Thursday, April 15, 2010

Framing Democracy

George Lakoff highlights a great example of framing effects. The lesson is: Ballot language matters a great deal. For 2301s, this further confuses whether poll results necessarily reflect public opinion.

A Defense of a Living Constitution

2302s take note: The author argues that the Constitution was intended to be interpreted loosely and claims that it can be strictly (neutrally) interpreted are false:

For 30 years, conservative commentators have persuaded the public that conservative judges apply the law, whereas liberal judges make up the law. According to Chief Justice John Roberts, his job is just to “call balls and strikes.” According to Justice Antonin Scalia, conservative jurists merely carry out the “original meaning” of the framers. These are appealing but wholly disingenuous descriptions of what judges — liberal or conservative — actually do.

To see why this is so, we need only look to the text of the Constitution. It defines our most fundamental rights and protections in open-ended terms: “freedom of speech,” for example, and “equal protection of the laws,” “due process of law,” “unreasonable searches and seizures,” “free exercise” of religion and “cruel and unusual punishment.” These terms are not self-defining; they did not have clear meanings even to the people who drafted them. The framers fully understood that they were leaving it to future generations to use their intelligence, judgment and experience to give concrete meaning to the expressed aspirations.

Rulings by conservative justices in the past decade make it perfectly clear that they do not “apply the law” in a neutral and detached manner. Consider, for example, their decisions holding that
corporations have the same right of free speech as individuals, that commercial advertising receives robust protection under the First Amendment, that the Second Amendment prohibits the regulation of guns, that affirmative action is unconstitutional, that the equal protection clause mandated the election of George W. Bush and that the Boy Scouts have a First Amendment right to exclude gay scoutmasters.

Whatever one thinks of these decisions, it should be apparent that conservative judges do not disinterestedly call balls and strikes. Rather, fueled by their own political and ideological convictions, they make value judgments, often in an aggressively activist manner that goes well beyond anything the framers themselves envisioned.

Wednesday, April 14, 2010

More Polling on Tea Party Identifiers

A NYT poll finds that Tea Party identifiers are older, better educated and more Anglo than the general population. They are also more likely to be male married, and to believe that Obama's policies benefit the poor at the expense of the rich and middle class. Full results are available here.

A separate poll find that identifiers hold more negative views of minority groups than does the general population.

More on Stevens and the First Amendment

A civil libertarian takes him to task for his support of a Texas law banning flag burning.

Explaining the Ideological Drift of Supreme Court Justices

Stuart Taylor gives it a good try. Yes, he says, Stevens has in fact gone to the left. The court hasn't simply shifted to the right. He argues that part of the reason Republican justices turn liberal more than Democratic justices turn conservative is that the nature of the news sources, interest groups and auxiliary organizations that surround the courts reward liberal rulings over conservative ones.

Perhaps the Supreme Court isn't as independent as we think.

Sick Today - 4/14/10

I'm feeling sick today and won't be able to make it in. Hopefully a note has been posted by now on the door, but if you are in my 8am class and get this in time, please make asure everyone else knows.

I've posted a revised schedule on the wiki, so please check that out.

thanks, and sorry for the incovenience, but you don't want what I have.

Tuesday, April 13, 2010

How To Become a Regent in Texas

You can start by contributing to Governor Perry's campaign.

This is one of the reasons why some executive agencies in the Texas Constitution were designed to be elected, not appointed. Appointed positions allow for governors to accumulate power.

Independent Conservative Republicans of Texas

Texas Senator Dan Patrick has announced a new organization, the Independent Conservative Republicans of Texas, which is invitation only and composed of Republican state legislators who share certain principles highlighted by the organization. They have identified themselves with the Tea Party movement.

Commentators have noted that the group does not include House Speaker Joe Straus who was elected Speaker with the overwhelming support of House Democrats. Will this group help or hurt Republicans as they try to maintain cohesion through the November elections? Is this another attempt by conservative Republicans to purge the party of moderates?

Read up on some commentary
- here.
- here.

The Overton Window

I've never heared of this before.

The Overton Window refers to a strategy -- used by politicians to influence public response to policy proposals, but almost certainly useful to most of us -- where a clearly unacceptable option is presented to the public first, with the hope that a second option would be seen as being more acceptable, and more acceptable had that second option been presented first.

Suppose in order to balance the budget, taxes have to be raised 5%. The public will not want that to happen. But suppose that the the first proposal presented is a 15% tax increase. Opposition would be heated, but as a compromise, a 5% increase will be accepted because it seems palatable by comparison.

Nate Silver argues that this might be happening in the names Obama is floating for potential Supreme Court picks.

Congressional Hispanic Caucus Pressures Obama to Move on Immigration Reform

Story in the National Journal.

Democrats believe that even if the bill does not pass this session, the issue will help split the Republican Party. Republican business interests tend to like the cheap labor, but grassroots activists see newly arrived immigrants as a threat to themselves and to national sovereignty in general.

Democrats also almost certainly hope for violent opposition by Republican grassroots -- perhaps the Tea Partiers? - that they can use to solidify Latino support for Democrats and mobilize the community to vote in November. The goal of the Republican leadership will be to contain the grassroots, but this has proven difficult to do.

