Friday, May 21, 2010

Finance Reform

Financial regulatory reform passes the Senate.

Andrew Sullivan has links that break the bill down.

Graphics from the NYT.

Defining the Tea Party as Extreme

The Rand Paul civil rights comment may allow Democrats an opportunity to paint the Tea Party as too extreme for the voting public. And apparently they have been banking on something like this happening. The public will not automatically see Paul as extreme unless Dems can successfully portray him as such.

Paul is apparently continuing to stir the pot, seemingly suggesting that the feds shouldn't dig into the BP and Masset Coal disasters. Accidents happen.

While this is going on, moderate Republicans may be making a comeback in New England.

Presidents, Rich and Poor

Here's background on the relative net worth of presidents.

Thursday, May 20, 2010

Can a Poll be Biased?

Daily Kos slams the Rasmussen Poll.

And Pollster.Com slams Research 2000.

Ugly, Therefore Guilty

Speaking of civil rights and equal protection under the law.

The Consequences of Rand Paul's Win in Kentucky

A couple of thoughts some pundits are offering after (the other) Dr. Paul's victory over the Republican establishment's candidate in the Kentucky Primary:

1 - The establishment is in trouble and the activists are moving the party further to the right and forcing out the heretics. Paul may be too conservative for Dick Cheney.

2 - Paul's objections to civil rights, including questions about the wisdom of the Civil Rights Act of 1964, have introduced new questions into the upcoming elections. Do private businesses have a right to discriminate?

Election 2010: Democrat wins Special Election in PA - 12 to fill John Murtha's Seat

Republicans had hoped to pick this one up. The early take is that a conservative Democrat (pro-gun, pro-life, said he would have voted against health care bill - but will not vote to repeal it) can still win elections. House elections are not national, they are district by district.

Wednesday, May 19, 2010

The Right to Competent Counsel -- Part 2

From the New York Times comes a story about who you do not want to represent you if you are accused of a capital crime:

A good way to end up on death row in Texas is to be accused of a capital crime and have Jerry Guerinot represent you.

Twenty of Mr. Guerinot’s clients have been sentenced to death. That is more people than are awaiting execution in about half of the 35 states that have the death penalty.

And next comes a chilling kicker:

“People who are well represented at trial do not get the death penalty,” Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg has said.

So what does this say about our justice system? Equal justice for all or are those who can afford it effectively allowed to be treated according to different rules? Is this a constitutional violation? If so how?

- Heres a previous post on the same subject.

Tuesday, May 18, 2010

A Test Case?

So in class today we had some fun tossing around a kooky little idea. Let's say you consider environmentalism to be akin to religious belief -- the whole "mother earth" Wicca type thing. If that's true (if) then isn't the Environmental Protection Agency, an executive agency designed to promote environmentalism (a religious belief) a form of state religion? If so (again, if) than doesn't the EPA violate the establishment clause?

I'll offer extra credit points to whoever want to put a brief together making that argument. We could have a press conference and announce a lawsuit. I bet Glenn Beck will take us seriously even if we dont.

Debating the Revolving Door

Some discussion of the phenomenon at the National Journal.

Texas Doctors are Dropping out of Medicare

At an alarming rate says the Chron. This is an unintended consequence of a 1997 effort to reduce spending on medial care.

A related story:
- Medicare Pay Cuts Averted, Cobra Extended — Why All the Sad Faces ...

Monday, May 17, 2010

Stanley Fish Comments on the Arizona Law Banning Ethnic Studies in K-12

Enjoy.

Do We Have Too Many Elections?

Some suggest that one of the reasons voter turnout is lower in the United States than in other countries is that we have more elections, and therefore place a huge burden on voters. Should more positions be appointed? Do terms need to be so short?

Here are two takes on this question

- Matt Yglesias.
- Jonathan Bernstein.

Two Supreme Court Decisions Regarding Sentencing

In one, Graham v. Florida, the court decided 6-3 that life sentences without the possibility of parole for juveniles convicted of crimes less than murder was cruel and unusual punishment which violated the eighth amendment.

In the other, United States v. Comstock, a 7-2 court stated the Congress had the authority to allow continued confinement of some sex offenders who had completed their sentences, even though this power is not an enumerated (or delegated) power granted to Congress in Article One. It was argued on the basis of the necessary and proper clause, though the dissent wondered necessary and proper to do what?

Sunday, May 16, 2010

The Office of Information and Regulatory Affairs

Meet Cass Sunstein.

Texting and Open Meetings

The legislatures of local and other small governments are subject to the Open Meetings Act which is meant to ensure that all meetings, and potential meetings -- such as cases when a quorum is likely to occur by happenstance -- are open to the public. Backroom deals, say made when a majority of a seven member city council somehow finds themselves alone on an elevator, are banned. But might enhanced communications, social networking and texting, also provide opportunities for these secret meetings and subsequent deal making? The Texas Legislature is set to consider this question in its next session.

Abortion Foes Take Advantage of Language in the Health Care Bill

From the Houston Chronicle.

