Tuesday, September 24, 2013

A few more links related to the iron triangle

To supplement 2305's look at the role iron triangles, issues networks, and the like play in sustaining existing public policies.

Images. I prefer this to the one I have on the slides:



Here's a reasonable definition from a polisci prof at Auburn:

The closed, mutually supportive relationships that often prevail in the United States between the government agencies, the special interest lobbying organizations, and the legislative committees or subcommittees with jurisdiction over a particular functional area of government policy. As long as they hang together, the members of these small groups of movers and shakers tend to dominate all policy-making in their respective specialized areas of concern, and they tend to present a united front against "outsiders" who attempt to invade their turf and alter established policies that have been worked out by years of private negotiations among the "insiders."

The classic example of an Iron Triangle is the military industrial complex, a term coined by Dwight Eisenhower to refer to the

. . . policy and monetary relationships between legislators, national armed forces, and the military industrial base that supports them. These relationships include political contributions, political approval for military spending, lobbying to support bureaucracies, and oversight of the industry. 

The Wikipedia entry has other examples. For example:

Agriculture: agribusiness (the food industry) is an interest group constituency that seeks to benefit from certain government agricultural policies, such as agricultural subsidies. The U.S. Department of Agriculture services these constituencies. Senators and representatives wield enormous power, and are unlikely to obtain office in agriculture-driven regions if they oppose these policies. This results in certain agricultural products being subsidized by taxpayers.

Ted Cruz wants to be Mel Gibson

That's what The Dish makes of our senator's effort to defund Obamacare despite the reservations of his party leaders.

What is your state worst at?



From Policymic

Has austerity hampered economic growth?

Here is an argument that it has.

In recent recessions, government spending has increased. Not in the current recession. Here's one factoid. Government jobs have been cut, which keeps the unemployment rate high. In previous recessions they increased.



A CBO report argues that austerity has cut GDP growth by .8 percent.

From Wonkblog: Why are 47 million Americans on food stamps? It’s the recession — mostly.

Charts and graphs are offered to provide background for the current debate over the program - the one House Republicans voted to cut substantively last week.

Aside from graphs - the story answers basic questions reagrding the current state of both the program and the nature of hunger in America.

Here's a look at the recent growth in the program:

SNAP participants

C40 Cities

The previous story mentions the C40 Climate Leadership Group which enlists cities in the effort to make adaptations to climate change.

Houston is one of 10 global cities designated as a "steering committee." I;m not clear on what that means, but it sounds impressive (Dallas ain't on the list).

Here it highlights a recent CNN story highlighting Houston's efforts, along with Seoul and Rio de Janeiro, to shift to renewable energy. The previous stories point is that while political disputes are hampering the ability of states and the nation to address these issues, cities are plowing right ahead.

It might be worth studying whether these is something in the governing structure of cities that allows them to move quicker on these issues than the other two levels of government.

From the Atlantic: Can Mayors Really Save the World?

For 2306 - where we recently looked at the nature of local governments and said a word or two about mayors.

The author of this article wonders if dysfunction on the national and state levels is empowering mayors, and city leaders in general to play a bigger role in setting and implementing public policies. He mentions a movement among members towards something called "glocalization" which provides local areas the opportunity to accept global standards, but adapt them to the needs of a specific community. The theory is based on the idea that the nation-state has failed.

"The federal government has basically sent the signal, 'We won’t be resolving any of this for the foreseeable future,'" says Bruce Katz, the director of the Brookings Institution's Metropolitan Policy Program and co-author of The Metropolitan Revolution. "And that’s a somewhat similar story around the world." For that reason, glocalists say, we should stop expecting big, centralized governments to solve the world's problems and start looking to cities for innovative solutions.

Provocative point.

Here are some other useful bits from the article - many dovetail with points we have made in 2306:

Mayors are driven my different motives than state and national leaders and are better suited to solve problems:


"Mayors are, by definition, non-ideological problem-solvers. They’re pragmatists – they have to be," Barber says. If cities don't function smoothly, people’s trash won’t get picked up. Their sewers won’t work. Their kids won’t be able to go to school. Especially in the United States, where national leaders are locked into ideological camps and party-line negotiations, there seems to be a fundamental difference in what national and local leaders can actually accomplish.

Perhaps this is because local elections are non-partisan. Worth a discussion.

Cities are networks of interests based on trade (economic entities as we suggested:

. . . it’s also important to remember that cities are more than just councils and mayors. "Cities are not governments, unlike the federal and state governments. They’re networks," says Katz. As urban theorist Jane Jacobs wrote in her famed 1961 book, The Death and Life of Great American Cities, "The economic foundation of cities is trade."
Urbanists often forget that part of Jacobs's work, Katz says. But what it means is that a lot of people and organizations, including hospitals, universities, companies, businesses, unions, and philanthropies, are investing money and thought in projects like creating jobs for 20-somethings and making sure buildings are sturdy enough to weather storms. This is what local innovation looks like: regular people finding work-arounds so that the stores they own or the homeless shelters they run can thrive.

Cities are more democratic than other levels of government and have a more tangible identity than a state or nation:

. . . local leaders understand what people want and need far better than national or international leaders ever could, glocalists say. "You pay taxes, and maybe serve in the military, and vote once in a while in the presidential election, and that’s the only relationship you have with the nation-state," Barber says. "Locally, you’re related to your workplace, your school, your church, your hospitals. … Our real connections with the political entity are local."
Put another way, glocalization is a fight to make democracy something people can touch and feel. Cities are made up of tangible things like streets and subways and storefronts, but nation-states are deeply theoretical entities — we have to use symbols like flags and food to understand what they mean. In the same way, glocalists might argue, national and international leaders are trapped in the realm of abstractions and ideas. By definition, they’re too removed from people and their problems to create effective policy.

Its an interesting - and light - read.

From the Atlantic: These 2 Charts Prove American Drivers Don't Pay Enough for Roads

While most Americans would argue they are overtaxed, the author argues that we are in a road funding crisis because we are not paying enough for roads and our infrastructure suffers as a result.

He points out that the federal gas tax has not been raised since 1993, and that Highway Trust Fund is expected to run out of money in two years as a result.

Chart one shows that we pay more for roads than we earn in road revenue, especially when compared to other nations:



Chart two show how much less American pay in road taxes than other nations. The authors point out that this means that funding for roads has to diverted from other sources.



They suggest that our current model for funding roads is unsustainable.

Could the Boston Tea Party be considered an act of terrorism by the British?