The Fractured Obama Coalition

National Journal reports (in a subscriber only post) that tensions exist within the Democratic Party since Obama has yet to act on issues of concern to some of his electoral supporters, notably Latinos. They point out that while the health care bill was passing, 250,000 Latinos were protesting - in DC - inattention to immigration reform:

But hours earlier on the National Mall, another group had gathered -- a boisterous crowd estimated at 250,000 -- to urge Obama to fulfill his promise to enact comprehensive immigration reform. You didn't have to be an intrepid reporter to pick up on a deep sense of disappointment -- and even betrayal -- that the president had not done more to advance the goal of bringing 11 million immigrants out of the shadows and giving them a pathway to citizenship.

Latinos had backed Obama 2-to-1 over Republican nominee John McCain in the 2008 presidential election, and their votes had made the difference in Colorado, Florida, Nevada, and New Mexico, all states that President Bush carried in 2004. "People are really, really upset. I have never seen it so bad," said Salvador Reza, a veteran activist and immigration reform advocate who arrived at the Mall after traveling 14 days in a caravan from Phoenix. "President Obama is in danger of losing the Latino vote, either because they won't go to the polls for him next time or they might vote for somebody else as a protest."

It is ironic that at the very moment Obama is ready for a victory lap, he instead faces a major political detour. Ire is rising within the broad coalition of activists -- including that crowd on the Mall -- that helped him win the first majority vote for a Democratic president since Jimmy Carter in 1976. They are frustrated and angry that he has neglected their priorities. Obama can no longer count on them to remain reflexively in his corner.


Similar sentiments are being expressed by women's, labor, and gay and lesbian groups. If these groups do not show up in 2010, Republican gains are guaranteed. I would expect to see at least token action begun on issues important to each constituency and will note them when they happen.

The Southern Republican Leadership Conference

Southern Republicans met in New Orleans over the weekend to strengthen party cohesion, work on strategies for the 2010 and 2012 elections, and listen to an evaluate current and future party candidates and leaders. While the party has surged recently and is expected to do well in the midterm elections, questions still exist about the degree to which party activists are pulling the entire party (perhaps too far) to the right.

Even if this is a successful strategy in the short run, does it marginalize the party in the future? A party can't win elections consistently if it comprised mostly of conservative, older whites. They are motivated, and tend to turn out in droves, but they represent a shrinking percentage of the overall population. The (possible) irony is that if this group defines the national Republican Party, it may drive moderates away, especially if the economy begins to improve and if animosity about health care reform ebbs.

Some comments:
- Five lessons from GOP's Southern gathering‎
- Republicans' Southern Comforts‎
- Lessons From the Republican Leadership Conference
- Republicans predict November gains, blast Obama‎

The Southern Republican Leadership Conference Straw Poll Results

Nate Silver comments on the validity of the results (a narrow Mitt Romney victory).

What are Straw Polls anyway?

Monday, April 12, 2010

The Economy and the 2010 Election

A nice piece by James Surowiecki in the New Yorker. Recent economic developments, plus $500 billion of unspent stimulus money, may lessen the negative impact expected in the upcoming election.

Goldman Sachs Works on its Image

Story here. And a link to the firm it hired to help it out here. You can follow them on Twitter!

For 2301s: think both free press and public opinion.

Sunday, April 11, 2010

Should Elected Leaders Follow Public Opinion?

For 2301 as we cover public opinion: Matt Bai notes that after hailing the Bush-Cheney Administration for being principled enough to ignore public opinion when they felt they had to, Republicans now assail Obama for doing the same. What role should public opinion play in governing decisions?

Note that the author points out the importance of the precise nature of the claims Democrats and Republicans have used to frame their accusations that the other party was being unfair, even to the point of using focus groups to make sure that the terminology was effective.

Democrats accused Republicans of "changing the rules in the middle of the game" when they considered changing rules concerning filibuster over judicial nominees. Now Republicans are accusing Democrats of having "rammed [health care reform] down the throats of the American people." in both cases the phrases were repeated over and over by various members of Congress to make sure the point was not missed.

Should the GOP Fight Obama's Nominee?

Republican Senators are unsure whether it is their best interest to stage a strong fight against the eventual nominee.

John Paul Stevens and the First Amendment

Here's a post that combines the topics in my 2301 and 23o2 classes. The First Amendment Center calls Stevens a friend of the First Amendment and outlines how the decisions he authored helped expand it.

Framing the Governor's Race

For my 2301s: We discussed how public opinion is often influenced by the frames of reference placed around whatever the public might be thinking about. Real power stems from being able to influence the context people use to form opinions about someone or something. This often determines the conclusions people make about those people or things. Its one of the goals of a successful campaign.

I was thinking about this when I saw the following effort by Governor Perry's campaign to frame Bill White a "liberal trial lawyer" rather than an ex-mayor.

Friday, April 9, 2010

Political Generations and the Future of the Democratic Party

For my 2301s as we continue to explore the sources of public opinion, some back and forth between the two authors about the impact a younger -- and possibly more libertarian -- cohort might have on the future of the Democratic Party.

- Liberaltarian Lessons from OKTrends?.
- Today's Social Liberal Is Tomorrow's Social Conservative.
- Liberaltarian Drift.
- Libertarian Electoral Fantasies.