Jaworski Learned From Obama Campaign

The Galveston County Daily News details Joe Jaworski's convincing victory in the Galveston Mayors race and notes that the campaign was run by a woman who learned campaigning from Obama's 2008 race. Heavy emphasis was placed on block walking and communication.

The Future of Miranda Warnings

The recent arrest of the Times Square bomber has led some, and possibly even the Obama Administration, to call for limits to Miranda Warnings. Constitutional tests to the warnings are nothing new, and given the conservative slant of the court it is worth wondering how secure the warnings are. History tells us that in times of threat, civil liberties take a hit.

For my 2301s, this fits into our discussion of the constitution, as a document that defines and limits governmental power, the Bill of Rights, civil liberties, and how the Supreme Court defines constitutional language.

Links:
- Miranda Warnings.
- Miranda v. Arizona.
- Right Against Self Incrimination.
- Fifth Amendment.
- Due Process.
- Warren Court.
- Dickerson v. U.S.
- The Origins of the Public Safety Exception to Miranda Warnings.

Friday, May 14, 2010

What Incumbency Advantage?

Not this year apparently.

Health Care Reform's Costs Adjusted

upward.

MMS to be Split in Two

The much maligned Minerals Management Service is about to be split in two. The part that collects royalties is to be split from the part that actually regulates wells for safety violations. The solution to many bureaucratic problems seems to be a redesign of the institutions at issue. Here's an example.

Oversight Hearings Held on Gulf Oil Spill

The House Energy and Commerce Committee's Subcommittee on Oversight and Investigations held hearings on the Gulf Oil spill.

Direct Democracy in the House

The House Republican leadership is allowing activists to vote on what spending items to cut. What would Madison say about this?

The American Power Act

That's the name given to the climate change bill introduced into the Senate by Liberman and Kerry. Ezra Klein argues that recent events give it less chance of passing this Congress.

- Info on the bill from Open Congress.
- and from Thomas.

Republican Election Strategy in the House

Target committee chairs.

White House Video Blog

Each new leap in technology allows the White House new ways to frame how it presents itself to the public. This doesn't meant the efforts are necessarily successful. Here's a link to the White House's video blog.

Monday, May 10, 2010

Gates Takes on the Military Industrial Complex

From The Atlantic.

Are We Naturally Good or Naturally Bad?

From a recent study.

Political Knowledge and Political Ideology

A worthy read:

...If we want to know the true impact of political knowledge on political opinions, it's necessary to test that impact while controlling for other variables in a randomly selected sample of adults. Political scientist Scott Althaus has actually done this in his book Collective Preferences and Democratic Politics. He shows that, controlling for a variety of demographic and other variables, increased knowledge makes people more socially liberal and economically conservative (i.e. - more libertarian). That does not mean that high political knowledge necessarily turns you into a libertarian. Far from it. It does mean that it is likely to make you more libertarian than you would be otherwise. The pattern is not completely consistent across all public policy questions. For example, greater knowledge reduces opposition to taxation (I suspect because antitax arguments are less counterintuitive than the protax ones). But it does hold true across most issues.

Finally, low knowledge levels are just one of two major negative effects of rational political ignorance. The second is poor evaluation of the information that we do possess, what economist Bryan Caplan has called
"rational irrationality." As I discuss in this article, the fact that there is little incentive to acquire political information for the purposes of becoming a "better" voter implies that most of the information people do learn is acquired for other purposes. Many of these purposes - such as entertainment value and confirmation of preexisting prejudices - are antithetical to rational, unbiased evaluation of evidence. In my article, I explain how rational irrationality may account for the fact that most citizens tend to discount information that goes against their preexisting views and only read and watch those political media that reinforce those views, while ignoring opposing positions. Such behavior is inexplicable if the goal is to get at the truth in order to be a better voter; it is perfectly rational, however, if truth-seeking is not the primary objective.

Executive and Legislative Attention to Auto Safety

In response to Toyota's troubles, the executive and legislative branches have placed automobile safety on their relative agendas.

In the executive, the Secretary of Transportation said that Toyota's response to the crisis would be monitored more carefully, the effective agency is the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration.

In the legislature, bills are being crafted in the House Energy and Commerce and Senate Commerce, Science and Transportation Committees. The bill is called the The Motor Vehicle Safety Act of 2010. The car lobby has come out against the bill: "seizing on a provision that would empower the top U.S. car regulator to order a recall when an "imminent hazard" is present."

Their efforts is being spearheaded by "top car-industry lobbyist (and former member of Congress - think "revolving door") Dave McCurdy, president of the Alliance of Automobile Manufacturers."

For more information on the legislation:
- S.3302: Motor Vehicle Safety Act of 2010 - U.S. Congress ...
- WashingtonWatch.com - S. 3302, The Motor Vehicle Safety Act of 2010
- Motor Vehicle Safety Act of 2010, Section by Section
- Motor Vehicle Safety Act of 2010 Unveiled The Truth About Cars

Black Republicans

Yes they do exist, and a number are running for office.

Its Elena Kagan

Obama is prepared to make the announcement soon.