This appears to be one of the questions that set off the opponents of CSCOPE and led them to believe that the curriculum is fraught with political bias.

Here's a related clip from a news source covering the debate:

Criticism intensified when parents discovered a lesson plan used in previous incarnations of CSCOPE that asked students to consider whether participants in the Boston Tea Party could be considered terrorists in some contexts by the British. Another sample lesson asked students to design a flag for a new socialist country. Some critics also suggested that lessons on the world’s major religions contained too much material on Islam.
Patrick opened Saturday’s debate arguing that studies showed that students in school districts that use CSCOPE performed worse on state standardized tests that those who didn’t. However, he acknowledged that his source was a survey conducted by a ninth-grade business class.
When the debate shifted to the question of bias, Ratliff referred to the Boston Tea Party lesson, saying: “The lesson does not say the Boston Tea party members were terrorists. It does not say it.”
Patrick shot back: “Do you think it’s a good idea to plant the seed (of terrorism) in the mind of high school students?” When Ratliff tried to answer about international perspectives, hecklers shouted: “This is America! You’re American!”
“Read it for yourself and see if you become a terrorist overnight,” Ratliff responded.

In a story last year, the Huntington Post hunted down the assignment, which has since been changed. It asked student to comment on a news story and whether the event covered met the definitions of terrorism:
News report: New Act of Terrorism A local militia, believed to be a terrorist organization, attacked the property of private citizens today at our nation’s busiest port. Although no one was injured in the attack, a large quantity of merchandise, considered to be valuable to its owners and loathsome to the perpetrators, was destroyed. The terrorists, dressed in disguise and apparently intoxicated, were able to escape into the night with the help of local citizens who harbor these fugitives and conceal their identities from the authorities. It is believed that the terrorist attack was a response to the policies enacted by the occupying country’s government. Even stronger policies are anticipated by the local citizens.

Its actually a question historians have asked before, so there's nothing new about it:

Here's the simple definition of terrorism from Websters: 

the use of violent acts to frighten the people in an area as a way of trying to achieve a political goal
And a description of the event from about.com: 

On the night of December 16, 1773, the Sons of Liberty, a loosely knit secret organization of American colonists in favor of American independence, illegally boarded three British East India cargo ships in the Boston Harbor and threw 45 tons of tea into the harbor, rather than let the tea be landed. Today, as some have argued, this protest might be considered an act of terrorism, since it was property sabotage designed to bring to wide attention the political objectives of a non-state group, the American colonists. The event is considered one of the catalysts of the American revolution.

Also check out the Wikipedia entry on the Boston Tea Party.

So the question seems to be whether property sabotage is an act of violence that tries to achieve a political goal. The goal was in fact to provoke the British to do something extreme, which it did by passing the Coercive Acts, which included shutting down trade. This hit the merchants in the pocket and drove them to stop waffling on independence and start supporting it.

So it did have its intended political consequence, though no lives were lost - maybe that does not make it terrorism in the minds of some.

Its worth trying to dig into what drives this dispute - aside from pure politics of course.

The entire CSCOPE lesson plan

Courtesy of the Texas Tribune.

We should click through the section on government at some point to see what the fuss is about.

The CSCOPE debate

CSCOPE, a K-12 educational curriculum support system designed to assist the smaller ISD's in Texas to prepare it students for the STARR tests (State of Texas Assessments of Academic Readiness) has been controversial for a variety of reasons.

Teachers complain it imposes limits on what they do in the classroom and parent complain about a lack of transparency - they can't see the lesson plans.

But the most heated area has to do - no big surprise - with content. How do students cover certain subjects, most social studies?

A month back - while we were discussing the importance of education in maintaining republics - a debate was held between a member of the State Board of Education - Thomas Ratliff - and the chair of the State Senate's Education Committee - Dan Patrick. While both men are Republicans, Patrick is affiliated with the Tea Party wing of the party. Ratliff sides with the moderates.

The Tea Party maintains the curriculum is liberal, Anti-American and pro-Islamic.

For further background:

- Ratliff, Patrick Exchange Words over CSCOPE Lessons.
- Debate again thrusts CSCOPE into Texas spotlight.
- Sen. CSCOPE announce sweeping changes.

The curriculum was designed by the Texas Education Service Center Curriculum Collaborative and overseen by the Texas Curriculum Management Program.

Sunday, September 22, 2013

There will be no written assignment for week 5

I know this disappoints you.

I'll catch up on grading, and if you need to catch up on work on your end, go for it.

This day in history - the first junior college opens in the state

From the TSHA, note the constitutional issue it raised in bold.

On this day in 1925, San Antonio College formally opened as University Junior College with an enrollment of 200 students. It is the oldest public two-year college in Texas still in operation. Classes were first conducted in San Antonio's old Main High School building. Under the administration of the University of Texas and in the absence of an appropriation to support the junior college, fees were charged on a quarterly basis. The state attorney general ruled in December 1925 that operation of a junior college by the University of Texas violated the state constitution; thus, supervision of the college, renamed San Antonio Junior College, passed to the San Antonio board of education for the second year of operation. In 1926 the college was assigned part of the building on Alamo Street formerly occupied by the German-English School. James Otis Loftin, president from 1941 to 1955, oversaw the period of the college's greatest growth. San Antonio College was adopted as the official name in 1948, and shortly thereafter the school moved to a thirty-seven-acre campus on San Pedro Avenue. The Alamo Community College District, consisting of San Antonio College, St. Philip's College, and two other campuses, enrolled nearly 49,000 students in the spring of 2003.

Friday, September 20, 2013

Money beats grassroots

The Texas Tribune reports that Debra Medina, who ran as the Tea Party candidate for Texas governor in 2010, is considering running again, but this time to be Tax Assessor.

But a lack of funds may prevent her from doing so:

Four years after emerging as a Tea Party darling, Medina is eyeing the open race to succeed Comptroller Susan Combs. But as she weighs another run, she knows that donations from grass-roots supporters can take a candidate only so far in Texas.
“I’m hesitant to go out to these meetings and say, ‘I’m running,’ because I’m not going to run underfunded,” said Medina, who predicts that grass-roots supporters could provide 30 percent of what she needs for a campaign.
“I think the other 70 percent is going to have to come from high-wealth individuals who fund campaigns in Texas. There, it’s not coming,” Medina said.
Her comments underscore the extent to which wealthy donors play an outsize role in Texas elections, where there are no limits on how much an individual can donate to a candidate for a state office. With the majority of voters spread among several large media markets, running a statewide campaign is prohibitively expensive.