Note the use of the term "liberaltarian" which is meant to distinguish younger, socially liberal members from the older folks.

Nuclear Posture Review

President Obama released an updated Nuclear Policy Review, which establishes the nation's policy regarding the use of nuclear weapons.

- A link to the report.
- Story in NPR.
- NYT Op-Ed.
- DOD info.

Stevens Makes it Official

He'll retire after this term is over.

- comments and further links from ScotusBlog.

Two Statements From Ben Bernanke

1 - The aggressive government response to the recent financial crisis prevented a depression worse than the one in the 1930s.

2 - The aging American population is creating strains on the fiscal health of the country and must be addressed immediately.

File this under economic policymaking and the executive branch, among other things.

Thursday, April 8, 2010

How to Measure Tea Partiers

This might be useful to my 2301s as we discuss the difficulty pollsters face in precisely (if that is even possible) measuring party identification.

Overall pid figures here. For likely voters here.

Some Random Gallup Poll Results

For discussion in my 2301s:

- Anti-incumbent attitudes prevail, but note that people have higher opinions of their own representative than of Congress as a whole.
- Opinions on Obama stabilize: Presidential Job Approval Center.
- Voters Rate Economy as Top Issue for 2010.
- Americans' Confidence in Banks Remains at Historical Low.

Wednesday, April 7, 2010

Economic Freedom

After a discussion of what freedom "is" in one of my classes yesterday, this link to the Index of Economic Freedom might be an interesting read.

- Economic freedom - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

K Street Compensation

It pays (well) to run a non-profit, advocacy group, think tank, interest group or trade organization in DC. So says the National Journal.

Tuesday, April 6, 2010

Net Neutrality Rules Struck Down

But an appellate court, so the SC has yet to rule. This limits the jurisdiction of the FCC, so file it under checks and balances.

Public Opinion and the Supreme Court

Here's a book review that combines the topics we're covering in both 2301 and 2302 this week. The author suggests that public opinion plays a bigger role in Supreme Court decisions than is generally appreciated:

. . . liberal commentators who fear that the Roberts Court could shift dramatically to the right in the coming years betray a lack of historical perspective. The Court will inevitably march to the tune that the American public plays. “The decisions of the justices on the meaning of the Constitution must be ratified by the American people,” Friedman matter-of-factly explains. “That’s just the way it is.” A Supreme Court decision, on this understanding, bears a resemblance to an opening bid in a hand of poker. “It is through the process of judicial responsiveness to public opinion that the meaning of the Constitution takes shape,” Friedman writes. “The Court rules. The public responds. Over time, sometimes a long period, public opinion jells, and the Court comes into line with the considered views of the American public.” In his account, the views of Supreme Court justices are, in comparison to the views of the American public, of trifling significance. “Ultimately, it is the people (and the people alone) who must decide what the Constitution means,” Friedman proclaims. And so the left need not gnash its teeth over the replacement of Justice Sandra Day O’Connor with Justice Samuel A. Alito Jr., or about any other personnel decisions for that matter, because “the long-run fate of the Roberts Court is not seriously in doubt; its decisions will fall tolerably within the mainstream of public opinion, or the Court will be yanked back into line.”


The reviewer begs to differ.

Massey Energy

Maybe this is just a coincidence, but Massey Energy, the owner of the mine that exploded recently, is the same Massey energy involved in a Supreme Court case involving a conflict of interest due to the company owner's involvement in the election of one of the judges to the same West Virginia court that would hear a lawsuit against him.

Obama as a Rorschach Test

Frank Rich tries to figure why so many people have so many conflicting attitudes about Obama. Attitudes about him, he argues, say less about him than they do about us. He's a Rorschach test where we see what we want to see whether it is good or bad.

Others have hit upon this before:

- Obama As Ideological Rorschach : NPR
- The Oil Drilling Rorschach Test - Swampland - TIME.com
- A plain blog about politics: Rorschach

Gallup Info on the Tea Party Identifiers

Click here for the poll.

David Frum Feels Purged

A casualty of the conservative movement's effort to drive the party further to the right?

Who is David Frum?

WikiLeaks

Another example of our decentralized media environment. Anyone can bring an items to the public's agenda now.

- Wikipedia entry.
- The Nation has questions about the site.

Wednesday, March 31, 2010

White Attitudes About Health Care

From the National Journal, an illustration for my 2301's about how different groups see the same things:

On the long climb to health care reform that ended with this week's momentous signing ceremony, President Obama aimed many of his arguments at a different audience from the one targeted by predecessors who faltered on the same steep hill.

Compared with earlier presidents, Obama focused his case less on helping the uninsured and more on providing those with coverage greater leverage against their insurers. That shift was especially evident in his final drive toward passage.

And yet, polling just before the bill's approval showed that most white Americans believed that the legislation would primarily benefit the uninsured and the poor, not people like them. In a mid-March Gallup survey, 57 percent of white respondents said that the bill would make things better for the uninsured, and 52 percent said that it would improve conditions for low-income families. But only one-third of whites said that it would benefit the country overall -- and just one-fifth said that it would help their own family.