Some miscellaneous readings:

- A Climb Marked by Confidence and Canniness
- How conservatives will attack Elena Kagan
- A timeline of Elena Kagan's career
- Kagan's Notable Statements and Writings
- Elena Kagan - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Advice for Bill White ...

... from a political consultant.

Sunday, May 9, 2010

The Upcoming Supreme Court Nominee and Executive Power

Justice Stevens was often the fifth vote against further expansions of executive power. Will the eventual nominee continue in this vein or add to the growing list of justices who seem to favor expansive executive powers?

Utah Tea Party Defeats Incumbent Republican Senator Bob Bennett

Bennett was apparently not conservative enough for the movement. His support of the bailout, continued acquisition of earmarks for the state and willingness to work with Democrats apparently worked against him. Endorsements by Mitt Romney, Newt Gingrich and Dick Cheney had no effect. Commenters argue that this will pull ordinarily moderate Republicans further to the right.

Attention now turns to Kentucky.

- Some background on Utah's peculiar method for selecting nominees.

Ten Suggestions For What Type of Person Should be the Next Nominee to the Supreme Court

Click.

Iron Triangle Watch: Monsanto and the Department of Agriculture

Thomas Barnett comments on the link between Monsanto and the Department of Agriculture. If you've seen Food.Inc you're also aware that one of Monsanto's old corporate lawyers, Clarence Thomas, is now on the Supreme Court.

Saturday, May 8, 2010

Are the State Attorney Generals' Lawsuits Against Health Care Reform Frivolous?

According to these authors, yes.

The Terrorist Expatriation Act

In response to the attempted bombing of Times Square, by a recently minted, Pakistani born, American citizen who received bomb making training apparently from the Pakistan Taliban, members of the U.S. House and Senate have proposed legislation that would "revoke American citizenship from people suspected of allying themselves with terrorists."

Senators Lieberman and Brown call theirs the Terrorist Expatriation Act. Jason Altmire and Charlie Dent are introducing the same bill in the House.

Questions are now being raised about the constitutionality of this legislation, and whether it is a good idea.

- PrawfsBlawg argues that it is unconstitutional. For one thing, the decision is not based on a conviction, but rather an accusation.
- Reason Magazine agrees. The law is vague and overbroad.

In all likelihood, the law has been introduced so that Congress appears to be on the ball and responsive to a threat. Members are well aware of the institution's low approval ratings and wants to be seen as being proactive. No word yet on whether this thing is likely to pass.

Friday, May 7, 2010

Both Jobs and the Unemployment Rate Increase. What's With That?

Some explanations:

- The NYT.
- David Leonhardt.
- David Indiviglio.

MMS: A Captured Agency?

More evidence that the Minerals Management Service was captured by the oil industry.

Agency records show that from 2001 to 2007, there were 1,443 serious drilling accidents in offshore operations, leading to 41 deaths, 302 injuries and 356 oil spills. Yet the federal agency continues to allow the oil industry largely to police itself, saying that the best technical experts work for industry, not for the government.

Critics say that, then and now, the minerals service has been crippled by this dependence on industry and by a climate of regulatory indulgence.

The 2010 British Elections

For my 2301s, we'll cover the just completed -- but still unresolved -- British elections as a contrast to our own.

Ours are non-stop, theirs begin and end in less than two months. We should consider whether this is an admirable distinction. Do we have too many elections in the United States?

Ours provide a clear winner, theirs -- at least now -- do not. The fact that there was no majority winner allows a minority party the opportunity to have an impact on policy because they are now king makers. The minor party is a non-entity in American politics -- at least as a positive force, they can still make life hell for the majority. Again, are there advantages to the British system that could prove valuable to ours?

Some Random Thoughts on the Judiciary

- Jeff Sessions (Republican Senator) wants Obama to appoint a textualist to the court.

- Joseph Ellis thinks the doctrine of original intent is bizarre and that the founders disagreed over what the document meant.

- Linda Greenhouse has some questions about originalism.

Thursday, May 6, 2010

Does the Oil Lobby Own Government Regulators?

Perhaps.

Arizona Immigration Law: Possibly Unconstitutional, Certainly Popular

Arizona's recently passed immigration legislation may prove unconstitutional since it intrudes on the national government's authority over immigration matter. There are also questions about whether its enforcement will lead to racial profiling, which could violate the equal protection clause. There are arguments that it is constitutional however, including this one from the law's author. Challenges have already begun, though as with similar challenges to health care legislation, it is unclear that anyone has standing to sue yet.

Regardless, a small majority of people who have heard of the law, like it.

David Broder thinks the passage of this law adds to the argument that Congress is broken.

Does Government Work Afterall?

E.J Dionne thinks recent events prove it does, or at least can. The trick will be selling that idea. Over the past few decades, conservatives have been able to convince people that, in the words of Dick Armey, "government is dumb." Will the Wall Street crash and the various other private sector screw-ups provide liberals the opportunity to change opinions, or are anti-government attitudes hard wired into the American psyche?

