect more soon:
- Texas legislators file flurry of bills before session’s deadline.
- Bill numbers just was Legislature organizes.
Some general notes:
Over 2,000 bills were introduced week before the deadline. Over 750 were filed Friday the 8th - the last day bill could be introduced. Some of the last bills filed were some of the more controversial: the school choice / voucher bill, regulations for charter schools, restrictions on abortion, among other topics. Fewer bill were filed this session than in the previous two, about 5,500 total, with just under 4,000 in the House and just under 2,000 in the Senate. Filing in general has been very slow this session.
Monday, March 11, 2013
State of the Judiciary Address
Last Wednesday Texas Chief Justice Wallace Jefferson gave the State of the Judiciary address before the legislature.
Here is the text of the remarks: Chief Justice Jefferson Calls for Continued Legal Help for Poor, Decriminalizing School Misbehavior, Study of Guardianship Needs for Elderly.
And some feedback about the remarks:
- Texas Tribune.
- The Atlantic.
- Texas' chief justice wants investigation of all wrongful convictions
- Jefferson pushes for judicial reforms
His speech drew notice for his focus on inequality in the state's justice system, an area we don't spend enough time on in class - this should help correct that deficiency. The Trib states that he:
Here is the text of the remarks: Chief Justice Jefferson Calls for Continued Legal Help for Poor, Decriminalizing School Misbehavior, Study of Guardianship Needs for Elderly.
And some feedback about the remarks:
- Texas Tribune.
- The Atlantic.
- Texas' chief justice wants investigation of all wrongful convictions
- Jefferson pushes for judicial reforms
His speech drew notice for his focus on inequality in the state's justice system, an area we don't spend enough time on in class - this should help correct that deficiency. The Trib states that he:
. . . "reiterated his calls for more funding for civil legal aid, indigent defense and juvenile justice reform, and pushed for the establishment of an 'innocence commission' to investigate wrongful convictions."
Presenting his State of the Judiciary speech to Texas lawmakers, Jefferson said that "wrongful convictions leave our citizens vulnerable, as actual perpetrators remain free" and recommended the Legislature create a commission "to investigate each instance of exoneration, to assess the likelihood of wrongful convictions in future cases, and to establish statewide reforms." He cited the recent exoneration of Michael Morton, who spent nearly 25 years in prison for murder.
The creation of such a commission nearly passed in 2011, but failed at the last minute. Part of the opposition has come from Jeff Blackburn, chief legal counsel of the Innocence Project of Texas, a nonprofit organization that attempts to overturn wrongful convictions and investigate why they happen in the first place. He said recently that such a commission would have to be “extremely well-funded,” and would more likely become “a paper commission that would give a lot of people an excuse to turn away from a lot of the real issues we face in the criminal justice system."
But the bill creating such a commission, House Bill 166, by state Rep. Ruth Jones McClendon, D-San Antonio, got a favorable review from the House Criminal Jurisprudence Committee on Tuesday.
Jefferson also pushed for indigent defense and more money for civil legal aid. "We must do more," he said, "to keep the courthouse doors open for all of our neighbors." He called on lawmakers to increase the amount of funding dedicated to organizations that provide indigent civil legal aid and criminal defense.
Saturday, March 9, 2013
Do you really know what's best for you? Does government?
A recently published book makes a provocative claims that fits with some general points I like to make when we begin both 2305 and 2306 (though I'm not sure I do a good enough job). What is government for? And in order to tie this into political conflicts involving ideology - which tend to contain predisposed opinions about whether the public or private sector (government or the individual) can best make decisions - we sometimes wonder what the "liberal" and "conservative" approach to certain problems might be.
The book I'm referring to it is Against Autonomy: Justifying Coercive Paternalism and it makes the case that we are far more irrational than we realize, and despite the value we place on individuals making decisions on their own, some limits ought to be placed on those types of decisions. The state - or more accurately, the collective decision we make as a democratic society and then impose on everyone - may be justified in being paternalistic in certain areas. Of course the state already does: Think about laws regarding drug and prostitution, and those of you who are under 21 - and rational - but can't legally drink alcohol. But this provides a more thorough justification for this behavior that is explicitly based on human irrationality rather than rationality.