Friday, March 26, 2010

Reconciliation Bill Passes, So Does Student Loan Bill

The NYT covers the HCR vote, as well as the vote on the Student Loan bill. This was the bill removed from the reconciliated health care bill. The bill effectively removes banks as middle men in the guaranteed federal student loan process.

Again there was unanimous Republican opposition to both bills.

Is the Health Care Legislation Constitutional?

More arguments that it is:

- Linda Greenhouse.
- Scott Lemieux.

DC Gun Laws Upheld

For my 2302's, from ScotusBlog, as we dive into the Supreme Court:

A federal judge in Washington, applying the Supreme Court’s 2008 decision creating a constitutional right to have a gun, ruled on Friday that three new gun control restrictions in the Nation’s capital city survive a Second Amendment challenge. . . .

Such gun control laws, the judge ruled, are to be subjected to constitutional analysis using an “intermediate” level of review — that is, a challenged law will be upheld if it is “substantially related to an important governmental interest.” Courts around the country have differed on what level of review should apply to gun regulation, and that issue thus is a likely one for future Supreme Court analysis.

Will John Paul Stevens Retire? And Who Will Replace Him if He Does?

The NYT makes some predictions and touches on the firestorm likely to result from it:

If Justice Stevens retires, Democrats close to the White House said, the leading contenders will be three runners-up from last year: Elena Kagan, the solicitor general; Diane P. Wood, an appeals court judge in Chicago; and Merrick B. Garland, an appeals court judge in Washington [The article also mentions Harold Hongju Koh, Cass R. Sunstein and Pamela S. Karlan].

The choice would depend in part on what kind of fight Mr. Obama is willing to wage amid other tough legislative battles. Energized if bruised from his campaign to overhaul the nation’s health system, Mr. Obama this year wants to push through energy, education and financial regulation measures, ratify an arms control treaty and make progress on immigration legislation.

A confirmation battle could not only provoke fresh skirmishing on longstanding issues like guns, abortion, race and terrorism; it might also generate new divisions stemming from constitutional challenges to Mr. Obama’s new health care program and a recent Supreme Court ruling guaranteeing the right of corporations and unions to spend unlimited amounts of money in candidate elections.

Mr. Obama may feel empowered to take on a fight.

Glenn Greenwald hopes the nominee is not Cass Sunstein.

Thursday, March 25, 2010

Flash Mobs

An unforeseen side effect of social networking.

About the Student Loan Provisions in the Health Care Bill

Here's background on the student loan bill tacked onto the health bill and later removed in the Senate.

Back to the House

Senate Republicans forced changes to the reconciliation bill, which means that the bill that was approved by the Senate now has to be approved by the House, due to the changes.

Apparently Republicans were able to successfully challenge education provisions tacked into the bill that had no direct impact on the budget, these were removed. That's why a new vote must take place, it's scheduled for today.

An Overview of the Health Care Bill

From the Washington Post:

COST: $940 billion over 10 years, according to the Congressional Budget Office.

HOW MANY COVERED: 32 million uninsured. Major coverage expansion begins in 2014. When fully phased in, 95 percent of eligible Americans would have coverage, compared with 83 percent today.

INSURANCE MANDATE: Almost everyone is required to be insured or else pay a fine. There is an exemption for low-income people. Mandate takes effect in 2014.

INSURANCE MARKET REFORMS: Starting this year, insurers would be forbidden from placing lifetime dollar limits on policies, from denying coverage to children because of pre-existing conditions, and from canceling policies because someone gets sick. Parents would be able to keep older kids on their coverage up to age 26. A new high-risk pool would offer coverage to uninsured people with medical problems until 2014, when the coverage expansion goes into high gear. Major consumer safeguards would also take effect in 2014. Insurers would be prohibited from denying coverage to people with medical problems or charging them more. Insurers could not charge women more.


MEDICAID: Expands the federal-state Medicaid insurance program for the poor to cover people with incomes up to 133 percent of the federal poverty level, $29,327 a year for a family of four. Childless adults would be covered for the first time, starting in 2014. The federal government would pay 100 percent of costs for covering newly eligible individuals through 2016. A special deal that would have given Nebraska 100 percent federal financing for newly eligible Medicaid recipients in perpetuity is eliminated. A different, one-time deal negotiated by Democratic Sen. Mary Landrieu for her state, Louisiana, worth as much as $300 million, remains.

TAXES: Dramatically scales back a Senate-passed tax on high-cost insurance plans that was opposed by House Democrats and labor unions. The tax would be delayed until 2018, and the thresholds at which it is imposed would be $10,200 for individuals and $27,500 for families. To make up for the lost revenue, the bill applies an increased Medicare payroll tax to the investment income and to the wages of individuals making more than $200,000, or married couples above $250,000. The tax on investment income would be 3.8 percent.

PRESCRIPTION DRUGS: Gradually closes the "doughnut hole" coverage gap in the Medicare prescription drug benefit that seniors fall into once they have spent $2,830. Seniors who hit the gap this year will receive a $250 rebate. Beginning in 2011, seniors in the gap receive a discount on brand name drugs, initially 50 percent off. When the gap is completely eliminated in 2020, seniors will still be responsible for 25 percent of the cost of their medications until Medicare's catastrophic coverage kicks in.