It's a reminder of who determines who wins state-wide office in Texas.


Medina’s campaign for governor came on the heels of the birth of the Tea Party movement. Though Gov. Rick Perry, who ultimately won re-election, quickly embraced many of the movement’s views of limited government, some voters believed it conflicted with his record, and they turned to Medina in the Republican primary, according to Mark Jones, chairman of political science at Rice University in Houston.
“There’s a certain level of support she has out there,” Jones said. “There are people who remember her and identify with that wing of the party.”
In July, Medina reported having $55,000 in her campaign account. Two Republicans already running for comptroller, state Sen. Glenn Hegar, of Katy, and state Rep.Harvey Hilderbran, of Kerrville, reported war chests of $1.8 million and $1 million, respectively. Former state Rep. Raul Torres, a Republican, is also a candidate and Democrat Michael Collier, a retired accountant, has said he may run for the position as well.

From the Atlantic: Here Are the 10 Biggest U.S. Cities by GDP—And How They've Grown Since 2009

According to the story, Houston's GDP grew quicker than that of any of the ten largest cities in the nation since the end of the recession.

Here's proof:



But Houston is still in the middle of the pack in total GDP:



Click here for the source of those numbers.

From the Atlantic: The States That Have Already Recovered From the Great Recession—and the States That Won't Until 201

Texas, New York, and a few others already recovered. Nevada and Michigan wont until 2018.

The oil and finance industries have done well, and the housing boom didn't hit these states as hard as others.


The author draws an interesting comparison between the governing system of the United States and that of the European Union in explaining how a federal system works better than a confederacy in speeding recovery along:

Okay, this is obviously horrible for Nevada, Michigan, and Rhode Island — but so what? It's good when people move from where the jobs aren't to where they are. It's part of what makes a currency union work. See, we don't usually think of it this way, but we live in something called the dollar zone. We have 50 states that share the same language and fiscal policy — and monetary policy too. But, as the euro zone amply shows, the monetary policy that makes sense for one member of a currency union might not make sense for others. So what do you do if one country (or state) is stuck in a depression, and the other is booming? Well, in Europe, nothing. Or, more accurately, blame the country stuck in a depression for being stuck in a depression — and demand that it cut spending like you'd always wanted it to.  

But, in the U.S., states have a few escape hatches from a slump. Or, more accurately, the people do. People can more readily move from a depressed state to a booming one than people can move from, say, Portugal to Germany (although that has happened to an extent). And, remember, the federal government will keep sending out Social Security checks to retirees in Nevada regardless of how many young workers leave the state. That isn't true when young Portuguese workers leave; that just makes its pension picture uglier. It's actually the same problem that U.S. state and municipalities face over state and municipal pensions — losing too many people for too long can leave state and municipal governments staring into too deep budget holes. But, again, at least people don't have to worry about their federal benefits.

What is a continuing resolution?

The NYT provides an overview of the politics associated with the continuing resolution just passed by the US House. The one that also cuts funding for ObamaCare.

But first - what is a continuing resolution (also referred to as continuing appropriations) and why do they matter?

Here's a definition from the US Senate website:
continuing resolution/continuing appropriations - Legislation in the form of a joint resolution enacted by Congress, when the new fiscal year is about to begin or has begun, to provide budget authority for Federal agencies and programs to continue in operation until the regular appropriations acts are enacted.
It all comes down to the budgetary process in the US, and that fact that the Constitution stipulates that money cannot be drawn from the Treasury unless it has been appropriated by law - the is the Appropriations Clause.

Both the House and Senate have Appropriations Committees that oversee this process.

Aside from that - as we will soon see - there is nothing in the Constitution about a budgetary process. One only began to be established in the early years of 20th Century when efforts were made - driven by progressives - to professionalize the governing process. This includes the establishment of Budget Committees in the House and Senate. They are in charge of determining how Congress wants funding to be directed - sort of - because some funding is mandatory. This is referred to as the authorization process of the budgetary process. We will cover this soon enough.

- Here's the Wikipedia on the US budget process.

But none of this really matters here. What matter is the appropriations process and the fact that we are near the end of the fiscal year. What is that? Again, from the Senate:
fiscal year - The fiscal year is the accounting period for the federal government which begins on October 1 and ends on September 30. The fiscal year is designated by the calendar year in which it ends; for example, fiscal year 2013 begins on October 1, 2012 and ends on September 30, 2013. Congress passes appropriations legislation to fund the government for every fiscal year.
- Click here for a CRS report on the process.
- And here for another CRS report - a bit more thorough.

We are coming up on the end of the 2012-2013 fiscal year. That's what the media really refers to when it says that the US government is about to run out of money. In theory, the new fiscal year 2013-2014 cannot begin, or at least money for that period cannot be drawn from the Treasury, unless appropriations bills are passed. These are to provide funding through the next fiscal year.

As we will see when we discuss the budget, this seldom really happens. Conflicts over spending usually result in these bills not being passed in time. So how does the US government get the money it is required to spend due to existing law?

From the continuing resolutions. These are bills that provide short term funding for government when the appropriations bills are not passed. So what the House passed was such a bill, but with a condition - that funding for Obamacare be terminated - which won't happen of course.

We'll follow this over the next couple of weeks. Since war does not appear to be likely with Syria - this is the most exciting stuff we have going on.

The 2003 Texas Redistricting

The case involving Tom Delay stemmed from his efforts to obtain a Republican Majority in the Texas House in the election of 2002, which would have been the first time the Republican Party had controlled the institution since Reconstruction.

Of course it was a very different Republican Party back then - nationalist in outlook and supportive of - Civil Rights.

What made this controversial was that DeLay's intent was to enable the Republican Party to draw new districts for the House of Representatives and give the Republican majority in the House a few extra seats. These are normally only redrawn in the legislative sessions immediately following the census when House seats are reapportioned. The Democratic Party still controlled the Texas Senate though, so Republicans were unable to dominate the redistricting process.

The legislature elected in 2000 was able to draw the US House districts that allowed the Democratic Party to continue to dominate the state delegation - there were 17 Democrats to 15 Republicans. The one elected in 2002 was able to redraw the districts, target certain Democrats - mostly white males - and result in a scheme that elected 21 Republicans and 11 Democrats.

This demonstrates the effectiveness of gerrymandering.

What got DeLay into trouble was that the manner in which donations from corporation were funneled to candidates. Corporate financing for candidates was illegal at that time. Prosecutors argued that DeLay circumvented those rules by funneling corporate money through his account to those of the Texas Senate candidates. The appellate court seems to have argued that these funds were not meant for the campaign, but rather to have access to DeLay.

