Showing posts with label voter behavior. Show all posts
Showing posts with label voter behavior. Show all posts

Thursday, October 6, 2016

From 538: Trump’s Doing Worse Than Romney Did Among White Voters

More support for the argument that college educated white voters are realigning from the Republican to Democratic Party just as those without a college degree have been headed in the opposite direction.

The only question is whether this shift will last more than one electoral cycle.

- Click here for the article.

Donald Trump’s strategy in this campaign has been fairly clear from the beginning: Drive up Republican support among white voters in order to compensate for the GOP’s shrinking share among the growing nonwhite portion of the electorate. And Trump has succeeded in over performing among a certain slice of white voters, those without a college degree. But overall, the strategy isn’t working. Trump has a smaller lead among white voters than Mitt Romney did in 2012, and Trump’s margin seems to be falling from where it was when the general election began.
. . . Perhaps, it would be better news for Trump if he were at least trending in the right direction with white voters. But he’s moved backward compared with polls back in May and early June. Back then, Trump led Clinton by 17 percentage points, on average, among white voters. In other words, the longer white voters have had a chance to listen to Trump’s message, the more they have been put off by it as a group.
To be more specific, Trump is trading one type of white voter for another. Even as he piles up support among white men without a college degree, he’s on track for a record poor performance for a Republican among white voterswith a degree. And right now, that tradeoff is a net negative for Trump, compared with Romney. If a ton of new white voters without a degree flooded into the electorate, that could change the math for Trump. But such a surge doesn’t look like it’s in the offing.

Monday, June 20, 2016

From the Washington Post: Hillary Clinton’s lead in the polls may be larger than it seems. Here’s why.

Building off our discussion of current problems with polling.

- Click here for the article.
In 2012, national polls in October suggested the presidential race was a virtual tie. The Real Clear Politics polling average gave Barack Obama a slight 0.7 point lead over Mitt Romney, but he actually won by almost 4 points. Of the final 11 national polls released in 2012, as reported on Real Clear Politics, 7 were a tie or had Romney ahead, while only 4 had Obama ahead.
Why were so many of the polls wrong? In part, because they failed to capture how minorities would vote. Unfortunately, some pollsters may be making the same mistakes in 2016 — and thereby underestimating Hillary Clinton’s lead in the polls.
In 2012, many polls underestimated how many minorities would vote and how many would vote for Obama. For example, a Politico poll released the morning of Election Day said the race was tied at 47 percent each for Obama and Romney. The poll said that 62 percent of Latinos supported Obama, while the exit polls reported 71 percent, and Latino Decisions reported 75 percent. Among the “another race” category, which is mostly comprised of Asian Americans, Politico reported that 47 percent supported Obama, while the exit polls reported 73 percent, and an Asian American Decisions exit poll reported 72 percent.
. . . In 2016, the country is even more diverse. Pollsters need to take steps to more accurately estimate the political attitudes and behavior of black, Latino and Asian American voters. Polls that are conducted only in English and that do few or no callbacks to try contact hard-to-reach populations are not going to accurately reflect the American electorate. Polls that are conducted via online panels need to ensure that they are not under-representing minority voters with less formal education and lower incomes. Finally, pollsters should take steps to make sure each racial subgroup in their poll is weighted to match the American Community Survey’s estimates for that particular group, not just their national sample overall.

Wednesday, March 30, 2016

From the New Republic: Who Is the Hillary Voter? The media is obsessed with the Sanders voter and the Trump voter. Yet it is the Hillary voter who may have the last laugh

Maybe the media is getting it all wrong. It's happened before.

- Click here for the article.