EMPLOYER RESPONSIBILITY: As in the Senate bill, businesses are not required to offer coverage. Instead, employers are hit with a fee if the government subsidizes their workers' coverage. The $2,000-per-employee fee would be assessed on the company's entire work force, minus an allowance. Companies with 50 or fewer workers are exempt from the requirement. Part-time workers are included in the calculations, counting two part-timers as one full-time worker.

SUBSIDIES: The proposal provides more generous tax credits for purchasing insurance than the original Senate bill did. The aid is available on a sliding scale for households making up to four times the federal poverty level, $88,200 for a family of four. Premiums for a family of four making $44,000 would be capped at around 6 percent of income.

HOW YOU CHOOSE YOUR HEALTH INSURANCE: Small businesses, the self-employed and the uninsured could pick a plan offered through new state-based purchasing pools called exchanges, opening for business in 2014. The exchanges would offer the same kind of purchasing power that employees of big companies benefit from. People working for medium-to-large firms would not see major changes. But if they lose their jobs or strike out on their own, they may be eligible for subsidized coverage through the exchange.

GOVERNMENT-RUN PLAN: No government-run insurance plan. People purchasing coverage through the new insurance exchanges would have the option of signing up for national plans overseen by the federal office that manages the health plans available to members of Congress. Those plans would be private, but one would have to be nonprofit.

ABORTION: The proposal keeps the abortion provision in the Senate bill. Abortion opponents disagree on whether restrictions on taxpayer funding go far enough. The bill tries to maintain a strict separation between taxpayer dollars and private premiums that would pay for abortion coverage. No health plan would be required to offer coverage for abortion. In plans that do cover abortion, policyholders would have to pay for it separately, and that money would have to be kept in a separate account from taxpayer money. States could ban abortion coverage in plans offered through the exchange. Exceptions would be made for cases of rape, incest and danger to the life of the mother.

GOP HEALTH CARE SUMMIT IDEAS: Following a bipartisan health care summit last month, Obama announced he was open to incorporating several Republican ideas into his legislation. But two of the principle ones - hiring investigators to pose as patients and search for fraud at hospitals and increasing spending for medical malpractice reform initiatives - did not make it into the legislation released Thursday. The legislation incorporates only one, an increase in payments to primary care physicians under Medicaid, an idea mentioned by Sen. Charles Grassley, R-Iowa.

Repeal the Seventeenth Amendment?

There's a move underway to do just that.

And a blog too.

Now the Public Supports Health Care Reform

I had a strange hunch this would happen. A few commentators try to figure out why this is the case. Perhaps as a a consequence, the U.S. Chamber of Commerce is backing away from its original support of an outright repeal.

So is this further evidence of an irrational public?

Tuesday, March 23, 2010

Health Care Legislative Histories

For my 2302's, links to the legislative histories of both the health care reform bill and the reconciliation bill:

- H.R. 3590.
- H.R. 4872.

What's With all the Pens?

A couple of students have asked about the large number of pens Obama used to sign the health care bill. He made different marks with each pen which added up to a complete signature. It simply allows a president the ability to give these pen to a variety of people who can each say that this was the pen used to sign the bill into law.

Nice PR basically.

Interpreting the National Labor Relations Act

For my 2302's, an example of statutory interpretation. One of the functions of the judicial system.

Greg Abbott explain the Texas Lawsuit Against Health Care Reform

An interview in the Texas Tribune.

Corporate Election Ads

The Texas Tribune reports on the first political ad paid by a corporation in a Texas newspaper since the Citizens United decision.

Responsible Party Model

For my 2301's, as we begin to discuss political parties:

Political science types tend to argue that parties must provide clear alternatives to the voters in order to provide them a choice. This allows the population to collectively influence the direction of public policy, enhancing the democratic nature of the republic. If this is true, then the division of the parties on health care provides such an opportunity -- assuming nothing else comes up between now and November to overshadow health care.

William Saletan says as much in Slate. He wonders whether there might be risks for Republicans in opposing the bill after Democrats are able to shift to campaign mode presenting the bill in a positive light:

This is the risk Republicans have taken by voting unanimously against health care reform. They've bet their whole party against it. If the public hates the program, they'll be rewarded at the polls. But if the public likes it, they're in trouble. And if the public fears it might be taken it away, they could suffer a beating, as they did in 1996 when voters feared cuts in Medicare.

Monday, March 22, 2010

Is the Health Care Bill Constitutional?

Some Smart people go at it:

No it isn't: Randy Barnett.
Yes it is: Jack Balkin.
Yes it is: Jeffrey Toobin.

Obama's Executive Order

Some commentary on the executive order Obama will sign to satisfy Democratic pro-lifers.

- Will the executive order restrict abortion?‎
- Text of the Executive Order on Abortion‎
- Abortion rights groups not happy with Obama executive order on ...‎

The Final Days

Slate's Whipometer details the process the health care bill took in its final days.

The Next Elephant in the Room

Finance reform.

