Hopefully the links below provide some context for the current controversy over the farm bill. Agriculture policy of some sort has been a major component of national public policy since the early years of the republic - manifest destiny was in many ways an effort to provide farm land for the property-less folks out east who would also help settle the new territory.
Farm policy took a new form during the Great Depression beginning with the passage of the Agriculture Adjustment Act of 1933, but codified in related legislation in 1938 which contained a requirement that the bill be updated every five years. It also contained a provision that allowed for the creation of a nutrition program, which would later become food stamps - then SNAP.
What this means is that the farm bill contains two separate, though related items: subsidies for farmers, and food for the poor. This has created broad support for the bill over time, but has led to the current conflict. Republicans have pushed for limits on food stamps and removing them from the farm bill while retaining the subsidies. So the farm bill can be though of in the broader context of the New Deal, and the battle against it - or at least the part that created nutrition programs.
Here are some links with further historical information:
- Wikipedia: Agriculture policy of the United States, and History of Agriculture in the United States.
- Wikipedia: United States Farm Bill.
This provides a good, brief look at the history of these bills and a
list of the major agriculture legislation passed since the late 19th
Century.
- Infographic might provide the most efficient way to get an idea of the history of the farm bill.
- For - what seems to me to be - the most comprehensive list of farm bills and supporting information related to them dating back to 1935, click on the National Agriculture Law Center here.
- Snap to Health has FAQ's about the farm bill.
- NPR: The Farm Bill: From Charitable Start to Prime Budget Target. This provides a good look at the impact the farm bill has on agriculture policy in the US. Click here for similar detail.
- USDA National Agriculture Library: Farm Bill.
Saturday, July 13, 2013
Next year's midterm contests expected to cost around $3.5 billion
Required reading from the National Journal:

A decade after Sens. John McCain and Russ Feingold spearheaded sweeping legislation to reform the campaign-finance system, a series of judicial and legislative setbacks have derailed any hopes its original sponsors had of curbing the influence and amount of money spent on politics.
Instead, the incredible explosion of money in federal elections demonstrates that McCain-Feingold was a speed bump, at best, on the way to a dramatic growth curve that suggests next year's contests will cost nearly $3.5 billion.
All told, candidates running for a seat in the House of Representatives spent more than $923 million in 2012, while candidates running for Senate seats dished out $587 million, according to new data compiled for the new edition of Vital Statistics on Congress, a joint publication of the American Enterprise Institute and the Brookings Institution. That's more than eight times the amount House and Senate candidates spent in 1980. Senate candidates spent twice what they did a decade ago, in 2002.
Labels:
campaign finance,
Congress,
election 2014,
money in politics
Life expectancy in the US slips - comparatively
From the National Journal, which reports on a study released by the Institute for Health Metrics and Evaluation.
In absolute terms, life expectancy has increased, but we've slipped in comparative terms:
And life expectancy is uneven across the nation:
From a public policy perspective, the proper question is whether this report is likely to place life expectancy on the policy agenda. Given what we know about what factors drive items to the top of the agenda, this will happen only if life expectancy dips in areas of the country - and among constituencies - with political power. I have a hunch that is not the case.
In absolute terms, life expectancy has increased, but we've slipped in comparative terms:
Compared with the rest of the industrialized world (OECD countries), America is falling behind. "These improvements are much less than what countries of similar income per capita have seen," the report states. The U.S. now ranks 39th and 40th out of 187 countries for life expectancy for males and females respectively.
And life expectancy is uneven across the nation:
The United States isn't uniformly underperforming in life expectancy. The county with the highest life-expectancy in the U.S. for males is Fairfax County, Va., where males live 81.67 years. That's better than the life expectancy of Japan and Switzerland, which are atop the list for worldwide longevity.
This is the second troubling aspect of the report: There's a huge disparity between the country's highest- and lowest-performing areas. For men, the difference in longevity in the top and lowest counties is 17.77 years. For women, that number is 12.37 years. Progress in national longevity can be attributed to increases in the highest-performing counties (and mainly among men). "Many counties have made no progress," the report states, "or for the period 1993 to 2002, there have been declines for females in several hundred counties."
The life expectancy of the U.S.'s poorest-performing counties is similar to the mortality rates of some of the world's poorer nations.
From a public policy perspective, the proper question is whether this report is likely to place life expectancy on the policy agenda. Given what we know about what factors drive items to the top of the agenda, this will happen only if life expectancy dips in areas of the country - and among constituencies - with political power. I have a hunch that is not the case.
Labels:
agenda setting,
data,
health policy,
inequality,
US v the World
The Federal Agriculture Reform and Risk Management Act of 2013
One of this week's major political stories was the narrow passage in the House of a farm bill which retained farm subsidies, but cut funding for food stamps. The Senate will not pass a similar bill, nor will the president sign it, so it won't go anywhere. But it has led to a broad range of commentary you - 2305 students anyway - might find applicable to the class.
- House Committee on Agriculture, Farm Bill.
- CBO cost estimate of HR 2624.
- The vote on the bill.
- From Thomas: Bill summary and status.
Here's a sampling of stories about the bill, more to come:
- Background from the NYT:
- House Committee on Agriculture, Farm Bill.
- CBO cost estimate of HR 2624.
- The vote on the bill.
- From Thomas: Bill summary and status.
Here's a sampling of stories about the bill, more to come:
- Background from the NYT:
By splitting farm policy from food stamps, the House effectively ended the decades-old political marriage between urban interests concerned about nutrition and rural areas who depend on farm subsidies.
The assertive rank-and-file Republicans in the House, though, sank a bipartisan farm bill by amending it to cut $20 billion from food stamps over 10 years. This week, House leaders stripped food stamps from the bill altogether, stunning the farm lobby. With a lot of arm twisting and derisive commentary from Democrats, leaders squeezed a bill through the House 216-208 (with six Republicans and five Democrats not voting.) All the Democratic votes were no.
No one’s quite sure what happens next. House Ag Chairman Frank Lucas (R., Okla.) promised a separate food stamp bill as soon as he can achieve consensus. Mr. Lucas and House Speaker John Boehner (R., Ohio), who wants to enact a farm bill, probably will try to get some food stamp bill through the House so they can get to a Senate-House conference and return with a compromise that will draw enough Democratic votes to offset Republican rank-and-file opposition.
But the House vote underscored a fundamental political reality in the House: A substantial bloc of Republicans, many of them relative newcomers, are determined to force confrontations as they press for sweeping changes to the food stamp program and other federal benefit programs long cherished by Democrats as opposed to pressing hard and then settling for compromises that pull policy slightly to the right. (One aside: As both conservative and liberal think tanks observed this week, details of the farm bill suggest that House Republican vows to cut government spending exempt farm subsidies.)
- The Cato Institute is critical of the bill:
But in passing the farm bill, Republicans demonstrated that they are just fine with bloated welfare programs as long as those welfare payments go to well-healed special interests.
In 2011, the last year for which full data is available, the average farm household had an income of $87,289, 25 percent higher than the average for all U.S. households. And about a third of the farm subsidies go to the largest four percent of farm operators. If you want to see real “welfare queens,” look no further than Pilgrim’s Pride, Tyler Farms, and Riceland Foods.
Labels:
113th Congress,
bill making,
farm bill,
Interest Groups,
social welfare
Friday, July 12, 2013
“coming to Washington to do good and staying to do well”
I can't give a great deal of advice - based on my experience - to student interested in getting involved in politics or government, but you could do worse than find a job in DC and begin making contacts and a degree of expertise in a given field.
But mostly contacts.
If you are good at this you can cash in at some point. Here's a cynical take on the process based on a recently published book: This Town: Two Parties and a Funeral—Plus Plenty of Valet Parking!—in America’s Gilded Capital.
Looks like a fun read. Here's more on it:
- Is This Town right about Washington?
- The Preening Egos of This Town.
But mostly contacts.
If you are good at this you can cash in at some point. Here's a cynical take on the process based on a recently published book: This Town: Two Parties and a Funeral—Plus Plenty of Valet Parking!—in America’s Gilded Capital.
The larger message of This Town is the sad-eyed truth that, ultimately, everyone sells out. The money quote for Leibovich is former Senate Majority Leader Trent Lott’s honest explanation, “Washington is where the money is. That’s generally what keeps people here.” That comment meshes with my favorite aphorism about dewy-eyed young aides “coming to Washington to do good and staying to do well.”