As we should expect, a Wikipedia page exists that provides an overview of the 2003 redistricting effort.

We will discuss elections in Texas soon enough - this gives us a head start.

Here are more sources:

- The Texas Gerrymander
- Justice staff saw Texas districting as illegal
- The Killer D's
- Sourcewatch

House Republicans pass bill cutting food stamps

This story applies to our discussion of several items in the class including Congress, Separated Powers the Bureaucracy, and Social Welfare policy making in 2305. It also touches on federalism as we cover it in both 2305 and 2306.

- From the Washington Post: House passes GOP plan slash food stamp funding.
- From the NYT: House Republicans pass deep cuts in Food Stamps.
- From the Hill: House votes to cut food stamps by $39 billion.

The bill is H.R. 3102, the Nutrition Reform and Work Opportunity Act. Click here for information on the bill from Thomas.You can also find it here - on govtrack.

We reviewed what the Constitution says about the bill making process in Section 7 of Article 1 and noticed that its says little about what happens within Congress. When we discuss the bill making process we will touch on how it has evolved over time as well as the institutions involved in the bill making process that are not mentioned in the Constitution, most notably committees and parties.

Just so you know, the bill now goes to the Senate and if approved there in the exact same language, it goes to the president for a signature. But this is not going to happen due to the dynamics between the political parties and how these exacerbate the checks and balances.

I'll post a few things below that apply this event to various topics in the class.

Thursday, September 19, 2013

A word on week 4's written assignment

Remember that you are to turn in your paper proposal this week.

I'm still getting questions about what types of topics are acceptable. Remember that you are to draw a topic from your assigned book and dig deeply into it. Develop a critical essay analyzing the topic. Be sure that the topic hits one of the major topics that we cover in class.

I need to repeat a key point: This is not a book report. I don't want to see you paper start of with something like: "insert title" is a book about really great things that happened in Texas."

Find some nuance with the book's content that's worthy of a 1000 word - at least - report. I'll help you fine tune it once you turn it in. I imagine that week 6's report will ask for a revision - then you can start getting the writing out of the way.

I hope this helps.

Remember to write at least 150 words.

What is the Fed doing to pump up the economy and why?

More from Wonkblog:
The Fed is doing two things right now to stimulate the economy. One is holding their interest rates pretty much at 0%. The other is buying $85 billion in housing and treasury bonds each month in order to try and pump money into the economy.
At some point, the Fed intends to begin backing off these policies. But they only want to do it once the economy is strong enough, and even then, they want to do it slowly, so the economy has time to adjust.
To put it differently, rather than cut off their support, they want to "taper" it.
We will discuss both the Federal Reserve and monetary policy on 2305 in a few weeks. Monetary policy refers to - according to Wikipedia -
". . . the process by which the monetary authority of a country controls the supply of money, often targeting a rate of interest for the purpose of promoting economic growth and stability. The official goals usually include relatively stable prices and low unemployment.
Here's a secondary definition:
Monetary policy is the process by which the government, central bank, or monetary authority of a country controls (i) the supply of money, (ii) availability of money, and (iii) cost of money or rate of interest to attain a set of objectives oriented towards the growth and stability of the economy.
The setting of interest rates is a standard part of the fed's toolkit, the purchasing of bonds is not. The purchasing of the bonds has a fancy name: quantitative easing. It means:

. . . an unconventional monetary policy used by central banks to stimulate the national economy when standard monetary policy has become ineffective. A central bank implements quantitative easing by buying specified amounts of financial assets from commercial banks and other private institutions, thus increasing the monetary base. This is distinguished from the more usual policy of buying or selling government bonds in order to keep market interest rates at a specified target value.
The big news this week is that the Fed decided not to cut back on the amount of bonds it is purchasing - that is what "the taper" refers to.

Why? Here's one answer: Because Congress is horrible.

Which fits a theme in 2305 so far - 2306 too, sort of. One of the major differences between the design of the legislative and executive branches in the US Constitution is that Congress' design lends itself to stalemate and dysfunction. This is due to its democratic nature, which is why Congress has done an awful job handling the economy.

The executive has more of an autocratic design, and many of its agencies - the Federal Reserve included - are designed to be able to act swiftly to address problems they have been designated to address. For that reason the Federal Reserve has been in a much better position to grow the economy than Congress. Its the nature of the beast.

From Wonkblog: Nine questions about the Federal Reserve you were too embarrassed to ask

This is a very good primer for an upcoming discussion in 2305 about economic policy, as well as the nature of bureaucratic power.

It includes very simple answers to very simple question about the Federal Reserve, its duties, the job of the chairman and what its been up to recently.

From the Monkey Cage: Will the Media Treat Navy Yard Like Newtown?

When events - like the recent Navy Yard shooting - occur, usually there is a call for some type of response. A look through the history of significant pieces of legislation shows that quite often their passage follows some type of event which created a window of opportunity for the passage of the law. Often the media plays a role because they highlight the issue and keeps it on the minds of both the public and of public officials

But that seems less and less the case with stories about gun control following mass shooting.

Monkey Cage contributor Danny Hayes shows how media attention to gun control waned quickly after the Sandy Hook shooting and is likely to do the same after the Navy Yard shooting.

hayes

Like with other shootings, gun control coverage increased dramatically after the Newtown massacre, but tailed off within a few weeks. But in contrast to other cases, gun control arrived back on the front page in early January, when President Obama issued a series of executive actions intended to reduce gun violence.

The president’s influence, however immediate, was short-lived, as media attention fell off through the early spring. It was only in April – when a Senate bill to expand background checks failed to surmount a filibuster – that the issue gained prominence again.

Since the bill’s demise, gun control has largely disappeared from debates on Capitol Hill – and with it, the news. While advocates have continued to push for change at both the state and federal levels (with one group coincidentally on lobbying trip to Washington this week), the national media’s interest has continued to wane. Even Giffords’ nationwide tour in July failed to stop the slide.

This pattern suggests that only if Sen. Dianne Feinstein gets her way, with Congress taking up gun control legislation once again, will a renewed media debate over gun control occur. If political leaders in Washington decide the issue isn’t worth pursuing, the media are likely to turn their attention elsewhere – whether back to Syria, the next NSA intelligence-gathering revelation, or the looming battle over the debt ceiling.

This suggests that gun control is less likely to be passed into law because it is less likely to get on, and stay on, the public's and Congress' agenda.