Obama's Leadership Style

An assessment of Obama's presidential style from Ronald Brownstein:

The fight has opened a . . . window into Obama. The key here is his 2008 campaign assertion that "Ronald Reagan changed the trajectory of America" more than Richard Nixon or Bill Clinton did. The health care struggle suggests that Obama views changing that trajectory as the ultimate measure of a presidency's success. His aim is to establish a long-term political direction -- one centered on a more activist government that shapes and polices the market to strengthen the foundation for sustainable, broadly shared growth. Everything else -- the legislative tactics, even most individual policies -- is negotiable. He wants to chart the course for the supertanker, not to steer it around each wave or decide which crates are loaded into its hull.

Sunday, March 21, 2010

Partisan Opinion on Health Care Reform

Here's more proof that Republicans and Democrats live in two separate worlds.

Comments on Health Care and the Obama Presidency

Here are a couple of interesting arguments:

- David Sanger.
- Andrew Sprung.

This is being considered already to be an historic achievement regardless of what happens next. Now commentators wonder whether Obama has spent political capital and can accomplish little else until after the next election, or whether this has actually built up his capital and can more effectively drive forward on climate change, financial regulation and energy.

Jamestown and the Common Law

I had a great spring break trip to Colonial Williamsburg, Virginia and popped over to Yorktown and Jamestown. Among the ruins in Jamestown -- the town was largely abandoned after the capitol moved to Williamsburg in the late 1600's -- is an old church where a variety of commemorative panels have been hung including this one that stated that the founding of Jamestown marked the introduction of the common law to America.

My 2302's will soon cover the judiciary and with it an overview of common law.

The House Passes Health Care Reform

Story in the NYT.

Friday, March 19, 2010

Public Perception v. Reality

Bruce Bartlett finds evidence that Tea Party members, on average, cannot correctly answer questions about taxes.

This is not a surprising result. As my 2301's dive into public opinion we'll see that people often distort facts to justify their image of the world. Tea Partiers are no different than anyone else.

Deem and Pass

This appears to be the term of the moment. It refers to the process Democrats plan to use to pass health care reform. The election of the 41st Republican to the Senate (the one that allows filibusters to be maintained) has made it necessary for the party to find someway to convince House members to pass the Senate plan, with the guarantees that changes to the bill will be made mandatory.

Its a confusing and controversial process that some argue may be unconstitutional. Here's some background:

- MSNBC.
- Ezra Klein.
- Kevin Drum.
- ProPublica.

Greenspan v the Regulatory State

Alan Greenspan reflects on the recent financial crisis and has second thoughts on the ability of the private sector to regulate itself.

Williamsburg

I've been in Williamsburg VA the past few days on spring break touring Jamestown (what little there is of it) Williamsburg and Yorktown. All things must end though so I'll be back to posting material for the class soon. I've learned a few things about the evolution of American governing institutions which I plan on sharing when I get back. This might be a tamer break than some of you care for, but I highly recommend a trip at some point in your lives.

- Jamestown.
- Williamsburg.
- Yorktown.

Thursday, March 11, 2010

The Rise of the Health Care Lobby

From Ezra Klein:

Over the past hundred or so years, the health-care system has gone from a very small portion of our economy to about a fifth of it. That's a remarkable rise. And it has been accompanied by a similar rise in the political power of the health-care industry.

File this under Iron Triangles.

Profiles of Timothy Geithner

A couple of articles about our current Secretary of the Treasury:

- Treasury Secretary Timothy Geithner : The New Yorker
- Inside Man - Magazine - The Atlantic

Privileges and Immunities v Due Process

Here's a link to an article in the National Law Journal that analyses the arguments used before the Supreme Court in the gun rights case, McDonald v. Chicago.

The attempt to persuade the court to use the privileges and immunities clause as the legal reasoning behind the case apparently failed, so the due process clause was used instead. There's inside info here that I'm not privy to, but it seems that some of the justices are uncomfortable with extending rights to the state, but felt the need to in this second amendment case. Their task was to ensure they did not extend this right using an argument that might be applied elsewhere.

I may be wrong in my reasoning though.

This'll be a good read for my 2302s as we begin to discuss the judiciary following the break

Roberts v. Obama

A war of words is heating up between the White House and the Supreme Court. The court tends to rank at the top of respected American governing institutions. I wonder if Robert's decision to criticize Obama's comments about the Citizens United decision in the state of the union address was wise. Might there be institutional consequences?

- Supreme debate: Obama vs. Roberts
- White House and Roberts get snippy again
- John Roberts' nonpartisan attack on presidential partisanship. - Dahlia ...
- Scotus Blog commentary.

Tuesday, March 9, 2010

An Awesome Resourse

Google Labs' Public Data Explorer.

Presidential Persuasion

Obama's push for passage of health care is a test of his powers of persuasion. Andrew Sullivan sees evidence it might be working.

Angling for Deals

Here's great insight into how Congress works. Health Care reform is a game of chicken. Some members arr pretending to be opposed to the bill so that they may be able to get goodies for their districts:

...if the representative wants to extract concessions from the Democratic leadership, it’s thus a good idea to signal uncertainty or even opposition to the bill — as many conservative Democrats have done. This raises the possibility, as one friend noted to me, that the prevalence of these signals in news stories may inflate the perceived chance that health care reform will fail in the House.