Wednesday, May 5, 2010

Louis Brandeis

The quote in the post below (about sunlight being a disinfectant for politics) is credited to Louis Brandeis. Ive been remiss in not discussing him further when we cover developments in First Amendment freedoms. I'll correct this this summer. My upcoming students should anticipate an assignment of some sort about him and the influence the Supreme Court has on our evolving understandings of what Constitutional freedoms mean at any given moment.

- Other People's Money.

No Backroom Deals for Finance Reform?

If these stories are to be believed, Senate Committees aren't what they used to be. It is said that sunlight is the best disinfectant, and it is alleged that media exposure breaks apart issue networks and iron triangles. Let's see.

Have Attitudes About Surveillance Cameras Changed?

Once seen as contrary to civil liberties -- living in a police state and all -- the Times Square near miss seems to have led to a reappraisal of the relative merits of police surveillance cameras. See the third lesson from the Times Square bomb.

Tuesday, May 4, 2010

An Off Shore Drilling Iron Triangle?

William Galston seems to think such a thing might lie at the root of the ongoing Gulf oil spill. He highlight changes in the Minerals Management Service (a division of the Interior Department) during the early years of the Bush Administration which Check Spellingmade the institution more oil friendly, and less likely to aggressivley inspect off shore oil wells.

Measuring Political Rhetoric

For our ongoing discussion of framing, a study of the positive and negative reactions various and phrases elicits from people. Most positive? Family Values. Most negative? Militia. My hunch is that ll of this is old news to political consultants.

The Limits of Policy

A worthwhile read from David Brooks. Public policy can make things worse, but seldom makes things better for people. Not a positive message.

Monday, May 3, 2010

Implementing Health Care Reform

With apologies to the National Journal, I copied and posted a recent piece detailing the issues associated with implementing the recently passed health care legislation.

Writing The Rules For The Health Law: The new law offers some benefits this year, but a quick turnaround on writing regulations could prove difficult.

by Marilyn Werber Serafini
Saturday, May 1, 2010

The Obama administration faces a monumental task this year in implementing the first changes dictated by the new health care reform law, not to mention laying the groundwork for the bigger changes to come in 2014.

On the political front, meanwhile, Obama and his team have a challenge in selling the public on health reform's benefits before November's congressional elections. Surveys show that opposition has grown since the law was enacted on March 23, with various April polls finding 40 to 54 percent of respondents unhappy. The White House announced last week that Stephanie Cutter, who handled the president's nomination of Sonia Sotomayor to the Supreme Court and advised first lady Michelle Obama on her childhood obesity initiative, will spearhead the effort to bolster public understanding of and support for the reforms. (See "
Winning the Perception Game," NJ, 4/24/10)

Democrats wrote the law so that some of its most appealing reforms come this year -- a good strategy so long as those changes happen smoothly and on time. "The major benefits of the law -- the coverage expansions, subsidies, and insurance market reforms -- do not kick in until 2014," Drew Altman, president of the Kaiser Family Foundation, wrote on the foundation's website. "To compensate for that, the architects of the legislation built in a long list of early deliverables so the public would see tangible and understandable benefits right away -- from allowing dependent children to stay on family policies until age 26, to beginning to eliminate the prescription drug doughnut hole for seniors."

These early reforms will help only a modest number of people, he cautioned, and premiums and out-of-pocket costs will continue to rise faster than wages. "So, on the one hand, the law might not provide the kind of help people are expecting in the first few years. On the other hand, the sky will not immediately fall, as many people seem to believe it might."
Altman predicted that few people will see any changes in the near term. "If the benefits and timetable for the law are communicated effectively, the expectations gap should be manageable; over time, the benefits the law provides will be highly valued by the American people, but it will be crucial to develop mechanisms to answer people's questions and link them to the benefits the law provides."

The Health and Human Services Department and other federal agencies are tasked with producing regulations for the changes that take effect this year. Nancy-Ann DeParle, director of the White House Office of Health Reform, is confident the administration can move quickly, although some observers predict missed deadlines.

The law provides $1 billion to help HHS implement the new law -- probably not enough, said Mark McClellan, director of the Engelberg Center for Health Care Reform at the Brookings Institution. As the Medicare administrator in the Bush administration, he launched the program's huge prescription drug benefit enacted in 2003. The Congressional Budget Office has estimated that HHS and the Internal Revenue Service will need $10 billion to $20 billion over 10 years to carry out health reform.

McClellan said that speeded-up hiring procedures helped him implement the drug benefit but added that HHS no longer has such authority. Even with that boost, he said, he needed six to nine months to get key staff on board, and he faced his share of criticism. As the program geared up, the media trumpeted stories of seniors who were turned away from pharmacies empty-handed because of confusion over coverage. The program's telephone help line sometimes kept frustrated seniors on hold too long and then provided incorrect advice. Still, McClellan was able to smooth the wrinkles quickly enough to earn good marks for the program in opinion polls.

The "biggest challenge coming up fast" for HHS, he said, is ensuring that states and the federal government meet a June 23 deadline for establishing subsidized high-risk insurance pools for the people who are hardest to insure. More than 30 states operate such pools, and they may enhance those programs or let the federal government step in.