Everyone’s convictions and contacts can be bought or, at least, rented. Leibovich quotes former AFL-CIO president John Sweeney calling former House Democratic leader Dick Gephardt “a powerful voice for working families.” But Leibovich archly notes that after giving up his House seat in 2005 to become a lobbyist, “Gephardt has become a powerful force for Dick Gephardt on issue after issue.” Ditto for former Connecticut Senator Chris Dodd who disdained the idea of lobbying until he was offered a $1.2 million job as the head of the Motion Picture Association. Then there’s Jeff Birnbaum who was an ace reporter for the Wall Street Journal and the Washington Post covering the lobbying beat until he became (wait for it) a high-priced lobbyist. As Leibovich puts it, “Birnbaum joining a lobbying firm was an extraordinary passage, akin to Bob Woodward joining a White House staff.”
. . .
The nation’s capital has always been a prized destination for young men and women with middle-aged dreams. If you pick the right friends and gamble on the right campaigns, you can find yourself with an exalted position on the White House staff in your late twenties or early thirties. As a former speechwriter for Jimmy Carter, I recall the heady master-of-the-West-Wing euphoria of being close to the person who is close to the person who is close to the Leader of the Free World.
That is why the most affecting and disturbing chapter in This Town is Leibovich’s portrayal of Kurt Bardella, a nakedly striving yet guileless 27-year-old press secretary to Darrell Issa, the Inspector Javert of the House Republicans. Bardella, who never graduated from college, is torn between two ambitions: White House press secretary someday (all that TV time) and quickly being able to “monetize his government service” (all that money). But before he can achieve either dream, Bardella is fired by Issa for leaking to Leibovich large chunks of the staffer’s daily emails from reporters and Capitol Hill Republicans. But this is Washington where only overly sensitive losers feel disgrace—within weeks Bardella was writing columns for the Daily Caller, negotiating with cable TV bookers and soon winning back a Capitol Hill job with Issa.
Looks like a fun read. Here's more on it:
- Is This Town right about Washington?
- The Preening Egos of This Town.
Partisan differences in attitudes about satisfaction with the federal government
The Gallup Poll released one of its periodic measures of how satisfied people are with the performance of the federal government along about 20 categories. They broke the results down by party identification and found an unsurprising result. Democratic identifiers are more satisfied with the federal government now than Republicans, but when the same questions were asked in 2005, the reverse was true.
The only real difference between now and then was the party membership of the president.
This confirms a point many make about party identification, it provides a lense through which people make evaluations about questions regarding things like the performance of governing institutions. When a Republican is president, Republican outlets say nice and positive things which are accepted by Republican identifiers while they ignore contrary messages by Democratic outlets. And the opposite is true when a Democrat is in the White House.
Here are two tables with Gallup's data. Note the differences between the two as well as the places where there has been a complete flip in attitudes about performance. Has policy really changed that much in each of these policy arenas to justify the shift?
From 2013:

From 2005:

The only real difference between now and then was the party membership of the president.
This confirms a point many make about party identification, it provides a lense through which people make evaluations about questions regarding things like the performance of governing institutions. When a Republican is president, Republican outlets say nice and positive things which are accepted by Republican identifiers while they ignore contrary messages by Democratic outlets. And the opposite is true when a Democrat is in the White House.
Here are two tables with Gallup's data. Note the differences between the two as well as the places where there has been a complete flip in attitudes about performance. Has policy really changed that much in each of these policy arenas to justify the shift?
From 2013:

From 2005:

Cities v Walmart
A battle in DC over how much Walmart must pay its workers in order to open stores in the city led this author to look at similar conflicts between Walmart and other cities. Who has leverage? The retailer or the cities?
- Click here for detail on the controversy.
Walmart has done a good job getting subsidies - public money - from cities to build. Walmart Subsidy Watch has background on all of it.
They report 29 deals in Texas which provided $90.8 million in funding.
- Click here for detail on the controversy.
Walmart has done a good job getting subsidies - public money - from cities to build. Walmart Subsidy Watch has background on all of it.
They report 29 deals in Texas which provided $90.8 million in funding.
The demographic consequences of gerrymandering
Here's visual evidence that gerrymandering has led to substantive differences in the racial composition of Democratic and Republican congressional districts. The typical Democratic district has twice as many Hispanics, Blacks and Asians and about 1/3rd fewer Whites. This helps explain what drives differences between the parties in the House of Representatives. They represent substantively "slices of the country."
What's more, the votes they cast are subject to review by primary voters in their districts. Since primary voters are more extreme ideologically than general elections voters, representatives must placate those voters if they want to stay in office. The Dish argues that this points out that gerrymandering incentivises members of Congress to polarize.
What's more, the votes they cast are subject to review by primary voters in their districts. Since primary voters are more extreme ideologically than general elections voters, representatives must placate those voters if they want to stay in office. The Dish argues that this points out that gerrymandering incentivises members of Congress to polarize.
Written Assignment #6 - GOVT 2306 - 11 week online class only
The big news from Texas this past week is that Rick Perry has opted not to be governor for life. He will not run again in 2014, which has fueled speculation that he might run for the presidency in 2016, as well as who will replace him.
In his 12 years as governor he seems to have transformed what had been a weak office into one with real power. The traditional story told in Texas politics is that real power lies with the Lieutenant Governor, mostly because of the control that office has over the Texas Senate. But few people would argue that Lieutenant Governor Dewhurst is more powerful than Governor Perry.
I want you to address whether in fact Governor Perry has strengthened the governor's office, and if so, how. What are the factors that make the Texas governor powerful? What factors limit it? Be sure to address whether Perry's strength is mostly due to his longevity in office.
Use this post below as a starting point, but do your own research to answer the question.
150 words at a minimum - thanks.
In his 12 years as governor he seems to have transformed what had been a weak office into one with real power. The traditional story told in Texas politics is that real power lies with the Lieutenant Governor, mostly because of the control that office has over the Texas Senate. But few people would argue that Lieutenant Governor Dewhurst is more powerful than Governor Perry.
I want you to address whether in fact Governor Perry has strengthened the governor's office, and if so, how. What are the factors that make the Texas governor powerful? What factors limit it? Be sure to address whether Perry's strength is mostly due to his longevity in office.
Use this post below as a starting point, but do your own research to answer the question.
150 words at a minimum - thanks.
Written Assignment #6 - GOVT 2305 - 11 week online class only
The use of the filibuster in the US Senate has increased greatly over the past few years, so much so that critics wonder whether it does more harm than good. Normally filibusters have been used sparingly by a minority in the Senate to stop bill they find objectionable, but more recently it has been used to place broad limits on the ability of government to operate at all. For example, executive and judicial positions remain unstaffed because Senate Republicans have enough votes to prevent the votes from getting to the Senate floor.
Senate Democrats are considering whether to change the rules that allow filibusters to happen - there is nothing in the Constitution about filibusters. They happen because of the process that evolved in the Senate over time. but these processes can be changed. That doesn't means its a good idea to do so, or that the change might not have consequences.
I want you to read up on this controversy and weigh in on it. What would the consequences of filibuster reform be on the the Senate? Is reform a good or bad idea?
150 words at a minimum.
Some links:
- Wikipedia: Filibuster in the US Senate.
- An Accident of History?
- US Senate: Filibuster and Cloture.
- Wikipedia: Rule XXII.
- Save the filibuster, Harry Reid.
- Democrats poised to limit filibusters, angering GOP.
Senate Democrats are considering whether to change the rules that allow filibusters to happen - there is nothing in the Constitution about filibusters. They happen because of the process that evolved in the Senate over time. but these processes can be changed. That doesn't means its a good idea to do so, or that the change might not have consequences.
I want you to read up on this controversy and weigh in on it. What would the consequences of filibuster reform be on the the Senate? Is reform a good or bad idea?
150 words at a minimum.
Some links:
- Wikipedia: Filibuster in the US Senate.
- An Accident of History?
- US Senate: Filibuster and Cloture.
- Wikipedia: Rule XXII.
- Save the filibuster, Harry Reid.
- Democrats poised to limit filibusters, angering GOP.
Thursday, July 11, 2013
From The Fiscal Times: The Outrageous Cost of Getting Elected to Congress
The Fiscal Times highlights findings from Vital Statistics on Congress related to the costs of running for office - among other things.
$1.3 million: Average spent by 256 incumbents among 2012 winners who won re-election in safe districts (where they won with 60 percent of the vote or more)
$156,000: Amount spent by their long-shot challengers, on average
$2.3 million: Average spending by 100 swing-state incumbents in 2012 who held onto their seats with less than 60 percent of the vote
$93,000: Amount spent by their challengers' campaigns, on average
103: House members from "swing" districts in 1992 (defined as districts where the presidential race was within five percentage points of the national result)
35: House members from "swing" districts in 2012 (the most prominent reason for the change is post-Census redistricting, which governing parties have used to draw lines favoring their side)
$1.3 million: Average spent by 256 incumbents among 2012 winners who won re-election in safe districts (where they won with 60 percent of the vote or more)
$156,000: Amount spent by their long-shot challengers, on average
$2.3 million: Average spending by 100 swing-state incumbents in 2012 who held onto their seats with less than 60 percent of the vote
$93,000: Amount spent by their challengers' campaigns, on average
103: House members from "swing" districts in 1992 (defined as districts where the presidential race was within five percentage points of the national result)
35: House members from "swing" districts in 2012 (the most prominent reason for the change is post-Census redistricting, which governing parties have used to draw lines favoring their side)
From the Brookings Institute: Vital Statistics on Congress
The latest edition of an ongoing project. I'm tempted to create a separate section in class just on this material.