Full disclosure: I haven't read the book yet, but I've some provocative reviews of it that outline and critique the argument in the book. Here's a good one. This reviewer points out that research has demonstrated multiple places where human rationality fails. Where we are fooled or make errant judgments. Some examples:
- Present Bias: We tend to focus on issue important to us today and ignore tomorrow.
- Probablity: We tend to not understand the actual likelyhood of different events occurring. Often we over estimate harms associeted with something that occured recently (like the recent meteor explosion) event though they are less likely to be repeated than other events.
- Optimism: We overestimate the likelyhood that we wil suffer consequences from any risky behaviors we engage in.
In a succinct sentence the books author states that “We are too fat, we are too much in debt, and we save too little for the future.” And we are due to the choices we make. Society as a whole suffers from these collective choices, so a degree of paternalism is justified.
This could be worth a class discussion.
In the meantime it suggests to me that I modify some of the slides I've put together detailing the role rationality plays in establishing governments based on the individual. The rationale still holds, but some nod to what research has told us about our actual ability to think rationally seems necessary.
The book I'm referring to it is Against Autonomy: Justifying Coercive Paternalism and it makes the case that we are far more irrational than we realize, and despite the value we place on individuals making decisions on their own, some limits ought to be placed on those types of decisions. The state - or more accurately, the collective decision we make as a democratic society and then impose on everyone - may be justified in being paternalistic in certain areas. Of course the state already does: Think about laws regarding drug and prostitution, and those of you who are under 21 - and rational - but can't legally drink alcohol. But this provides a more thorough justification for this behavior that is explicitly based on human irrationality rather than rationality.
Full disclosure: I haven't read the book yet, but I've some provocative reviews of it that outline and critique the argument in the book. Here's a good one. This reviewer points out that research has demonstrated multiple places where human rationality fails. Where we are fooled or make errant judgments. Some examples:
- Present Bias: We tend to focus on issue important to us today and ignore tomorrow.
- Probablity: We tend to not understand the actual likelyhood of different events occurring. Often we over estimate harms associeted with something that occured recently (like the recent meteor explosion) event though they are less likely to be repeated than other events.
- Optimism: We overestimate the likelyhood that we wil suffer consequences from any risky behaviors we engage in.
In a succinct sentence the books author states that “We are too fat, we are too much in debt, and we save too little for the future.” And we are due to the choices we make. Society as a whole suffers from these collective choices, so a degree of paternalism is justified.
This could be worth a class discussion.
In the meantime it suggests to me that I modify some of the slides I've put together detailing the role rationality plays in establishing governments based on the individual. The rationale still holds, but some nod to what research has told us about our actual ability to think rationally seems necessary.
Welcome Mini 2 2305 and 2306 students
Hopefully you've figured out how to get to this site and what you'll find here. Send me a note through the acc email if you have questions.
As you know - you don't really get a spring break, so the bulk of the posts I'll have up over the next week will be for you. 16 week students might tag along since they'll help review for the comprehensive final coming up in May - which is closer than you think.
As you know - you don't really get a spring break, so the bulk of the posts I'll have up over the next week will be for you. 16 week students might tag along since they'll help review for the comprehensive final coming up in May - which is closer than you think.
16 week students - take a break
Its spring break - so unless you have to catch up, I suggest taking time off of from class.
If you've been taking time off from day one however, you might want to use this week as an opportunity to get up to speed. Things will pick up soon enough, and remember that I do not accept work after May 9th.
If you've been taking time off from day one however, you might want to use this week as an opportunity to get up to speed. Things will pick up soon enough, and remember that I do not accept work after May 9th.
More on the filibuster against Judge Halligan
There are four vacancies on the DC Circuit Court of Appeals and Senate Republicans have been able to prevent President Obama from filling any of them. Democrats are strategizing to figure out how to respond.
From the NYT:
From the NYT:
A fresh feud over federal judgeships has again begun to agitate the Senate, with Republicans so far blocking President Obama from filling any of the four vacancies on the nation’s most prestigious and important appeals court.
After Republicans this week filibustered the nomination of Caitlin J. Halligan of New York to the United States Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit, Democrats quickly began discussions over how to respond. One possibility is for Mr. Obama to make several simultaneous nominations, in effect daring Republicans to find specific objections in multiple instances. Democrats say Republicans would be hard pressed to come up with legitimate reasons to disqualify all four.