From the NYT: The Money Behind the Shutdown Crisis

The NYT editorializes on one of the causes of dysfunction in Congress - the fact that conservative interest groups increasingly target Republican member of Congress who are not conservative enough, and who have shown a willingness to make compromises.

Representative Aaron Schock is a conservative Republican from Illinois, but not conservative enough for the hard-right activist group Club for Growth, which is seeking someone to run against him in next year’s primary.
His crime? In 2011, he voted to increase the debt ceiling, and, in 2012, he voted for a stopgap spending bill that prevented a government shutdown. In neither case did he demand the defunding of health care reform.
Club for Growth and other extremist groups consider a record like his an unforgivable failure, and they are raising and spending millions to make sure that no Republicans will take similar positions in the next few weeks when the fiscal year ends and the debt limit expires.
If you’re wondering why so many House Republicans seem to believe they can force President Obama to accept a “defunding” of the health care reform law by threatening a government shutdown or a default, it’s because these groups have promised to inflict political pain on any Republican official who doesn’t go along.

When we discuss elections in future classes, we will look at arguments that the primary election process has evolved into a mechanism for rewarding extremism and punishing moderation. This editorial provides evidence.

Wednesday, September 18, 2013

What is a government shutdown?

Now that Syria is off the radar screen - for now - attention is turning to a more predictable crisis: the looming government shut down.

This comes at a convenient time because we will be discussing the budgeting process very soon.

You may need a primer on this, so here's the obligatory Wikipedia entry on government shutdown, CNN has a guide to it, and the Washington Post lists 5 reasons why its likely to happen.

Simply put its a negotiating tactic that can be used by one side that wants to force concessions from another by refusing to allow for any spending at all if the concession is not met. It can be effectively the end of the budgetary cycle - when a new budget has to passed and money appropriated to fund governmental projects - or when the budget ceiling is about to be hit.

Both of those are looming right now. Tea Party Republicans are using this scenario to try to force Democrats to defund ObamaCare. If not - no spending so the government shuts down.

We will go over the budget process and the political issues associated with the shutdown in the coming weeks. in the meantime here are freaky slides showing the process.

Thursday, September 12, 2013

Meet the Unites States Election Assistance Commission

The article linked to in the previous story mentions this agency, so here's a link to it.

Politifact Texas weigh in on the claim that 500 registered Republicans are moving into Texas each day.

They call the claim half true.

Quick comment: This might be good for the Republican Party in the state, which doesn't really need it, but not for the Republican Part in the states where those Republicans are leaving. It could well weaken the party nationally.

Written Assignment #4

As I suggested already, I want you to propose a topic for your 1000 word critical essay. I want you to draw the subject matter out of your assigned book. By now I hope you've purchased it and at least skimmed through the contents. Ideally the subject will integrate the book's topic with one the themes we cover in class.

I'll work with you to refine your topic. The more work you do now, the less work you will have to do later.

One note of caution: I don't want a book report.

This will be due September 23rd.

"Constitutional War Powers"

I've had a few distressed 2305 students come into my office claiming they can't find material for week 3's question.

I just googled the title above and found lots of good stuff. Try it. Here's a choice few:

- CFR: Balance of Wars Powers: The U.S. President and War Powers.
- Garrett Epps: The Power Obama Does not have.
- LII: War Powers.
- War Powers and the Use of Force in Syria.
- War and Treat Making Power.

You should be able to craft a good response from this material.

The "fundamental principle of equal sovereignty among the states"

Some Justice Steven's remarks in the story below touch on points made in 2305. As we look through the principles embedded in the original document as ratified, not as amended, we've noted that there's very little about equality. And there wouldn't be until after the Civil War and the inclusion of the 14th Amendment.

But its argued that while there was no recognition of the equality of the people, there is one of the states, largely because they each have equal representation in the Senate. At least that's what the majority of court in the Shelby decision argued, and Steven says it formed the basis of their decision.

He disagrees with that argument and says the Constitution did not create equal sovereignty because the 3/5ths compromise tipped the balance of power towards the slave states - he calls it the slave bonus. While the states are still sovereign entities, they are not equal:

The Court’s heavy reliance on the importance of a “fundamental principle of equal sovereignty among the States,” while supported by language in an earlier opinion by Chief Justice Roberts, ignored the fact that Article I, Section 2 of the Constitution created a serious inequality among the states. That clause counted “three fifths” of a state’s slaves for the purpose of measuring the size of its congressional delegation and its representation in the Electoral College. That provision was offensive because it treated African-Americans as though each of them was equal to only three fifths of a white person, but it was even more offensive because it increased the power of the southern states by counting three fifths of their slaves even though those slaves were not allowed to vote. The northern states would have been politically better off if the slave population had been simply omitted from the number used to measure the voting power of the slave states.

The fact that this “slave bonus” created a basic inequality between the slave states and the free states has often been overlooked, as has its far-reaching impact. In 1800, for example, that bonus determined the outcome of the presidential election since it then gave the southern states an extra nine or ten votes in the Electoral College, and Thomas Jefferson prevailed over John Adams by only eight electoral votes. Because of the slave bonus, Adams served only one term as president.

The slave bonus unfairly enhanced the power of the southern states in Congress throughout the period prior to the Civil War. It was after the war that Section 2 of the Fourteenth Amendment, passed in 1868, put an end to the slave bonus. When the Fifteenth Amendment was ratified in 1870 during the Grant administration, the size of the southern states’ congressional delegations was governed by the number of citizens eligible to vote. Since that number included blacks as well as whites, during Reconstruction those states were no longer overrepresented in either Congress or the Electoral College.

Note that he points out that one of the Civil War amendments was responsible for ending the slave bonus and providing equality to the states under the Constitution. That fits one of the basic arguments we make in class - at least in 2305.

This is also a question that touches heavily on items we hit in 2306 when we discussed the role of states in the constitutional system. Does the Constitution guarantee that they be treated equally? There is no explicit language making that case.

Here's more on equal sovereignty:

- Chief Justice Robert's Paean to . . .
- How did we get the principle of equal sovereignty . . .
- Do the states have the right to be treated equally?
- Blue states should get a refund under equal sovereignty.
- The Dignity of the South.

Wednesday, September 11, 2013

Retired Justice John Paul Stevens weigh in on the right to vote

He reviews a book on the Voting Rights Act and uses it weigh in on the court's decision this summer in Shelby County v Holder. He is critical of it.

This might be helpful to 2306 students working on week 3's written assignment.



The rich are getting richer.

The NYT provides proof.

The Dish weighs in.

