Showing posts with label libertarianism. Show all posts
Showing posts with label libertarianism. Show all posts

Monday, February 8, 2016

538: Why Young Democrats Love Bernie Sanders

He's the oldest - looking anyway - candidate out there and is pummeling the opposition with young voters. Part of the reason is that younger voters don;t have the same negative feelings about socialism that older voters have. Generational change helps explain this. Older generations equate socialism with the Soviet Union and communism. Younger voters equate it with the more benign governments of Scandinavia.

It's interesting to point out that the same voters who are now attracted to Sander's socialism were also attracted to Ron Paul's libertarianism a few years back. The two ideologies share little in common - though there is some overlap between the two.

538 walks through the phenomenon and has some useful things to say about the ideological incoherence of the two parties.

- Click here for the article.
. . . terms such as “liberal” and “conservative” are fairly cynical also, at least in the way they’re applied in contemporary American politics. Rather than reflecting their original, philosophical meanings, they instead tend to be used as euphemisms for the policy positions of the Democratic and Republican parties, respectively. Those parties’ platforms are not all that philosophically coherent, nor do they reflect the relatively diverse and multidimensional political views of individual Americans. Instead, the major American political parties are best understood as coalitions of interest groups that work together to further one another’s agendas.
What’s distinctive about both the Sanders and Ron Paul coalitions is that they consist mostly of people who do not feel fully at home in the two-party system but are not part of historically underprivileged groups. On the whole, young voters lack political influence. But a young black voter might feel more comfortable within the Democratic coalition, which black political leaders have embraced, while a young evangelical voter might see herself as part of a wave of religious conservatives who long ago found a place within the GOP.
A young, secular white voter might not have a natural partisan identity, however, while surrounded by relatively successful peers. In part, then, the “revolutions” that both Sanders and Paul speak of are revolutions of rising expectations.

And a key graphic:

silver-bernieyouth-1

"isms" in the news

The section ideology in 2305 covers pertinent terms. Here's an example of their use in the media.

These are limited to progressivism, populism, libertarianism and democratic socialism. Scroll them if you wish - we might want to talk about how the terms are used, and if they jive with any of the dictionary definitions we would have covered in class.

- The Clinton-Sanders Fight: What Does It Mean to Be Progressive?
- Democrats Debate: What Is A Progressive And Who Wants To Be One?
- The progressive crack up.
- Bernie Sanders and the New Populism.
- Toward a Conservative Populism.
- Rand Paul's Campaign Proved Libertarianism and Conservatism Are Antithetical.
- With Rand Paul’s Exit, Has the “Libertarian Moment” Died Once Again?
- Most are democratic socialists; just don’t know it.
- Democratic socialism might be inevitable in America, even if Bernie Sanders loses.
- The Libertarian Populist Agenda.

Monday, January 11, 2016

Libertarianism and the Second Amendment.

I'll try wrapping this up in a written assignment of some sort. Libertarians seem conflicted over how to best secure gun rights. They like the Second Amendment, but its in the national constitution. They're uneasy about using the power of the national government to limit state and local power. But, perhaps that's necessary.

From the Hoover Institution: The Libertarian Gun Fallacy.
From Reason.com: Libertarians, Guns, and Federalism.
From the Yale Law Journal:
- Firearm Localism.
- Why Firearm Federalism Beats Firearm Localism.

Sunday, December 27, 2015

Is Rand Paul a Libertarian?

The consensus of these articles is that he is not - and even if he is, the libertarian movement is at best a minor force in the Republican Party.

Be prepared for questions about ideology next week, including what a libertarian is. Those of you writing about the differences between Republican candidates might find these useful.

- The collapse of Rand Paul and the libertarian moment that never was.

The collapse of the Rand Paul campaign speaks volumes. In a 15-person field, Paul is the only candidate who looks even remotely libertarian (social tolerance, foreign policy restraint, and limited government). He started the campaign with decent name recognition, a seat in the United States Senate, lavish media attention, a serious will to win, and a battle-tested, national political operation inherited from his father, Ron. If there were any significant support for Libertarian ideas in the GOP—any at all—Rand Paul would be near the top of an otherwise crowded, fragmented field that is fighting over every non-libertarian voter in the party. Yet he’s polling at a mere 1 percent among Republican voters nationwide and has a higher unfavorability rating than anyone else in the GOP race.

- Rand Paul Is Not A Libertarian.