“We need to design a strategy to counter the Republicans, and we are going to need the president,” said Senator Tom Udall, Democrat of New Mexico. “Rather than putting just one up, we should put before the Senate all four and expose what is happening here.”
If Republicans were to continue to steadfastly block a series of appeals court nominees, Democrats say they might then have justification to revisit Senate rules and claim new power to thwart filibusters.
Presidential Portraits
OK, so I was surfing through different web sites with one of sons looking at pictures of people with sideburns. Their choir teacher had said something in class about Elvis and what a big stink his sideburns kicked up in the 50s.
Then we scrolled through Civil War era sideburns - and how crazy they were - and stubled across a photo of Martin Van Buren, then this awesome drawing:

Some web guys threw this together to celebrate presidents with facial hair - they have more.
Here's Rutherford B Hayes:

I'm totally stealing these for my slides.
Then we scrolled through Civil War era sideburns - and how crazy they were - and stubled across a photo of Martin Van Buren, then this awesome drawing:
Some web guys threw this together to celebrate presidents with facial hair - they have more.
Here's Rutherford B Hayes:
I'm totally stealing these for my slides.
Friday, March 8, 2013
Wealth Inequality in America
This has been making the rounds. We'll be looking at economic policymaking at some point - so it'll be relevant soon enough.
For now, you might want to consider which groups might be concerned about the issues it raises, and what power they might have to impact policies addressing inequality.
Texas has the largest percentage of uninsured people by far
According to the Gallup Poll, 28.8% of Texans are uninsured. Louisiana is second at 24%.
The lowest is Massachusetts at 4.5%.
The lowest is Massachusetts at 4.5%.
The latest on the battle over Medicaid expansion in the state
- The House of Representatives appears divided over the possibility of expansion. Supporters are trying to figure out how to get the national government to allow for adjustments - like co-payments and turning the program into a block grant. The block grant proposal appears to be a no-go from the feds.
- Speaker Straus wants a "Texas Solution" to Medicaid expansion. This article repeats a lot of what is contained in the story above. There is mention of the fact that the federal government accepted Arkansas proposal that private insurance options be available for Medicaid recipients.
- The Texas Tribune adds more to the "Texas Solution" proposal - which still needs to be fleshed out.
- The Tribune also has an interactive section where you can compare the approaches taken by different states, and you can weigh the pros and cons of Medicaid expansion.
- Speaker Straus wants a "Texas Solution" to Medicaid expansion. This article repeats a lot of what is contained in the story above. There is mention of the fact that the federal government accepted Arkansas proposal that private insurance options be available for Medicaid recipients.
- The Texas Tribune adds more to the "Texas Solution" proposal - which still needs to be fleshed out.
- The Tribune also has an interactive section where you can compare the approaches taken by different states, and you can weigh the pros and cons of Medicaid expansion.
Labels:
83rd Session,
federalism,
medicaid,
US - Texas conflict
So signing DOMA was all about winning the 1996 election
Bill Clinton has stated that it was wrong for him to have signed the Defense of Marriage Act. He wants the Supreme Court to overturn it. But why did he sign it in the first place? Because doing so helped him win the 1996 election. Here's detail, and as you read it, think about what this suggest about the role elections play in establishing public policy in a democracy - especially when the policy affects a numeric minority.
As Republicans prepared for the 1996 Presidential election, they came up with what they thought was an extremely clever strategy. A gay-rights lawsuit in Hawaii was gaining press coverage as an initial series of preliminary court rulings suggested that gay marriage might be legally conceivable there. Clinton was on the record opposing marriage equality. But Republicans in Congress believed that he would still veto legislation banning federal recognition of otherwise valid same-sex marriages, giving them a campaign issue: the defense of marriage.
What Republicans had not counted on, though, was just how adverse the Administration had become, especially in an election year, to getting ahead of public opinion on gay rights after having had to backtrack on open military service.