The top 10 percent of earners took more than half of the country’s total income in 2012, the highest level recorded since the government began collecting the relevant data a century ago, according to an updated study by the prominent economists Emmanuel Saez and Thomas Piketty.

The top 1 percent took more than one-fifth of the income earned by Americans, one of the highest levels on record since 1913, when the government instituted an income tax.

What's fixed and what isn't five years after the crash?

Wonkblog reminds us that the fifth anniversary of the crash of Lehman Brothers is looming. The Treasury Department has issued a slew of graphs showing what has happened since.

- The Financial Crisis Five Years Later.

There's good news and bad of course.

Here's a couple years worth of the crisis in one graph:

Source: Treasury Department


Totally gratuitous photograph of Donald Trump's hair

 

Someone in class today thought Justice Hecht's hair - look below - reminded him of Donald Trump's. Maybe. But the double comb over - quadruple comb over if you believe this diagram - is tough to match. 

Tuesday, September 10, 2013

The debt ceiling will be hit somewhere between October 19 and November 5

Good times.

From Wonkblog:

That’s according to a new analysis from the Bipartisan Policy Center. At some point in those two weeks, the Treasury Department will have exhausted all its options and will no longer have enough money to meet its financial obligations. Either Congress lifts the debt ceiling or the federal government will have to default on some of its bills.
The BPC calls this the “X Date”:
debtXdate



Judgepedia assessment of the political ideology of state supreme court justices

For your amusement - and for an upcoming look at state courts.


The big surprise is that Texas is only the third most conservative state court. Behind the two Dakotas.

Governor Perry names replacement for Chief Justice Jefferson



It's Justice Nathan Hecht. Hecht was not a Perry appointee to the court. He was elected in 1988 and has been re-elected four times.

More on Justice Hecht:

- Judgepedia.
- Texas Tribune.
- Wikipedia.
- News about Hecht.

Going Public on Syria

When we talk about the increase of presidential power over time, we will point out that increasingly powerful media technology has allowed presidents to attempt to mobilize public opinion in his favor. The term used to describe this is "going public" and it refers to a type of presidential leadership that has developed in the past two or three decades and involves presidents making direct appeals to the public primarily rather than Congress, and event tries to use the public as leverage against Congress.

President Obama attempted to do so tonight with a speech from the White House. The NYT details the speech here.

The problem for presidents in the contemporary environment is that their opponents have the same ability to get their messages out. Going public may have worked best in a simpler media environment where it was difficult to get a message out. That's less the case in this age of Facebook and Twitter.

For 2305 - Catching up with Federalist #10



I have a strong hunch that students don't appreciate Federalist 10 as much as I do, and that reading through the thing is a mundane exercise, but I think its important that you read at least one of the Federalist Papers all the way through at some point in your life. We will do the same for 51 soon enough as well as touch on the arguments in a handful of others.

Remember that this section introduces us to the first of the principles embedded within the original Constitution - republicanism - which refers to the fact that we are an indirect democracy. While the people retain sovereignty, their influence lies in having influence over who holds positions in a variety of governing institutions, specifically Congress, the presidency and the courts. James Madison argues that this arrangement allows both for retaining the principles of self government and for providing the stability necessary for maintaining the republic. This, he argues, is an improvement over previous constitutional arrangements.

As we read through the document I want you to note Madison's assessment of human nature and how he claims the constitutional design compensates for it. It is in our nature to form into groups that promote our understanding of our self interest. It is also in our nature to come into conflict with each other. We create groups in order to pursue our self interest at the expense of that of others. It's not a rosy picture, but it becomes useful one because it allows him to argue that a large republic prevents a tyrannical majority to control the government. Its an interesting approach because instead of arguing that people can be made better, it assumes human nature is a constant, but that this allows for its use to achieve an important objective.

I'll throw out a few other comments about this paper later, as well as the others that will be used to illustrate central principles within the document, but here is a link to past stories I thought illustrate Madison's argument. It might help with class discussion, especially whether Madison's beliefs about the formations of groups are in fact accurate. Mutual interests do not always lead to the creation of equally powerful groups.

Is Houston America's next great global city?

Yes, according to the authors of this analysis of the regional economies in the US. They argue that the US contains seven distinct regions and three city states" Los Angeles, New York and Miami.

Houston it the capital of the Third Coast. Click here for a map. 
Once a sleepy, semitropical backwater, the Third Coast, which stretches along the Gulf of Mexico from south Texas to western Florida, has come out of the recession stronger than virtually any other region. Since 2001, its job base has expanded 7%, and it is projected to grow another 18% the coming decade.
The energy industry and burgeoning trade with Latin America are powering the Third Coast, combined with a relatively low cost, business-friendly climate. By 2023 its capital–Houston–will be widely acknowledged as America’s next great global city. Many other cities across the Gulf, including New Orleans and Corpus Christi, are also major energy hubs. The Third Coast has a concentration of energy jobs five times the national rate, and those jobs have an average annual salary of $100,000, according to EMSI.
As the area gets wealthier, The Third Coast’s economy will continue to diversify. Houston, which is now the country’s most racially and ethnically diverse metro area, according to a recent Rice study, is home to the world’s largest medical center and has dethroned New York City as the nation’s leading exporter. Mobile, Ala., seems poised to become an industrial center and locus for trade with Latin America, and New Orleans has made a dramatic comeback as a cultural and business destination since Katrina.

The Pacificus-Helvidius Debate

Despite the fact that James Madison and Alexander Hamilton worked together on both the drafting of the Constitution and the campaign to get it ratified, they soon started to disagree with each other over aspects of the document - including the relative powers of the legislative and executive branches over foreign policy making, including war making powers.

Like the Federalist Papers, this argument was carried out in dueling essays, this time Madison and Hamilton were on opposing sides of the issue.

They were called the Pacificus-Helvidius Debates.

Here's a description of the debates from the Liberty Fund:

The Pacificus-Helvidius Debates of 1793–1794 matched Hamilton and Madison in the first chapter of an enduring discussion about the proper roles of executive and legislative branches in the conduct of American foreign policy. Ignited by President Washington’s Neutrality Proclamation of 1793, which annulled the eleventh article of America’s Treaty with France of 1778, the debate addressed whether Washington had the authority to declare America neutral, despite an early alliance treaty with France. Hamilton argued that Washington’s actions were constitutional and that friction between the two branches was an unavoidable, but not harmful, consequence of the separation of powers. Madison countered that Washington’s proclamation would introduce “new principles and new constructions” into the Constitution and contended that “the power to declare war and make treaties can never fall within the definition of executive powers.” In the introduction, Morton Frisch asserts that the debate between Hamilton and Madison helped to clarify “certain constitutional principles that we now associate with executive power generally” such as that foreign policy is essentially an executive function. Yet it is the open-ended character of our Constitution that has continued to allow different interpretations of the limits of the powers of government, a debate that continues to this day. Frisch writes in the introduction, “The open-ended character of some of the constitutional provisions afforded opportunities for extending the powers of government beyond their specified limits. Although not given prior sanction by the Constitutional Convention, such additions served to provide a more complete definition of powers without actually changing the ends of government.”

