Friday, September 9, 2011

Is Horse Race Journalism Unfairly Maligned?

The political press is commonly criticized for simply focusing on the horse race aspect of presidential campaigns and ignoring policy proposals and other aspects of it, but here is a defense of that approach. This type of jouranism may be necessary in the early stages of a campaign - the invisible primary (or the money primary) - when many decisions regarding which candidates should run and who will work and provide monetary support for them are done out of sight.

. . . primary elections are different. A primary campaign, and especially its early “invisible” period, can be understood as a time when party leaders—in other words, “insiders”—talk to, and argue with, each other about who their standard-bearer should be. Many factors go into that choice, from perceptions about electability to petty personal considerations. But the argument is, in large part, a contest over who wields power within the party, and what sort of values and goals the party wants to prioritize.