Tuesday, March 19, 2013

Weekly assignment #3 - 8 week classes

These assignments are for students in the 8 week mini:

GOVT 2305: I want you to look at immigration reform, and specifically the question about whether it is likely to be passed by the Senate and the House. I've posted a few items on this already. A "gang" of four Democratic and four Republican Senators proposed comprehensive immigration reform, and speculation exists that passage of these reform might easily pass that chamber. The president has also made a set of proposals and seems ready to "go public" to promote them. The question is what will happen in the House because Republicans are in the majority and they are split between a faction that sees it necessary to pass immigration reform in order to gain support from the emerging Latino community, and a factions that is opposed to it - mostly the remnants of the Tea Party.

I want you to read up on this conflict and provide a reasoned, informed commentary on the likelihood that immigration reform can actually pass the 113th Congress, and if so, in what form. Part of the purpose of this assignment is to get you to think more about the separated powers and the fact that each of the elected institutions on the national level are designed differently in order to ensure that they behave differently. The conflict we see is intended. But explain what design factors make this issue - that seems ready to be passed in the Senate - may not be in the House.

GOVT 2306: We've been looking at founding documents, including the Declaration of Independence. We noted that the declaration was intended to convince an impartial world that their desire to be independent. Normally this is something nations do not like to see happen - for an obviously self interested reason - which is why it was important that substantive reasons be offered in order to ensure that the decision was based on reason, not passion.

As you may know, after the 2012 election many petitions were sent to the White House requesting permission for some states - Texas included - to secede from the nation. I want you to find these petitions, and any other supporting documents, and analyze the arguments they make. What reasons were offered? How do these stack up against the arguments made in the Texas Declaration of Independence (2301s might want to look at the US Declaration of Independence). Are the arguments reasonable, or driven by passion? Support your assessment.