Georgia's insurance commissioner last month announced that his state would let the feds take over. It will be much easier (and cheaper) if states build on their existing pools, said McClellan, who agreed with other health care experts that the $5 billion to fund the pools until 2014 won't be enough; that amount might not last even a year, he said. If the funding runs out, the administration will have to ask Congress for another appropriation. Conversely, if the money lasts, it would probably signal that the pools are reaching too few people.

"Insurance availability for people who can't get it now is expected to be a high-profile issue," McClellan said. "If programs are not working, then that would confirm some views of the critics and create momentum for change. On the other hand, if the initial provisions go well and the administration can point to people who are benefiting, it keeps the overall package on track."

Also this year, Medicare beneficiaries who hit the so-called doughnut hole -- a gap in their prescription coverage -- will get a $250 rebate. Under the drug program, when spending on an individual has reached $2,250 on prescriptions in a given year, the person must pay 100 percent of the cost of their medications unless and until spending reaches $5,100. The doughnut hole, which Congress created to lower the cost of the program, has been an irritant for seniors and Democrats, who have long vowed to close the coverage gap as soon as possible.

Small businesses that have up to 25 workers and pay average wages under $50,000 are eligible for tax credits to help cover their employees. States may also draw down federal matching money this year if they begin expanding Medicaid to people who earn up to 133 percent of the federal poverty level (about $14,400 for an individual). Moreover, the government will reimburse employers up to 80 percent of the cost if they offer health insurance to retirees over 55 who don't qualify for Medicare. Regulations must spell out all of this in detail, and Health and Human Services Secretary Kathleen Sebelius has significant leeway in defining such concepts as pre-existing conditions and dependent care.

By the end of September, the act will prohibit insurers from imposing cost-sharing on patients for preventive medical services identified by the U.S. Preventive Services Task Force. In addition, insurers must cover young adults up to age 26 on their parents' policies and must not exclude children under age 19 from coverage because of pre-existing medical conditions. Insurers are forbidden to cancel anyone's policy unless the initial application was fraudulent, or to impose lifetime benefit limits.

Sebelius is encouraging insurers to voluntarily make some changes sooner, and already a handful of carriers have agreed to speed up their coverage of young adults on their parents' policies. The secretary announced last week that Blue Cross Blue Shield plans, Kaiser Permanente, and Humana will begin covering young adults before the end of September.

The law requires HHS and other agencies to take a number of other steps by the end of the year, including:

• Reduce annual increases in Medicare payments for inpatient hospital, home health, skilled nursing, hospice, and other services.

• Increase the Medicaid drug rebate for brand-name drugs.

• Create a process for the approval of generic versions of biologic drugs.

• Launch a nonprofit institute to research and compare the effectiveness of medical services.

• Establish a committee to develop a national health care workforce strategy.

• Administer a 10 percent tax on indoor tanning services.

The federal government, states, employers, insurers, and medical providers have all begun laying the groundwork for the massive changes to come in 2014 and beyond. Washington will need to work with states to establish health insurance exchanges and expand Medicaid programs. Federal administrators will also have to prepare for new taxes (and tax breaks), and for Medicare pilot projects to test such concepts as accountable care organizations and bundled payments.

Obama Comments on the State of Politics

And uses an example we discuss in class:

So before we get too depressed about the current state of our politics, let’s remember our history. The great debates of the past all stirred great passions. They all made somebody angry, and at least once led to a terrible war. What is amazing is that despite all the conflict, despite all its flaws and its frustrations, our experiment in democracy has worked better than any form of government on Earth.

On the last day of the Constitutional Convention, Benjamin Franklin was famously asked, “Well, Doctor, what have we got -– a republic or a monarchy?” And Franklin gave an answer that’s been quoted for ages: He said, “A republic, if you can keep it.” If you can keep it.

Well, for more than 200 years, we have kept it. Through revolution and civil war, our democracy has survived. Through depression and world war, it has prevailed. Through periods of great social and economic unrest, from civil rights to women’s rights, it has allowed us slowly, sometimes painfully, to move towards a more perfect union.

Sacrificing Freedom to Gain Greater Freedoms

Here's some commentary on the different conceptions liberals and conservatives have about freedom. This guy uses an example I've used in class for years:

If freedom involves having a decent set of alternatives available to us, then government action can enhance our freedom even if it involves restraints on conduct that would not otherwise violate anyone’s rights. Consider traffic laws. Those of us who drive are constantly subjected to government dictates telling us what we can and cannot do. We can only drive on one side of the street. We have to stop at red lights and stop signs even when no one else is around. If freedom means only that government should not tell us what to do, then the traffic laws are a massive intrusion on our liberty.

I suspect that most people don’t see things that way, though. They probably agree with Elizabeth Anderson, from whom I have taken
this example:

To be sure, in a state of gridlock, one has the formal freedom to choose any movement in one's opportunity set -- which amounts to being able to rock forward and back a couple of inches from bumper to bumper, getting nowhere. Some freedom!