Can Democrats rebuild a state party in Texas?
This question has been asked a lot recently since some national and state party leaders see opportunity. They haven't since 1994, but demographic changes may make open things up.
Here are the latest thoughts on the future:
After two decades, the permanent party organization has withered and needs to be rebuilt, which takes time.
Here are the latest thoughts on the future:
It has been nearly two decades since a Democrat was elected to statewide office and nearly 40 since the party carried Texas in a presidential race; White House hopefuls stopped trying to win here a long time ago.
But after a generation's worth of Democratic failure, many are convinced the state is on the cusp of competitiveness, thanks to the rapid growth of Texas' minority population, especially Latinos, and a slow rebuilding of the party from the ground level — city, county, legislative offices — up.
"It's inevitable," said Matt Angle, a Democratic consultant whose Lone Star Project has chipped away at Republican dominance over the last several elections. "But only with a lot of hard work."
Among those drawn by the prospect are some of the data-driven strategists of President Obama's campaigns, whose targeting and mobilization boosted black and Latino turnout and twice helped win such battlegrounds as Ohio, Virginia, Colorado and Nevada. They have dispatched field teams throughout the state, hoping to apply their organizing techniques to Texas, where millions of eligible minority voters have either failed to register or haven't bothered voting.
After two decades, the permanent party organization has withered and needs to be rebuilt, which takes time.
. . . one of the higher hurdles facing Democrats in Texas [is] the lack of viable statewide candidates. When Gov. Rick Perry said Monday he would not run again in 2014, the odds-on favorite to replace him, Republican Atty. Gen. Greg Abbott, already had more than $18 million in the bank. Democrats, meantime, are struggling to find a single plausible contender.
Building a campaign infrastructure, something Texas Democrats sorely lack, is vital. But "you also need to create some organic reason for people to want to vote for you and identify with you," said James Henson, who directs the Texas Politics Project at the University of Texas in Austin. That, he and others suggested, requires a compelling — or at least viable — slate of statewide candidates.
Democrats talk up the prospects of San Antonio's mayor, 38-year-old Julian Castro, and his twin brother, Joaquin, a congressman from the city. Neither, however, is expected to run for higher office any time soon.
Davis, 50, was touted as a possible gubernatorial candidate even before her attention-grabbing filibuster, which blocked — at least temporarily — Republican passage of sweeping antiabortion legislation. But although the Fort Worth Democrat has expressed a desire to run statewide, she also knows of the challenges she would face in 2014.
State Rep. Trey Martinez Fischer, a San Antonio lawmaker and head of the Mexican American Legislative Caucus, said Democrats were wise to rebuild their party from the bottom up, rather than counting on a candidate to do it from the top down. That's been tried, he said, "and when the campaign folded, so did the computer that had all the data."
From Pro-Publica: Redistricting, a Devil’s Dictionary
A great look at the gory details of gerrymandering. Complete with examples.
The article's subtitle says it all:
Redistricting: How Powerful Interests Are Drawing You Out of a Vote
The article's subtitle says it all:
Redistricting: How Powerful Interests Are Drawing You Out of a Vote
Is the South - state legislatures specifically - resegregating?
Here is an argument that is has.
The percentage of black legislators in positions of power in southern state legislatures is the lowest it has been since the passage of the Voting Rights Act. The ability to draw legislative districts has been a key instrument in accomplishing this.
Here's a take on the strategy:
The percentage of black legislators in positions of power in southern state legislatures is the lowest it has been since the passage of the Voting Rights Act. The ability to draw legislative districts has been a key instrument in accomplishing this.
Here's a take on the strategy:
Republicans in control of redistricting have two goals: the defeat of white Democrats, and the creation of safe districts for Republicans. They have achieved both of these goals by increasing the number of districts likely to elect an African-American. Black voters are gerrymandered out of districts represented by whites of both parties, making the Democratic incumbent weaker and the Republican incumbent stronger.
Take Mississippi. In the state’s 2012 redistricting, all of the decisively black legislative districts – where 60 percent or more of the voters are African-American – have been preserved, and four new majority-black districts have been created. This, in turn, has allowed Republicans to reduce the percentage of blacks in districts where Republican incumbents had close contests in Mississippi’s 2011 off-year elections.
While increasing the number of blacks elected to state legislatures, Republicans have been effectively implementing their long-range goal of decimating the number of white Democrats. Depending on local demographics, this has been achieved in two ways.
Where possible, Republican redistricting strategists have reduced the number of blacks in white Democratic legislative districts in order to render the incumbent vulnerable to Republican challenge. In other areas of the state, where it has not been not possible to “bleach” a district, Republicans have sharply increased the percentage of blacks to over 50 percent in order to encourage a successful black challenge to the white Democratic incumbent.
In private discussions, Republicans in the South talk explicitly about their goal of turning the Democratic Party into a black party, and in many Southern states they have succeeded. African-American legislators make up the majority of state House and Senate Democratic caucuses in most of the Southern states.
The growing Hispanic population in Texas
Click here for Texas Tribunes' interactive graphic displaying the greater number of Hispanics aged 0-4 than the rest of the population. This provides visual confirmation of looming changes in party competition in the state.
The understaffed federal judiciary in a handful of charts
This is one of the factors driving possible filibuster reform.
From WonkBlog, some charts detailing the factors leading to an understaffed - and possibly weakened - federal judiciary.
One of the featured charts:
From WonkBlog, some charts detailing the factors leading to an understaffed - and possibly weakened - federal judiciary.
One of the featured charts:
From Bruce Ackerman: To Save Egypt, Drop the Presidency
I probably don't spend enough time in class pointing out the difference between presidential and parliamentary governing systems - I usually only refer to them when we talk about the winner take all elections systems we hold versus the proportional representational systems common to parliamentary elections.
But most democracies are parliamentary, not presidential. Proponents of the former argue that they are better suited to include all the various interests in a society.
A Yale Law professor argues that makes it better suited to Egypt:
But most democracies are parliamentary, not presidential. Proponents of the former argue that they are better suited to include all the various interests in a society.
A Yale Law professor argues that makes it better suited to Egypt:
AS violence escalates, Egypt’s military is trying to bridge a widening political gap by promising a rapid return to civilian rule. But its gesture of accommodation does not get to the heart of the problem: the presidential system, inherited from the Mubarak era, virtually guarantees a repetition of the tragic events of the past year. A democratic breakthrough requires a more fundamental constitutional redesign, in which the contending sides compete for power in a European-style parliamentary system.
If Egypt had made that switch in the interim Constitution adopted two years ago, or in the revisions that Mohamed Morsi, as president, rammed through last year, it could well have avoided the current upheaval and bloodshed in the first place.The presidency is a winner-take-all office. This may be acceptable in countries like the United States, where well-organized parties contend for the prize. But it is a recipe for tyranny in places like Egypt, where Islamists have powerful organizational advantages in delivering the vote.Because their opponents will have great difficulties uniting behind a single candidate, Islamists could probably parlay their strong minority support into another presidential victory. To prevent that result, it is predictable that the military will suppress the political efforts of the Muslim Brotherhood and similar groups — transforming the next election into a democratic farce. The next president would not only emerge with an illegitimate mandate. His victory would convert the Islamists into undying opponents of the regime.Only a parliamentary system provides a realistic path to a more stable, inclusive future. Even if Islamist parties won a substantial share of the vote, they would not be able to monopolize power.
Tuesday, July 9, 2013
Mark Jones: Red State, Purple Legislation
The Rice professor explains how a cohesive Democratic Party in the Texas Legislature has been able to force concessions on legislation which has denied more conservative Republicans the opportunity to dominate the legislative process. They did better this spring than they did in the November 2012 elections.
There were enough moderate Republicans that had more in common with Democrats then their more conservative party members to win votes. This graph shows the "win rate" for members of the House. Democrats doid better than conservative winds of the Republican Party.