Libertarians, in general, are fiscally conservative but socially liberal, with a non-interventionist approach to foreign policy. His father, Ron Paul is a “libertarian cult figure” who had tremendous appeal to young Republicans. Rand Paul is clearly marketing himself as the heir apparent to those supporters — the one candidate with a chance of expanding the Republican base. But is Rand Paul a libertarian? He certainly likes to talk like a libertarian. Let’s take a look at where he stands on the issues.

- The strange death of GOP libertarianism: Rand Paul’s collapse and the fading of a political moment.

In a recent article, Jerry Taylor, president of the Niskanen Center, Washington’s newest libertarian think-tank, discusses the collapsing presidential campaign of Kentucky Sen. Rand Paul and what it means for the larger libertarian movement in the United States. As I pointed out last month, Taylor concludes that the sudden rise of Donald Trump, who may just be the least libertarian of all GOP front-runners, is not a good sign for the libertarian movement, which not too long ago seemed poised to take over a large segment of the Republican Party. Today, this optimism had been shattered.

- IS RAND PAUL A TRUE LIBERTARIAN? NO, HE’S A POLITICIAN.

. . . it seems to me that many people are hitching their wagons to Paul without really looking at his record. While I can appreciate Senator Paul’s filibuster regarding the use of drones abroad and his opposition to the USA Patriot Act and the Freedom Act, he’s hardly the pinnacle of the classical liberal ideal. He’s still a politician.
Let me repeat that. He’s a politician. Look at Paul’s voting record. Far from breaking away from partisan politics, Paul votes align with the Republican Party some 84 percent of the time. This includes affirmative votes for the annual National Defense Authorization Acts.

- Is Rand Paul struggling because he isn't libertarian enough?

This has been the week of articles painting a dismal portrait of Rand Paul's presidential campaign. Hispolling has slipped since the last time I wrote about this topic and his fundraising numbers, including super PACs, have been a major letdown. Disappointed libertarians are starting to speak out about these struggles, somelamenting that Paul hasn't been libertarian enough while others note that he hasn'trecaptured the excitement of his father Ron Paul's Republican presidential campaigns.

Monday, August 31, 2015

From the New Republic: Inside the Libertarian Movement to Take Over the Legal System

We look at Libertarianism in GOVT 2305 along with many of the other "isms" along the left right political continuum. Here's a definition: "a political philosophy that upholds liberty as its principal objective. Libertarians seek to maximize autonomy and freedom of choice, emphasizing political freedom, voluntary association and the primacy of individual judgment."

Sounds fine, but the movement is opposed to many of the policies put in place to protect workers: the 40 hour work week, overtime pay, child labor laws and the like. Freedom of the business owner takes precedence over governmental laws meant to protect workers. Capital trumps labor.

Here's an argument that a handful of libertarian legal scholars are working to undo the legal rationale that underlies the New Deal. This includes revisiting a controversial case from  1905 Lochner v New York. I'll post something that separately, but this article tells us a few things about how change on the Supreme Court can be accomplished.

It focuses primarily on one of the leading figures of this movement, Randy Barnett, and his efforts to redefine conservatism on the court from being restrained to activist.

- Click here for it.

Eventually, Barnett clawed his way to Boston University, and then to Georgetown, where he joined the faculty in 2006. (“I love the situation here,” he said of his current digs. “I don’t need to be on the outs.”) But even as his career took off, his legal views remained decidedly anti-establishment. Barnett believes the Constitution exists to secure inalienable property and contract rights for individuals. This may sound like a bland and inconsequential opinion, but if widely adopted by our courts and political systems it would prohibit or call into question basic governmental protections—minimum wages, food-safety regulations, child-labor laws—that most of us take for granted. For nearly a century now, a legal counterculture has insisted that the whole New Deal project was a big, unconstitutional error, and Barnett is a big part of that movement today.

Friday, July 10, 2015

From Reason: Is This Where Libertarians and the Gay Community Part Ways?

The author argues that the recent gay marriage decision marks a turning point in the alliance between the two groups. This illustrates the ways the groups can coalesce around certain issue and how those relationships can change over time.

- Click here for the article.

Areas of disagreement:
- Employment Nondiscrimination.
- Religious Freedom Exemptions.

Areas of agreement:
- Transgender Recognition.
- Adoption.

Tuesday, April 7, 2015

From 538: Rand Paul Is Losing His Father’s Base

Building off a post below, Rand Paul's attempts to re position himself as a more moderate Republican in order to make himself more electable - which he claims to be - might be turning off the libertarians. They already suspicious of the Republican Party. 

- Click here for the article.