. . . Inside the White House, there was a genuine belief that if the President vetoed the Defense of Marriage Act, his reëlection could be in jeopardy. There was a heated debate about whether this was a realistic assessment, but it became clear that the President’s chief political advisers were not willing to take any chances. Some in the White House pointed out that DOMA, once enacted, would have no immediate practical effect on anyone—there were no state-sanctioned same-sex marriages then for the federal government to ignore. I remember a Presidential adviser saying that he was not about to risk a second term on a veto, however noble, that wouldn’t change a single thing nor make a single person’s life better.So there was the assumption that public opinion was not behind the issue in 1996, so signing it was risky. This is apparently not the case now. Perhaps we should consider whether Clinton's decision was or was not in keeping with what we want policymaking in a democracy to look like.
An inside look at the rulemaking process
When we covered the executive branch in both 2305 and 2306 we discussed the rulemaking process, which is the way that executive agencies charged with implementing the law are able to clarify the meaning of legislation in order to facilitate implementation.
In this discussion we mentioned that interest groups try to - actually must - intervene in this process in order to ensure that their interests are served by those rules, in the same way that they intervene in the legislative process in order to make sure that the law itself reflects their interests.
Here's an inside look at how representatives of the major commodities exchanges in the nation worked to influence how the U.S. Commodity Futures Trading Commission interpreted a simple sounding phrase in the Dodd-Frank bill passed in 2011.
This story also applies to our discussion of interest groups.
In this discussion we mentioned that interest groups try to - actually must - intervene in this process in order to ensure that their interests are served by those rules, in the same way that they intervene in the legislative process in order to make sure that the law itself reflects their interests.
Here's an inside look at how representatives of the major commodities exchanges in the nation worked to influence how the U.S. Commodity Futures Trading Commission interpreted a simple sounding phrase in the Dodd-Frank bill passed in 2011.
This story also applies to our discussion of interest groups.
Labels:
financial crisis,
iron triangles,
lobbying,
rulemaking
Is the Voting Rights Act still necessary?
That cuts to the heart of the challenge to the act presented in Shelby v Holder. Is there evidence that election laws passed in the state subject to pre-clearance because of past discriminatory acts, still discriminate based on race, meaning pre-clearance is still necessary?
Here's an argument that there are political incentives for majorities in the states to discriminate, regardless of whether it is done due to racial animosity. The argument reminds me of points made in 2305 about factions in Federalist #10:
We can assume that minority votes will be suppressed in these states because it makes electoral sense to do so.
Here's an argument that there are political incentives for majorities in the states to discriminate, regardless of whether it is done due to racial animosity. The argument reminds me of points made in 2305 about factions in Federalist #10:
. . . regardless of whether white political leaders in these states hold racist views, they have substantial political incentives for engaging in actions to suppress or dilute the minority vote.
In addition to a history of racial discrimination, the states covered by Section 5 are characterized by an exceptionally high degree of racial polarization in voting up to the present day. Whites and nonwhites in these states are deeply divided in their political preferences, resulting in a two-party system in which one party depends overwhelmingly on votes from whites and the other party depends overwhelmingly on votes from African Americans and other nonwhites. This racial polarization continues to provide a powerful incentive for leaders of the party that depends overwhelmingly on white votes to suppress or dilute the votes of African Americans and other minorities.Party identification is more polarized along racial lines in states covered under Section 5 than those that are not:
We can assume that minority votes will be suppressed in these states because it makes electoral sense to do so.
Labels:
civil rights,
discrimination,
race,
Supreme Court,
voting rights
The Disease Olympics
Here's a good look at the battles that happen between different "disease lobbies" who try to maximize spending on their preferred malady (be it cancer, HIV/AIDS, or whatever). Increasingly, this includes taking cases directly to members of Congress rather than to the different agencies set up to fund that research. $1,000 in lobbying seems to correspond to $25,000 in research funds. It's a terrific look at the networks that develop around spending items.
Special attention is given to the recently signed Recalcitrant Cancer Research Act.
Here's an additional look at how the sequester might impact funding for research on disease in general. Might there be increasingly contentious fights over limited resources? Let's hope if you get sick you get sick with a disease that has forceful advocates.
credit: The Dish.
Special attention is given to the recently signed Recalcitrant Cancer Research Act.
Here's an additional look at how the sequester might impact funding for research on disease in general. Might there be increasingly contentious fights over limited resources? Let's hope if you get sick you get sick with a disease that has forceful advocates.
credit: The Dish.