The voter we almost never hear about, however, is the Clinton voter. Which is surprising, since Hillary Clinton has won more votes in the primaries than any other candidate so far. She has amassed over 2.5 million more votes than Sanders; over 1.1 million more votes than Trump. Clearly Clinton voters exist, yet there has been very little analysis as to who they are or why they are showing up to vote for her. Sure, there has been talk of Clinton’sdominance among African-American voters, and, to a lesser extent,Hispanic voters. Her voters seem to skew older and more affluent. But these are demographics. (And even demographics have a hard time explaining her commanding win in Ohio, or her wins in Massachusetts and Missouri.) There is almost no discussion of what is motivating these voters. If anything, the media seems to think they are holding their noses as they vote for Hillary. As a recent New York Times article suggested, Clinton is winning “votes, not hearts.”

Thursday, November 5, 2015

From the New Republic: How Opponents of LGBT Rights Are Exploiting the Politics of Disgust

We discussed this earlier this semester. It touches on what factors influence the decision to both turnout to vote and how to vote.

- Click here for the story.
The gay marriage movement succeeded by convincing people that gay men and women just wanted to be normal. Having lost that battle, the opponents of LGBT rights have made a partial comeback by turning their focus to transgender discrimination, bringing old fears of the abnormal and the deviant back to the forefront.

On Tuesday, voters in Houston overwhelmingly rejected a broad anti-discrimination ordinance by a whopping 62 percent to 38 percent margin after its opponents shamelessly pitched the measure as a vehicle for sexual predators to victimize young women. “Any man at any time could enter a woman’s bathroom simply by claiming to be a woman that day. … Even registered sex offenders could follow women or young girls into the bathroom,” warned one TV ad depicting a faceless man following a young uniformed school girl in into a bathroom stall and shutting the door. “It would allowed troubled men to enter women’s public bathrooms, showers, and locker rooms,” former Houston Astros baseball star Lance Berkman said in a radio ad against the ordinance.
That message preyed on all kinds of base fears and stereotypes—that trans people are disturbed freaks; that the world is crawling with sexual predators; and that women and girls must be shielded from men’s private parts. The reality is that 17 states and more than 200 towns and cities broadly prohibit discrimination based on gender identity, including at public bathrooms. And there's no evidence that these laws are enabling sexual assault by sexual predators pretending to be transgendered. Violence against transgender people, on the other hand, is still distressingly real and on the rise.

Tuesday, November 19, 2013

From the New Yorker: On the Face of It: The Psychology of Electability

We just finished talking about how personal characteristics can influence voters. When we cover the media, we will see the impact that television has had on how candidates are evaluated.

Looks matter.

Here's a more exhaustive look at these factors:


In 2003, the Princeton psychologist Alexander Todorov began to suspect that, except for those people who have hard-core political beliefs, the reasons we vote for particular candidates could have less to do with politics and more to do with basic cognitive processes—in particular, perception. When people are asked about their ideal leader, one of the single most important characteristics that they say they look for is competence—how qualified and capable a candidate is. Todorov wondered whether that judgment was made on the basis of intuitive responses to basic facial features rather than on any deep, rational calculus. It would make sense: in the past, extensive research has shown just how quickly we form impressions of people’s character traits, even before we’ve had a conversation with them. That impression then colors whatever else we learn about them, from their hobbies to, presumably, their political abilities. In other words, when we think that we are making rational political judgments, we could be, in fact, judging someone at least partly based on a fleeting impression of his or her face.

Starting that fall, and through the following spring, Todorov showed pairs of portraits to roughly a thousand people, and asked them to rate the competence of each person. Unbeknownst to the test subjects, they were looking at candidates for the House and Senate in 2000, 2002, and 2004. In study after study, participants’ responses to the question of whether someone looked competent predicted actual election outcomes at a rate much higher than chance—from sixty-six to seventy-three per cent of the time. Even looking at the faces for as little as one second, Todorov found, yielded the exact same result: a snap judgment that generally identified the winners and losers. Todorov concluded that when we make what we think of as well-reasoned voting decisions, we are actually driven in part by our initial, instinctive reactions to candidates.