In the state Capitol’s west wing, House Democrats brokered a tacit alliance with the GOP’s moderate/centrist conservative bloc, led by Speaker Joe Straus, R-San Antonio. Liberal-Conservative Scores were calculated for legislators using their regular session roll call vote behavior (final 2013 House and Senate ideological scores and rankings will be published following the end of this summer’s special session or sessions). These scores indicate that virtually all of the most prominent Republicans on the speaker’s leadership team either were located in the GOP’s moderate conservative wing (i.e., representatives with Lib-Con Scores significantly less conservative than those of more than one-half of their Republican colleagues) or, and less commonly, in its centrist conservative wing (i.e., representatives with Lib-Con Scores neither significantly more conservative or less conservative than over one-half of their fellow Republicans).
This alliance allowed a relatively cohesive and disciplined Democratic delegation to block the passage of most legislation opposed by its members. In a similar vein, the moderate conservative Republicans prevented the passage of almost all legislation they objected to either on pure policy grounds and/or because they believed it would damage the Texas GOP brand and in doing so undermine their long-term goal of maintaining the party’s grip on power in the state. Finally, this informal alliance pushed through bills that addressed several, though certainly not all, of these legislators’ most pressing policy concerns in areas ranging from public education to water infrastructure.
There were enough moderate Republicans that had more in common with Democrats then their more conservative party members to win votes. This graph shows the "win rate" for members of the House. Democrats doid better than conservative winds of the Republican Party.

The figures reveal the informal alliance that existed during the regular session between Democrats and the moderate conservative and, to a somewhat lesser extent, centrist conservative wings of the Republican Party. This alliance produced predominantly purple legislation that was frequently opposed by the House and Senate’s more conservative Republicans. The end result was legislation that on average was closer to the policy preferences of the median Texas voter than to those of the median Texas Republican Party primary voter, an outcome viewed as positive by a majority of the 181 legislators, the editorial boards of the state’s leading newspapers and the Austin lobby, but perhaps not by a majority of the 1 to 1.5 million Texans who regularly participate in the GOP primaries.
Ross Ramsey: A Weak Governor System, With a Strong Governor
The Texas Tribune writer points out that longevity and the cultivation of loyalists that he has placed throughout state government has given Perry far more power than is typical in the office. Its unlikely his successor will enjoy the same clout he developed, but he transformed the office while he held it:
Before Perry, half the stories about the doings in the state Capitol were either about the inherent weakness of the governor’s office or the ancient lore about how the lieutenant governor holds the state’s most powerful office.
The governor has no cabinet. He or she can appoint the people who populate the various boards and commissions, but only a third of them come up for appointment every two years, and the governor doesn’t have direct control over them once they’ve been posted. They can’t be fired — they can be made pretty uncomfortable, but that takes a lot of work — and they often behave as if they have their own brains and their own goals and ways of doing things.
That means that most of the people who head the executive branch of Texas government have never had full control over it. Other elected officials head some of the major agencies, and a powerful legislative branch can, with strong personalities in charge, control the agencies to some extent by controlling their budgets.
. . . After six years of Perry being in the governor’s office, virtually every appointee had him to thank for their post. And over his first decade in office, the governor seeded the executive branch with his former aides and their like-minded peers. They’re all over the place, with titles like executive director, general counsel, communications director and so on.
. . . Perry’s transformation of the office might be permanent. The agencies might naturally turn their ears to a governor for guidance after all these years out of habit.
It will take six years to replace all the appointees who owe their jobs to Perry, a third of the jobs turning over every two years. The people at the tops of all of those agency organization charts will linger until retirement — Perry’s legacy —and while they may be helpful to a new governor, they will not be indebted like they are to the old boss.
. . . Perry, because of his tenure and the methodical placement of former staffers throughout the government, changed all that, turning a weak office into a powerful one. It’s hard to remember how it used to be.
14 is enough - Perry will not run for re-election
The Texas Tribune reports:
Gov. Rick Perry announced Monday that he will not run for re-election next year, creating the first open race for Texas governor since 1990 and making Attorney General Greg Abbott the instant favorite to replace him.
"I remain excited about the future and the challenges ahead, but the time has come to pass on the mantle of leadership," Perry said. "Today I am announcing I will not seek re-election as governor of Texas. I will spend the next 18 months working to create more jobs, opportunity and innovation. I will actively lead this great state."
. . . Perry made Monday’s announcement at Holt Cat, one of the largest Caterpillar equipment dealers in the United States. The CEO of the company, Peter Holt, owns the San Antonio Spurs basketball team and is a major donor (nearly $600,000 since 2000) to Perry. He’s given $95,000 to Abbott since 2002, records show.
A huge throng of media was on hand for the announcement. Perry kept a tight grip on his plans, ratcheting up the speculation to a feverish pitch. Reporters were left guessing and parsing the words sent out in a “save the date” email that indicated he would reveal some “exciting future plans.”
Perry has 18 months left in his current term, so he’ll still have a huge political megaphone, appointment power and the ability to call a 30-day special session on any topic at any time. No one watching politics in Texas will be surprised if Perry makes full use of his authority and then some during his remaining time in office.
. . . Perry, who will have been in office for more than 14 years when he departs in January 2015, leaves behind a long and colorful legacy at the helm of state government and the GOP political establishment. A former Texas House member and state agriculture commissioner, Perry was elected lieutenant governor in 1998. He became governor on Dec. 21, 2000, when George W. Bush resigned to become president. Perry is now the longest continuously serving governor in the United States and the longest-serving governor in Texas history by far.
Sunday, July 7, 2013
Written Assignment #5 - GOVT 2306 - 11 week online class only
Texas Republicans apparently are a bit upset with how Lieutenant Governor David Dewhurst has been doing his job. Many argue that he was responsible for the sucessful filibuster against the abortion bill that led to the need to call a second special session.
The Texas Tribune reports that area Senator Dan Patrick will run against Dewhurst for Lieutenant Governor in 2014 partly due tto his ineffectiveness in the office.
For this week's assignment I want you to research the precise criticisms made of Dewhurst's performance. Why is he argued to be an ineffective Lieutenant Governor? Might he be damaging the office?
The Texas Tribune reports that area Senator Dan Patrick will run against Dewhurst for Lieutenant Governor in 2014 partly due tto his ineffectiveness in the office.
For this week's assignment I want you to research the precise criticisms made of Dewhurst's performance. Why is he argued to be an ineffective Lieutenant Governor? Might he be damaging the office?
Written Assignment #5 - GOVT 2305 - 11 week online class only
So Egypt seems to have trouble sticking to its constitution. After recently electing a president for the first time in its history, he was deposed with the apparent help of the army, which has also replaced him.
Despite the fact that the constitutional order was clearly violated, there are those that support what was done because the previous president - it was feared - intended to prevent a democratic system from evolving at all and perhaps send Egypt down the road to becoming an Islamic Republic. The constitution had to be violated in order to preserve the constitution - so to speak.
I want you to read through the facts and commentary about what's going on and comment on it. Specically I want to you to give me your thoughts on this question: Was the ousting of the Egyptian president the right thing to do? Why or why not?
Despite the fact that the constitutional order was clearly violated, there are those that support what was done because the previous president - it was feared - intended to prevent a democratic system from evolving at all and perhaps send Egypt down the road to becoming an Islamic Republic. The constitution had to be violated in order to preserve the constitution - so to speak.
I want you to read through the facts and commentary about what's going on and comment on it. Specically I want to you to give me your thoughts on this question: Was the ousting of the Egyptian president the right thing to do? Why or why not?
Wednesday, July 3, 2013
Review for the Summer One 2013 Final
Summer One finals are in class on Tuesday, July 9.
Bring a Scantron and a #2 pencil, and be prepared to answer 100 multiple choice questions.
Some hints for the review can be found here:
- GOVT 2305
- GOVT 2306
Remember to review the assessment question carefully, and to send in you papers through Blackboard.
Bring a Scantron and a #2 pencil, and be prepared to answer 100 multiple choice questions.
Some hints for the review can be found here:
- GOVT 2305
- GOVT 2306
Remember to review the assessment question carefully, and to send in you papers through Blackboard.
Monday, July 1, 2013
Written Assignment #5 - GOVT 2306 - 11 week online class only
As you probably know, the first special session of the 83rd legislature ended with a dramatic filibuster.
Now the whole process starts again in the session starting today.
I want you to use this to get familiar with the actual bill making process in the state. Click to here to get specific information about the steps SB 5 took through the legislature. Condense these steps into a quick summary. Try to get into the steps used to both prolong and stop the filibuster.
Its a good look at Texas politics.
Now the whole process starts again in the session starting today.
I want you to use this to get familiar with the actual bill making process in the state. Click to here to get specific information about the steps SB 5 took through the legislature. Condense these steps into a quick summary. Try to get into the steps used to both prolong and stop the filibuster.
Its a good look at Texas politics.