Defy Ventures
In a post below I mentioned that the Texas Association of Business wants to focus on recidivism. Too many felons return to prison after finishing their terms, often because (legal) work opportunities are limited for them. But those running illegal operations do have entrepreneurial skills. Here's the website of an outfit in New York that tries to reorient those skills towards legal endeavors. Given laws in Texas, the question is whether similar people here will be allowed to make that transition. The TBA seems about to support them - it worth following.
Top federal executive positions remain vacant
ProPublica reports on the number of top executive positions that remain vacant in the Obama Administration (click here for data).
NPR points out that delaying or denying these positions can be a strategic decision by opponents who cannot terminate an agency, but want to make it difficult for the agancy to carry out its mission.
All presidential administrations have vacancies. But an analysis of appointments data by ProPublica shows that President Obama hasn’t kept up with his predecessors in filling them. A greater share of presidentially appointed positions that require Senate confirmation were sitting vacant at the end of Obama’s first term than at the end of Bill Clinton’s or George W. Bush’s first terms. At least 68 of the positions remain vacant, including 43 that have been vacant for more than a year.
The vacancies have been spread across dozens of different departments and agencies, with some hit harder than others. At the Department of the Interior, for instance, six of its 18 appointed positions were vacant at the end of Obama’s first term. The department had three vacancies midway through Clinton’s presidency and only one midway through Bush’s.
The lack of appointed leaders can create problems. Too many vacancies can put agencies “in stand-down, waiting for policymakers to show up,” said Terry Sullivan, a political science professor at the University of North Carolina who has studied appointments.
Acting heads of agencies “don’t make any big decisions,” said Cal Mackenzie, a professor of government at Colby College who has studied appointments since the 1970s. “Your authority is not going to be recognized in the same way a Senate-confirmed appointee is going to be recognized.”
NPR points out that delaying or denying these positions can be a strategic decision by opponents who cannot terminate an agency, but want to make it difficult for the agancy to carry out its mission.
The filibuster against Brennan failed, but the filibuster against Halligan succeeded
As mentioned below, Senator Paul took to the Senate floor this week to mount and old fashioned filibuster against the nomination of John Brennan to head the CIA. This article notes that - without much fanfare - a newfangled filibuster defeated the nomination of an Obama appointee to the federal courts - specifically the very important DC Circuit Court of Appeals.
As we've discussed in class, what is now considered a filibuster is the inability of of supporters of a bill or nomination to amass 60 votes to guarantee a floor vote. This explains the increase in filibusters recently.
The use of the filibuster against the judicial nominee explains the large number of vacancies in the federal judiciary. During the Obama Administration, the wait for judicial nominations has increased substantively.
Links:
- Would-Be Federal Judges Face The Washington Waiting Game.
- Vacancies, backlogs plague federal judiciary.
- DOJ: Judicial Nominations.
- Judicial Nominations.
As we've discussed in class, what is now considered a filibuster is the inability of of supporters of a bill or nomination to amass 60 votes to guarantee a floor vote. This explains the increase in filibusters recently.
The use of the filibuster against the judicial nominee explains the large number of vacancies in the federal judiciary. During the Obama Administration, the wait for judicial nominations has increased substantively.
Links:
- Would-Be Federal Judges Face The Washington Waiting Game.
- Vacancies, backlogs plague federal judiciary.
- DOJ: Judicial Nominations.
- Judicial Nominations.
Thursday, March 7, 2013
What impact will sequestration have on military spending?
This question came up in one of my 2305s.
Hopefully this helps address the question
Facts related to the sequester: As a result of a compromise to increase the federal debt ceiling in 2011 (contained in the Budget Control Act of 2011) an agreement was made that if spending cuts cannot be agreed upon by Congress and the White House, then automatic cuts will be imposed. The idea was that the automatic cuts would be so bad a deal would be inevitable (click here for a look at the agreement at the time). A committee was put together to find a way to cut $1.2 trillion from the budget from 2013-2021, but it could not reach a deal, so the cuts were triggered. These cuts were originally set to happen this past January 2, but the deadline was extended until March 1 - a few days back.