Kentucky Sen. Rand Paul’s presidential campaign is less than a day old but already suffers from an identity crisis. Paul wants to win, but he can only do so if he is seen as more mainstream than his father, Ron Paul, who ran for president in 2008 and 2012. At the same time, Paul can’t completely jettison the far-left and far-right positions that have made him a hero to the substantial number of Republican libertarians who made up his father’s base.
In Paul’s dream world, he’ll satisfy everyone. In the most likely real world, he’ll end up satisfying no one.
The most obvious path for Paul to win the GOP nomination is to build on the 21 percent of the vote his father earned in Iowa in 2012, and the 23 percent Paul Sr. picked up in New Hampshire that year. In a divided primary field, that might not seem so difficult; 25 percent might be enough to win both states. And with wins in the first two contests, Paul might be able to ride the Big Mo’ to the nomination.
But right now, Paul isn’t anywhere close to where his father ended up in either state in 2012. Paul is polling at a little less than 9 percent in Iowa and nearly 11 percent in New Hampshire.
. . . We’ll see a lot of ups and downs in the 2016 campaign, but there’s reason to read more into Paul’s recent polling slide, as he’s spent the last year trying to increase his appeal with the GOP establishment, particularly on foreign policy.
When was the last time you heard Paul accused of being an isolationist? He used to advocate for cutting foreign aid to Israel, but now he offers pro-Israeli bill after pro-Israeli bill to cut off funding to the Palestinians. He once seemed to favor President Obama’s diplomatic overtures to Iran, but he signed Sen. Tom Cotton’s letter aimed at hurting those negotiations. Paul was once reluctant to get involved in fighting the Islamic State, but he now wants more airstrikes.
There really isn’t good public data on the views of libertarian Republican voters, but interviews and internal polls suggest that Paul’s evolution on foreign policy has been too successful in separating him from his father, and has eroded his libertarian credentials. Ron Paul’s 2012 Iowa campaign chairman Drew Ivers would “prefer if [Rand Paul] had a different strategy” than “meeting [mainstream Republicans] in the middle.” Aaron Day of the libertarian Free State movement in New Hampshire sees less enthusiasm for Rand Paul than for his dad.

From the New Republic: Rand Paul Will Break Libertarian Hearts, Just Like Reagan Did

In our discussion of the winner take all system, we've been talking about the compromise that libertarians and others have to make between the urge to be pure that the desire to have an actual practical impact on politics.

This article walks through the tension that libertarians have with the Republican Party.

- Click here for it.

For Senator Rand Paul, winning the Republican presidential nomination will involve a delicate balancing act of keeping faith with his libertarian roots while also appealing to the broader conservative base of the party. On issues like the war on drugs and government surveillance, Paul has articulated strongly anti-statist positions that are rarely heard from either party. Yet to be a plausible Republican presidential candidate, Paul, to the disappointment of many of his more orthodox libertarian followers, is increasingly sounding like a typical conservative, especially on foreign policy.
Paul’s conundrum shouldn’t surprise us: Libertarians have always been an uneasy fit within the broader Republican coalition. Libertarians claim to have roots in classical liberalism of the early modern era, but only emerged as a salient and self-conscious political movement in the 1930s, as a reaction to the expansion of the welfare state initiated by Franklin Roosevelt’s New Deal. That didn’t make libertarians comfortable Republicans, though. As purist counter-revolutionaries who wanted to roll back FDR’s achievements, libertarians all too often found Republicans to be cowardly and unreliable allies.

Friday, January 24, 2014

The World's Smallest Political Quiz

I caught up with grading week one's assignment last night - I'm sure more have been snuck in since though. If you gave a reasonable answer of at least 150 words you got an A. If you wrote less than 150 word you got less, depending on how much you wrote.

There were a lot of comments on the nature of the quiz since it didn't really ask you anything about your political opinions.

Here's one that does, its the world's smallest political quiz - ten question - and it was put together by libertarians. It measures the degree to which you approve of governmental intervention in personal affairs and on economic affairs. So the results are arrayed across two dimensions. The result - they argue - tells whether you are liberal, conservative, libertarian, statist or centrist.

Click here for the quiz.

Here is the chart used to show the results - its called the Nolan Chart:



I might have you take this for a future written assignment and have you compare the two results, not sure yet, but try taking it your self and see what you get. Do you get the same results?

Sunday, November 17, 2013

Not a nation of moderates - and little evidence of a political realignment

The Dish flags a paper by some political scientists who challenge the idea that we are a nation of moderates. It depends on how you measure moderation. They also argue against the notion the recent elections - like Obama's reelection in 2012 - indicate a political realignment is underway that will likely favor the Democratic Party. These two arguments are related.