Written Assignment #5 - GOVT 2305 - 11 week online class only
Last week the Supreme Court struck down Section 4 - but not Section 5 - of the Voting Rights Act. This means that while pre-clearance is OK, the map used to determine which states and local jurisdictions are subject to pre-clearance is not.
It also means that Congress has to redo the map, if there is to be any federal oversight of state election laws. Here's where things get tricky. No new map, no more pre-clearance, and not everyone in Congress has an incentive to redo the map. Some do however, and many members of Congress have promised to support a revised map.
I want you to write about the likelihood that this Congress, as dysfunctional as it is, can create a new map replacing the one used since the 1960s to guide the preclearance process.
Give at least at least 150 words - as you know
It also means that Congress has to redo the map, if there is to be any federal oversight of state election laws. Here's where things get tricky. No new map, no more pre-clearance, and not everyone in Congress has an incentive to redo the map. Some do however, and many members of Congress have promised to support a revised map.
I want you to write about the likelihood that this Congress, as dysfunctional as it is, can create a new map replacing the one used since the 1960s to guide the preclearance process.
Give at least at least 150 words - as you know
Sunday, June 30, 2013
A reminder: Yes Week 4's written assignment was cancelled
I had the notice up on blackboard, but just in case you didn't see it ....
Friday, June 28, 2013
Will voter suppression tactics return now that the VRA has been weakened?
Here's a concern that they will.
It comes with a complied list of 12 tactics used in the past. A nice history review for our purposes.
It comes with a complied list of 12 tactics used in the past. A nice history review for our purposes.
1. Changing polling locations. An election official can make this call just days before an election.
2. Changing polling hours or eliminating early voting days. This may be particularly problematic in urban counties where long polling lines are most likely, as Henry Grabar reported last fall.
3. Reducing the number of polling places. This raises the same problem as above, particularly when the eliminated polling places had disproportionately served minority communities.
4. At-large elections. At-large elections for school-board members or city councils often dilute the voting power of minorities who have greater influence in single-candidate district elections. In an at-large election, a cohesive voting block with 51 percent of the vote can elect 100 percent of the officials.
5. Packing majority-minority districts. Election maps drawn to push all of a community's minorities in one or a handful of districts can dilute their voting power.
6. Dividing minority districts. Similarly, election maps can slice minority communities into multiple districts so that they have no cumulative influence in any one place. The line between these two tactics is a fine one (and also illustrates why the VRA was useful for assessing facts on the ground).
7. Voter ID laws: This increasingly popular tactic, sometimes likened to a modern-day poll tax, has the potential to disenfranchise voters who don't have a driver's license, or who don't have the money or ability to obtain one (a disproportionate share of these people are minorities). Such laws can also have a disproportionate impact in cities, where many people don't own cars.
8. Onerous candidate qualifications. In 2007, a Texas provision tried to limit those people eligible to become water district supervisors to landowners who were registered to vote.
9. Changing multi-lingual voter assistance. Making it harder for non-English language speakers to vote is a good way to dilute their power.
10. Changing election dates. Another trick that may not require legislative approval.
11. Creating new elections. In 2006, the DOJ objected to a plan in the Houston area that would have eliminated some joint elections and required voters to travel to multiple polling places.
12. Canceling elections. We're not even really sure how Kilmichael, Mississippi, thought they could get away with this.
Thursday, June 27, 2013
Is the Republican Party broken?
Next week we will start discussing political parties in both 2305 and 2306. Conventional wisdom has held for a while that the Republican Party needs major adjustments in order to become competitive again. Its important to not that as recently as 2004 the same things were said about the Democratic Party, so things can change quickly.
Here's an article from March suggesting that this story may be inaccurate.
Its contains a little insight about public opinion that'll be worth talking about next week. Public opinion tends to move away from the position of the party in power:

Here's an article from March suggesting that this story may be inaccurate.
Its contains a little insight about public opinion that'll be worth talking about next week. Public opinion tends to move away from the position of the party in power:
Voters serve as “thermostats” for public policy. They move in the opposite direction as the party controlling the White House—to the left under Republican administrations and to the right under Democratic administrations. It is as if when the government does too much, or is “too hot,” the public says “cool it.” And when the government does too little, or is “too cold,” the public says “turn up the heat in here.”
So after Obama was elected in 2008, thermostatic public opinion soon moved against him. See the graph below, which uses an omnibus measure of the public’s support for government programs that was created by political scientist James Stimson from hundreds of different survey questions. In this graph, the absolute numbers are arbitrary; by itself, “50” doesn’t mean anything. The key is how the numbers shift over time.

Under Reagan, the public became more liberal, in contrast to the prevailing view that Reagan’s skills as a communicator made the public more conservative. During the Obama administration, as during the Clinton administration, there has been another shift to the right. Far from ushering in a liberal majority, the Obama administration has presided over a shift among Americans toward preferring less government, not more government. Obama has helped to increase the overall conservatism of the American public more than Reagan ever did, ironically enough.
From Wonkblog: Obamacare starts in 100 days
A little less actually since this was posted on June 23rd, its set to start up October 1st:

There are, arguably, two big things that need to happen between now and October. The first is technical:
The federal government needs to finish building the infrastructure that allows multiple government agencies to transmit information, determining whether an individual should qualify for tax subsidies. This is a really big lift that means connecting Health and Human Services, Treasury, Homeland Security and other agencies in a way that has never really happened before.
Also in the technical arena, the federal government needs to finish building the federal exchange, an online portal that most states will have their residents use to purchase health insurance. Fifteen states are also in the midst of putting finishing touches on the insurance markets they opted to run.
“It’s a compressed time frame,” says Kevin Walsh, a top executive at Xerox, who has worked extensively on Nevada’s health insurance exchange. “We are working diligently to implement the entire scope of work for October 1. So, you back up from there. It means we have to have all our enhancements done in mid-July, so we can do the integration testing.”
A few months ago, Walsh gave me one of my favorite charts on the health insurance exchanges, which explains why this technology piece is such a big lift for state and federal governments.

From outreach to eligibility determinations to bringing health plans into the marketplace, all of that needs to be ready by Oct. 1.
There’s one other task on the Obama administration’s plate just as big as technological work, and that’s outreach. Even if the technological launch goes off without a hitch, that won’t be much good if no shoppers show up to the marketplace.
To that end, non-profit Enroll America last week launched its education and enrollment campaign. The group started shortly after health reform became law. And their goal is, come October, making it impossible for an uninsured person not to know that there are new options available.
“If I’m uninsured and it’s October, I won’t be able to go anywhere without escaping a message,” John Gilbert, who leads Enroll America’s field operations, told supporters in a Thursday night presentation. “I turn on my TV and there’s an ad. I go on the Internet and there’s another ad. Someone shows up at my door to talk about it. I go to church and my pastor is talking about it.”
From the Monkey Cage: Crowd-Filibustering in the Texas Senate
Its also being called the citizen filibuster. A handful of actors both inside and outside the Texas Senate worked together to defeat SB5 - at least temporarily.
One of the authors at The Monkey Cage walks through several aspects of the filibuster. I'd consider this essential reading for my students since it reminds us of the reality of how political power is exercised.
One of the authors at The Monkey Cage walks through several aspects of the filibuster. I'd consider this essential reading for my students since it reminds us of the reality of how political power is exercised.
Labels:
filibusters,
social media,
Texas bill making,
Texas Senate
Did Dewhurst screw up?
Accusations are flying that the Lieutenant Governor's mismanagement of the special session set the stage for Davis' filibuster. Dewhurst's political future may have evaporated. We've been reading about Allen Shivers and how he made the Lieutenant Governor a powerful position. I wonder if history will look at Dewhurst as being responsible for undermining it.
Great detail from Ross Ramsey:
Great detail from Ross Ramsey:
When the special session began (and, to be fair, before abortion was on the agenda), Dewhurst took a long-planned trip to France. That had to do with the dedication of a D-Day museum, a project that involves some family history for Dewhurst, whose father was on a bomber crew. Most lawmakers gave him a pass, even if they rolled their eyes at the same time.
When it came time for Dewhurst to give someone a pass, it was the last day of the session, and he decided that the most important issue on his plate was more important than the funeral of the father of Sen. Leticia Van de Putte, D-San Antonio. It’s true that the funeral was held on the last day of a special session with several bills still in play.
But it’s also true that the first bill in line — because Dewhurst put it there — was the abortion bill. He and everybody else knew there would be a filibuster and that it might imperil other legislation on tap.
He might have asked senators to vote out the other bills, gone to the funeral and let Davis have a short filibuster on Tuesday night. That would have completed the other business, taken some of the spotlight away from Davis and set up a story for Republicans coming back in another special session to get their work done in a way the Democrats couldn’t block.
