Saturday, July 13, 2013

Perceptions of poverty

I thought a segment of the article linked to in the previous post was worth a separate post. When the public thinks of the poor, does it have an accurate picture of who the poor really are? The authors of a study titled "How the Poor Became Black" trace how over time media coverage of poverty over time began to portray poverty increasingly as an African-American phenomenon, ignoring the fact that 2/3rds of those in poverty are not African-American.

This meant that when people - anglos anyway - thought about poverty, they thought of it in terms of race. This may have contributed to increased animosity towards the program.

The 1960s saw a rise in poverty and children born out of wedlock, particularly in urban communities. Sensational media stories about families "abusing" welfare -- especially when the putative abusers were portrayed as African-American -- helped cement opposition to public assistance. One study found that in the early 1970s, nearly three-quarters of magazine stories about welfare or poverty featured images of African-Americans, even though African Americans comprised only about a third of welfare recipients.

africanamericansmagazines.png "I do think that racial divisions are an important factor here -- the sense among many people that universal benefits will take from 'us' and give to 'them' -- to a part of society that is seen as different, less deserving, imagined as racially different," Cook, from Brown University, said. "I think that many middle-class Americans favor social benefits for what they see as 'deserving' people who have worked and earned them -- so Medicare is good -- but universal health care would provide benefits for people who are imagined as not deserving."

In a 1976 speech, Ronald Reagan made mention of supposed "welfare queens" who make six-figure salaries while drawing government funds, stoking a sense of outrage over perceived waste in public assistance. (It was later shown that he used an exaggerated anecdote). Arguing that social insurance dis-incentivized work, and prioritizing markets and individual liberty, the growing new conservative movement eventually joined together businesses and working-class voters in pushing for cuts in government programs.