Click here for more on the debates. I find it interesting - and instructive - that we've been arguing about the nature of war making powers as long as we have.

From Quorum Report: Texas Craft Dislillers Toast Their Successful Lobbying Effort

This seems to be one dispute most people in the Texas Legislature could agree one. It also provides an example of one smaller industry group that was able to expand its influence over the bigger players. Not sure if that's just because people liked what they produced. Maybe.

The fight over whether to expand the rights of microbreweries in Texas was a well-covered flashpoint during the regular session this year. But, perhaps not as well-noted was the successful lobbying effort by small distilleries to be able to market their products in new ways that they say will help their industry grow. That’s why they along with their “champions” in the legislature on Tuesday afternoon officially kicked off the state’s first-ever Craft Spirits Month, something we at QR are happy to raise a glass to. Bourbon in Mr. Braddock’s, please. Vodka for Mr. Kronberg.

A slate of bills loosening regulations on small distillers passed the Lege and were all signed by Gov. Perry, the most significant of which may have been Senate Bill 905. That new law allows distillers to sell their product to consumers for off-premise consumption up to 3,500 gallons annually, with some restrictions. They'll also be able to make on-premise sales of spirits up to 3,000 gallons per year.

Daniel Barnes, owner and founder of Treaty Oak Distilling in Austin, said he felt the enactment of these new laws is going to be beneficial to his industry as well as the Texas economy overall. “It would be a huge understatement” to say that this is an exciting time for distillers in Texas, he said. Craft bottles and cocktails will be able to be sold directly to the public, which they could not previously do on-site.
Rep. John Kuempel, R-Seguin, hailed the loosened regulations as a way to put distilleries in Texas on an even playing field with out-of-state players who have long had a leg up on those who make whiskey, bourbon, vodka, and other spirits in the Lone Star State. “This industry did not exist in our state 20 years ago,” Kuempel said. “This industry has the potential for even more growth,” he said while noting that the Texas Package Stores Association and Texas Restaurant Association worked together with others to make the new laws become reality.
Sen. Leticia Van de Putte, D-San Antonio, said the work that went into crafting this legislation was time-consuming but worth it. She said that stakeholders came together in meetings for about a year and a half, and their efforts resulted in about 30 pieces of proposed legislation. She said the handful of bills that became law represented the best of the ideas that came about as a result of those talks. And, she added, that she could not have filed and passed more than 30 bills “even during a great session.”

Kuempel said that Sen. Van de Putte told him after she passed the bills through the Senate, his job was to take care of them in the House and that was not to be taken lightly. At the time, she told him that handing the bills off to him to be their caretaker in the House was a bit like dropping kids off at school and hoping they make it home okay. “That is the perfect way to do that,” Kuempel said.

Some random items on Syria

From Foreign Policy: The War Precedent.

- The author review recent history regarding presidential war powers.

From Breaking Defense: A Limited Strike on Syria?

- The author questions the effectiveness of limited strikes and wonders if a limited strike on Syria will be truly limited.

From The Atlantic: Your Labor Day Syria Reader.

- The author highlights commentary from an analyst with expertise on the Middle East that tries to determine what we know and don;t know about the chemical attack in Syria.

Notes on 2306 Week Two

Like 2305 - we're a bit off kilter due to Labor Day, but you should to keep track on your own.

The big point behind last week's material was that Texas exists within a federal and cultural landscape that creates multiple opportunities for conflict between the state and nation.

The first set of powers points took us back to the US Constitution and highlighted those areas that pertain to the creation of new states, the obligations states have to each other and the relative relationship between the national and state governments. This of course was after a reminder that delegates of twelve of the original states (Rhode Island did not participate in the convention) created the constitution - as well as its predecessor. So the states wrestled with the proper design of the national government, and as we know the first option was to establish a very very weak one, and the second was to establish one on equal par - at least in terms of sovereignty - with the states.

This isn't to say that the design is not without its confusing aspects, especially once amendments are added - notably the 14th - which create tension between the two levels of government. I tried to highlight those areas where that tension arises. In retrospects I don't think I've given sufficient time to the Supremacy Clause (I'm a bit of a 14th Amendment freak), but no need to concerns yourself with that at the moment.

Try to come to grips with the legal and constitutional sources of the conflict between the national and state governments and much of what is in the news regarding that conflict ought to make a bit more sense.

The same with the section on political culture. Its one thing to say that Texas is unique and that this leads to conflict, but quite another - and better - thing to understand why those conflicts exist. As with most classes on state government, we use Daniel Elazar's three part typology of political culture in order to trace the roots of the individualistic and traditionalistic cultures, and explain why Texas lacks a strong moralistic culture.

Again, and understanding of these concepts should go a long way to helping us understand the roots of the conflict we see between Texas and the national government.

As you probably have already noticed - hopefully - this week is devoted to understanding the argument presented in the Texas Declaration of Independence, and the evolving nature of the constitutions of Texas, culminating in the 1876 Constitution. In order to properly understand the governing system in the state, its a good idea to understand its foundation.

A bit more on the history of the Declaration of Independence

This is copied and pasted from the Library of Congress page on the Declaration of Independence.

It shows dates related to the document's creation and publication.
  • June 7 - Richard Henry Lee introduced a resolution urging Congress to declare independence from Great Britain.
  • June 11 - Thomas Jefferson, John Adams, Benjamin Franklin, Roger Sherman, and Robert R. Livingston were appointed to a committee to draft a declaration of independence.
  • June 28 - A fair copy of the committee draft of the Declaration of Independence was read in Congress.
  • July 1-4 - Congress debated and revised the Declaration of Independence.
  • July 2 - Congress declared independence by adopting the Lee Resolution.
  • July 4 - Congress adopted the Declaration of Independence.
  • July 4 - Congress ordered that the Declaration of Independence be printed (Dunlap Broadsides).
  • July 19 - Congress ordered the Declaration of Independence engrossed (officially inscribed) and signed by members.
  • August 2 - The engrossed copy of the Declaration of Independence was signed by most of the delegates. Elbridge Gerry, Oliver Wolcott, Lewis Morris, Thomas McKean, and Matthew Thornton all signed on a later date.
Here are a few more links with history related to the document - in case you find this sort of thing interesting.I do.

