Friday, September 12, 2014

Security trumps civil liberty

Just in time for our upcoming look at civil liberties, Andrew Sullivan points to a Pew Center report which reveals - among other things - that Americans are more worried about security than civil rights. The poll was conducted from September 2 - 9th, meaning that it is likely that this is a response to the recent be-headings.

This might be the key graphic in the study:

Shifting Public Views on Balance Between Security and Civil Liberties  

Notice that we tend to err on the side of security since 2004 - almost certainly a reaction to 9/11. I mentioned in a couple classes that Congress is not expected to work on legislation curtailing the NSA surveillance program, and given recent events it may well be that members of Congress will feel little support for doing so now.

We should spend sometime discussing how two be headings in a desert thousands of miles from the United States has been able to transform American public policy so quickly. In 2305 we will be looking at Federalist #10 and the constitutional mechanism in place intended to limit the direct impact shifts in opinion can have on public policy.

It's worth considering whether the nature of social media has negated those limits.