Normally, the point of driving is to get somewhere. The traffic laws enable us to get where we are going much more quickly and safely than we would if each of us had to decide for him- or herself which side of the street to drive on. The traffic laws do not tell us where to go. They leave the choice of destination, and for that matter the decision whether to drive at all, entirely up to us. They simply tell us which side of the road to drive on, that we should stop at various points, and so forth. By taking away our freedom to drive on the left, or to blast through busy intersections, they grant us much more freedom in the form of a greatly enhanced ability to get wherever we want to go quickly and safely.
Anyone who thinks that the traffic laws enhance our freedom should acknowledge that in some cases, including this one, government action can enhance our freedom, even if that action takes the form of restrictions on what we can and cannot do.

A Tradition of Self Governance

The founders were not amateurs, and their experience in self governance came in handy for a newly formed republic searching for stability.

Friday, April 30, 2010

Is An Ideologically Polarized Congress Healthy?

Some thoughts.

Obama Criticizes Liberal Judicial Activism

From the NYT:

“It used to be that the notion of an activist judge was somebody who ignored the will of Congress, ignored democratic processes, and tried to impose judicial solutions on problems instead of letting the process work itself through politically,” Mr. Obama said.

“And in the ’60s and ’70s, the feeling was — is that liberals were guilty of that kind of approach. What you’re now seeing, I think, is a conservative jurisprudence that oftentimes makes the same error.”

He added, “The concept of judicial restraint cuts both ways.”

A Window of Opportunity for Non-Carbon Energy?

We've had two tragedies in rapid succession involving standard carbon based energy industries, the coal mining disaster and the Off shore oil well explosion followed by the spill. Might this create an opportunity for proponents of wind/solar and other non-carbon energy sources to generate support for their efforts to develop them? David Brooks argues that governments have always played a role in jump-starting new technologies and should do the same for clean energy.

In 2302 we discuss agenda setting, and the role events can play determining what governments do. Here's a current example.

5/3/10: Paul Krugman agrees with me.

Thursday, April 29, 2010

A Third -- Moderate -- Party?

A Tea Party backed candidate in Florida, Marco Rubio, seems about to force a more moderate (or opportunistic) Charlie Crist to run as an independent. Though the impact has yet to be felt, this could split the Republican vote and hand the Senate election to the Democrat. We've discussed in class as we've considered the potential consequence of the Tea Party movement. Might they be pulling the Republican Party too far to the right? Is the first of other similar moves?

Is There a Right to Secrecy?

The Supreme Court considered arguments that ballot petitions should be secret. The case is Doe v. Reed.

- Doe v. Reed - ScotusWiki
- Doe v. Reed: Citizens United, Part Two
- Doe v. Reed : First Amendment Coalition
- Election Law: Doe v. Reed Commentaries

Religious Monuments on Government Property OK

The Supreme Court ruled -- in Salazar, et al., v. Buono -- that a Christian cross erected on government ground did not violate the establishment clause. The decision was 5-4 and contentious.

- Salazar v. Buono - ScotusWiki
- Salazar v. Buono - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Study Guide For 2302 Final, Spring 2010

Here are words and phrases to guide you as you prepare for the 80 question final:

Unalienable Rights
Purpose of Constitutions
Republics
Pure Democracies
Purpose of Separated Powers
Autocracy
Oligarchy
Democracy
Legislatures
Executive
Judiciary
Basic functions of each institution
Bicameralism
Magna Carta
Security Clause
Petition of Rights
British Bill of Rights
Grievances in the Declaration of Independence
Design of Congress in the Articles of Confederation
Proposals presented to the Constitutional Convention
Constitutional Compromises
The Great Compromise
Design of the House and Senate
Constitutional principles which protect the legislature from the executive
The Speaker and President of the Senate
The Uniqueness of the Texas Legislature
The development of parties in Congress
Party positions
Committees, role in the legislative process
Standing committee assignments in Congress and the Texas Legislature
Budgeting
Filibusters
Party Whips
Role of the executive, dangers of the office
Design of the U.S. and Texas executive
The Bureaucracy
Henry II
Henry VIII
Limits Imposed on the monarchy in the British Bill of Rights
Executive and judicial power under the Articles of Confederation
Presidential Advising
Energy in the executive
Constitutional Powers of the President
Anti-Federalist concerns
Advice and Consent
Foreign Policy and the President
Executive Checks
Chief Executive
Limits on presidential power
Factors leading to the growth of the executive branch
Source of bureaucratic strenght
The Modern Presidency
The Post Modern Presidency
Functions of the Judiciary
Common Law
Statutory Law
Constitutional Law
Due Process and the Magna Carta
Star Chamber
Judicial Independence
Design of the Judiciary
Cases and Controversies
Appointing and Electing Judges
Judicial Review
Strict and Loose Interpretations of the Constitution
Original Intent and Textualism
The Living Constitution
Judicial Restraint
Judicial Activism

Study Guide For 2301 Final, Spring 2010

Here are words and phrases to guide you as you prepare for the 80 question final:

Franklin
Government
Politics
Consent
Coercion
Sovereignty
Autocracy
Oligarchy
Democracy
Ideology
Liberalism
Conservatism
Equality
Liberty
The Declaration of Independence
Tyranny
Full Faith and Credit
Privileges and Immunities
The structure of the Constitution
Constitutional principles
The driving force(s) behind the Constitutional Convention
The Great Compromise
The Preamble
Government institutions
The delegated powers of the national government
The uniqueness of the Texas Constitution
Federalist #10
Factions
Majority Rule
Republicanism
Human Nature
Pure democracy
Federalist #51
Separated Powers
Electoral Systems
Appointments
Checks and Balances, purpose and examples
The design of the U.S. and Texas House and Senate
Ambition
The Bill of Rights
Civil Liberties
Arguments for and against the Bill of Rights
The First Amendment
Limits on the Freedom of Speech
The expansion of the Bill of Rights
The 14th Amendment
Strict and Loose Interpretations of the Constitution
Substantive Liberty
Procedural Liberty
Federalism
Reserved and Implied Powers
The Necessary and Proper Clause
The Commerce Clause
State Sovereign Immunity
Elections
Direct elections
Constituencies
Winner Take All elections
The Right to Vote
Primary Elections
General Elections
Voter Turnout
Political Parties
Coalitions
Factions in each major party
Issues of each major party
Disputes within each major party
Third parties
Washington's Farewell Address
Public Opinion
Civil Rights
The Equal Protection Clause
Suspect Classifications
Strict Scrutiny

Should Cameras be Placed in the Supreme Court?

Legislation has been introduced in the Senate and House to do so.

Is this a good or bad idea? Proponents argue that it makes the court more transparent, opponents argue that it will lead to grandstanding by the justices and encourage them to play to constituencies outside the court. Hamilton, in Fed #78, wanted the court to stick to the Constitution and the laws. Might cameras compromise this?

Wednesday, April 28, 2010

Can Legislators Still Legislate?

Maybe not. Especially if legislating means talking with the opposition. Ezra Klein considers the case of Republican Senator Bob Bennett. Are voters, driven by extremist ideological groups, punishing legislators who legislate?

Arizona's Immigration Legislation

Will it energize the always dormant Latino voter? It happened in California and killed the Republican Party's chance to broaden its coalition to include the community. Republicans are more passionate at the moment, but there is enough time for events to occur that energize Democrats.

For 2301s, this illustrates the decentralized nature of parties in the United States. Arizona Republicans have made a move that could well jeopardize the long term competitiveness of the party nationally. But who can stop them?

But Obama has to move quickly in order to ensure that the faction is brought fully into the fold.

Ideological Polarization in the House

It keeps widening, according to this National Journal story.

Over the past eight election cycles, a great sorting of the House has taken place. Congressional districts have become more strongly Democratic or Republican, and voters across the country have been sending representatives to Washington who are more strongly liberal or conservative, according to a new analysis by National Journal. From 1994 to 2008, voters became less willing to tolerate representatives who were out of step with their ideological preferences, and lawmakers responded by voting more in sync with their districts.

The authors argue that the ideological homogeneity that results from redistricting (the creation of districts that are solidly democrat or republican) makes it easier for errant representatives to either be kept in line, or replaced, by constituents. The partisan realignment of voters based on party ideology also contributes to this polarization.

Tuesday, April 27, 2010

We Are All Activists Now

Barry Friedman and Jeffrey Rosen argue that both the left and right have grown accustomed to the use of an activist court to achieve their political aims.

Defining the Terms of Political Debates

E.J. Dionne thinks conservatives have been able to do so for several decades now and that its about time liberals stepped up.

Monday, April 26, 2010

The Country Isn't Angrier, Anger Has Switched Sides.

The anger conservatives feel today was matched by the anger liberals felt in 2006. Maybe each side is just upset to be out of power.

Bill White and the Liberal Trial Lawyer Tag

The Texas Tribune wonders whether it fits, and whether it works.

Do National Political Party Committees Matter?

Not anymore, according to Matthew Dowd. Elections results seem not to be influenced by the state of either party. The conditions that surround a given election (the state of the economy, whether we are at war, etc...) plus candidate characteristics matter far more than campaigns and tactics. He points to polls that suggest that a generic Democrat would have comfortably beat a generic Republican in the 2008 presidential election. Obama's campaign mattered little.

He argues that the "political-industrial complex" plus the need to fill the 24 hour news cycle with campaign details gives the illusion that party organization matters. This is a false impression.

We've hit this point before. Political scientists who forecast elections tell us it all boils down to the economy and who voters perceive as being responsible for it, and the have the models to back it up. Campaigns and parties may not matter as much as we think, or as political leaders would like us to believe.

Thursday, April 22, 2010

Equal Protection for Pregnant Volleyball Players?

A case out of Ft. Worth illustrates the different ways that the equal protection clause can be applied depending on what criteria is used to treat people differently. Was a high school student discriminated against when she was kicked off the volleyball team because she was pregnant? The feds say no, the ISD had just cause to do so.