Or he could have used the rules to cut off the filibuster, which turned out to be the strategy he pursued. He assured the governor and House leaders that the abortion legislation would pass on Tuesday. But the day slipped away from him.
Senators are allowed to talk as long as they want, and when they do that in a strategic way — to delay a vote, for instance — it’s a filibuster. Those can be stopped if the senator doing the talking breaks the rules of the filibuster, yielding the floor to another senator, sitting or leaning on furniture, or going off subject. It’s a three-strikes-you’re-out rule, and Senate Republicans decided that was the way to go.
Instead of the customary empty chamber where one senator filibusters and friendly colleagues take shifts asking questions to pass the time, senators stuck around for Davis’ debate, watching for mistakes. They eventually found three that Dewhurst would sustain, and the filibuster came to a halt. But it was late and his rulings were questionable — to some of the senators and most of the spectators — and a challenge pushed Dewhurst out of the chair.
The parliamentary wrangling and the protesters ate up the rest of the time, and when Sen. Robert Duncan, R-Lubbock, finally called a vote on the abortion bill, it turned out that the midnight deadline had passed.
Republicans had the votes they needed, and the conversations about whether and when to come back and try again started right away on Wednesday morning.|
They might be able to put the bill back together, but Dewhurst’s fortunes are another issue. In his attempt at a political revival, he flopped on stage with everyone watching.
From the Texas Tribune: Rick Perry Calls Second Special Session
No big surprise after the recent successful filibuster:
Hours after Democrats won a rare victory by blocking a restrictive abortion bill, Republican Gov. Rick Perry called a second special session to take up the issue again.
Perry also put transportation funding and a juvenile justice measure on the agenda for the session, which is set to begin July 1.
“I am calling the Legislature back into session because too much important work remains undone for the people of Texas. Through their duly elected representatives, the citizens of our state have made crystal clear their priorities for our great state," Perry said. "Texans value life and want to protect women and the unborn. Texans want a transportation system that keeps them moving. Texans want a court system that is fair and just. We will not allow the breakdown of decorum and decency to prevent us from doing what the people of this state hired us to do."The governor had been almost universally urged by conservative grassroots activists and Republican lawmakers to call a new session after Democrats, with the help of boisterous activists in the Senate gallery, killed abortion restrictions in the final seconds of the first special session, which ended in chaos Tuesday night.
What's not immediately clear is if Perry will make good on his vow earlier to make a decision about his own political future by July 1. Now that there's a new session about to start, he might choose to delay an announcement so that he won't be considered a lame duck while legislation is being debated.
Wednesday, June 26, 2013
From the Texas Tribune: DPS to Offer Free Voter ID Cards
From the story:
Following the U.S. Supreme Court’s decision on Tuesday that paves the way for implementation of Texas’ voter ID law, the Texas Department of Public Safety announced it will begin processing applications for free voter ID cards this week.
On Wednesday, the department will begin issuing so-called election identification certificates for qualified voters. Offering the certificates is required by Senate Bill 14, a measure that passed in 2011 but was on hold until Tuesday's decision.
The IDs are free and will be available to voters who do not yet have a viable form of ID, such as a driver’s license, a concealed handgun license, a passport or military ID. Applicants must go to a DPS driver’s license office to apply and show proof of citizenship. The IDs can only be used to vote, and are not acceptable forms of personal identification for other purposes.
To qualify, applicants must be U.S. citizens and Texas residents and be eligible to vote in Texas. They must prove it by showing a valid voter registration card or submitting a voter registration application when applying for the card. Most documents will be valid for six years, though they do not expire for citizens 70 or older.
An accepted list of documents that prove citizenship can be found here, and proof of identity documents can be found here.
Has Windsor established a standard of review for sexual orientation under the equal protection clause?
We discussed this in class, and couldn't find any clear language to that effect in the decision.
Nothing like "strict scrutiny" or "rational basis review" stuck out.
Here are a couple takes on that question.
Jack Balkin:
Ilya Solim:
Nothing like "strict scrutiny" or "rational basis review" stuck out.
Here are a couple takes on that question.
Jack Balkin:
Windsor is a reminder of the fact that the scrutiny rules we teach our students as gospel are a relatively recent invention--less than fifty years old. They were designed to make it easier to think about when laws are constitutionally unequal. But sometimes they don't really assist our understanding of the issues; they just get in the way. In fact, you actually can explain Windsor in terms of the existing structure-- it's a "rational basis with a bite" case, and that's how the casebooks (including the one I co-author) will probably classify it. But we should be able to look behind the doctrinal superstructure, which explains little, and see the deeper principles at stake, principles that have a long history in American constitutional thought. DOMA singled out gay people for special burdens in an important area of social life; it declared their marriages less valuable, and therefore, to that extent, it made them second-class citizens. Even if this wasn't obvious in 1996, it is increasingly obvious today.
Ilya Solim:
As with some of Kennedy’s other important opinions, the exact meaning of this one is hard to figure out. But what he seems to be saying is that the the Congress’ pursuit of purposes beyond the normal scope of federal authority in DOMA makes the law a “discrimination... of an unusual character” and justifies imposing tougher scrutiny under the Fifth Amendment. According to longstanding precedent, the Fifth Amendment imposes on the federal government equal protection antidiscrimination principles that the Fourteenth Amendment imposed on the states. Fifth and Fourteenth Amendment precedent impose different levels of scrutiny on different types of laws, depending in part on the purposes those laws pursue. Here, Kennedy suggests that the level of scrutiny is higher if discriminatory federal laws are intruding into areas generally left to the states. Later in the opinion, he notes that ““‘[d]iscriminations of an unusual character” [require] especially require careful consideration” to determine whether they are based on “animus” against a particular class, and that “DOMA’s unusual deviation from the usual tradition of recognizing and accepting state definitions of marriage... is strong evidence of a law having the purpose and effect of disapproval of that class [gays and lesbians].”
The VRA map
The NYT explains the formula that was struck down yesterday. These are the affected states and local areas:
On the long term consequences of the VRA decision
Andrew Sullivan compiles reactions to the Voting Rights decision.
One author wonders if the decision will have short term benefits but long term harms for the Republican Party. The benefits come from Republican dominated legislatures now being free to pass whatever electoral rules they choose without having to worry about pre-clearance, but the harm being that these legislatures are primarily in the south and will further define the party as white and conservative. It may make it easier for the party to hold onto the House due to gerrymandering, but more difficult to broaden its coalition in order to win the White House.
Here's a related argument in the NYT. The decision may eventually make the party less competitive in the South as well due to the rise of the Latino population.
One author wonders if the decision will have short term benefits but long term harms for the Republican Party. The benefits come from Republican dominated legislatures now being free to pass whatever electoral rules they choose without having to worry about pre-clearance, but the harm being that these legislatures are primarily in the south and will further define the party as white and conservative. It may make it easier for the party to hold onto the House due to gerrymandering, but more difficult to broaden its coalition in order to win the White House.
Here's a related argument in the NYT. The decision may eventually make the party less competitive in the South as well due to the rise of the Latino population.
. . . those who have studied the region closely say that a more unstoppable force is approaching that will alter the power structure throughout the South and upend the understanding of politics there: demographic change.
The states with the highest growth in the Latino population over the last decade are in the South, which is also absorbing an influx of people of all races moving in from other parts of the country.While most experts expect battles over voting restrictions in the coming years, they say that ultimately those efforts cannot hold back the wave of change that will bring about a multiethnic South.“All the voter suppression measures in the world aren’t going to be enough to eventually stem this rising tide,” said Representative David E. Price, a veteran North Carolina Democrat and a political scientist by training.As the region continues to change, Republicans who control legislatures in the South will confront a basic question: how to retain political power when the demographics are no longer on your side.The temptation in the short term, now that the Supreme Court has significantly relaxed federal oversight, may be to pass laws and gerrymander districts to protect Republican political power and limit the influence of the new more diverse population.But that could be devastating to the party’s long-term prospects, especially if it is seen as discriminating against the groups that will make up an ever larger share of the future electorate.
The Davis Filibuster
The special session finished with a successful 13 hour filibuster against SB5 Fort Worth Senator Wendy Davis.
Some related items - mostly from the Texas Tribune:
- Legislative History of SB5.
- The impact of proposed abortion restrictions.
- Led by Davis, Democrats Defeat Abortion Legislation.
- Slideshow.
- Filibuster Launches Davis Onto National Stage.
Some related items - mostly from the Texas Tribune:
- Legislative History of SB5.
- The impact of proposed abortion restrictions.
- Led by Davis, Democrats Defeat Abortion Legislation.
- Slideshow.
- Filibuster Launches Davis Onto National Stage.