As a result of the deal, $85 billion in spending has to be cut from the current budget. These are to be across the board, meaning that the cuts have to impact all affected agencies equally. Not all programs are affected. Mandatory programs - what we come to know as non-discretionary programs - like Medicaid and Social Security are exempted. Partly this is because they are set in law, and must be paid as a result, but partly because they are politically popular and no member of Congress dare touch them without risking upsetting the elderly. This includes some of the largest, and fastest growing, spending items on the national level - which leads some to question whether these cuts will do anything to address the deficit and debt, but let's leave that to another day.
Click here for a breakdown from the Bipartisan Policy Center. It describes how the current cuts, as maintained for the next 9 years, add up to $1.2 trillion in total cuts including the money saved in debt service.
Most of the cuts come from discretionary programs (click here for the Washington Post's look at the cuts). This spending is not set in law, so it can be changed very easily. These cuts are split between defense and domestic programs. The Post mentions that the defense cuts are likely to affect weapons purchasing, base operations, and construction work among other items. Federal News Radio says the cuts will affect operations and maintenance and include such things as "civilian worker pay and upkeep of facilities." I highly recommend looking at the previous links to get detail.
The National Journal also has a handy list of affected programs. They fall into four categories: defense discretionary spending, non-defense discretionary spending, Medicare, and non- defense mandatory spending.
The Office of Management and Budget released a report detailing the amount of money that will be cut from affected programs, but the actual programs that will be cut are not detailed. As best as I can tell, we still do not know exactly what specific programs will be cut. I'll fill in details as I find them. This is not unusual by the way. ACC is asked from time to time - and most recently last year - to prepare budgets to send to the governor's office that include decreases in spending. Last year we were asked to prepare a request that accounted for a 10% reduction in state funding. So the ball was in our court. I assume that is the same for the federal agencies affected by the sequester - but we'll find this out as time goes.
- Congressional Budget Office: The Budget and Economic Outlook: Fiscal years 2013-2023.
Hopefully this helps address the question
Facts related to the sequester: As a result of a compromise to increase the federal debt ceiling in 2011 (contained in the Budget Control Act of 2011) an agreement was made that if spending cuts cannot be agreed upon by Congress and the White House, then automatic cuts will be imposed. The idea was that the automatic cuts would be so bad a deal would be inevitable (click here for a look at the agreement at the time). A committee was put together to find a way to cut $1.2 trillion from the budget from 2013-2021, but it could not reach a deal, so the cuts were triggered. These cuts were originally set to happen this past January 2, but the deadline was extended until March 1 - a few days back.
As a result of the deal, $85 billion in spending has to be cut from the current budget. These are to be across the board, meaning that the cuts have to impact all affected agencies equally. Not all programs are affected. Mandatory programs - what we come to know as non-discretionary programs - like Medicaid and Social Security are exempted. Partly this is because they are set in law, and must be paid as a result, but partly because they are politically popular and no member of Congress dare touch them without risking upsetting the elderly. This includes some of the largest, and fastest growing, spending items on the national level - which leads some to question whether these cuts will do anything to address the deficit and debt, but let's leave that to another day.
Click here for a breakdown from the Bipartisan Policy Center. It describes how the current cuts, as maintained for the next 9 years, add up to $1.2 trillion in total cuts including the money saved in debt service.
Most of the cuts come from discretionary programs (click here for the Washington Post's look at the cuts). This spending is not set in law, so it can be changed very easily. These cuts are split between defense and domestic programs. The Post mentions that the defense cuts are likely to affect weapons purchasing, base operations, and construction work among other items. Federal News Radio says the cuts will affect operations and maintenance and include such things as "civilian worker pay and upkeep of facilities." I highly recommend looking at the previous links to get detail.
The National Journal also has a handy list of affected programs. They fall into four categories: defense discretionary spending, non-defense discretionary spending, Medicare, and non- defense mandatory spending.
The Office of Management and Budget released a report detailing the amount of money that will be cut from affected programs, but the actual programs that will be cut are not detailed. As best as I can tell, we still do not know exactly what specific programs will be cut. I'll fill in details as I find them. This is not unusual by the way. ACC is asked from time to time - and most recently last year - to prepare budgets to send to the governor's office that include decreases in spending. Last year we were asked to prepare a request that accounted for a 10% reduction in state funding. So the ball was in our court. I assume that is the same for the federal agencies affected by the sequester - but we'll find this out as time goes.