If you measure it alone one dimension - for example social or economic ideology - then moderates rule, but reality is more complex. The political world not contains your standard liberals and conservatives, it also contains libertarians, populists and moderates. The former two complicate things. Libertarians are liberal on social issues and conservative on economic issues, populists are the reverse. People may be moderate on economic issues, but extreme on social issues, or vice versa. People who are moderate on both social and economic issues are very rare.

This graph purports to explain that fact:



Wednesday, May 30, 2012

Tuesday, February 28, 2012

David Frum doesn't care for the term "The Founders"

He points out, as we have also, that the nation was built up for 150 years prior to the actual revolution. What would become the nation had already been founded in many ways prior to 1776. Between 1776 and 1787, the American Republic was constructed. He also reminds us that the North American colonies were quite aristocratic, and that would continue until the revolution:

When called to church on a Sunday morning, the people of a southern colony would not enter all at once–or even family by family. The commonfolk of the parish would enter first. Then the wives and children of the major landowners. These squires assembled as a body, and entered together after all others had sat down.

True, the colonies lacked the extremes of wealth and poverty to be seen in the mother country. As Wood notes, the most opulent house in colonial America, William Byrd’s Westover, was 65 feet long. The Marquess of Rockingham had a house ten times the size; the Sackvilles’ palace of Knole had 365 rooms.

But if the hierarchy was truncated at top and bottom, it was finely elaborated in between. In New England, people carefully assessed who ranked as a mere husbandman, who counted as a yeoman, who should be addressed as “Mr.,” and who was entitled to the yet more respectful, “Your honor.”

African slaves occupied the very lowest rank in a vast system of unfreedom and dependency. Yet their condition differed only in degree from that of white indentured servants and apprentices. The servant or the apprentice might be held only for a term of years rather than for life. The apprentice might expect some kind of support and patronage after his term expired. While the indenture or apprenticeship lasted, however, white servants could be beaten just like a black slave; could be refused permission to marry; and could discover that their service had been sold to a new master.

The American revolution collapsed this elaborate hierarchical world into a new scheme that recognized only two statuses, slave and free.
He also challenges the idea that the founders were libertarian, as is often suggested by contemporary politicians. Individualism, as we understand it today, evolved over time:

What would today’s Tea Party make of this statement? “Private property is a creature of society, and is subject to the calls of that society whenever its necessities shall require it, down to the last farthing.” No, that’s not Karl Marx–that’s the Benjamin Franklin of the Constitutional period. (p. 219, The Americanization of Benjamin Franklin.)

Nor was Franklin unique. Modern libertarianism was an utterly foreign mode of thought to the revolutionary generation.

Ironically, those members of the revolutionary generation who sound most libertarian to our modern ears (Thomas Jefferson for example) were the most mistrustful of commerce and enterprise. Those most sympathetic to commerce and enterprise (Alexander Hamilton) sound least libertarian.

Yet as commerce advanced–and as pre-modern forms of authority based on claims of public virtue were rejected–American politics evolved in directions more and more recognizable to us.

In 19th century America, equality would come to mean “not just that a man was as good as his neighbor and possessed equal rights, but that he was ‘weighed by his purse, not by his mind, and according to the preponderance of that, he rises or sinks in the scale of individual opinion.’ That was a kind of equality no revolutionary had anticipated.” (p. 243, Radicalism of the American Revolution.) The quoted words come from one of the correspondents of the painter and inventor, Samuel FB Morse.

Thursday, September 15, 2011

From the Washington Post: The budding alliance between greens and libertarians

An unusual alliance seems to be evolving on environmental policy:

After a climate bill fizzled out in the Senate last year and Republicans won big in the midterms, many observers wondered how the environmental movement could reinvent itself. Would it shift to playing defense on the EPA? Try to build a broader grass-roots movement? But few could have predicted the trend we’re seeing now: Amid calls for austerity, some green groups are aligning with conservative think tanks to push for cuts to environmentally harmful programs.
The odd alliance kicked off last month when Friends of the Earth and Public Citizen teamed up with Taxpayers for Common Sense and the conservative Heartland Institute for their “Green Scissors” report, focusing on cuts to everything from ethanol and oil tax credits to timber subsidies. And this month? The Natural Resources Defense Council (NRDC) is teaming up with the libertarian Reason Foundation and Taxpayers for Common Sense to attack the Essential Air Service program, which has been a small but controversial part of the ongoing fight over FAA funding in Congress.

-
Can big budget cuts be environmentally friendly?

Should the uninsured be left to die?