Some useful background:
- Pregnancy Discrimination; Know Your Rights
- NOAA Civil Rights Office -- Facts: Pregnancy Discrimination
- Facts About Pregnancy Discrimination
- The Civil Rights of Pregnant and Parenting Teens - Policy Brief ...

Framing Financial Reform

From Politico, a story about a debate regarding where the idea emerged that opposition to financial aid reform is best done by framing it as being a "permanent bailout."

Regulations on Derivatives Pass Senate Committee

The Agriculture Committee of all things.

Supreme Court to Rule on Sexting Case

The case is City of Ontario vs. Quon.

Members of the court seem to be unsure about texting, emails and that tech stuff.

And what would the founders have to say about that?

Comments on Steven's Approach to the Constitution

A thirty day series kicks off on ScotusBlog.

Losing Can Be Winning

I mentioned this possibility in class. A Republican victory in 2010, could help Obama in 2012.

Monday, April 19, 2010

Saturday, April 17, 2010

An Inside Peek at a Policy Change

The Washington Post has a story today on how an influential interest group, The Human Rights Campaign, was consulted by the Obama Administration on what potential policy changes would best affect the gay and lesbian community, and provoke the least backlash.

A good example of an advocacy network, perhaps an iron triangle, but an unconventional one.

Friday, April 16, 2010

Whisper Campaigns

Here's an interesting use of the media, an influential individual -- an opinion leader -- starts a rumor (that one of the top potential Supreme Court nominees is lesbian) in a public, though somewhat discrete place, and the rumor takes off. The White House backlash has led some to speculate that she might be the eventual nominee.

- Wikipedia - Whisper Campaigns.

Senate Republicans United in Opposition to Financial Reforms

But apparently not all 41 support a filibuster. There are concerns whether opposition to the bill will be seen as protecting Wall Street from the wrath of Main Street.

Here are the key parts of the bill (copied from calculatedriskblog):

- The consumer financial protection agency would be part of the Federal Reserve.

- Creates a systemic risk council that would be headed by the Treasury Secretary and would include "representatives of the Fed, the new consumer agency, the F.D.I.C., the Securities and Exchange Commission, the Commodity Futures Trading Commission and the Federal Housing Finance Agency — along with an official appointed to monitor the insurance industry, which is largely regulated by the states."

- Regulate over-the-counter derivatives: "Standardized swaps and derivatives would have to be traded on exchanges or clearinghouses."

- The Federal Reserve would regulate bank holding companies with $50 billion or more in assets, and "systemically important nonbank financial institutions".

- Many smaller banks that the Federal Reserve currently regulates would be overseen by the Office of the Comptroller of the Currency or the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation, depending on the bank charter.

- Some shareholder provisions that allow shareholders to vote on executive pay and nominate directors.

click here for the committee report.

The Securities and Exchange Commission Sues Goldman-Sachs

The company is accused of packaging mortgage bonds they thought were likely to fail into a single portfolio, selling it to investors, and then betting against the portfolio. When the housing market collapsed, the investors lost money, but the company did very very well.

This is fraud.

More from the Huffington Post. They end their story by wondering whether the SEC will in fact punish the company. The agency looked the other way while it was going on, might it still? Has the SEC been captured by the financial industry?

For more info: Financial Regulatory Reform.

Perry will Not Call Special Session to Discuss Nullification

From the Dallas Morning News.

Obama v A Generic Republican

Nate Silver points out a curious phenomenon. Based on his analysis of current polls, if the 2012 election were held today, Obama loses to a generic Republican, but defeats all potential flesh and blood Republican candidates. Is this good news or bad news for Obama? What does this tell us about the information we get from public opinion polls? Or people's assessment of the Republican Party as an institution versus the characteristics of any potential candidate?

Online Political Segregation

This story modifies up our discussion about how the current media environment furthers
ideological polarization in America. Online exposure to news tends to be less polarizing than others types of exposure. This is an important observation.

The Swing Justice

A National Journal Story on perhaps the most powerful man in America, Anthony Kennedy. In an otherwise 4-4 court, he picks the winner.

Same Sex Visitation Rights

A few posts below I referred to a National Journal story that pointed out the fractured nature of Obama's coalition because certain groups (Latino, women's rights, gays and Lesbians, and labor among others) are upset because he has not moved on issues important to them. I predicted he would probably start making at least token efforts to appease them. He did so to the GLBT community by issuing a directive that any hospital the receives federal funds allow full visitation right to same sex partners.

This seems to have been receive well by the community, though it is to early to tell if it repairs their relationship to Obama. It was simply executed -- I believe by an executive order though I don;t know for sure. It will also, I believe, be difficult to oppose even by staunch opponents of homosexuality because it'll just appear unseemly to not allow a person in a hospital the ability to see people they fell closest to. It's too early to judge but this seem to be an astute political move.

Thursday, April 15, 2010

The Patient President?

David Broder thinks Obama has been patient in his approach to the presidency, but wonders whether this might hurt him in an age of instant gratification.