- Congressional Budget Office: The Budget and Economic Outlook: Fiscal years 2013-2023.
What The Shining has in common with the Wilson Administration and the early Federal Reserve Board
So I shut things down last might when the Shining came on TV and watched it from the beginning with the family. I had talked my boys into muttering "redrum" at school from time to time to freak their teacher out, so they were familiar with the movie and I figured this was as good a time as any to watch their first real horror movie.
If you've seen the movie you know what its all about and that it ends with a zoom-in shot of a photograph from a very fancy party at a swanky hotel taken in 1921. The kicker is that the Jack Nicholson character is in the photograph even though the movie was set around the late 1970s.
Very eerie.
Anyway, my boys and I were looking at some You Tubes that described how the movie was made and stumbled across one that described the original photograph that Nicholson's image was airbrushed into. The narrator discovered that the photograph included members of Woodrow Wilson's Administration and of the recently created Federal Reserve Board. I thought this was an interesting coincidence considering what I teach.
Here's a bio of one of the guys he mentions
- Benjamin Strong, Jr.
One less felony in Texas . . . maybe
The Texas Tribune tells us that legislators are considering reversing part of a bill passed in the 82nd legislature that expanded felony classification for certain laws - but then had an unintended consequence:
In 2011, Gov. Rick Perry signed Senate Bill 694, which edited a line in the penal code focused on theft valued at less than $20,000. The law originally classified such theft as a state jail felony if at least 50 percent of the stolen item was made of certain metals, such as copper or aluminum. SB 694, authored by state Sen. Royce West, D-Dallas, struck out the 50 percent threshold, which allowed items of any value with even tiny amounts of copper to fall under the statute.
A penny is 2.5 percent copper, according to the U.S. Mint.
Prosecutors haven’t seized on the accidental felony as an excuse to start rounding up penny thieves, but the Texas District and County Attorneys Association has cited the law as an example of the unintended consequences of legislation. Though the potential penny felony has drawn more attention, prosecutors have joked they could also use the law to amp up the penalty for someone who steals a 12-pack of beer from a convenience store, said Shannon Edmonds, the group’s director of governmental relations.
“You could raise it to a felony by charging them with theft of aluminum,” Edmonds said.
Kleinschmidt, a lawyer who has handled some copper wire theft cases in the past, filed a bill this session to narrow the statute so that pennies and aluminum cans are no longer covered.
“It’s just a hole in the statute that needs to be fixed,” Kleinschmidt said.
Kleinschmidt’s bill, HB 544, would require that the enhanced penalties only apply to metal thefts worth $500 or more. He said the current law, with no minimum value for felony-grade metal thefts, is too broad and confusing.
Wednesday, March 6, 2013
The Drone Lobby and the Drone Caucus
Why not?
We've had Drone Court and Drone Journalism, now here's a story about the individuals who argue in favor of drone technology and the members of Congress who support them.
Here's a snippet describing a meeting among drone supporters worried about how the technology is perceived:
Here's a link to the Congressional Unmanned Systems Caucus. Local Reps Gene Green, Michael McCaul, and Pete Olson are members.
We've had Drone Court and Drone Journalism, now here's a story about the individuals who argue in favor of drone technology and the members of Congress who support them.
Here's a snippet describing a meeting among drone supporters worried about how the technology is perceived:
“As you can see,” [Lobbyist Ben] Gielow said dryly, “we have a challenge with the media.”
A pink drone - great idea. The Soft Kitty 2000.As the second day went on, the focus shifted to solutions. I overheard attendees muttering that maybe the safest thing to do for now was to market to farmers who wanted drones to survey their crops. “No one’s gonna say you’re spying on the corn,” one said darkly.
It was also agreed that the D-word had to go. “That term ‘drone’ kills us every time,” said Don Roby, a garrulous Baltimore County police captain leading a nationwide push to deploy drones for police work. Barton mentioned that, when doing business in England, he’d been urged to call drones “remote-sensing platforms.” Unfortunately, this euphemism proved to be overly euphemistic. One potential investor told Barton: “That remote-sensing platform—if it had wings, just imagine what it could do!”
