Thursday, February 27, 2014

The Top 21 Sources of Legislative History

This might be of interest to 2305 students since we are now looking at the judiciary and also discussing how the courts go about the business of interpreting the Constitution and statutory law.

One things some judges and justices look to - though some discount it - is legislative history. This helps judges understand what legislators were trying to accomplish when they passed a law they might be reviewing.

The blog of Nicholas J. Wagoner - which appears to be dormant - runs through the top 21 places judges may look to seek out legislative history.

- Click here for a description.

In order of importance they are:
  1. Conference Committee Reports
  2. Committee Debates and Bill Mark-ups
  3. Committee Reports
  4. The Status of the Person Speaking—Sponsor, Committee Chairman, Floor Leader, Etc.
  5. Accepted and Rejected Amendments
  6. Floor Debates
  7. Planned Colloquy
  8. Transcripts of Discussions at Committee Hearings
  9. Prepared Statements on Submission of a Bill, in Committee Hearings, and at the Time of Floor Debates
  10. Revised and Amended Statements
  11. Actions on and Discussions About Separate Bills on the Same Topic
  12. Prior Relevant Administrative Action or Judicial Decisions, with or without Congressional Acknowledgement
  13. Executive Branch Messages and Proposals Whether from the President, Cabinet Secretaries, or from Independent Agencies
  14. Analysis of Bills by Legislative Counsel
  15. Analysis of Bills by Relevant Executive Departments
  16. Related Statutes, Provisions, and Terms (click here)
  17. Dictionaries (click here)
  18. Statements by Executive Branch Administrators (click here)
  19. Statements and Submissions by Lobbyists (click here)
  20. Subsequent or Prior Unrelated, but Conflicting Legislation (click here)
  21. Recorded Votes