Wednesday, November 6, 2013

Gallup: In U.S., Voter Registration Lags Among Hispanics and Asians

This confirms some points we made in 2305 earlier today about ethnic disparity in registration and voting.

U.S. Hispanics and Asians are much less likely to be registered to vote than whites or blacks. Whereas more than eight in 10 blacks and whites are registered, and therefore able to vote in elections, 60% of Asians and barely half of Hispanics are currently able to participate in the electoral process.

Self-Reported Voter Registration by Racial and Ethnic Subgroup, July-September 2013


The relevance of greater Hispanic and Asian participation in the political process is clear. Both Hispanics and Asians have decidedly Democratic political leanings. Notably, Hispanics and Asians who are registered to vote are even more Democratic than those who are not registered.

Party Affiliation Among Hispanics and Asians, by Voter Registration Status, July-September 2013

Monday, December 10, 2012

Becker and Posner on the Paradox of Voting

A couple rational guys try to figure out why people do something apparently irrational: Vote in an election that there is little or no chance they will be able to sway. One person's vote out of 100 million will not change results, but ...

Posner sees a similarity to clapping:

Some people vote because the political campaigns make it costly for them not to vote—one technique in “get out the vote” drives is pestering people to vote so that they will feel uncomfortable not voting. Some vote because they think that it will encourage others to do so. Some vote because they consider it a civic duty. Some voting is purely expressive—a way of expressing strong feelings pro or con a candidate (or pro one and con his opponent); certainly anger played a role in votes against Romney by members of groups that he or his party seemed to disrespect, and anger at Obama played a role in the large number of votes that Romney received. In this respect voting is like booing or cheering at an athletic event or other entertainment. One person’s applause at a concert is inaudible to the performers, yet people applaud, and not mainly I think because others in the audience would look askance at them if they did not. And finally people interested in politics like to vote to convince themselves and others that their interest is serious—they are willing to put their money (not money exactly, but the cost in time and bother of voting) where their mouth is.

No one thinks that applauding is irrational, even though like voting it has no instrumental value, and has some, though very slight, cost.


Becker is concerned that the fact that we know our vote does not matter makes it unlikely we will learn about the candidates we are voting for:

Since the great majority of voters presumably do not expect to influence election outcomes, who they support is influenced disproportionately by campaign rhetoric, debates among candidates that have little intellectual content, and by other methods of persuasion that are not very informative about the candidates. I like to say that consumers put more time and effort into deciding which cereal to buy and into other small consumer choices than in gathering information on economic and other issues about presidential candidates.
But I am not claiming that voters are less “rational” than consumers of everyday products. Individuals pay more attention to what they buy than whom they vote for because what they buy has a direct and tangible effect on their wellbeing. Since the incentives to become well informed are radically different, “rational” voting implies very different kinds of behavior than does rational choice of cereals or peanut butter.

Sunday, October 28, 2012

Do people know what they are voting for?

As we discuss elections in most of my current classes, we ought to take a critical look at one of the assumptions of elections. The electorate - the argument goes - can direct the actions of government by making choices between candidates that will determine that direction. But this assumes that people know which party and which candidate stands for what.

A YouGov study throws water on that assumption. People determine which candidate they like - for whatever reason - and change their positions on issues to match that. In all honesty, this finding is not novel.

In deciding between Barack Obama and Mitt Romney, we hope that voters are choosing between candidates based in part on candidates’ policy stances, such as their positions on taxes and war. In a book I have coming out this month, Follow the Leader (press release), I find surprisingly little evidence that policy stances matter to voters. Specifically, I find that voters’ prior policy views rarely lead them to change votes or even approval of candidates during campaigns. Instead, voters usually choose candidates for some other reason, such as the election-year economy, and then follow their preferred candidate on policy issues, adopting that candidate’s stances as their own. Rather than leading politicians on policy, voters mostly follow.