Jerry Wright, a retired Air Force colonel, had another idea. When the police chief of Seattle sought approval to use drones, he brought in an ominous-looking black Draganflyer X6 to display during his presentation. City officials recoiled in horror. So, Wright said, the chief went back to the manufacturer. “They came back with the same platform painted pink and they were going to call it the Soft Kitty 2000.” To Wright, there was a clear lesson to be drawn here: “As an industry, we need more pink ones and less black ones.”
Here's a link to the Congressional Unmanned Systems Caucus. Local Reps Gene Green, Michael McCaul, and Pete Olson are members.
Labels:
113th Congress,
caucuses,
drones,
Interest Groups,
privacy,
surveillance cameras
Filibuster Alert
The Atlantic is reporting that Kentucky Senator Rand Paul is doing an actual old-time filibuster on the floor of the US Senate. There are not enough vote to prevent the cloture vote that allows for the Senate to consider the nomination of John Brennan as CIA Director so he's talking it up.
Should the Bill of Rights be updated?
Here's an argument that recent developments in surveillance technology (drones etc...) make updating a good idea, even an imperative one.
Ultimately, it doesn't matter whether we trust the authorities to impose limits upon themselves when it comes to deployment of surveillance technologies that legislators nor courts have specifically circumscribed. The fact is that the law is out of date. The Bill of Rights was written a long time ago, well before cellphones, the internet, spy drones or even video cameras were invented. Our Electronic Communications Privacy law is woefully obsolete, itself predating widespread usage of three of those four technologies.
We need to bring the Bill of Rights into the 21st century for the same reason the ACLU and others want the Obama administration to tell us its legal rationale for its overseas killing operations: the public should know what rules the government is bound by, particularly when it comes to our rights to privacy and due process. Unfortunately, that's simply not the case. Today, we live in an era of secret law, from top-secret CIA and military killings abroad, all the way down to the DOJ's view of law enforcement location tracking powers here in the US. Where the law doesn't explicitly provide guidance, we are largely ignorant of how the government interprets its authorities with respect to new technologies, its powers, and our rights.
Labels:
bill of rights,
privacy,
surveillance cameras,
technology
Cut spending, but not spending on what I like
This is one of those stories that gets rewritten every time spending cuts are topical.
One person's pork is another person's job. This has always made federal spending cuts difficult to enact. Constituencies develop around different spending projects which aim to preserve programs.
But here's a question: Why doesn't this logic work in Texas - or why does it work only selectively? The legislature was able ti cut $5 billion in public education in the 82nd session (pending the ongoing lawsuit), but supporters of the cuts were able to survive electorally. Why? Perhaps it comes down to the nature of the political factions in the state as opposed to national factions. This would make a good research project.
The general idea of slicing government spending is popular, with majorities of Republicans, independents and Democrats all saying they support an across-the-board five percent reduction in federal outlays. (This poll asked only about cuts started with the so-called sequester, not about taxes, or any possible budget deal.)
. . . The large support for cutting government spending stands in stark contrast deep public opposition to decreasing spending on particular programs. In February the Pew Research Center surveyed Americans on 19 areas of federal spending, and there was majority support for decreasing spending in precisely zero of them. (See also Huffpost Pollster’s write-up of the cuts paradox.)
In short: the American public likes the idea of cutting federal spending; what they don’t like are actual cuts in federal spending.
That paradox makes it very difficult for elected officials to navigate the issue of whether — and what — to cut. It also explains why we should have seen the sequester as politically inevitable right from the start. Without any clear signal from the public of how, specifically, it wants the cuts to happen, politicians did the easy thing: They let an across-the-board cut go into effect without having to vote (read: explain) on it.
One person's pork is another person's job. This has always made federal spending cuts difficult to enact. Constituencies develop around different spending projects which aim to preserve programs.
But here's a question: Why doesn't this logic work in Texas - or why does it work only selectively? The legislature was able ti cut $5 billion in public education in the 82nd session (pending the ongoing lawsuit), but supporters of the cuts were able to survive electorally. Why? Perhaps it comes down to the nature of the political factions in the state as opposed to national factions. This would make a good research project.
Labels:
budgeting,
iron triangles,
spending cuts,
Texas budget
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)