Perhaps the health care bill has more support than is being reported

The President as Party Leader

Obama reverts to campaign mode to push passage of health care reform.

For 2302's this illustrates (tests?) the central aspect of presidential power: the power to persuade.

Possible Impeachment

The House of Representatives considers impeaching a federal judge.

He's Back......

Miss Me Yet?

An Irreparably Polarized Supreme Court?

From the NYT:

A few times a year, Supreme Court justices go out of their way to emphasize their unhappiness by reading a dissent from the bench out loud, supplementing the dry reason on the page with vivid tones of sarcasm, regret, anger and disdain. The practice is on the rise, and it is suggestive of an increasingly polarized court.

“Dissenting from the bench,”
a new study to be published in Justice System Journal contends, is a sort of nuclear option that “may indicate that bargaining and accommodation have broken down irreparably.”

Monday, March 8, 2010

The First Amendment and Funeral Protests

The Supreme Court will determine whether funeral protests are protected by the First Amendment.

Contributions and Earmarks

From the Washington Post:

House Appropriations defense subcommittee member James P. Moran Jr. (D-Va.) works hard at fundraising: Two to three times a week, he telephones contributors to ask for more. Yet, according to the account he supplied to the Office of Congressional Ethics last year, he is unaware of "who made donations" or how much they gave, and so that information plays no role in his earmarking -- the systematic granting of public funds for mostly private purposes.

Fellow subcommittee member Norm Dicks (D-Wash.) similarly presides over fundraisers arranged by his staff for defense firms and
lobbyists every three months or so, according to his office's account. An aide in charge of Dicks's earmarks attends the fundraising events. But Dicks and the aide told investigators they were unaware of the substantial overlap between defense industry contributions to Dicks and his earmarks to contributors.

We'll be discussing elections in 2301 and the amount of time and energy members of Congress have to spend raising campaign funds. This story suggests that the contributors may be getting more than an open ear from recipients.

Liberal Wing of Democratic Party Pulls Party to the Left

From the Washington Post, word of a rupture within the Democratic Party. Liberals are as upset about Washington as as conservatives.

Democratic activists flooding money into a primary challenge against Sen. Blanche Lincoln (D-Ark.) say the race isn't simply about defeating the incumbent. It is also about rebuking a Democratic-controlled Congress that they say isn't pursuing an aggressive, populist agenda.

After Arkansas Lt. Gov. Bill Halter announced Monday that he would challenge Lincoln, liberal donors from groups such as MoveOn.org poured more than $1 million into his campaign, an unusually high sum for the first two days of campaigning. Liberals blasted Lincoln with anti-Washington rhetoric that sounded more like the conservative tea party movement. The groups are particularly critical of her opposition to the public option, as it is known, in the health-care bill and her support in 2008 for a Wall Street bailout.

Saturday, March 6, 2010

Friday, March 5, 2010

Political Mythology

Michael Lind places the Tea Party/Obama conflict in historical perspective. My 2302's should be able to follow his historical references. He claims that our current political debate comes down to archetypes that have persisted over the centuries.

David Brooks picks up from this argument and argues ties the current tea party devotees to the radicals of the 1960s. Each believed that the pure innocent masses were being unduly persecuted by elites.

Public Knowledge About the Senate.

Some information from the Pew Research Center.

Thursday, March 4, 2010

Judging John Roberts

Perhaps more activist than he first seemed.

What's in a Word?

Plenty, especially if the word is "navigable," and it is used in legislation to state what waters the EPA can regulate.

A narrow definition of navigable by the Supreme Court (in two cases: Solid Waste Agency of Northern Cook County v. United States Army Corps of Engineers in 2001 and Rapanos v. United States in 2006) has, according to the New York Times, led to increased levels of water pollution in the country. The majority stuck to what it considered to be the plain meaning of the text, despite arguments by others that that negated the intent of the act itself.

Congress is currently determining whether to revise the Clean Water Act to restore the intended broad intent of the law.

Not So Faithfully Executing the Laws

Charlie Savage, who investigates the use of signing statements by President Bush, notices that they are continuing under Obama. Or at least he continues to make the claim that a President does not have to execute laws he believes are unconstitutional.

Some history from the article:

Since the 19th century, presidents have occasionally used signing statements to declare that parts of a bill were unconstitutional and need not be enforced or obeyed as written. But the tactic was rare until the second term of President Ronald Reagan, whose legal team developed a strategy of issuing the statements more frequently to increase presidential power.
Reagan’s successors continued that approach. And the practice escalated again under Mr. Bush, who used it to advance expansive theories of executive power. He challenged about 1,200 sections of bills — more than all predecessors combined — including a ban on torture and oversight provisions of the
USA Patriot Act.

Mr. Bush’s assertive use of the tactic set off a national debate over its propriety. The
American Bar Association declared that signing statements “undermine the rule of law and our constitutional system of separation of powers,” and argued that the Constitution gave presidents only two choices: veto a bill, or sign it and obey all of it.

But other scholars said the tactic was appropriate if a president cited only mainstream legal theories. Mr. Obama, whose advisers sided with the latter camp, has characterized Mr. Bush’s use of signing statements as an abuse and
pledged greater restraint.