Tuesday, June 25, 2013
Sesame Street has new character with a dad in jail
Something we focused on in 2306 today.
Those friendly, fuzzy Muppets from “Sesame Street” have helped kids open up about all sorts of serious subjects, from hunger and divorce to military deployment.
But they’re now tackling a much more unexpected issue: incarceration.
Meet Alex, the first Muppet to have a dad in jail. According to a Pew Charitable Trusts report, one in 28 children in the United States now has a parent behind bars -- more than the number of kids with a parent who is deployed -- so it’s a real issue, but it’s talked about far less because of the stigma.
That’s why the Sesame Workshop says it created the “Little Children, Big Challenges: Incarceration” initiative, an online tool kit intended to help kids with a parent in prison find support and comfort, and provide families with strategies and tips to talk to their children about incarceration.
This is what happens when incarceration is used as an option to solve non-violent crime. And its become a more recent phenomenon, as can be seen by the following graph.
Those friendly, fuzzy Muppets from “Sesame Street” have helped kids open up about all sorts of serious subjects, from hunger and divorce to military deployment.
But they’re now tackling a much more unexpected issue: incarceration.
Meet Alex, the first Muppet to have a dad in jail. According to a Pew Charitable Trusts report, one in 28 children in the United States now has a parent behind bars -- more than the number of kids with a parent who is deployed -- so it’s a real issue, but it’s talked about far less because of the stigma.
That’s why the Sesame Workshop says it created the “Little Children, Big Challenges: Incarceration” initiative, an online tool kit intended to help kids with a parent in prison find support and comfort, and provide families with strategies and tips to talk to their children about incarceration.
This is what happens when incarceration is used as an option to solve non-violent crime. And its become a more recent phenomenon, as can be seen by the following graph.
Section 4 of the Voting Rights Act is found unconstitutional
Click here for ScotusBlog's coverage of Shelby Co. v Holder.
From what I see, The SC wants Congress to update the pre-clearance map. Discrimination is still illegal and pre-clearance is still allowable. More soon.
From what I see, The SC wants Congress to update the pre-clearance map. Discrimination is still illegal and pre-clearance is still allowable. More soon.
The Supreme Court narrows the meaning of "supervisor"
Which makes it more difficult for harrassed employees to sue for discrimination.
In two decisions issued on Monday, the Supreme Court effectively made it harder for workers to prove that they had suffered employment discrimination.Click here for ScotusBlog material on Vance v. Ball State University.
One ruling narrows the definition of what constitutes a supervisor in racial and sexual harassment cases, while the other adopts a tougher standard for workers to prove that they had faced illegal retaliation for complaining about employment discrimination.
In both cases, the rulings were decided by a 5-to-4 majority, with the dissenting justices, the court’s four most liberal members, calling on Congress to fix what they said were overly restrictive rulings.
In Vance v. Ball State University, in which an African-American worker accused her supervisor of racial harassment, the court held that the person she accused was a co-worker and not a supervisor — a distinction that requires a higher burden of proof for the plaintiff’s employer to be found liable.
The majority decision, written by Justice Samuel A. Alito Jr., rejected the definition of “supervisor” advanced by the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission as someone authorized to take “tangible employment actions” or direct the employee’s daily work activities.
From the NYT: Obama to Outline Ambitious Plan to Cut Greenhouse Gases
Expect backlash from Congress, and attempts to implement this agenda through executive orders:
The plan, to be announced in a policy address at Georgetown University, is the most far-reaching effort by an American president to address what many experts consider the defining environmental and economic challenge of the 21st century. But it also could provoke a backlash from some in Congress and in states dependant on coal and other industries, who will say that it imposes costly, job-killing burdens on a still-fragile economy.
In a speech in Berlin last week, Mr. Obama called climate change “the global threat of our time” and promised swift action to avert it. The plan to be announced on Tuesday represents his first serious effort to engage the problem since he threw his support behind a Democratic cap and trade proposal in the House in 2009 to reduce carbon-dioxide emissions. That legislation died in the Senate in 2010.
None of what the president plans to propose will require action by Congress, which has shown no appetite for dealing with global warming and its attendant energy challenges in a comprehensive way. But some of what the president hopes to accomplish will likely face legal and political challenges, including the possible use of a rarely used law that allows Congress to overturn executive branch regulations.
Top-level White House aides and cabinet officers have been working on the climate plan for months to support the “conversation” on climate change that Mr. Obama promised shortly after he was re-elected last November.
Monday, June 24, 2013
The Supreme Court kicks the can on affirmative action
The Supreme Court issued its decision in Fisher v UT, which was to send it back down to the lower courts and ask them to review the programs more stringently, and specifically to apply strict scrutiny when making that review.
Scotusblog's review in plain english is worth a read - here's a chunk of what it says:
And a bit more from the NYT:
Scotusblog's review in plain english is worth a read - here's a chunk of what it says:
Today a broad majority of the Court reinforced that affirmative action must be strictly reviewed, but it did not outlaw those programs. In an opinion that required only thirteen pages, the Court explained that a university’s use of race must meet a test known as “strict scrutiny.” Under this test, a university’s use of affirmative action will be constitutional only if it is “narrowly tailored.” The Court in Fisher took pains to make clear exactly what this means: courts can no longer simply rubber-stamp a university’s determination that it needs to use affirmative action to have a diverse student body. Instead, courts themselves will need to confirm that the use of race is “necessary” – that is, that there is no other realistic alternative that does not use race that would also create a diverse student body. Because the lower court had not done so, the Court sent the case back for it to determine whether the university could make this showing.
And a bit more from the NYT:
The admissions system that Ms. Fisher challenged is idiosyncratic. Three-quarters of applicants from Texas are admitted under a program that guarantees admission to the top students in every high school in the state. (Almost everyone calls this the Top 10 program, though the percentage cutoff can vary by year. Ms. Fisher just missed the cutoff.)
The remaining Texas students and those from elsewhere are considered under standards that take account of academic achievement and other factors, including race and ethnicity. Many colleges and universities admit all of their students on such “holistic” grounds. The question in the case decided Monday was whether Texas was entitled to supplement its race-neutral Top 10 program with a race-conscious holistic one.
The Top 10 program has produced significant racial and ethnic diversity. In recent years, about 25 percent of freshmen who enrolled under the program were Hispanic, and 6 percent were black. Thirty-eight percent of Texans are Hispanic, and 12 percent are black.
Monday’s decision let stand, for now, a longstanding but fragile societal compromise, one that forbids quotas but allows using race as one factor among many in the admissions process. That was the essential message of the court’s two earlier major encounters with the issue, University of California v. Bakke, in 1978, and Grutter v. Bollinger, in 2003.
The Texas Tribune reports that the filibuster just might work
Governor Perry has a wild card though - he can call another special session.
From the story:
From the story:
Using delaying tactics and parliamentary rules, the minority party argued into the wee hours in the state House on Monday morning and then stuck together to keep the GOP from jamming Senate Bill 5 through the Senate in the afternoon and evening. Republicans vowed to try to muster enough support to push the bill through Monday night, but that effort failed. And Democrats are prepared for a final talk-a-thon Tuesday that could spell death — for now — for the bill.
SB 5, by state Sen. Glenn Hegar, R-Katy, would make abortion illegal after 20 weeks and would establish stringent new requirements for facilities that perform abortions. Supporters of the bill say it would make the procedures safer for women and protect unborn babies. Abortion rights proponents say the legislation would shut down most of the abortion facilities in Texas.
With barely more than a day left in the 30-day special session called by Gov. Rick Perry at the end of May, that means Democrats have moved much closer to putting the controversial measure within the range of a filibuster.
From the Chron: Texas Senate has a history of record-breaking filibusters
Opponents of the abortion bill being debated in the Senate are planning a filibuster.
The Houston Chronicle points out that the record was set in the Texas Senate in 1977 - 43 hours. They also point out that the filibustered bill passed immediately after the filibuster was over.
The Houston Chronicle points out that the record was set in the Texas Senate in 1977 - 43 hours. They also point out that the filibustered bill passed immediately after the filibuster was over.
Sunday, June 23, 2013
From the Chron: Dewhurst: Second special session likely unless ‘certain items’ pass
The "certain items" appears to be the abortion measures introduced in Senate Bill 5:
Lt. Gov. David Dewhurst strongly hinted Sunday that Gov. Rick Perry would call lawmakers back to work if certain bills failed to pass during the current special session.
Dewhurst, talking to reporters shortly after the Senate recessed for the day, declined to say specifically which proposals Perry would call a second special for if they failed. But a package of bills containing some of the toughest abortion restrictions in the country has been the center of attention.