Are voters choosing between Obama and Romney on policy issues such as healthcare, taxes, and the war in Afghanistan? Or are they merely following, adopting their preferred candidates' views? Determining whether citizens are leading or following on policy is tricky—it's a “chicken and egg” problem. In the book, I use repeated interviews with the same individuals. But I can illustrate this tendency to follow with a surprising pattern that shows up in a single survey.

In a recent YouGov poll, I asked participants about their views on abortion policy and what position they thought Obama, Romney, the Democratic Party, and the Republican Party took on abortion. Only about 60% of respondents knew that Obama and the Democrats supported more pro-choice policies than Romney and Republicans. Given that the parties have had clear and long-standing positions on this issue, it's astonishing that 40% of Americans don't know this basic fact (other surveys find even higher levels of ignorance).

Thursday, July 12, 2012

Economic trends, campaign advertising, the ground game

In response to a question about what matters between now and election day for Obama and Romney, smart guy John Sides lists the three factors above. Equally smart guy Jonathan Bernstein chimes in.

Commentators are suggesting that a very large percentage of the electorate has made a decision about who they will support and their positions will not change. Any shifts will happen among a very small number of people.

Wednesday, April 18, 2012

Romney, Obama and the gender gap

While Romney has problems with Latinos and Women, Obama has problems with men, and a couple articles suggest that Romney's advantage with men may overshadow Obama's advantage with the other two.

Friday, January 13, 2012

The Economy and the 2012 Elections

In a post below I mentioned that some argue that presidential campaigns do not matter and that votes for or against sitting presidents are driven purely by the economy. If they believe it is improving, they vote for re-election, if it is not, they don't Charlie Cook builds off this in light of some numbers which suggest the rebound might be impacting the unemployment rate:

Although the presidential race is dominating the media this week, other events are worth watching: the recent spate of brighter economic news and lower unemployment numbers. These trends could change the trajectory of the general election. The latest Blue Chip Economic Indicators survey of 56 top economists forecasts an 8.7 percent unemployment rate for calendar year 2012 and an 8.5 rate for the fourth quarter, when Election Day occurs.

My rule of thumb has been that if unemployment is near 9 percent on Election Day, President Obama would very likely lose. If it’s near 8 percent, he would likely win. But if it’s around 8.5 percent, the race would be a toss-up. Worthy of note, the Blue Chip survey was conducted on January 4-5, before the Bureau of Labor Statistics released the December unemployment numbers that dropped to 8.5 percent from an upwardly revised 8.7 percent in November. This means that the jobless rate has inched downward four months in a row, from 9.1 percent in August to 8.5 percent in December.
While we talk about the unemployment rate, the number that researchers have stated most closely predicts voting decisions is real disposable income, more specifically, which direction the number is heading. Roughly this means whether you feel that you have more to spend, or less to spend. It seems to be the most tangible way for individuals to feel whether the state of the economy is affecting them positively or negatively.

Friday, September 9, 2011

Should voters blame themselves?

As we continue to discuss the instability fostered by democracy, this reader's comments from Andrew Sullivan's website are worth considering:

Yes, the public is incredibly discouraged about the economy and extremely angry at Washington. What everybody seems to be missing, though, is that the American people did this (created the dysfunction in DC) to ourselves. We voted for Barack Obama in 2008, then turned around and elected a huge number of radically conservative (actually, not conservative at all - reactionary) Republican House members in 2010. What did people think was going to happen? Was there any thought put into the implications of doing this? I’m not willing to just blame the Beltway; I also blame the American voter. We live in a democracy, and elections matter.
What are the chances that voters will blame themselves for the current state of the political environment?

And though it is far too early to make reasonable predictions about 2012 - some see signs of another wave election, but back to the left. It's not unreasonable.

Friday, August 5, 2011

Age, Income Inequality and the Polarized Electorate

While the existence of primary elections and sophisticated gerrymandering remain dominant explanations for political polarization, here is an argument that two socio-demographic factors also drive this tendency.