Mr. Obama nevertheless challenged dozens of provisions early last year. The last time was in June, when his
claim that he could disobey a new law requiring officials to push the World Bank and the International Monetary Fund to adopt certain policies angered Congress. The White House sought to reassure lawmakers that it intended to take those negotiating positions anyway and was merely noting its view that Congress cannot control foreign negotiations. Many lawmakers rejected that theory, and the House quickly voted 429 to 2 to bar officials from disobeying the restrictions.

- Some background from Findlaw.

Wednesday, March 3, 2010

Executive Agency in the News: The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration

Toyota's recent troubles led to congressional investigations that also included oversight of the actions of the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration, an agency within the Department of Transportation.

- NYT Story.
- NHTSA website.
- Wikipedia entry.
- Times Topics: NHTSA.
- House Committee on Oversight and Government Reform.

Has the Stimulus Worked?

Some economists weigh in.

How the First Amendment Works

An interesting read by Stanley Fish.

States' Rights vs. Gun Rights

A nice discussion in the NYT.

The Bureau of Financial Protection

The Senate Banking Committee continues to discuss financial regulation reform. One item on the table is the creation of another independent agency in the executive. At one time it was to be called the Consumer Financial Protection Agency, but the banking lobby was put off by the proposal.

Now it is to be called the Bureau of Financial Protection. It will not be a stand alone agency like the Consumer Agency was to be, but will exist within the Treasury Department and is to "supervise mortgages, credit cards and other financial products."

My 2302's should take note since we have been discussing the growth of the executive branch. Agencies are developed piecemeal to respond to various crises as they happen. Here's an example.

Related stories:

- Frank Luntz Pens Memo To Kill Financial Regulatory Reform
- Financial Regulatory Reform News - The New York Times
- United States - Department of The Treasury - Keeping the Economy ...
- Regulatory Reform - FinancialStability.gov US Department of the ...

Texas 2010 Primary Results

Here are a few links to stories about yesterday's primaries. We'll cover these in 2301 primarily, since we're about to discuss elections.

- Gov. Perry defeats Hutchison in Texas GOP primary
- Tea Party activists coming up short in Texas Legislature races
- Lessons From The Texas Republican Primary
- In Texas, It's Perry Vs. White
- Carl Leubsdorf: Is Rick Perry's next race for president?
- Brazoria County Results.
- Harris County Results.
- Results from the Texas Secreatry of State's Office.

Obama '10 = Reagan '82?

Are pundits being premature in predicting Obama's demise? They said similar things about Reagan.

Tuesday, March 2, 2010

Protected Speech: Flippin the Bird

This is for an interested student:

- The Bird is the (Constitutionally Protected) Word - Law Blog - WSJ

Just One Senator...

...can cause a whole lot of problems.

- United States Senator Jim Bunning, Kentucky :: Home
- Jim Bunning - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

U.S. Post Office in Trouble

From the Washington Post:

The U.S. Postal Service estimates $238 billion in losses in the next 10 years if lawmakers, postal regulators and unions don't give the mail agency more flexibility in setting delivery schedules, price increases and labor costs.

- USPS - The United States Postal Service (U.S. Postal Service)
- United States Post Office Department - Wikipedia, the free ...

Is Obama Not Listening to his Chief of Staff?

From the Washington Post:

Rahm Emanuel is officially a Washington caricature. He's the town's resident leviathan, a bullying, bruising White House chief of staff who is a prime target for the failings of the Obama administration.

But a contrarian narrative is emerging: Emanuel is a force of political reason within the White House and could have helped the administration avoid its current bind if the president had heeded his advice on some of the most sensitive subjects of the year: health-care reform, jobs and trying alleged terrorists in civilian courts.

It is a view propounded by lawmakers and early supporters of
President Obama who are frustrated because they think the administration has gone for the perfect at the expense of the plausible. They believe Emanuel, the town's leading purveyor of four-letter words, a former Israeli army volunteer and a product of a famously argumentative family, was not aggressive enough in trying to persuade a singularly self-assured president and a coterie of true-believer advisers that "change you can believe in" is best pursued through accomplishments you can pass.

read on ....

For more info
- White House Chief of Staff - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
- Rahm Emanuel - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
- Chief of Staff Rahm Emanuel The White House
- Obama's White House: There's something about Rahm‎

Now For Something Completely Radical

The Coffee Party.

Their mission statement: The Coffee Party Movement gives voice to Americans who want to see cooperation in government. We recognize that the federal government is not the enemy of the people, but the expression of our collective will, and that we must participate in the democratic process in order to address the challenges that we face as Americans. As voters and grassroots volunteers, we will support leaders who work toward positive solutions, and hold accountable those who obstruct them.

That'll tick the Tea Party people off. Are people really ready to hear good things about government or are we hard wired to always think it is bad?

Apparently this has been organized primarily through Facebook. Social networking sites are having a fascinating impact on politics. They fascilitate rapid organization. Its up in the air whether they have legs though.

The "coffee" label in interesting. The term "tea party" has the obvious connection to the American revolution against the British, but the concept of individual freedom and the formation of early political groups happened in coffee houses. Ale Houses and taverns too, so I'm holding out for the Beer Party.

For more info:
- NYT Story.
- Facebook page.