Aside from the abortion measures, a bill to boost transportation funding and a proposal dealing with sentencing guidelines for 17-year-old murderers are also currently in limbo. The Legislature must pass those measures before the special session wraps up Tuesday or face the potential for Perry to call a second special session.
“Unless I’m misreading him, we’re going to be called back in,” Dewhurst said. “There are certain items on this call that he shared with me that are a must pass.”
The most pressing of the issues still up in the air for Republicans, which control the House and Senate, is clearly the abortion proposals. Dewhurst, along with Republicans in both chambers, lobbied Perry to add the measures to the special session.
A catch-all anti-abortion proposal — Senate Bill 5 — would ban the procedure at 20 weeks, would allow abortions only in surgical facilities, require doctors performing abortions to have admitting privileges at a nearby hospital and place greater controls on abortion-inducing medications.
From the Hill: 10 to watch on ObamaCare rollout
The Affordable Care Act is going through the implementation phase of the public policy process.
Time to get caught up. Here's The Hill's look at the major players in the process.
Here's one:
Time to get caught up. Here's The Hill's look at the major players in the process.
Here's one:
* Andy Allison (Arkansas Medicaid Director)
Allison has been called a visionary for his role in a proposal to use funding from ObamaCare’s Medicaid expansion to finance the purchase of private coverage for low-income people on the state’s insurance exchange. The plan is seen as a possible red-state alternative to the expansion and has been approved both by federal health officials and the Arkansas state legislature. It’s also expected that the plan could lower premiums on the exchange and draw in new insurance carriers.
Allison moved the Arkansas Medicaid program away from fee-for-service payments and toward a model that rewards quality and efficiency. He formerly served as head of Medicaid in Kansas, and started his work in the field as a Medicaid analyst at the Office of Management and Budget.
Labels:
federalism,
health care,
Implementation,
the bureaucracy
From the NYT: The Endless Battle Over Judicial Nominees
The author tests the idea that Obama's judicial appointees have been treated worse than W. Bush or Clinton. He finds the record mixed.
First he points out why a controversy even exists over these nominations:
He then points out that the picture varies depending on whether the appointment is for a district court, or a circuit court judge.
He finds that vacancies in trial courts happen mostly in states with two Republican Senators.
First he points out why a controversy even exists over these nominations:
Judicial nominations tend to be drawn-out, process-heavy affairs, as do the trials and appeals over which federal judges ultimately preside. Yet in the last few years alone, federal judges have shaped policy on climate change, health care, voting rights, labor relations, contraception, gun control and campaign finance, among other issues. Congressional action may get the bigger headlines, but federal judges often have the last word.
He then points out that the picture varies depending on whether the appointment is for a district court, or a circuit court judge.
. . . Mr. Obama has been roughly as successful as his recent predecessors in getting his circuit court nominees confirmed. He has placed a handful fewer judges because he has nominated fewer. His fifth-year failure rate (14 percent of nominees not confirmed) is actually somewhat lower than Mr. Bush’s (22 percent) and Bill Clinton’s (21 percent).
. . . The district courts, where federal trials occur, are a different story. There, Democratic presidents really have had a harder time winning Senate confirmation for their nominees.
The Senate failed to confirm only 3 percent of Mr. Bush’s district court nominees through June of his fifth year in office (and 1 percent by the end of his presidency). The fifth-year failure rate for Mr. Clinton was 11 percent, and it has been 8 percent for Mr. Obama. If every recent president had a confirmation rate as high as Mr. Bush’s, Democrats might have placed 25 more trial judges on the federal bench.
The difference is especially notable, legal experts say, because Democratic presidents have generally avoided nominating passionate liberals, while Mr. Bush did not shy away from putting strong conservatives in the mold of Justice Antonin Scalia on appellate courts.
Republicans, in other words, have played a tougher brand of politics with federal trial courts. Depending on one’s perspective, that strategy is more partisan or more successful — or both.
He finds that vacancies in trial courts happen mostly in states with two Republican Senators.
The US Supreme Court nixes social media - and most of the rest of the 21st Century
And maybe this is a good thing. Even if it isn't, it fits the picture of an institution that prefers - and is designed to be - removed from the new and the novel:
In a city beset by leaks — a 30-year-old programmer recently gave a hoard of top-secret documents to newspapers — the high court’s annual rulings remain stubbornly opaque until they are handed out (on paper, first) by the court’s public relations staff. Meanwhile, the nine justices have the luxury of appearing publicly oblivious to the swirl of social media, the angst of Washington’s legal community and the voracious appetite of America’s 24-hour news cycle.After the decisions are released however, social media takes over:
Many Washington institutions are making the high-tech transition; even the chairman of the Federal Reserve holds regular news conferences now. But like the Kremlinologists of the cold war, who deduced Communist power struggles by a leader’s presence on the Red Square reviewing stand, modern-day court watchers can do little more than speculate about when and how the court might rule.
“You never know when it’s going to come down,” said Mr. Olson, a former solicitor general who would know, if anyone would. A court observer for decades, he has shown up on each of the last three decision days at the court. “I just try to prepare for anything.”
A year ago, in the minutes before the court announced its decision on President Obama’s health care law, Twitter users posted more than 13,000 messages a minute about the court. (By comparison, there were 160,000 a minute at the height of the presidential debate in Denver last year.)
Tuesday, June 18, 2013
The Hastert Rule and the Bill Making Process
Here's a story that provides some detail for our discussion of the US bill making process tomorrow in 2305. It involves the Hastert Rule - or the majority of the majority principle - which is a rule House Republicans have used since the mid 1990s whenever they are in the majority (it is named for former Speaker Dennis Hastert, but is said to have been developed by Former Speaker Newt Gingrich).
The rule simply requires that the Speaker of the House will not allow a vote on a bill unless it is supported by a majority of the majority - meaning a majority of his party. This prevents the minority from brining up a bill they support that has enough support from majority party members to potentially pass the House.
The rule effectively prevents the minority party - Democrats in the House - to have the ability to pass anything. It allows the Speaker to behave less the presiding officer of the House than the leader of his party.
Here's more on the subject:
- GOP House 'Insurgents Pushing to Weaponize the Hastert Rule."
- What the "Hastert Rule" figth tells us about House Republicans.
- Hastert Rule pushed by insurgent Republicans.
Remember that the Constitution says nothing about what happens prior to the presentation of a bill to the president for a possible signature, with two exceptions. Bill for raising revenue have to be introduced in the House and the bill has to have passed both the House and Senate.
Everything else presumably falls under the ability of Congress to determine its own rules of procedure. The current bill making process has evolved over the time into the comprehensive process that exists today.
What I cannot address - and cannot readily find though I'm sure such a thing exists - is a historical description of how the bill making process has evolved over time. I'd like to locate such a study.
One thing that needs to be emphasized as well is that the comprehensive bill making process that is described in most textbooks - see this one for example - is not how many bills actually become law. The actual process varies from time to time depending on circumstance.
One of the best ways to see this is by looking at the legislative histories of actual bills that have become law - you can find these in Thomas, which is run by the Library of Congress.
Here's a list of the laws which have been enacted so far this year. We'll walk through a few to see what the actual bill making process looks like. The Violence Against Women Reauthorization Act, for example, seems to have spent no time in committee.
The rule simply requires that the Speaker of the House will not allow a vote on a bill unless it is supported by a majority of the majority - meaning a majority of his party. This prevents the minority from brining up a bill they support that has enough support from majority party members to potentially pass the House.
The rule effectively prevents the minority party - Democrats in the House - to have the ability to pass anything. It allows the Speaker to behave less the presiding officer of the House than the leader of his party.
Here's more on the subject:
- GOP House 'Insurgents Pushing to Weaponize the Hastert Rule."
- What the "Hastert Rule" figth tells us about House Republicans.
- Hastert Rule pushed by insurgent Republicans.
Remember that the Constitution says nothing about what happens prior to the presentation of a bill to the president for a possible signature, with two exceptions. Bill for raising revenue have to be introduced in the House and the bill has to have passed both the House and Senate.
Everything else presumably falls under the ability of Congress to determine its own rules of procedure. The current bill making process has evolved over the time into the comprehensive process that exists today.
What I cannot address - and cannot readily find though I'm sure such a thing exists - is a historical description of how the bill making process has evolved over time. I'd like to locate such a study.
One thing that needs to be emphasized as well is that the comprehensive bill making process that is described in most textbooks - see this one for example - is not how many bills actually become law. The actual process varies from time to time depending on circumstance.
One of the best ways to see this is by looking at the legislative histories of actual bills that have become law - you can find these in Thomas, which is run by the Library of Congress.
Here's a list of the laws which have been enacted so far this year. We'll walk through a few to see what the actual bill making process looks like. The Violence Against Women Reauthorization Act, for example, seems to have spent no time in committee.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