- Wikipedia: John Dunlap.
- Publishing and Publicizing the Declaration of Independence.
- Federal Legislation Establishing the Fourth of July Holiday.
- History of the Declaration of Independence.
- Facts about the Declaration.

Notes on 2305 Week Two

Labor Day threw us off a bit. MW classes only met once so this week is devoted to catching up in the classroom - though I fully expect that you're up to date on your own reading.

The point behind last week was to become familiar with the layout of the two principle documents in the founding of the US - the Declaration of Independence and the Constitution. This included an appreciation of the history that lead up to each.

I've always thought that its tough to understand the merit of the argument - the novelty of it even - in the Declaration without understanding the historical shifts contained within it. The first being that power is properly based on the consent of the governed, not the will of the divinely placed monarch. The second that the consolidation of power is the definition of tyranny. Together these two points were meant to justify something that normally is difficult. The overthrow of one governing system for another.

This is always worth considering when people get frustrated with a governing system and start calling for "revolution." Do current circumstances rise to the level here overthrow is warranted, or are those really "light and transient causes" which Jefferson rejected.

Last fall I had 2305 students address a written assignment on that subject. There were some very upset people after Obama got re-elected last year who wanted to secede. I asked students to compare their rationale with those of the North American colonists. I'll try to dig up some of the answers, but I thought it was a good exercise - probably still is.

I'm not sure how well I was able to describe the political conflict that emerged over what type of constitutional system should govern the nation - and what the very nature of the "nation" was. A confederacy? A unitary system" A hybrid? Remember that constitutions embody the politics of a given era. When we start discussing politics more carefully, we'll discuss how politics today is a reflection of the politics of that era.

As you know, once we look at the overview of the Constitution, we will dig into various aspects of it. That's where we will be heading soon.

The US and Texas militaries conflict over offering benefits to same-sex spouses.

This is the same conflict we see in other areas regarding same-sex issues.

Following a recent Supreme Court decision overturning part of the Defense of Marriage Act, the Obama Administration judged that a rule banning same sex spouses from receiving benefits could not be enforced. So VA's across the country - including Texas and other states banning same-sex marriage - have to provide them.

But the Texas Military Forces (yes there is such a thing) do not - and cannot according to Texas statutory and constitutional law. So any of their members with same-sex spouses cannot receive benefits in Texas facilities. They can received them in federal facilities.

There's a hitch however. When called to active duty, the Texas Military falls under control of the federal government, at which same-sex spouses have to be provided benefits. But the conflict remains, and a handful of Democratic legislators in the state have asked the attorney general to reconcile state and federal law.

More for 2306's look at federalism and the conflict that stems from it.

Story in the Texas Tribune.

Monday, September 9, 2013

San Antonio v Texas

I don't have nearly enough on conflict between the state and local government, though there's plenty of material.

The latest is the conflict between the city of San Antonio - which recently passed an ordinance adding lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender people to the city's non-discrimination code. - and Texas Attorney General Greg Abbott, who has stated that he might sue the city based on his belief that the law is an unconstitutional violation the rights of speech and religion.

It is often suggested that the major cities in the state of Texas are more liberal than the state as a whole. The fact that they tend to be more tolerant of alternative lifestyles is evidence. Abbott is running for governor, so its safe to assume that anything he does as attorney general is done with an eye towards the governor's mansion. Will a specific activity help enhance his support among the groups he is hoping to back his campaign? Those groups do not necessarily have the same pull in the major cities.

The NYT provides some detail for the conflict. most of it seems tied into the politics surrounding next year's statewide elections than the substance of the ordinance:

All of the major statewide elected positions are open contests in the Republican primary. And while voters do not head to the polls until March, many Republicans seeking statewide office have seized on San Antonio’s ordinance in what some see as a way to appeal to the grass-roots conservatives who make up the bulk of the electorate in the party’s Texas primaries.
“It is Republican statewide candidates signaling their base that they are true and trustworthy conservatives,” said Calvin Jillson, a political science professor at Southern Methodist University in Dallas. “When you’re running for statewide office, you don’t control what the San Antonio mayor and Council do. So all you’re really doing is taking an ideological position that you then project toward the Republican primary electorate, so that they can see that you’re a social conservative and you are manning the ramparts against undesirable social change.”
For background on local non discrimination ordinances across the nation click here.









Sunday, September 8, 2013

Texas Supreme Court Chief Justice Wallace Jefferson Resigns

As is customary, he leaves office prior to completing his term so that the governor gets to appoint a replacement. Jefferson (Texas' first African-American Chief Justice) himself was appointed by Governor Perry in 2001 to replace Alberto Gonzales.

From the USA Today:


Jefferson, who earns $170,000 annually, said he does not have another job lined up but hopes to continue working on judicial policy in a way that helps Texas residents.
"I want to remain open to possibilities, work that is challenging, that is meaningful, that will give me time to continue to serve the public in some fashion as a private citizen," he said.
Gov. Rick Perry appointed Jefferson to the high court in 2001, when former Justice Alberto Gonzales stepped down to become White House counsel to President George W. Bush. Jefferson won election in November 2002. Perry selected him as chief justice in 2004, and he was elected to the lead the court in Austin in 2006 and 2008. His current term runs through 2014.
Perry's office did not immediately comment Tuesday about a possible replacement. Jefferson, who is married with three sons in college, high school and middle school, said he told Perry of his plans to step down last week.
During his tenure, Jefferson has pushed for making courts more public with documents available online.
Jefferson, who formerly was in private practice in San Antonio, said he hopes that the state's courts get more direct public funding for legal aid and continuing juvenile justice reforms. He also said he hopes judges and justices stay engaged in issues affecting the state.
His resignation gives the governor another opportunity to influence the judiciary since he gets to appoint his replacement. 13 years in office has given the governor plenty of opportunity to put his stamp on the judiciary, though his ability to in fact do so has been subject to debate.

Some background:

- Supreme Court is elected but bears Perry's stamp.
- Judges appointed by Rick Perry.
- In Judicial Picks, Perry reaches Past Executive Branch.
- Perry's Texas Supreme Court picks criticized as too business friendly.
- Rick Perry and the Imperial Governorship.