The cheers that erupted in the last Republican debate when it was suggested that the uninsured should be left to die if there was no guarantee that they could pay their bills has led to some soul searching, as well as interesting questions posed about the responsibilities we, collectively, have to each other - or whether any such responsibilities exist.

From Ezra Klein: Why libertarianism fails in health care.

It’s all well and good to say personal responsibility is the bedrock of liberty, but even the hardest of libertarians has always understood that there are places where your person ends and mine begins. Generally, we think of this in terms of violent intrusion or property transgressions. But in health care, it has to do with compassion.
We are a decent society, and we do not want to look in people’s pockets for an insurance card when they fall to the floor with chest pains. If we’re not going to look in their pockets, however, we need some answer for who pays when they wake up — or, God forbid, after they stop breathing — in the hospital. And though it sounds nice to say that charities will pick up the slack, any hospital system in America will tell you that even with Medicare and Medicaid assuming much of the burden for the most intractable and expensive cases, charities are not capable of or interested in fully compensating the medical system for the services needed by the un- or underinsured.
From Andrew Sullivan: Indecent.

Friday, January 28, 2011

Senator Ron Paul?

Paul Burka comments on the possibility he might make a run, and offers this ominous comment:

The problem with having Ron Paul represent Texas in the United States Senate is that Paul doesn’t chase after federal money. It’s against his principles. Forget money for NASA, for highways, for universities, for military bases. He will cost Texas hundreds of millions of dollars in foregone federal aid. Paul will have none of it. He is a unique type of politician. He represents principles rather than people. If he chooses to run, he will be very difficult to defeat. And Texas will never get back a dime of the money its taxpayers send to Washington.

Tuesday, November 23, 2010

Ron Paul Profile

From the Atlantic, a profile on our own Rep. Ron Paul. The comments are probably more interesting than the article.

Sunday, October 17, 2010

Another Thought Regarding Hyper Libertarianism ....

From the story referred to below:

Offline, Thiel is the lead backer of Seasteading, a movement to create law-free floating communes based on voluntary association.
Libertarians often argue that societies based on norms are more philosophically just than those based on rules. This is on line with our 2301 discussion about coercive vs consensual foundations of governments. My question is more pragmatic, how capable is a norm based society to secure its liberties? Can they protect themselves from Somali pirates?

Hyper Libertarianism

This analysis of Pay Pal co-founder Peter Thiel is a bit harsh (I can't vouch for its accuracy), but it touches on political conflicts central to this class. Note the highlight in the following quote from the story:

To describe Peter Thiel as simply a libertarian wildly understates the case. His belief system is based on unapologetic selfishness and economic Darwinism. His most famous quote—borrowed from Vince Lombardi—is, "Show me a good loser and I'll show you a loser." In a personal statement produced last year for the CATO Foundation, Thiel announced: "I no longer believe that freedom and democracy are compatible." The public, he says, doesn't support unregulated, winner-take-all capitalism and so he doesn't support the public making decisions. This anti-democratic proclamation comes with some curious historical analysis. Thiel says that the Roaring 20s were the last period when it was possible for supporters of freedom like him to be optimistic about politics. "Since 1920, the vast increase in welfare beneficiaries and the extension of the franchise to women—two constituencies that are notoriously tough for libertarians—have rendered the notion of 'capitalist democracy' into an oxymoron," he writes.


This is similar to a point we make in the early lectures in 2301, but instead of "democracy" I we use "equality." Since democracy in based on political equality, we could probably use the terms synonymously. The story goes on ask some interesting questions about the role of government in these time. Perhaps you agree with the sentiment.

We will discuss.

Saturday, October 2, 2010

Washington Republicans Try to Maintain Cohesion

Neo-Conservative Republicans are rightly concerned about the possible impact Libertarian Conservatives might have on the cohesiveness of the party should the latter be elected in large number in November. Libertarians object to the aggressive use of American military power and want to cut the military as much as other spending areas. Marc Ambinger comments on neocon efforts to persuade the libertarians to support high levels of military spending.

Tuesday, August 31, 2010

Conservatives v Libertarians

For 2301s discussion of ideology, here are a couple of critiques a noted libertarian -- Brink Lindsey -- wrote regarding the current state of conservatism.

- Where do Libertarians Belong?
- Another Culture War? No Thanks.

Lindsey does not believe the Tea Party movement actually wants to reduce the size of government -- at least where it matters most: Middle Class Entitlement like Social Security and Medicare. Like the story on the Koch brothers below, his analysis offers a summary of recent political history.

Lindsey and was recently "purged" from the Cato Institute for, the rumor has it, aligning more with liberals than conservatives.