We have an increasingly old population - who happen to command, and fight to preserve, most of the entitlements - and a larger and larger gap is growing between the wealthy and the poor in the nation. This means that the interests of the elderly and the young are increasingly at odds, as are those of the wealthy and the poor, as are the voter choices (to the degree that the young and the poor vote at all) between both groups.

Monday, July 18, 2011

Report: Some voters swayed by looks alone

A bit depressing, but this isn't the first study to point out that it matters how attractive a candidate is. This is argued to be a product of the television age. Do you think Abraham Lincoln could be elected today?

A new Massachusetts Institute of Technology study found that so-called “low-information voters” — those who watch a lot of TV but who aren’t up-to-date on policy issues — are most likely vote for a candidate based on looks alone.

For every 10-point increase a candidate gets because of his or her appearance, about half of that increase comes from the voters with the least amount of political knowledge and the most time spent in front of the TV.

The study analyzed data from two surveys conducted during the 2006 midterm elections: the Cooperative Congressional Election Study, which surveyed voters on their candidate preferences and television-watching habits; and a study headed by Princeton University professor Alex Todorov, which asked participants to rate ’06 Senate and gubernatorial candidates based solely on appearance.

“People judge other people all the time when they first meet them, but once they learn more about them they update their impressions and forget their initial judgments,” said MIT associate professor Gabriel Lenz, who co-authored the study. “The problem with democracy is that we ask people to vote in all these elections where they don’t know all that much except their first impression.”

Monday, July 11, 2011

Comment or Vote

From a link taken from the post below, possibly the greatest video ever made.

http://www.commentorvote.com/

Friday, November 5, 2010

Did Roll Call Votes Matter?

More analysis of the 2010 vote from the Monkey Cage:

Did votes on the controversial bills (stimulus, cap and trade, TRAP and heath care) the past two years make a real difference in the elections? Overall, the answer is no, but for those Democrats who were defeated (many of whome were in districts that did not vote for Obama in 2008), the answer seems to be yes. There's the outside (very outside) chance that had these Democrats all voed against these bills that Democrats woudl stil be in the majority.

What does this model tell us about roll call votes on these four bills? Simple answer: they mattered. A lot. A Democratic incumbent in the average district represented by Democratic incumbents actually lost about 2/3 of a percentage point for every yes vote. That doesn't sound like a lot, but that's for incumbents in districts that voted 63% for Obama.

For Democrats in the least Democratic districts (Chet Edwards of TX or Gene Taylor of MS), the model suggests a loss of about 4% for every yes vote. Does that mean poor Chet lost 16 points on roll call votes alone? No, because he wasn't a big supporter of Obama's agenda. But he did vote for both TARP and the stimulus. In fact, virtually every Democratic incumbent on the ballot yesterday supported at least one of these four bills. That support was costly.

Again, this suggests that what really matters more than votes, is the way that districts are drawn. Had each district been more balanced, not gerrymandered one way or the other, the election would have turned out differently. What does this tell us about democracy?

Wednesday, October 13, 2010

Do Campaigns Matter?

Here's some evidence that they may not.

It's a common point made by political scientists. Some analyses suggest that pocketbook economic conditions (change in disposable income) six months prior to an election best predicts election results. That being the case, the slip in the economy that began around April and May may have doomed any chance Democrats had of a good result, but history has consistently show that -- all things equal -- the party out of power is more motivated to vote in midterm elections than the party in power.

Thursday, August 5, 2010

Its Still the Economy Stupid

A story in today's NYT illustrates the point. Voters tend to be motivated by the economy (pocketbook voting) more than other factors, and vote against who ever is in power if the economy sours. What got Democrats voted into office in 2008, works against them in 2010. So, what happens if the economy is still bad in 2012?

This also complicates the idea that voters send messages about which policies (health care, education, climate change, gay marriage, etc...) with their votes. Perhaps its just about the economy, and everything else is secondary.